366:
Australia (although perhaps with some of the material to be obtained from the United States). The problem of
British construction was twofold; Britain was at the height of its war effort and it was unrealistic to think that the British could embark on the construction of 127 (as was originally planned) large locomotives when their own munitions industries were pressed to the limit and their ships desperately needed for military transport and supply tasks. The other problem was that the ships involved and their cargos would have risked being lost to enemy action during the long voyage. The British were alive to these problems and Ellis was advised that priority, if any, could be allocated only following a firm order to Britain. If a high priority were then obtained and if a co-operative scheme could be established Australia could probably expect to receive three units per week with the first deliveries to be made six months after order.
305:(QR) a logistical task that they were hard-pressed to accommodate; in fact a worse situation could scarcely be imagined. When the military forces needed machinery, people, and supplies moved in vast quantities as a matter of priority they had at their disposal the modest infrastructure of QR; light-weight track and structures, a tortuous geographic profile, unpretentious locomotives with low axle-loads, and train lengths limited by these factors. Added to that was the proportion of current QR motive-power that was rotating through overhaul and repair. Against this background, the requirement for extra, effective motive-power in Queensland (and to a slightly lesser-extent, the rest of the nation) was identified as a critical requirement.
374:
Beyer-Peacock & Co, had expired as
Garratt's patent came to an end. Anyone obtaining a set of Garratt plans could simply build more of them whenever they wished. Hence it would have been possible for the QR or any entity to build its own Garratts if it so desired or privately if the railway or entity could obtain the plans and adapt them accordingly. Common sense dictates though that it would be wise to use the established experience of Beyer-Peacock & Co to either draw a set of plans specifically for the end-user and to construct at least some of the locomotives in
169:. Despite his insistence that their construction constituted essential war work, production of the S Class was postponed, and it wasn't until 1943 that the first three of an eventual total of ten were placed into service. The S class was to prove one of the more controversial of Western Australia's locomotives; suffering from a variety of early problems due to Mills' implementation of some bold new ideas. However, despite numerous complaints from various railway unions they eventually became solid performers.
226:
358:
design. Mills' design for the ASG was thus a variation of this drawing but he does not appear to have drawn great attention to the fact that he used it as the basis of his plan; hardly surprising as he was a proud man and proud of his design. If it had worked to everybody's satisfaction it would have been an historic first; the only steam locomotive ever designed and built in
Australia for availability on all narrow-gauge systems.
328:
Commonwealth Land
Transport Board (CLTB) which was charged with giving effect to the regulations and directing what rail and road transport services should be maintained and the terms and conditions of operation. The CLTB was also responsible for the acquisition, by purchase or manufacture, of any required vehicles and accessories and to operate and use them and determine routes and priorities of transport.
407:
known in designing the ASG and with the benefit that at least some QR staff would become familiar with the locomotive (after all, the QR was to get ten of the thirty to be built). The appeals were to no avail; QR stated emphatically that no assistance could be given, and in view of the then state of locomotive maintenance in
Queensland, Mills felt that little could be done to combat its attitude.
452:
with great resistance. Mills' intransigence to criticism did not place him in a good light following an eventual Royal
Commission into the ASG and also meant that modifications that may have resulted in their successful operation were delayed or refused and the locomotives were finally withdrawn to become monuments to human folly of various categories; but perhaps mostly hubris.
350:, originally ordered in 1911, being the first main-line Garratts ever built). His secret report — to a singular Term of Reference — would be used to justify the acquisition of what would become known as the Australian Standard Garratt, to alleviate a wartime motive-power deficit most critically being felt in Queensland.
309:
Mills was not overly-tolerant or possessed of an excess of humility; in fact he was arrogant, authoritarian and obstinate. Given the hostility that later developed between QR and those in wartime control of the nation’s railways over the design and introduction of the ASG, the personalities of Mills and
406:
It seems, therefore, simply common sense that at least one QR officer should have been included in the team of designers of the ASG although, incredibly, not a single one was involved. Special appeals were made by the CLTB to QR to obtain representation so that the locomotive practices of QR would be
188:
and the
Institution of Locomotive Engineers. As a graduate of the second of those worthy bodies, Mills won special prizes for his papers on locomotive boilers and steam locomotive design and construction. He published in the engineering press several articles on locomotive and rollingstock design and
451:
The first ASGs eventually commenced service with QR, with a VR locomotive inspector provided to assist the
Queensland enginemen. They were considered by both QR and its enginemen to be deficient in many respects — and later, perhaps even unsafe due to their unflanged leading driving wheels — and met
373:
Up until 1927, the only lawful manner of obtaining a
Garratt was to either have Beyer-Peacock & Co build it or, as was sometimes the case when that firm had sufficient work in hand, a company might be licensed by it to do the work upon payment of a fee. After 1927 however, the global monopoly of
357:
In the course of their investigation Ellis and Mills had become aware of the Beyer-Peacock & Co. outline drawing № 120328 for a light
Garratt-type locomotive and it is apparent that it was on this drawing that Mills later based the specifications for the locomotive he would propose, and go on to
455:
In his comprehensive historical work (see ref. 4 below) Alan Whiting has a final, erudite word on the conception and development of the ASG. He states of the development and construction of the ASG, "The reality was, despite the QRG's lethargy, whether justifiable or not, there is no excuse for the
369:
One further possibility was for the end-user to build the locomotives themselves under licence from Beyer-Peacock & Co in which case (at that time) a licence fee would have been payable. Enquiries of the WAGR in late 1922 had revealed that Beyer-Peacock & Co had requested £850 per unit as a
361:
At a time when the administrators of the QR had lost the legal right to conduct their empire as they pleased, the way in which the Commonwealth officers approached their task was vital if proper organisation was to be achieved. Clapp and Mills could never be described as conducting their task with
390:
classes for the motive-power expansion, Ellis' report neglects to mention the fact that the plans, jigs and patterns for these were immediately available and delivery of them could have been commenced immediately subject only to the availability of material. The C17 could run on the WAGR and the
308:
Mills was an eminent locomotive engineer and had considerable experience in locomotive design but he lacked one quality that was to increase the friction that was later to develop between his new employer (the Commonwealth Ministry of Munitions) and QR in the design and introduction of the ASG.
192:
Also in 1939, the James F Lincoln Arc Welding Foundation of the United States conducted a worldwide competition for papers on new applications of electric welding. Mills won the £1,000 first prize in the Railway Locomotive section for his design of a welded engine frame. In 1940 he was appointed
427:
could be deferred in favour of that company assembling ASGs, and promised staff to carry out inspections of construction. The Tasmanian Government Railways, claimed Mills, also agreed to defer its locomotive construction programme and the Victorian Railways and WAGR agreed likewise and further,
365:
The means of acquisition of the locomotives thus became the next challenge for the participants. United States builders were too preoccupied with their own wartime production to construct the locomotives, so this left only Great Britain as a manufacturing source if they were not to be built in
353:
It is perhaps understandable that Ellis chose both his home-state Chief Mechanical Engineer and Assistant Secretary (C. Raymond) to assist in the investigation which eventually arrived at a recommendation to use the Garratt type for all Australian narrow-gauge systems; QR itself apparently not
327:
in 1942, was responsible for the administration of the National Security Act (1942) and Regulations. These gave the Commonwealth full power and authority to control rail and road transport and do all things necessary to give effect to the regulations. This included provision for setting up the
335:
In April 1942, Joseph Ellis Commissioner of Railways for Western Australia since 1934 and being now — as Director of Locomotive and Rollingstock Construction in the Commonwealth Ministry of Munitions — a member of the CLTB, was requested by the War Railway Committee to examine Australia’s 3'
342:-type locomotives, and advise the CLTB. The War Railway Committee was composed of the Director-General of Land Transport, the Commissioners of the State and Commonwealth railway systems, the Director of Rail Transport, a nominee of the Minister for Army, and two rail union representatives.
131:, another well-known builder. While working for his two British employers, Mills participated in the design of locomotives for export to railways throughout the world. In 1926, on the recommendation of Sir WG Armstrong-Whitworth & Co, he was appointed Designing Draughtsman for the
447:
for the drawing office and lent other officers to assist the ASG programme in other ways. The absurdity had been reached though, that most of the designers were to come from the states that were not going to be allocated any ASGs and whose systems were wider-gauge.
354:
represented in the eventual recommendation. Once the decision had been made to proceed with the ASG, Ellis elevated Mills to Controller of Locomotive and Rollingstock Construction for the Ministry of Munitions with responsibility for the actual design work.
331:
The eminence of Victorian Railway's Commissioner Harold Winthrop Clapp as a railway manager resulted in his appointment by Lawson as the Director-General of the CLTB. In this position Clapp was empowered to authorise and direct all CLTB activity.
422:
could not undertake assembly work, because its workshops were equipped for only maintenance and new workshops built for locomotive construction were making munitions. They did agree though, that their locomotives then being built by
381:
So it was that QR found itself pressed by the CLTB to provide the workshop capacity to construct the locomotives, while struggling to maintain its own war-worn fleet. Although QR had agitated unceasingly for adoption of its
362:
tact insofar as the Queenslanders were concerned. For various reasons the QR did not agree that the ASG was the best locomotive for Queensland and did not accept the decision to build them with any degree of enthusiasm.
456:
Commonwealth through the agency of Clapp and Mills, visiting upon the QGR and its military users what stands out as a disaster unprecedented in the history of locomotive engineering in Australia."
99:
and was known throughout his career for designing a number of the influential steam locomotives for operation in Western Australia, including a number of controversial designs. No fewer than four
583:
324:
443:
As a consequence Mills surrounded himself with twelve design staff from the various systems as follows: NSWGR – 6, VR – 4, WAGR – 1, and TGR – 1. The VR provided premises in
346:
Ellis was an appropriate appointee. He had been an engineer for the Queensland Railways from 1910 to 1926, and the WAGR had used Garratt locomotives for some 30 years (the
286:
In 1942, Mills was seconded to the Federal Government to lead a team tasked with providing a design for a new standard-class narrow-gauge locomotive; the result being the
172:
Mills was just as well-educated in engineering theory as railway locomotive design practice. In 1939 he relieved the Associate Professor of Mechanical Engineering at the
464:
From his appointment as Locomotive Design Draftsman in 1926 a new era of locomotive design for the WAGR began. Designs introduced by Mills over his career include:
204:
the WAGR, like other Australian railway systems, was facing severe economic crisis. The problems in Western Australia, however, were exaggerated by a succession of
107:
locomotive and other aspects pertinent to its design and development – during his tenure, all of them into issues against which Mills himself fought unceasingly.
181:
576:
212:. Approximately half of the WAGR's locomotive fleet dated back before the turn of the century, and by 1943 a quarter were out of service pending overhaul.
515:
Bertola, P and Oliver, B (Eds.), 'The Workshop: A History of the Midland Government Railway Workshops', 2006, University of Western Australia Press, Perth
527:
Gunzburg, Adrian.(1984) A history of W.A.G.R. steam locomotives Perth, W.A : Australian Railway Historical Society, Western Australian Division.
611:
593:
247:
636:
621:
123:
and after passing the necessary examination was admitted to that company's drawing office during his apprenticeship. He served in the
414:
resisted Commonwealth requests to defer a programme of locomotive construction but eventually agreed to assemble twelve ASGs at its
132:
88:
616:
320:
301:
due to its strategic location vis á vis the Pacific theatre. The Australian and American military machines required of the
290:
of which 25 were used by the WAGR from a total of 57 locomotives built. The class were all withdrawn within fifteen years.
419:
383:
177:
557:
532:
273:
255:
17:
387:
205:
173:
396:
251:
392:
115:
Frederick Mills was born in England in 1898. He served for six years as an apprentice fitter-and-turner with
488:
433:
415:
287:
208:
having provided little for the railways, meaning that they had not yet recovered from the effects of the
116:
104:
543:
Rogers, P., 'Troops, Trains and Trades: The Wartime Role of the Railways of Western Australia, 1939–1945
147:
477:
429:
411:
194:
166:
84:
72:
338:-gauge railway systems (but most specifically that of Queensland) as to the practicability of using
236:
103:
were held into various aspects of WAGR operations – including an examination of the safety of the
240:
92:
161:
locomotive class to assist in Western Australia's failing railway system. They would become the
428:
offered their workshops as assembly places. Thus assembly was to take place at four locations:
151:
400:
314:
631:
626:
476:(the only class of steam locomotive to be completely conceived, designed and built at the
8:
302:
135:(WAGR) and emigrated to Western Australia. He was promoted to Chief Draughtsman in 1931.
128:
120:
552:
Whiting, Alan: Engine of Destruction – The Australian Standard Garratt Scandal,₯₯ 1988,
310:
370:
licence fee for the Garratts the WAGR had at that time been planning to build itself.
553:
528:
437:
424:
53:
418:
although it refused to make officers available to assist with the design work. The
209:
100:
124:
605:
483:
468:
378:
or to have that company superintend construction at the end-user's facility.
215:
317:
were to have significance in some absurd circumstances that were to follow.
297:
had turned Australia into a military base, with no state more affected than
165:, the only locomotive to be completely conceived, designed and built at the
493:
473:
347:
201:
162:
143:
96:
154:
required work to be done on the re-distribution of weight and the pivots.
294:
138:
During 1928 Mills was handed the responsibility for designing the first
584:
Chief Mechanical Engineer of the Western Australian Government Railways
375:
298:
444:
142:
type of locomotive built in Australia. The design was similar to the
225:
339:
139:
158:
49:
182:
North East Coast Institution of Engineers & Shipbuilders
185:
216:
Wartime service with the Commonwealth Land Transport Board
91:
from 1940 until his death in 1949. He was seconded to the
440:(Victoria), and Clyde Engineering (New South Wales).
157:During the 1930s, Mills submitted plans for a new
189:read papers before the Institution of Engineers.
127:and on de-mobilisation became a draughtsman with
603:
254:. Unsourced material may be challenged and
523:
521:
274:Learn how and when to remove this message
16:For other people with the same name, see
186:American Society of Mechanical Engineers
612:Australian railway mechanical engineers
518:
604:
546:
511:
509:
133:Western Australian Government Railways
89:Western Australian Government Railways
537:
459:
252:adding citations to reliable sources
219:
506:
420:New South Wales Government Railways
129:Sir WG Armstrong-Whitworth & Co
13:
178:Institution of Engineers Australia
14:
648:
637:20th-century Australian engineers
622:Locomotive builders and designers
224:
117:R&W Hawthorn Leslie & Co
174:University of Western Australia
325:Federal Minister for Transport
1:
499:
393:Tasmanian Government Railways
150:, but the lengthening of the
617:History of Western Australia
110:
7:
489:Australian Standard Garratt
434:Islington Railway Workshops
416:Islington Railway Workshops
288:Australian Standard Garratt
105:Australian Standard Garratt
10:
653:
83:(1898 – 22 June 1949) was
15:
590:
581:
573:
568:
478:Midland Railway Workshops
430:Midland Railway Workshops
412:South Australian Railways
195:Chief Mechanical Engineer
176:. He was a Member of the
167:Midland Railway Workshops
85:Chief Mechanical Engineer
73:Chief Mechanical Engineer
68:
60:
42:
34:
27:
399:had already run on the
148:Beyer, Peacock & Co
46:22 June 1949 (aged 51)
432:(Western Australia),
401:Commonwealth Railways
484:WAGR Dd Class 4-6-4T
469:WAGR Dm Class 4-6-4T
248:improve this section
577:John W.R. Broadfoot
569:Business positions
436:(South Australia),
303:Queensland Railways
121:Newcastle upon Tyne
494:WAGR W Class 4-8-2
474:WAGR S Class 4-8-2
460:Locomotive Designs
311:Victorian Railways
295:War in the Pacific
93:Federal Government
600:
599:
591:Succeeded by
438:Newport Workshops
425:Clyde Engineering
284:
283:
276:
206:State Governments
101:Royal Commissions
78:
77:
54:Western Australia
644:
574:Preceded by
566:
565:
560:
550:
544:
541:
535:
525:
516:
513:
279:
272:
268:
265:
259:
228:
220:
210:Great Depression
25:
24:
652:
651:
647:
646:
645:
643:
642:
641:
602:
601:
596:
587:
579:
564:
563:
551:
547:
542:
538:
526:
519:
514:
507:
502:
462:
313:' Commissioner
280:
269:
263:
260:
245:
229:
218:
125:Royal Air Force
113:
81:Frederick Mills
56:
47:
30:
29:Frederick Mills
21:
18:Frederick Mills
12:
11:
5:
650:
640:
639:
634:
629:
624:
619:
614:
598:
597:
592:
589:
580:
575:
571:
570:
562:
561:
545:
536:
517:
504:
503:
501:
498:
497:
496:
491:
486:
481:
471:
461:
458:
282:
281:
232:
230:
223:
217:
214:
112:
109:
76:
75:
70:
66:
65:
62:
58:
57:
48:
44:
40:
39:
36:
32:
31:
28:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
649:
638:
635:
633:
630:
628:
625:
623:
620:
618:
615:
613:
610:
609:
607:
595:
586:
585:
578:
572:
567:
559:
558:0-7316-1466-6
555:
549:
540:
534:
533:0-9599690-3-9
530:
524:
522:
512:
510:
505:
495:
492:
490:
487:
485:
482:
479:
475:
472:
470:
467:
466:
465:
457:
453:
449:
446:
441:
439:
435:
431:
426:
421:
417:
413:
408:
404:
402:
398:
395:, and as the
394:
389:
385:
379:
377:
371:
367:
363:
359:
355:
351:
349:
344:
343:
341:
333:
329:
326:
322:
321:George Lawson
318:
316:
312:
306:
304:
300:
296:
291:
289:
278:
275:
267:
257:
253:
249:
243:
242:
238:
233:This section
231:
227:
222:
221:
213:
211:
207:
203:
198:
196:
190:
187:
183:
179:
175:
170:
168:
164:
160:
155:
153:
149:
145:
141:
136:
134:
130:
126:
122:
118:
108:
106:
102:
98:
94:
90:
86:
82:
74:
71:
67:
63:
59:
55:
51:
45:
41:
37:
33:
26:
23:
19:
594:Tom Marsland
582:
548:
539:
463:
454:
450:
442:
409:
405:
380:
372:
368:
364:
360:
356:
352:
345:
337:
334:
330:
319:
315:Harold Clapp
307:
292:
285:
270:
264:October 2015
261:
246:Please help
234:
202:World War II
199:
191:
171:
163:WAGR S Class
156:
146:supplied by
137:
114:
97:World War II
80:
79:
22:
632:1949 deaths
627:1898 births
61:Nationality
606:Categories
588:1940–1949
500:References
376:Manchester
299:Queensland
64:Australian
445:Melbourne
235:does not
111:Biography
397:NM class
348:M class
340:Garratt
256:removed
241:sources
200:During
152:firebox
144:M class
140:Garratt
95:during
87:of the
556:
531:
184:, the
180:, the
159:4-8-2
69:Title
50:Perth
554:ISBN
529:ISBN
410:The
386:and
384:B18¼
293:The
239:any
237:cite
43:Died
38:1898
35:Born
388:C17
250:by
119:at
608::
520:^
508:^
403:.
323:,
197:.
52:,
480:)
336:6
277:)
271:(
266:)
262:(
258:.
244:.
20:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.