Knowledge

Constructible universe

Source 📝

17604: 15256: 536: 6292: 5527: 13408: 4515: 345: 7855:
Of course, any consistent theory must have a model, so even within the minimal model of set theory there are sets that are models of ZF (assuming ZF is consistent). However, those set models are non-standard. In particular, they do not use the normal element relation and they are not well founded.
6977: 12568: 336:
By limiting oneself to sets defined only in terms of what has already been constructed, one ensures that the resulting sets will be constructed in a way that is independent of the peculiarities of the surrounding model of set theory and contained in any such model.
6420: 11786: 5833: 5346: 4059: 13204: 1046: 6118: 5351: 10110:; if there are multiple sequences of parameters that define one of the sets, we choose the least one under this ordering. It being understood that each parameter's possible values are ordered according to the restriction of the ordering of 11220: 4349: 13546:
Actually, even this complex formula has been simplified from what the instructions given in the first paragraph would yield. But the point remains, there is a formula of set theory that is true only for the desired constructible set
1408: 13542: 14040: 4991: 747: 6853: 531:{\displaystyle \operatorname {Def} (X):={\Bigl \{}\{y\mid y\in X{\text{ and }}(X,\in )\models \Phi (y,z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n})\}~{\Big |}~\Phi {\text{ is a first-order formula and }}z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n}\in X{\Bigr \}}.} 12415: 877: 662: 12055: 9295: 12153: 3631: 14103: 8225: 6297: 2859: 2754: 2312: 13944: 12853: 6546: 7500: 2791: 11641: 1892: 8262: 5711: 4896: 4781: 159:
of set theory, if ZF itself is consistent. Since many other theorems only hold in systems in which one or both of the propositions is true, their consistency is an important result.
10901: 10726: 14374: 12983: 5225: 3935: 600: 12634: 12199: 10772: 9782: 9696: 5129: 773: 14688: 13595:, but that includes or is influenced by a set that is not constructible. This gives rise to the concept of relative constructibility, of which there are two flavors, denoted by 12410: 10104: 9960: 2128: 1779: 14411: 13009: 11088: 10671: 9203: 941: 13891: 12888: 10989: 4243: 3930: 3897: 14254: 10052: 14653: 12917: 9868: 9554: 9229: 13177: 13142: 12760: 12331: 11893: 11596: 10271: 9042: 7533: 4742: 2663: 2615: 2562: 2482: 2429: 2396: 2239: 1726: 1693: 1660: 1106: 249: 10605: 10200:-tuples of parameters are well-ordered by the product ordering. The formulas with parameters are well-ordered by the ordered sum (by Gödel numbers) of well-orderings. And 9095: 6287:{\displaystyle \{y\mid y\in L\;\mathrm {and} \;\mathrm {there} \;\mathrm {exists} \;x\in S\;\mathrm {such} \;\mathrm {that} \;P(x,y)\;\mathrm {holds} \;\mathrm {in} \;L\}} 5522:{\displaystyle \{x\mid x\in L_{\alpha }\;\mathrm {and} \;x\in S\;\mathrm {and} \;P(x,z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n})\;\mathrm {holds} \;\mathrm {in} \;L_{\alpha }\}\in L_{\alpha +1}} 4807: 4589: 4097: 12661: 12266: 12003: 11840: 11506: 11351: 10155: 10000: 9908: 9650: 9580: 9322: 8711: 8616: 8562: 8535: 8468: 8151: 8078: 8051: 8004: 7840: 7773: 7396: 6848: 5176: 5063: 4681: 4344: 4297: 4270: 3261: 2509: 2266: 2175: 2068: 1994: 1966: 1859: 1832: 1753: 1579: 1552: 1316: 1137: 1073: 936: 280: 129: 14501: 13452: 11813: 11559: 11405: 11296: 10928: 10846: 10799: 3687: 14463: 13966: 13797: 3209: 3177: 2898: 815: 684: 135:
in his 1938 paper "The Consistency of the Axiom of Choice and of the Generalized Continuum-Hypothesis". In this paper, he proved that the constructible universe is an
13109: 12371: 12239: 11976: 11936: 11636: 11616: 10645: 10238: 10175: 9135: 7726: 7456: 6500: 5036: 4709: 3864: 3787: 2815: 2710: 2690: 2582: 2449: 2363: 2343: 2088: 2037: 2014: 1912: 1339: 793: 14576: 13445: 13403:{\displaystyle \forall y(y\in s\iff (y\in L_{\omega +1}\land (\forall a(a\in y\iff a\in L_{5}\land Ord(a))\lor \forall b(b\in y\iff b\in L_{\omega }\land Ord(b)))))} 12786: 12707: 11049: 9828: 9115: 8989: 8963: 5873: 5680: 5645: 5610: 4541: 3844: 3818: 3307: 14431: 14162: 13847: 12588: 11459: 11432: 11378: 11269: 11242: 9716: 9603: 9486: 9466: 9426: 9386: 4510:{\displaystyle y=\{s\mid s\in L_{\alpha }\;\mathrm {and} \;\mathrm {there} \;\mathrm {exists} \;z\in x\;\mathrm {such} \;\mathrm {that} \;s\in z\}\in L_{\alpha +1}} 3658: 1485: 1458: 14840: 14550: 14220: 14191: 14136: 13754: 13683: 13622: 2529: 11532: 8177: 8104: 5706: 1938: 1805: 1238: 11094: 14889: 14869: 14808: 14788: 14759: 14739: 14719: 14625: 14605: 14521: 14330: 14310: 14290: 13817: 13723: 13703: 13651: 13593: 13565: 13197: 13089: 13069: 13049: 13029: 12937: 12727: 12681: 12351: 12290: 12219: 12173: 12095: 12075: 11956: 11916: 11860: 11479: 11324: 11029: 11009: 10948: 10819: 10625: 10576: 10552: 10501: 10481: 10458: 10438: 10418: 10398: 10378: 10358: 10334: 10314: 10294: 10218: 10198: 10128: 9802: 9736: 9623: 9527: 9507: 9446: 9406: 9362: 9342: 9176: 9156: 9062: 9009: 8937: 8917: 8897: 8874: 8849: 8827: 8799: 8779: 8759: 8731: 8684: 8664: 8636: 8586: 8508: 8488: 8438: 8398: 8374: 8350: 8326: 8302: 8282: 8124: 8024: 7977: 7957: 7937: 7917: 7897: 7877: 7813: 7793: 7746: 7702: 7682: 7656: 7636: 7616: 7596: 7576: 7556: 7436: 7416: 7369: 7349: 7329: 7309: 7289: 7269: 7241: 7217: 7197: 7174: 7154: 7134: 7114: 7085: 7065: 7045: 7025: 6997: 6821: 6801: 6778: 6758: 6738: 6718: 6698: 6673: 6653: 6633: 6613: 6586: 6566: 6480: 6460: 6440: 6113: 6093: 6073: 6053: 6033: 6013: 5993: 5973: 5953: 5933: 5913: 5893: 5575: 5547: 5216: 5196: 5149: 5083: 5016: 4835: 4649: 4629: 4609: 4569: 4317: 4205: 4185: 4165: 4137: 4117: 3755: 3735: 3707: 3540: 3520: 3500: 3480: 3460: 3440: 3420: 3400: 3367: 3347: 3327: 3281: 3229: 3141: 3121: 3101: 3081: 3046: 3026: 3006: 2986: 2966: 2946: 2918: 2203: 2148: 1627: 1607: 1525: 1505: 1431: 1344: 1278: 1258: 1208: 1188: 1161: 909: 557: 300: 208: 184: 99: 71: 2630: 17: 15983: 8856:
in his 1972 paper entitled "The fine structure of the constructible hierarchy". Instead of explaining the fine structure, we will give an outline of how
13971: 16658: 15720: 6972:{\displaystyle \{z\mid z\in L_{\alpha }\;\mathrm {and} \;z\;\mathrm {is} \;\mathrm {a} \;\mathrm {subset} \;\mathrm {of} \;x\}\in L_{\alpha +1}} 4901: 12563:{\displaystyle S=\{y\mid y\in L_{\alpha }\;\mathrm {and} \;\Phi (y,z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n})\;\mathrm {holds} \;\mathrm {in} \;(L_{\alpha },\in )\}} 693: 16741: 15882: 10463:
It is well known that the axiom of choice is equivalent to the ability to well-order every set. Being able to well-order the proper class
10180:
The well-ordering of the values of single parameters is provided by the inductive hypothesis of the transfinite induction. The values of
822: 606: 12008: 17055: 148: 9237: 12100: 3557: 17213: 15161: 16001: 17068: 16391: 15409: 15222: 14047: 6415:{\displaystyle \{y\mid \mathrm {there} \;\mathrm {exists} \;\mathrm {x} \in S\;\mathrm {such} \;\mathrm {that} \;Q(x,y)\}} 14871:
are usually not actually constructible, and the properties of these models may be quite different from the properties of
8190: 17073: 17063: 16800: 16653: 16006: 15737: 15997: 17209: 15191: 15079: 15060: 15038: 8417: 2820: 2715: 2271: 16551: 13896: 12791: 17306: 17050: 15875: 12269: 8377: 11781:{\displaystyle T=\{x\in L_{\beta }:x\in S\wedge \Phi (x,z_{i})\}=\{x\in L_{\gamma }:x\in S\wedge \Phi (x,w_{i})\}} 6505: 17628: 16611: 16304: 15715: 15309: 10400:(some other standard model of ZF with the same ordinals) and we will suppose that the formula is false if either 7461: 5828:{\displaystyle \{y\mid \;\mathrm {there} \;\mathrm {exists} \;x\in S\;\mathrm {such} \;\mathrm {that} \;P(x,y)\}} 3049: 2759: 1586: 140: 17633: 16045: 15595: 11299: 7849: 17567: 17269: 17032: 17027: 16852: 16273: 15957: 1864: 8230: 5341:{\displaystyle \{x\mid x\in S\;\mathrm {and} \;P(x,z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n})\;\mathrm {holds} \;\mathrm {in} \;L\}} 4840: 4747: 4054:{\displaystyle \{x,y\}=\{s\mid s\in L_{\alpha }\;\mathrm {and} \;(s=x\;\mathrm {or} \;s=y)\}\in L_{\alpha +1}} 17562: 17345: 17262: 16975: 16906: 16783: 16025: 15489: 15368: 10851: 10676: 795: 17487: 17313: 16999: 16633: 16232: 15732: 14335: 12942: 311: 1041:{\displaystyle z=\{y\in L_{\alpha }\ {\text{and}}\ y\in z\}\in {\textrm {Def}}(L_{\alpha })=L_{\alpha +1}} 569: 17365: 17360: 16970: 16709: 16638: 15967: 15868: 15725: 15363: 15326: 12593: 12178: 10731: 9741: 9655: 5088: 2669: 752: 14658: 12376: 10057: 9913: 7116:
by their definitions and by the rank they appear at. So one chooses the least element of each member of
2100: 1758: 17294: 16884: 16278: 16246: 15937: 14379: 12988: 11054: 10650: 9182: 7844: 1941: 15380: 14974:(1984), ch. 2, "The Constructible Universe, p.58. Perspectives in Mathematical Logic, Springer-Verlag. 13854: 12858: 10961: 4215: 3902: 3869: 17584: 17533: 17430: 16928: 16889: 16366: 16011: 15414: 15299: 15287: 15282: 14900: 14228: 10005: 2794: 2584:, such as the set of (natural numbers coding) true arithmetical statements (this can be defined from 1211: 16040: 14630: 12893: 9833: 9533: 9208: 17425: 17355: 16894: 16746: 16729: 16452: 15932: 15215: 13820: 13150: 13114: 12732: 12303: 11865: 11568: 11303: 10243: 9014: 7505: 4714: 2635: 2587: 2534: 2454: 2401: 2368: 2211: 1698: 1665: 1632: 1078: 221: 10584: 9067: 4786: 4574: 4064: 3689:. Since the element relation is the same and no new elements were added, this is the empty set of 17257: 17234: 17195: 17081: 17022: 16668: 16588: 16432: 16376: 15989: 15834: 15752: 15627: 15579: 15393: 15316: 14332:
may be a (presumably non-constructible) set or a proper class. The definition of this class uses
12639: 12244: 11981: 11818: 11484: 11329: 10133: 9965: 9873: 9628: 9559: 9300: 8689: 8594: 8540: 8513: 8446: 8129: 8056: 8029: 7982: 7818: 7751: 7374: 6826: 5154: 5041: 4654: 4322: 4275: 4248: 3374: 3234: 2487: 2244: 2153: 2046: 1972: 1944: 1837: 1810: 1731: 1582: 1557: 1530: 1294: 1115: 1051: 914: 258: 107: 14468: 11791: 11537: 11383: 11274: 10906: 10824: 10777: 17547: 17274: 17252: 17219: 17112: 16958: 16943: 16916: 16867: 16751: 16686: 16511: 16472: 16346: 16177: 16154: 15786: 15667: 15292: 14257: 10504: 10107: 3663: 2322: 14436: 13951: 13766: 3182: 3150: 2871: 800: 669: 17477: 17330: 17122: 16840: 16576: 16482: 16341: 16326: 16207: 16182: 15702: 15672: 15616: 15536: 15516: 15494: 14256:, the smallest model that contains all the real numbers, which is used extensively in modern 13757: 13094: 12356: 12224: 11961: 11921: 11621: 11601: 10630: 10223: 10160: 9120: 8401: 7711: 7441: 6485: 5021: 4694: 4688: 3849: 3760: 2925: 2800: 2695: 2675: 2567: 2434: 2348: 2328: 2073: 2022: 1999: 1897: 1324: 778: 560: 15156:. Annals of Mathematics Studies. Vol. 3. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press. 14555: 13415: 12765: 12686: 11034: 9807: 9100: 8968: 8942: 5843: 5650: 5615: 5580: 4520: 3823: 3797: 3286: 17450: 17412: 17289: 17093: 16933: 16857: 16835: 16663: 16621: 16520: 16487: 16351: 16139: 16050: 15776: 15766: 15600: 15531: 15484: 15424: 15304: 15171: 15102: 14915: 14910: 14905: 14416: 14141: 13826: 12573: 11437: 11410: 11356: 11247: 11227: 11215:{\displaystyle T=\{x\in L_{\beta }:x\in S\wedge \Phi (x,z_{i})\}=\{x\in S:\Phi (x,z_{i})\}} 10555: 10527: 9701: 9588: 9471: 9451: 9411: 9371: 8738: 8227:, properties of ordinals that depend on the absence of a function or other structure (i.e. 5554: 5219: 3636: 1463: 1436: 187: 14816: 14526: 14196: 14167: 14112: 13730: 13659: 13598: 7638:
is the smallest class containing all the ordinals that is a standard model of ZF. Indeed,
2514: 1403:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }=\bigcup _{\beta <\alpha }\operatorname {Def} (L_{\beta })\!} 8: 17579: 17470: 17455: 17435: 17392: 17279: 17229: 17155: 17100: 17037: 16830: 16825: 16773: 16541: 16530: 16202: 16102: 16030: 16021: 16017: 15952: 15947: 15771: 15682: 15590: 15585: 15399: 15341: 15272: 15208: 11511: 10523: 9364:. If one discounts (for the moment) the parameters, the formulas can be given a standard 8565: 8156: 8083: 7815:. If there is a set that is a standard model of ZF, then the smallest such set is such a 5685: 4814: 3060: 2182: 1917: 1784: 1217: 15106: 17608: 17377: 17340: 17325: 17318: 17301: 17105: 17087: 16953: 16879: 16862: 16815: 16628: 16537: 16371: 16356: 16316: 16268: 16253: 16241: 16197: 16172: 15942: 15891: 15694: 15689: 15474: 15429: 15336: 15133: 15120: 15090: 15027: 14874: 14845: 14793: 14764: 14744: 14724: 14695: 14610: 14581: 14506: 14315: 14295: 14266: 13802: 13708: 13688: 13627: 13578: 13550: 13182: 13074: 13054: 13034: 13014: 12922: 12712: 12666: 12336: 12275: 12204: 12158: 12080: 12060: 11941: 11901: 11845: 11464: 11309: 11014: 10994: 10933: 10804: 10610: 10561: 10537: 10486: 10466: 10443: 10423: 10403: 10383: 10363: 10343: 10319: 10299: 10279: 10203: 10183: 10113: 9787: 9721: 9608: 9512: 9492: 9431: 9391: 9347: 9327: 9161: 9141: 9047: 8994: 8922: 8902: 8882: 8859: 8834: 8812: 8784: 8764: 8744: 8716: 8669: 8649: 8621: 8571: 8493: 8473: 8423: 8383: 8359: 8335: 8311: 8287: 8267: 8109: 8009: 7962: 7942: 7922: 7902: 7882: 7862: 7798: 7778: 7731: 7687: 7667: 7641: 7621: 7601: 7581: 7561: 7541: 7421: 7401: 7354: 7334: 7314: 7294: 7274: 7254: 7226: 7202: 7182: 7159: 7139: 7119: 7099: 7070: 7050: 7030: 7010: 6982: 6806: 6786: 6763: 6743: 6723: 6703: 6683: 6658: 6638: 6618: 6598: 6592: 6571: 6551: 6465: 6445: 6425: 6098: 6078: 6058: 6038: 6018: 5998: 5978: 5958: 5938: 5918: 5898: 5878: 5560: 5532: 5201: 5181: 5134: 5068: 5001: 4820: 4634: 4614: 4594: 4554: 4302: 4190: 4170: 4150: 4122: 4102: 3740: 3720: 3692: 3547: 3525: 3505: 3485: 3465: 3445: 3425: 3405: 3385: 3352: 3332: 3312: 3266: 3214: 3126: 3106: 3086: 3066: 3031: 3011: 2991: 2971: 2951: 2931: 2903: 2188: 2133: 1612: 1592: 1510: 1490: 1416: 1263: 1243: 1193: 1173: 1164: 1146: 894: 884: 542: 329: 285: 193: 169: 84: 74: 56: 16561: 13705:
is the intersection of all classes that are standard models of set theory and contain
9365: 8830: 2619: 2315: 17603: 17543: 17350: 17160: 17150: 17042: 16923: 16758: 16734: 16515: 16499: 16404: 16381: 16258: 16227: 16192: 16087: 15922: 15551: 15388: 15351: 15321: 15245: 15187: 15157: 15138: 15075: 15056: 15034: 14930: 8537:
cease to have those large cardinal properties, but retain the properties weaker than
4548: 215: 78: 15091:"The Consistency of the Axiom of Choice and of the Generalized Continuum-Hypothesis" 17557: 17552: 17445: 17402: 17224: 17185: 17180: 17165: 16991: 16948: 16845: 16643: 16593: 16167: 16129: 15839: 15829: 15814: 15809: 15677: 15331: 15128: 15110: 13537:{\displaystyle \forall c\in a(\forall d\in c(d\in a\land \forall e\in d(e\in c))).} 3714: 2921: 17538: 17528: 17482: 17465: 17420: 17382: 17284: 17204: 17011: 16938: 16911: 16899: 16805: 16719: 16693: 16648: 16616: 16417: 16219: 16162: 16112: 16077: 16035: 15708: 15646: 15464: 15277: 15167: 10531: 10508: 8329: 8305: 7004: 315: 144: 27:
Particular class of sets which can be described entirely in terms of simpler sets
31: 17523: 17502: 17460: 17440: 17335: 17190: 16788: 16778: 16768: 16763: 16697: 16571: 16447: 16336: 16331: 16309: 15910: 15844: 15641: 15622: 15526: 15511: 15468: 15404: 15346: 15095:
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
14984: 14958: 14920: 8734: 8409: 8405: 8353: 4144: 2178: 1140: 211: 15151: 10296:
itself by a formula of set theory with no parameters, only the free-variables
151:
are true in the constructible universe. This shows that both propositions are
17622: 17497: 17175: 16682: 16467: 16457: 16427: 16412: 16082: 15849: 15651: 15565: 15560: 8853: 8643: 687: 322: 15819: 14035:{\displaystyle L_{\lambda }(A)=\bigcup _{\alpha <\lambda }L_{\alpha }(A)} 13575:
Sometimes it is desirable to find a model of set theory that is narrow like
186:
can be thought of as being built in "stages" resembling the construction of
132: 17397: 17244: 17145: 17137: 17017: 16965: 16874: 16810: 16793: 16724: 16583: 16442: 16144: 15927: 15799: 15794: 15612: 15541: 15499: 15358: 15255: 15142: 15115: 15048: 6760:. What we need here is to show that the intersection of the power set with 2091: 15186:. Springer Monographs in Mathematics (3rd millennium ed.). Springer. 4986:{\displaystyle \{x\mid x\in S\;\mathrm {and} \;P(x,z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n})\}} 3369:
because we are using the same element relation and no new sets were added.
17507: 17387: 16566: 16556: 16503: 16187: 16107: 16092: 15972: 15917: 15824: 15459: 15179: 15022: 10337: 9428:
is the formula with the smallest Gödel number that can be used to define
9388:
is the formula with the smallest Gödel number that can be used to define
7852:, one can show that the minimal model (if it exists) is a countable set. 7705: 136: 38: 12373:. Using this we can expand the definition of each constructible set. If 8733:. Furthermore, any strictly increasing class function from the class of 742:{\displaystyle L_{\lambda }:=\bigcup _{\alpha <\lambda }L_{\alpha }.} 16437: 16292: 16263: 16069: 15804: 15575: 15231: 8413: 152: 42: 17589: 17492: 16545: 16462: 16422: 16386: 16322: 16134: 16124: 16097: 15860: 15607: 15570: 15521: 15419: 15124: 13071:'s outside and one gets a formula that defines the constructible set 12295: 6823:
to show that there is an α such that the intersection is a subset of
2040: 1109: 14985:
An Introduction to the Fine Structure of the Constructible Hierarchy
14959:
An introduction to the fine structure of the constructible hierarchy
2924:
and the interpretation uses the real element relationship, so it is
17574: 17372: 16820: 16525: 16119: 8639: 872:{\displaystyle L:=\bigcup _{\alpha \in \mathbf {Ord} }L_{\alpha }.} 10953: 17170: 15962: 657:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}:=\operatorname {Def} (L_{\alpha }).} 15632: 15454: 2948:
is an inner model, i.e. it contains all the ordinal numbers of
14996:
Barwise 1975, page 60 (comment following proof of theorem 5.9)
12300:
There is a formula of set theory that expresses the idea that
1585:. Equality beyond this point does not hold. Even in models of 16714: 16060: 15905: 15504: 15264: 15200: 15009:, pp.427. Studies in Logic and the Foundations of Mathematics 8876:
could be well-ordered using only the definition given above.
4187:
whose elements are precisely the elements of the elements of
3053: 156: 12050:{\displaystyle L\cap {\mathcal {P}}(S)\subseteq L_{\delta }} 14925: 8686:, they have all the large cardinal properties weaker than 2314:
under a collection of nine explicit functions, similar to
14292:
is the class of sets whose construction is influenced by
10511:
because it also covers proper classes of non-empty sets.
9290:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}=\mathrm {Def} (L_{\alpha })} 7271:
is any standard model of ZF sharing the same ordinals as
81:
that can be described entirely in terms of simpler sets.
12148:{\displaystyle L\cap {\mathcal {P}}(S)\in L_{\delta +1}} 7092:
One can show that there is a definable well-ordering of
3626:{\displaystyle \{\}=L_{0}=\{y\mid y\in L_{0}\land y=y\}} 2090:, and the bijection is constructible. So these sets are 10157:, so this definition involves transfinite recursion on 8666:. While some of these are not even initial ordinals in 3377:: Two sets are the same if they have the same elements. 2622: 14138:
contains a well-ordering of the transitive closure of
10821:
symbols (counting a constant symbol for an element of
2318:. This definition makes no reference to definability. 14877: 14848: 14819: 14796: 14767: 14747: 14727: 14698: 14661: 14633: 14613: 14584: 14558: 14529: 14523:
is a unary predicate. The intended interpretation of
14509: 14471: 14439: 14419: 14382: 14338: 14318: 14298: 14269: 14231: 14199: 14170: 14144: 14115: 14098:{\displaystyle L(A)=\bigcup _{\alpha }L_{\alpha }(A)} 14050: 13974: 13954: 13899: 13857: 13829: 13805: 13769: 13733: 13711: 13691: 13662: 13630: 13601: 13581: 13553: 13455: 13418: 13207: 13185: 13153: 13117: 13097: 13077: 13057: 13037: 13017: 12991: 12945: 12925: 12896: 12861: 12794: 12768: 12735: 12715: 12689: 12669: 12642: 12596: 12576: 12418: 12379: 12359: 12339: 12306: 12278: 12247: 12227: 12207: 12181: 12161: 12103: 12083: 12063: 12011: 11984: 11964: 11944: 11924: 11904: 11868: 11848: 11821: 11794: 11644: 11624: 11604: 11571: 11540: 11514: 11487: 11467: 11440: 11413: 11386: 11359: 11332: 11312: 11277: 11250: 11230: 11097: 11057: 11037: 11017: 10997: 10964: 10936: 10909: 10854: 10827: 10807: 10780: 10734: 10679: 10653: 10633: 10613: 10587: 10564: 10540: 10489: 10469: 10446: 10426: 10406: 10386: 10366: 10346: 10322: 10302: 10282: 10276:
Notice that this well-ordering can be defined within
10246: 10226: 10206: 10186: 10163: 10136: 10116: 10060: 10008: 9968: 9916: 9876: 9836: 9810: 9790: 9744: 9724: 9704: 9658: 9631: 9611: 9591: 9562: 9536: 9515: 9495: 9474: 9454: 9434: 9414: 9394: 9374: 9350: 9330: 9303: 9240: 9211: 9185: 9164: 9144: 9123: 9103: 9070: 9050: 9017: 8997: 8971: 8945: 8925: 8905: 8885: 8862: 8837: 8815: 8787: 8767: 8747: 8719: 8692: 8672: 8652: 8624: 8597: 8574: 8543: 8516: 8510:. So all the large cardinals whose existence implies 8496: 8476: 8449: 8426: 8386: 8362: 8338: 8314: 8290: 8270: 8233: 8193: 8159: 8132: 8112: 8086: 8059: 8032: 8012: 7985: 7965: 7945: 7925: 7905: 7885: 7865: 7821: 7801: 7781: 7754: 7734: 7714: 7690: 7670: 7644: 7624: 7604: 7584: 7564: 7544: 7508: 7464: 7444: 7424: 7404: 7377: 7357: 7337: 7317: 7297: 7277: 7257: 7229: 7205: 7185: 7162: 7142: 7122: 7102: 7073: 7067:) containing exactly one element from each member of 7053: 7033: 7013: 6985: 6856: 6829: 6809: 6789: 6766: 6746: 6726: 6706: 6686: 6661: 6641: 6621: 6601: 6574: 6554: 6508: 6488: 6468: 6448: 6428: 6300: 6121: 6101: 6081: 6061: 6041: 6021: 6001: 5981: 5961: 5941: 5921: 5901: 5881: 5846: 5714: 5688: 5653: 5618: 5583: 5563: 5535: 5354: 5228: 5204: 5184: 5157: 5137: 5091: 5071: 5044: 5024: 5004: 4904: 4843: 4823: 4789: 4750: 4717: 4697: 4657: 4637: 4617: 4597: 4577: 4557: 4523: 4352: 4325: 4305: 4278: 4251: 4218: 4193: 4173: 4153: 4125: 4105: 4067: 3938: 3905: 3872: 3852: 3826: 3800: 3763: 3743: 3723: 3695: 3666: 3639: 3560: 3528: 3508: 3488: 3468: 3448: 3428: 3408: 3388: 3355: 3335: 3315: 3289: 3269: 3237: 3217: 3185: 3153: 3129: 3109: 3089: 3069: 3034: 3014: 2994: 2974: 2954: 2934: 2906: 2874: 2864: 2823: 2803: 2762: 2718: 2698: 2678: 2638: 2590: 2570: 2564:
already contains certain non-arithmetical subsets of
2537: 2517: 2490: 2457: 2437: 2404: 2371: 2351: 2331: 2274: 2247: 2214: 2208:
Another definition, due to Gödel, characterizes each
2191: 2156: 2136: 2103: 2076: 2049: 2025: 2002: 1975: 1947: 1920: 1900: 1867: 1840: 1813: 1787: 1761: 1734: 1701: 1668: 1635: 1615: 1595: 1560: 1533: 1513: 1493: 1466: 1439: 1419: 1347: 1327: 1297: 1283: 1266: 1246: 1220: 1196: 1176: 1149: 1118: 1081: 1054: 944: 917: 897: 825: 803: 781: 755: 696: 672: 609: 572: 545: 348: 288: 261: 224: 196: 172: 147:
excluded), and also that the axiom of choice and the
110: 87: 59: 11898:
So all the constructible subsets of an infinite set
9698:
is the sequence of parameters that can be used with
9556:
in the Gödel numbering. Henceforth, we suppose that
2531:
is definable, i.e., arithmetic). On the other hand,
14413:except instead of evaluating the truth of formulas 7027:of mutually disjoint nonempty sets, there is a set 5577:and any mapping (formally defined as a proposition 2511:can be coded by natural numbers in such a way that 15026: 14883: 14863: 14834: 14802: 14782: 14753: 14733: 14721:is always a model of the axiom of choice. Even if 14713: 14682: 14647: 14619: 14599: 14570: 14544: 14515: 14495: 14457: 14425: 14405: 14368: 14324: 14304: 14284: 14248: 14214: 14185: 14164:, then this can be extended to a well-ordering of 14156: 14130: 14097: 14034: 13960: 13938: 13885: 13841: 13811: 13791: 13748: 13717: 13697: 13677: 13645: 13616: 13587: 13559: 13536: 13439: 13402: 13191: 13171: 13136: 13103: 13083: 13063: 13043: 13023: 13003: 12977: 12931: 12911: 12882: 12847: 12780: 12754: 12721: 12701: 12675: 12655: 12628: 12582: 12562: 12404: 12365: 12345: 12325: 12296:Constructible sets are definable from the ordinals 12284: 12260: 12241:, the "power set" must then have cardinal exactly 12233: 12213: 12193: 12167: 12147: 12089: 12069: 12049: 11997: 11970: 11950: 11930: 11910: 11887: 11854: 11834: 11807: 11780: 11630: 11610: 11590: 11553: 11526: 11500: 11473: 11453: 11426: 11399: 11372: 11345: 11318: 11290: 11263: 11236: 11214: 11082: 11043: 11023: 11003: 10983: 10942: 10922: 10895: 10840: 10813: 10793: 10766: 10720: 10665: 10639: 10619: 10599: 10570: 10546: 10495: 10475: 10452: 10432: 10412: 10392: 10372: 10352: 10328: 10308: 10288: 10265: 10232: 10212: 10192: 10169: 10149: 10122: 10098: 10046: 9994: 9954: 9902: 9862: 9822: 9796: 9776: 9730: 9710: 9690: 9644: 9617: 9597: 9574: 9548: 9521: 9501: 9480: 9460: 9440: 9420: 9400: 9380: 9356: 9336: 9316: 9289: 9223: 9197: 9170: 9150: 9129: 9109: 9089: 9056: 9036: 9003: 8983: 8957: 8931: 8911: 8891: 8868: 8843: 8821: 8793: 8773: 8753: 8725: 8705: 8678: 8658: 8630: 8610: 8580: 8556: 8529: 8502: 8482: 8462: 8432: 8392: 8368: 8344: 8320: 8296: 8276: 8256: 8220:{\displaystyle \mathrm {Ord} \subset L\subseteq V} 8219: 8171: 8145: 8118: 8098: 8072: 8045: 8018: 7998: 7971: 7951: 7931: 7911: 7891: 7871: 7834: 7807: 7787: 7767: 7740: 7720: 7696: 7676: 7650: 7630: 7610: 7590: 7570: 7550: 7527: 7494: 7450: 7430: 7410: 7390: 7363: 7343: 7323: 7303: 7283: 7263: 7235: 7211: 7191: 7168: 7148: 7128: 7108: 7079: 7059: 7039: 7019: 6991: 6971: 6842: 6815: 6795: 6772: 6752: 6732: 6712: 6692: 6667: 6647: 6627: 6607: 6580: 6560: 6540: 6494: 6474: 6454: 6434: 6414: 6286: 6107: 6087: 6067: 6047: 6027: 6007: 5987: 5967: 5947: 5927: 5907: 5887: 5867: 5827: 5700: 5674: 5639: 5604: 5569: 5541: 5521: 5340: 5210: 5190: 5170: 5143: 5123: 5077: 5057: 5030: 5010: 4985: 4890: 4829: 4801: 4775: 4736: 4703: 4675: 4643: 4623: 4603: 4583: 4563: 4535: 4509: 4338: 4311: 4291: 4264: 4237: 4199: 4179: 4159: 4131: 4111: 4091: 4053: 3924: 3891: 3858: 3838: 3812: 3781: 3749: 3729: 3701: 3681: 3652: 3625: 3534: 3514: 3494: 3474: 3454: 3434: 3414: 3394: 3361: 3341: 3321: 3301: 3275: 3255: 3223: 3203: 3171: 3135: 3115: 3095: 3075: 3040: 3020: 3000: 2980: 2960: 2940: 2912: 2892: 2853: 2809: 2785: 2748: 2704: 2684: 2657: 2624: 2609: 2576: 2556: 2523: 2503: 2476: 2443: 2423: 2390: 2357: 2337: 2306: 2260: 2233: 2197: 2169: 2142: 2122: 2082: 2062: 2031: 2008: 1988: 1960: 1932: 1906: 1886: 1853: 1826: 1799: 1773: 1747: 1720: 1687: 1654: 1621: 1601: 1573: 1546: 1519: 1499: 1479: 1452: 1425: 1402: 1333: 1310: 1272: 1252: 1232: 1202: 1182: 1155: 1131: 1100: 1067: 1040: 930: 903: 871: 809: 787: 767: 741: 678: 656: 594: 551: 530: 294: 274: 243: 202: 178: 123: 93: 65: 15074:. Lecture Notes in Mathematics. Springer-Verlag. 12155:. And this in turn means that the "power set" of 8179:does not hold in any other standard model of ZF. 3482:'s transitivity, they have the same elements (in 1399: 520: 467: 369: 282:. By contrast, in Gödel's constructible universe 17620: 13567:and that contains parameters only for ordinals. 12890:is the result of restricting each quantifier in 10554:requires (at least as shown above) the use of a 8737:to itself can be extended in a unique way to an 2398:(because the arithmetic definition gives one in 10954:The generalized continuum hypothesis holds in L 10514: 10220:is well-ordered by the ordered sum (indexed by 8408:become strongly Mahlo. And more generally, any 2854:{\displaystyle L_{\omega _{1}^{\mathrm {CK} }}} 2749:{\displaystyle L_{\omega _{1}^{\mathrm {CK} }}} 2307:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }\cup \{L_{\alpha }\}} 2181:, i.e., formulas of set theory containing only 2094:in any model of set theory that includes them. 14193:. Otherwise, the axiom of choice will fail in 13939:{\displaystyle \mathrm {Def} (L_{\alpha }(A))} 12848:{\displaystyle \Psi (X,y,z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n})} 7096:, in particular based on ordering all sets in 6548:. Then one can use the axiom of separation in 5995:, but it is still a finite formula, and since 3052:, which means that it satisfies the following 306:those subsets of the previous stage that are: 15876: 15216: 15101:(12). National Academy of Sciences: 556–557. 12663:. This is equivalent to saying that: for all 8264:formulas) are preserved when going down from 1210:itself is the "constructible universe". The " 332:interpreted to range over the previous stage. 14151: 14145: 13836: 13830: 13570: 13166: 13154: 12557: 12425: 12188: 12182: 11918:have ranks with (at most) the same cardinal 11775: 11716: 11710: 11651: 11380:, and having the same first-order theory as 11209: 11169: 11163: 11104: 7246: 7156:using the axioms of union and separation in 6947: 6857: 6541:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }\in L_{\alpha +1}} 6409: 6301: 6281: 6122: 5822: 5715: 5497: 5355: 5335: 5229: 4980: 4905: 4670: 4664: 4485: 4359: 4080: 4068: 4029: 3957: 3951: 3939: 3776: 3764: 3670: 3667: 3620: 3583: 3564: 3561: 2301: 2288: 990: 951: 459: 374: 15153:The Consistency of the Continuum Hypothesis 13051:and apply existential quantifiers over the 10507:, which is more powerful than the ordinary 8568:cease to be measurable but remain Mahlo in 7495:{\displaystyle \mathrm {Def} (L_{\alpha })} 6568:to finish showing that it is an element of 2968:and it has no "extra" sets beyond those in 2786:{\displaystyle \omega _{1}^{\mathrm {CK} }} 16068: 15883: 15869: 15223: 15209: 13350: 13346: 13284: 13280: 13230: 13226: 12534: 12525: 12507: 12462: 12450: 7458:. And the same formulas and parameters in 6943: 6934: 6913: 6907: 6898: 6894: 6882: 6462:. Again using the axiom of replacement in 6390: 6375: 6360: 6348: 6327: 6277: 6268: 6250: 6231: 6216: 6201: 6191: 6170: 6152: 6140: 5803: 5788: 5773: 5763: 5742: 5724: 5486: 5477: 5459: 5414: 5402: 5392: 5380: 5331: 5322: 5304: 5259: 5247: 4935: 4923: 4475: 4460: 4445: 4435: 4414: 4396: 4384: 4016: 4007: 3994: 3982: 1139:. Consequently, this is a tower of nested 15132: 15114: 14239: 13799:= the smallest transitive set containing 10340:regardless of whether it is evaluated in 7658:is the intersection of all such classes. 7223:assume that the axiom of choice holds in 1887:{\displaystyle \alpha =\omega _{\alpha }} 8809:There are various ways of well-ordering 8804: 8801:a nice structure of repeating segments. 8257:{\displaystyle \Pi _{1}^{\mathrm {ZF} }} 8182: 4891:{\displaystyle P(x,z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n})} 4776:{\displaystyle \omega \in L_{\omega +1}} 2241:as the intersection of the power set of 480: is a first-order formula and  15069: 15021: 13179:is constructible. It is the unique set 7502:produce the same constructible sets in 2039:is an infinite ordinal then there is a 1728:is a proper subset of the power set of 14: 17621: 15890: 15047: 14761:is not necessarily itself a member of 10896:{\displaystyle P(z_{1},\ldots ,z_{k})} 10721:{\displaystyle P(z_{1},\ldots ,z_{k})} 8564:which they also possess. For example, 15864: 15204: 15149: 15088: 14369:{\displaystyle \mathrm {Def} _{A}(X)} 12978:{\displaystyle z_{k}\in L_{\beta +1}} 10578:. Here we describe such a principle. 8404:become strongly inaccessible. Weakly 7728:is the set of ordinals that occur in 7199:is a model of ZFC only requires that 6680:In general, some subsets of a set in 2484:is arithmetical (because elements of 1190:are called "constructible" sets; and 15178: 14961:" (1974). Accessed 20 February 2023. 11306:, there must be some transitive set 6482:, we can show that there must be an 5975:is a much more complex formula than 595:{\displaystyle L_{0}:=\varnothing .} 12629:{\displaystyle z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n}} 12194:{\displaystyle \vert \delta \vert } 10767:{\displaystyle z_{1},\ldots ,z_{k}} 10106:), etc. This is called the reverse 9777:{\displaystyle w_{1},\ldots ,w_{n}} 9691:{\displaystyle z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n}} 9297:uses formulas with parameters from 6720:So the whole power set of a set in 6075:; thus we can apply replacement in 5124:{\displaystyle z_{1},\ldots ,z_{n}} 3442:and they have the same elements in 3231:is well founded. In particular, if 768:{\displaystyle \alpha <\lambda } 24: 18:Gödel's constructible universe 14683:{\displaystyle \mathrm {Def} _{A}} 14670: 14667: 14664: 14641: 14638: 14635: 14420: 14390: 14387: 14384: 14347: 14344: 14341: 13907: 13904: 13901: 13498: 13471: 13456: 13328: 13262: 13208: 12897: 12862: 12795: 12577: 12530: 12527: 12521: 12518: 12515: 12512: 12509: 12463: 12458: 12455: 12452: 12405:{\displaystyle S\in L_{\alpha +1}} 12112: 12020: 11750: 11685: 11231: 11184: 11138: 10336:. And this formula gives the same 10099:{\displaystyle z_{n-2}<w_{n-2}} 9955:{\displaystyle z_{n-1}<w_{n-1}} 9705: 9592: 9569: 9563: 9543: 9537: 9475: 9455: 9415: 9375: 9267: 9264: 9261: 8698: 8603: 8549: 8522: 8455: 8248: 8245: 8235: 8201: 8198: 8195: 7472: 7469: 7466: 6939: 6936: 6930: 6927: 6924: 6921: 6918: 6915: 6909: 6903: 6900: 6890: 6887: 6884: 6502:such that this set is a subset of 6386: 6383: 6380: 6377: 6371: 6368: 6365: 6362: 6350: 6344: 6341: 6338: 6335: 6332: 6329: 6323: 6320: 6317: 6314: 6311: 6273: 6270: 6264: 6261: 6258: 6255: 6252: 6227: 6224: 6221: 6218: 6212: 6209: 6206: 6203: 6187: 6184: 6181: 6178: 6175: 6172: 6166: 6163: 6160: 6157: 6154: 6148: 6145: 6142: 5799: 5796: 5793: 5790: 5784: 5781: 5778: 5775: 5759: 5756: 5753: 5750: 5747: 5744: 5738: 5735: 5732: 5729: 5726: 5482: 5479: 5473: 5470: 5467: 5464: 5461: 5410: 5407: 5404: 5388: 5385: 5382: 5327: 5324: 5318: 5315: 5312: 5309: 5306: 5255: 5252: 5249: 4931: 4928: 4925: 4471: 4468: 4465: 4462: 4456: 4453: 4450: 4447: 4431: 4428: 4425: 4422: 4419: 4416: 4410: 4407: 4404: 4401: 4398: 4392: 4389: 4386: 4012: 4009: 3990: 3987: 3984: 2865:L is a standard inner model of ZFC 2843: 2840: 2777: 2774: 2738: 2735: 2158: 2123:{\displaystyle {\textrm {Def}}(X)} 1774:{\displaystyle \alpha >\omega } 475: 415: 214:. In von Neumann's universe, at a 25: 17645: 14406:{\displaystyle \mathrm {Def} (X)} 13004:{\displaystyle \beta <\alpha } 12333:. It has only free variables for 11083:{\displaystyle T\in L_{\beta +1}} 10666:{\displaystyle \beta >\alpha } 9198:{\displaystyle \alpha <\beta } 8939:and we wish to determine whether 8418:list of large cardinal properties 8356:become strong limit cardinals in 4691:can be used to show each ordinal 3349:, then it is still disjoint from 1914:is inaccessible. More generally, 1581:: their elements are exactly the 1284:Additional facts about the sets L 586: 17602: 15254: 13886:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}(A)} 13111:that appear in expressions like 12883:{\displaystyle \Psi (X,\ldots )} 12270:generalized continuum hypothesis 10984:{\displaystyle S\in L_{\alpha }} 8378:generalized continuum hypothesis 8153:that is a model of ZF. However, 5875:be the formula that relativizes 5018:, one can show that there is an 4238:{\displaystyle x\in L_{\alpha }} 4099:and it has the same meaning for 3925:{\displaystyle y\in L_{\alpha }} 3892:{\displaystyle x\in L_{\alpha }} 3008:might be strictly a subclass of 2797:), and conversely any subset of 850: 847: 844: 149:generalized continuum hypothesis 14249:{\displaystyle L(\mathbb {R} )} 11481:will have the same cardinal as 11011:be any constructible subset of 10047:{\displaystyle z_{n-1}=w_{n-1}} 8852:, which was first described by 8308:of cardinals remain initial in 4998:By induction on subformulas of 4272:and their elements are also in 255:subsets of the previous stage, 15230: 15029:Admissible Sets and Structures 14999: 14990: 14977: 14964: 14951: 14942: 14858: 14852: 14829: 14823: 14777: 14771: 14708: 14702: 14648:{\displaystyle \mathrm {Def} } 14594: 14588: 14539: 14533: 14490: 14472: 14452: 14440: 14400: 14394: 14363: 14357: 14279: 14273: 14243: 14235: 14209: 14203: 14180: 14174: 14125: 14119: 14092: 14086: 14060: 14054: 14029: 14023: 13991: 13985: 13933: 13930: 13924: 13911: 13880: 13874: 13786: 13780: 13743: 13737: 13672: 13666: 13640: 13634: 13611: 13605: 13528: 13525: 13522: 13510: 13483: 13468: 13434: 13428: 13397: 13394: 13391: 13388: 13385: 13379: 13347: 13334: 13322: 13319: 13313: 13281: 13268: 13259: 13231: 13227: 13214: 12912:{\displaystyle \Phi (\ldots )} 12906: 12900: 12877: 12865: 12842: 12798: 12554: 12535: 12504: 12466: 12123: 12117: 12031: 12025: 11772: 11753: 11707: 11688: 11206: 11187: 11160: 11141: 10890: 10858: 10715: 10683: 10627:to prove that for any ordinal 9863:{\displaystyle z_{n}<w_{n}} 9549:{\displaystyle \Phi <\Psi } 9284: 9271: 9224:{\displaystyle \beta =\alpha } 9205:. Henceforth, we suppose that 7489: 7476: 6979:. Thus the required set is in 6406: 6394: 6247: 6235: 5862: 5850: 5819: 5807: 5669: 5657: 5634: 5622: 5599: 5587: 5456: 5418: 5301: 5263: 4977: 4939: 4885: 4847: 4026: 3995: 3263:, then by the transitivity of 3198: 3186: 3166: 3154: 2887: 2875: 2185:) that use as parameters only 2177:formulas (with respect to the 2117: 2111: 1396: 1383: 1016: 1003: 648: 635: 456: 418: 409: 397: 361: 355: 139:of ZF set theory (that is, of 51:Gödel's constructible universe 13: 1: 17563:History of mathematical logic 15015: 13172:{\displaystyle \{5,\omega \}} 13137:{\displaystyle x=L_{\alpha }} 12755:{\displaystyle X=L_{\alpha }} 12709:if and only if [there exists 12326:{\displaystyle X=L_{\alpha }} 12057:serves as the "power set" of 11888:{\displaystyle L_{\gamma +1}} 11591:{\displaystyle K=L_{\gamma }} 10266:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}} 9037:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}} 7528:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}} 7219:be a model of ZF, i.e. we do 6655:are precisely the subsets of 5218:), the latter is called the " 4737:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}} 3846:, then there is some ordinal 2658:{\displaystyle L_{\omega +2}} 2610:{\displaystyle L_{\omega +1}} 2557:{\displaystyle L_{\omega +2}} 2477:{\displaystyle L_{\omega +1}} 2431:). Conversely, any subset of 2424:{\displaystyle L_{\omega +1}} 2391:{\displaystyle L_{\omega +1}} 2234:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}} 1721:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}} 1688:{\displaystyle V_{\omega +1}} 1655:{\displaystyle L_{\omega +1}} 1291:An equivalent definition for 1101:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha +1}} 244:{\displaystyle V_{\alpha +1}} 17488:Primitive recursive function 13685:for a non-constructible set 13199:that satisfies the formula: 12268:. But this is precisely the 11618:having the same cardinal as 10600:{\displaystyle n<\omega } 9090:{\displaystyle L_{\beta +1}} 8829:. Some of these involve the 6635:, such that the elements of 4802:{\displaystyle \omega \in L} 4584:{\displaystyle \varnothing } 4092:{\displaystyle \{x,y\}\in L} 3211:, which is well founded, so 1260:) is constructible, i.e. in 325:from the previous stage and, 210:. The stages are indexed by 162: 7: 15055:. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. 15033:. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. 14987:(p.2). Accessed 2021-05-12. 14894: 14790:, although it always is if 13011:. Combine formulas for the 12656:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 12261:{\displaystyle \kappa ^{+}} 11998:{\displaystyle \kappa ^{+}} 11978:is the initial ordinal for 11835:{\displaystyle L_{\gamma }} 11501:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 11346:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 10930:if and only if it holds in 10848:as one symbol) we get that 10673:such that for any sentence 10483:(as we have done here with 10150:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 9995:{\displaystyle z_{n}=w_{n}} 9903:{\displaystyle z_{n}=w_{n}} 9645:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 9575:{\displaystyle \Psi =\Phi } 9368:by the natural numbers. If 9317:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 8706:{\displaystyle 0^{\sharp }} 8611:{\displaystyle 0^{\sharp }} 8557:{\displaystyle 0^{\sharp }} 8530:{\displaystyle 0^{\sharp }} 8463:{\displaystyle 0^{\sharp }} 8146:{\displaystyle L_{\kappa }} 8073:{\displaystyle L_{\kappa }} 8046:{\displaystyle L_{\kappa }} 7999:{\displaystyle L_{\kappa }} 7848:of ZFC. Using the downward 7835:{\displaystyle L_{\kappa }} 7768:{\displaystyle L_{\kappa }} 7391:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 7179:Notice that the proof that 6850:. Then the intersection is 6843:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 5171:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 5058:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 4676:{\displaystyle y\cup \{y\}} 4339:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 4292:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 4265:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 4245:, then its elements are in 3256:{\displaystyle y\in x\in L} 2504:{\displaystyle L_{\omega }} 2261:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 2170:{\displaystyle \Delta _{0}} 2063:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 1996:for all infinite cardinals 1989:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 1961:{\displaystyle H_{\alpha }} 1854:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 1827:{\displaystyle V_{\alpha }} 1748:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 1574:{\displaystyle V_{\omega }} 1547:{\displaystyle L_{\omega }} 1311:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 1240:", says that every set (of 1132:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 1108:, which is a subset of the 1068:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 931:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 275:{\displaystyle V_{\alpha }} 141:Zermelo–Fraenkel set theory 124:{\displaystyle L_{\alpha }} 10: 17650: 16552:Schröder–Bernstein theorem 16279:Monadic predicate calculus 15938:Foundations of mathematics 15721:von Neumann–Bernays–Gödel 15007:Classical Recursion Theory 14496:{\displaystyle (X,\in ,A)} 11808:{\displaystyle L_{\beta }} 11554:{\displaystyle L_{\beta }} 11400:{\displaystyle L_{\beta }} 11291:{\displaystyle L_{\beta }} 10923:{\displaystyle L_{\beta }} 10841:{\displaystyle L_{\beta }} 10801:and containing fewer than 10794:{\displaystyle L_{\beta }} 10518:has a reflection principle 8919:are two different sets in 5915:, i.e. all quantifiers in 2900:is a standard model, i.e. 29: 17598: 17585:Philosophy of mathematics 17534:Automated theorem proving 17516: 17411: 17243: 17136: 16988: 16705: 16681: 16659:Von Neumann–Bernays–Gödel 16604: 16498: 16402: 16300: 16291: 16218: 16153: 16059: 15981: 15898: 15785: 15748: 15660: 15550: 15522:One-to-one correspondence 15438: 15379: 15263: 15252: 15238: 14901:Axiom of constructibility 14578:. Then the definition of 13968:is a limit ordinal, then 13571:Relative constructibility 11842:have the same theory. So 7842:. This set is called the 7247:L is absolute and minimal 3682:{\displaystyle \{\}\in L} 3502:). So they are equal (in 2130:is the set of subsets of 1212:axiom of constructibility 340:Define the Def operator: 15070:Felgner, Ulrich (1971). 14936: 14458:{\displaystyle (X,\in )} 13961:{\displaystyle \lambda } 13819:as an element, i.e. the 13792:{\displaystyle L_{0}(A)} 13091:using only the ordinals 13031:'s with the formula for 11300:Löwenheim–Skolem theorem 7850:Löwenheim–Skolem theorem 5529:. Thus the subset is in 3204:{\displaystyle (V,\in )} 3172:{\displaystyle (L,\in )} 2893:{\displaystyle (L,\in )} 1583:hereditarily finite sets 810:{\displaystyle \lambda } 679:{\displaystyle \lambda } 30:Not to be confused with 17235:Self-verifying theories 17056:Tarski's axiomatization 16007:Tarski's undefinability 16002:incompleteness theorems 15072:Models of ZF-Set Theory 14376:, which is the same as 13104:{\displaystyle \alpha } 12366:{\displaystyle \alpha } 12234:{\displaystyle \kappa } 11971:{\displaystyle \delta } 11931:{\displaystyle \kappa } 11631:{\displaystyle \alpha } 11611:{\displaystyle \gamma } 10640:{\displaystyle \alpha } 10503:) is equivalent to the 10233:{\displaystyle \alpha } 10170:{\displaystyle \alpha } 9130:{\displaystyle \alpha } 7721:{\displaystyle \kappa } 7708:of ZF, and the ordinal 7451:{\displaystyle \alpha } 6740:will usually not be in 6495:{\displaystyle \alpha } 6055:must be a mapping over 5031:{\displaystyle \alpha } 4704:{\displaystyle \alpha } 3859:{\displaystyle \alpha } 3782:{\displaystyle \{x,y\}} 3375:Axiom of extensionality 2810:{\displaystyle \omega } 2705:{\displaystyle \omega } 2685:{\displaystyle \omega } 2577:{\displaystyle \omega } 2444:{\displaystyle \omega } 2358:{\displaystyle \omega } 2338:{\displaystyle \omega } 2083:{\displaystyle \alpha } 2032:{\displaystyle \alpha } 2009:{\displaystyle \alpha } 1907:{\displaystyle \alpha } 1413:For any finite ordinal 1334:{\displaystyle \alpha } 788:{\displaystyle \alpha } 131:. It was introduced by 103:constructible hierarchy 17629:Constructible universe 17609:Mathematics portal 17220:Proof of impossibility 16868:propositional variable 16178:Propositional calculus 15480:Constructible universe 15300:Constructibility (V=L) 15116:10.1073/pnas.24.12.556 14885: 14865: 14836: 14810:is a set of ordinals. 14804: 14784: 14755: 14735: 14715: 14684: 14649: 14621: 14601: 14572: 14571:{\displaystyle y\in A} 14546: 14517: 14497: 14459: 14427: 14407: 14370: 14326: 14306: 14286: 14258:descriptive set theory 14250: 14216: 14187: 14158: 14132: 14099: 14036: 13962: 13940: 13887: 13843: 13813: 13793: 13750: 13725:and all the ordinals. 13719: 13699: 13679: 13647: 13618: 13589: 13561: 13538: 13441: 13440:{\displaystyle Ord(a)} 13404: 13193: 13173: 13138: 13105: 13085: 13065: 13045: 13025: 13005: 12979: 12933: 12913: 12884: 12849: 12782: 12781:{\displaystyle y\in X} 12756: 12723: 12703: 12702:{\displaystyle y\in S} 12677: 12657: 12630: 12584: 12564: 12406: 12367: 12347: 12327: 12286: 12262: 12235: 12215: 12195: 12169: 12149: 12097:Thus this "power set" 12091: 12071: 12051: 11999: 11972: 11952: 11932: 11912: 11889: 11856: 11836: 11809: 11782: 11632: 11612: 11592: 11555: 11528: 11502: 11475: 11455: 11428: 11401: 11374: 11347: 11320: 11292: 11265: 11238: 11216: 11084: 11045: 11044:{\displaystyle \beta } 11025: 11005: 10985: 10944: 10924: 10897: 10842: 10815: 10795: 10768: 10722: 10667: 10647:, there is an ordinal 10641: 10621: 10601: 10572: 10548: 10505:axiom of global choice 10497: 10477: 10454: 10434: 10414: 10394: 10374: 10354: 10330: 10310: 10290: 10267: 10240:) of the orderings on 10234: 10214: 10194: 10171: 10151: 10124: 10108:lexicographic ordering 10100: 10048: 9996: 9956: 9904: 9864: 9830:if and only if either 9824: 9823:{\displaystyle x<y} 9798: 9778: 9732: 9712: 9692: 9646: 9619: 9599: 9576: 9550: 9523: 9503: 9482: 9462: 9442: 9422: 9402: 9382: 9358: 9338: 9318: 9291: 9225: 9199: 9172: 9152: 9131: 9111: 9110:{\displaystyle \beta } 9091: 9058: 9038: 9005: 8985: 8984:{\displaystyle x>y} 8959: 8958:{\displaystyle x<y} 8933: 8913: 8893: 8870: 8845: 8823: 8795: 8775: 8755: 8727: 8707: 8680: 8660: 8640:closed unbounded class 8632: 8612: 8582: 8558: 8531: 8504: 8484: 8464: 8434: 8420:) will be retained in 8402:inaccessible cardinals 8394: 8370: 8346: 8322: 8298: 8278: 8258: 8221: 8173: 8147: 8120: 8100: 8074: 8047: 8020: 8000: 7973: 7953: 7933: 7913: 7893: 7873: 7836: 7809: 7789: 7769: 7742: 7722: 7698: 7678: 7652: 7632: 7612: 7592: 7572: 7552: 7529: 7496: 7452: 7432: 7412: 7392: 7365: 7345: 7325: 7305: 7285: 7265: 7237: 7213: 7193: 7170: 7150: 7130: 7110: 7081: 7061: 7041: 7021: 6993: 6973: 6844: 6817: 6797: 6774: 6754: 6734: 6714: 6694: 6669: 6649: 6629: 6609: 6582: 6562: 6542: 6496: 6476: 6456: 6436: 6416: 6288: 6109: 6089: 6069: 6049: 6029: 6009: 5989: 5969: 5949: 5929: 5909: 5889: 5869: 5868:{\displaystyle Q(x,y)} 5829: 5702: 5676: 5675:{\displaystyle P(x,z)} 5641: 5640:{\displaystyle P(x,y)} 5606: 5605:{\displaystyle P(x,y)} 5571: 5543: 5523: 5342: 5212: 5192: 5172: 5145: 5125: 5079: 5059: 5032: 5012: 4987: 4892: 4831: 4803: 4777: 4738: 4705: 4677: 4645: 4625: 4605: 4585: 4565: 4537: 4536:{\displaystyle y\in L} 4511: 4340: 4313: 4293: 4266: 4239: 4201: 4181: 4161: 4133: 4113: 4093: 4055: 3926: 3893: 3860: 3840: 3839:{\displaystyle y\in L} 3814: 3813:{\displaystyle x\in L} 3783: 3751: 3731: 3703: 3683: 3654: 3627: 3536: 3516: 3496: 3476: 3456: 3436: 3416: 3396: 3363: 3343: 3323: 3309:. If we use this same 3303: 3302:{\displaystyle y\in L} 3277: 3257: 3225: 3205: 3173: 3137: 3117: 3097: 3083:contains some element 3077: 3063:: Every non-empty set 3042: 3022: 3002: 2982: 2962: 2942: 2914: 2894: 2861:is hyperarithmetical. 2855: 2811: 2787: 2750: 2706: 2686: 2659: 2626: 2611: 2578: 2558: 2525: 2505: 2478: 2445: 2425: 2392: 2359: 2339: 2308: 2262: 2235: 2199: 2171: 2144: 2124: 2084: 2064: 2033: 2010: 1990: 1962: 1934: 1908: 1888: 1855: 1828: 1801: 1775: 1749: 1722: 1689: 1662:is a proper subset of 1656: 1623: 1603: 1575: 1548: 1521: 1501: 1487:are the same (whether 1481: 1454: 1427: 1404: 1335: 1312: 1274: 1254: 1234: 1204: 1184: 1157: 1133: 1102: 1069: 1042: 932: 905: 873: 811: 789: 769: 743: 680: 658: 596: 553: 532: 296: 276: 245: 204: 180: 125: 95: 67: 47:constructible universe 17478:Kolmogorov complexity 17431:Computably enumerable 17331:Model complete theory 17123:Principia Mathematica 16183:Propositional formula 16012:Banach–Tarski paradox 15703:Principia Mathematica 15537:Transfinite induction 15396:(i.e. set difference) 14886: 14866: 14837: 14805: 14785: 14756: 14736: 14716: 14685: 14650: 14622: 14602: 14573: 14547: 14518: 14498: 14465:, one uses the model 14460: 14428: 14426:{\displaystyle \Phi } 14408: 14371: 14327: 14307: 14287: 14251: 14217: 14188: 14159: 14157:{\displaystyle \{A\}} 14133: 14100: 14037: 13963: 13941: 13888: 13844: 13842:{\displaystyle \{A\}} 13814: 13794: 13758:transfinite recursion 13751: 13720: 13700: 13680: 13648: 13619: 13590: 13562: 13539: 13442: 13405: 13194: 13174: 13139: 13106: 13086: 13066: 13046: 13026: 13006: 12980: 12934: 12914: 12885: 12850: 12783: 12757: 12724: 12704: 12678: 12658: 12631: 12585: 12583:{\displaystyle \Phi } 12565: 12407: 12368: 12348: 12328: 12287: 12263: 12236: 12216: 12196: 12175:has cardinal at most 12170: 12150: 12092: 12072: 12052: 12000: 11973: 11958:; it follows that if 11953: 11933: 11913: 11890: 11857: 11837: 11810: 11783: 11633: 11613: 11593: 11561:, it is also true in 11556: 11529: 11503: 11476: 11456: 11454:{\displaystyle z_{i}} 11429: 11427:{\displaystyle w_{i}} 11402: 11375: 11373:{\displaystyle w_{i}} 11348: 11321: 11293: 11266: 11264:{\displaystyle z_{i}} 11239: 11237:{\displaystyle \Phi } 11217: 11085: 11046: 11031:. Then there is some 11026: 11006: 10986: 10945: 10925: 10898: 10843: 10816: 10796: 10769: 10723: 10668: 10642: 10622: 10602: 10573: 10549: 10498: 10478: 10455: 10435: 10415: 10395: 10375: 10355: 10331: 10311: 10291: 10268: 10235: 10215: 10195: 10172: 10152: 10125: 10101: 10049: 9997: 9957: 9905: 9865: 9825: 9799: 9779: 9733: 9713: 9711:{\displaystyle \Phi } 9693: 9647: 9620: 9600: 9598:{\displaystyle \Phi } 9577: 9551: 9524: 9504: 9483: 9481:{\displaystyle \Phi } 9463: 9461:{\displaystyle \Psi } 9443: 9423: 9421:{\displaystyle \Psi } 9403: 9383: 9381:{\displaystyle \Phi } 9359: 9339: 9319: 9292: 9226: 9200: 9173: 9153: 9132: 9112: 9092: 9059: 9039: 9006: 8986: 8960: 8934: 8914: 8894: 8871: 8846: 8824: 8805:L can be well-ordered 8796: 8776: 8756: 8728: 8708: 8681: 8661: 8642:of ordinals that are 8633: 8613: 8583: 8559: 8532: 8505: 8485: 8465: 8435: 8412:property weaker than 8395: 8371: 8347: 8323: 8299: 8279: 8259: 8222: 8183:L and large cardinals 8174: 8148: 8121: 8101: 8075: 8048: 8021: 8001: 7974: 7954: 7939:" result in the real 7934: 7914: 7894: 7874: 7837: 7810: 7790: 7770: 7743: 7723: 7699: 7679: 7653: 7633: 7613: 7593: 7573: 7553: 7530: 7497: 7453: 7433: 7413: 7393: 7366: 7346: 7326: 7306: 7286: 7266: 7238: 7214: 7194: 7171: 7151: 7131: 7111: 7082: 7062: 7042: 7022: 6994: 6974: 6845: 6818: 6803:. Use replacement in 6798: 6775: 6755: 6735: 6715: 6695: 6670: 6650: 6630: 6610: 6583: 6563: 6543: 6497: 6477: 6457: 6437: 6417: 6289: 6110: 6090: 6070: 6050: 6030: 6010: 5990: 5970: 5950: 5930: 5910: 5890: 5870: 5830: 5703: 5677: 5642: 5607: 5572: 5544: 5524: 5343: 5213: 5193: 5173: 5146: 5126: 5080: 5060: 5033: 5013: 4988: 4893: 4832: 4804: 4778: 4739: 4706: 4689:Transfinite induction 4678: 4646: 4626: 4606: 4586: 4566: 4551:: There exists a set 4538: 4512: 4341: 4314: 4294: 4267: 4240: 4202: 4182: 4162: 4134: 4114: 4094: 4056: 3927: 3894: 3861: 3841: 3815: 3784: 3752: 3732: 3704: 3684: 3655: 3653:{\displaystyle L_{1}} 3628: 3537: 3517: 3497: 3477: 3457: 3437: 3417: 3397: 3364: 3344: 3324: 3304: 3278: 3258: 3226: 3206: 3179:is a substructure of 3174: 3138: 3118: 3098: 3078: 3043: 3023: 3003: 2983: 2963: 2943: 2915: 2895: 2856: 2812: 2795:Church–Kleene ordinal 2788: 2751: 2707: 2687: 2660: 2627: 2612: 2579: 2559: 2526: 2506: 2479: 2446: 2426: 2393: 2360: 2340: 2309: 2263: 2236: 2200: 2172: 2145: 2125: 2085: 2065: 2034: 2011: 1991: 1963: 1935: 1909: 1889: 1856: 1829: 1802: 1781:. On the other hand, 1776: 1750: 1723: 1690: 1657: 1624: 1604: 1576: 1549: 1522: 1502: 1482: 1480:{\displaystyle V_{n}} 1455: 1453:{\displaystyle L_{n}} 1428: 1405: 1336: 1313: 1275: 1255: 1235: 1205: 1185: 1158: 1134: 1103: 1070: 1043: 933: 906: 874: 812: 790: 770: 744: 681: 659: 597: 561:transfinite recursion 554: 533: 297: 277: 246: 205: 181: 126: 96: 68: 17426:Church–Turing thesis 17413:Computability theory 16622:continuum hypothesis 16140:Square of opposition 15998:Gödel's completeness 15777:Burali-Forti paradox 15532:Set-builder notation 15485:Continuum hypothesis 15425:Symmetric difference 15150:Gödel, Kurt (1940). 15089:Gödel, Kurt (1938). 14916:Axiomatic set theory 14911:Reflection principle 14906:Statements true in L 14875: 14846: 14835:{\displaystyle L(A)} 14817: 14794: 14765: 14745: 14725: 14696: 14659: 14631: 14611: 14582: 14556: 14545:{\displaystyle A(y)} 14527: 14507: 14469: 14437: 14417: 14380: 14336: 14316: 14296: 14267: 14229: 14225:A common example is 14215:{\displaystyle L(A)} 14197: 14186:{\displaystyle L(A)} 14168: 14142: 14131:{\displaystyle L(A)} 14113: 14048: 13972: 13952: 13897: 13855: 13827: 13803: 13767: 13749:{\displaystyle L(A)} 13731: 13709: 13689: 13678:{\displaystyle L(A)} 13660: 13628: 13617:{\displaystyle L(A)} 13599: 13579: 13551: 13453: 13416: 13205: 13183: 13151: 13115: 13095: 13075: 13055: 13035: 13015: 12989: 12943: 12923: 12894: 12859: 12792: 12766: 12733: 12713: 12687: 12667: 12640: 12594: 12574: 12416: 12377: 12357: 12337: 12304: 12276: 12245: 12225: 12221:itself has cardinal 12205: 12179: 12159: 12101: 12081: 12061: 12009: 11982: 11962: 11942: 11922: 11902: 11866: 11846: 11819: 11792: 11642: 11622: 11602: 11569: 11538: 11512: 11485: 11465: 11438: 11434:substituted for the 11411: 11384: 11357: 11330: 11310: 11275: 11248: 11228: 11095: 11055: 11035: 11015: 10995: 10962: 10934: 10907: 10852: 10825: 10805: 10778: 10732: 10677: 10651: 10631: 10611: 10585: 10562: 10556:reflection principle 10538: 10528:axiom of replacement 10487: 10467: 10444: 10424: 10404: 10384: 10364: 10344: 10320: 10300: 10280: 10244: 10224: 10204: 10184: 10161: 10134: 10114: 10058: 10006: 9966: 9914: 9874: 9834: 9808: 9788: 9742: 9722: 9702: 9656: 9629: 9609: 9589: 9560: 9534: 9513: 9493: 9472: 9452: 9432: 9412: 9392: 9372: 9348: 9328: 9301: 9238: 9209: 9183: 9162: 9142: 9121: 9101: 9068: 9048: 9015: 8995: 8969: 8943: 8923: 8903: 8883: 8860: 8835: 8831:"fine structure" of 8813: 8785: 8765: 8745: 8739:elementary embedding 8717: 8690: 8670: 8650: 8622: 8595: 8572: 8566:measurable cardinals 8541: 8514: 8494: 8474: 8447: 8424: 8384: 8360: 8336: 8312: 8288: 8268: 8231: 8191: 8157: 8130: 8110: 8084: 8057: 8030: 8010: 7983: 7963: 7943: 7923: 7903: 7883: 7863: 7819: 7799: 7779: 7752: 7732: 7712: 7688: 7668: 7642: 7622: 7602: 7582: 7562: 7542: 7506: 7462: 7442: 7422: 7402: 7375: 7355: 7335: 7315: 7295: 7275: 7255: 7227: 7203: 7183: 7160: 7140: 7120: 7100: 7071: 7051: 7031: 7011: 6983: 6854: 6827: 6807: 6787: 6764: 6744: 6724: 6704: 6684: 6659: 6639: 6619: 6599: 6572: 6552: 6506: 6486: 6466: 6446: 6426: 6298: 6119: 6099: 6079: 6059: 6039: 6019: 5999: 5979: 5959: 5939: 5919: 5899: 5879: 5844: 5712: 5686: 5651: 5616: 5581: 5561: 5555:Axiom of replacement 5533: 5352: 5226: 5220:reflection principle 5202: 5182: 5155: 5135: 5089: 5069: 5042: 5022: 5002: 4902: 4841: 4837:and any proposition 4821: 4787: 4748: 4715: 4695: 4655: 4635: 4615: 4595: 4575: 4555: 4521: 4350: 4323: 4303: 4276: 4249: 4216: 4191: 4171: 4151: 4123: 4103: 4065: 3936: 3903: 3870: 3850: 3824: 3798: 3761: 3741: 3721: 3693: 3664: 3637: 3558: 3526: 3506: 3486: 3466: 3446: 3426: 3406: 3386: 3353: 3333: 3313: 3287: 3267: 3235: 3215: 3183: 3151: 3127: 3107: 3087: 3067: 3032: 3012: 2992: 2972: 2952: 2932: 2904: 2872: 2821: 2801: 2760: 2716: 2696: 2676: 2636: 2620: 2588: 2568: 2535: 2524:{\displaystyle \in } 2515: 2488: 2455: 2435: 2402: 2369: 2349: 2329: 2272: 2268:with the closure of 2245: 2212: 2189: 2154: 2134: 2101: 2074: 2047: 2023: 2000: 1973: 1945: 1918: 1898: 1865: 1838: 1811: 1785: 1759: 1732: 1699: 1666: 1633: 1613: 1593: 1558: 1531: 1511: 1491: 1464: 1437: 1417: 1345: 1325: 1295: 1264: 1244: 1218: 1194: 1174: 1147: 1116: 1079: 1052: 942: 915: 895: 823: 801: 779: 753: 694: 670: 607: 570: 543: 346: 286: 259: 222: 194: 188:von Neumann universe 170: 108: 101:is the union of the 85: 57: 17634:Works by Kurt Gödel 17580:Mathematical object 17471:P versus NP problem 17436:Computable function 17230:Reverse mathematics 17156:Logical consequence 17033:primitive recursive 17028:elementary function 16801:Free/bound variable 16654:Tarski–Grothendieck 16173:Logical connectives 16103:Logical equivalence 15953:Logical consequence 15738:Tarski–Grothendieck 15107:1938PNAS...24..556G 14607:is exactly that of 12939:. Notice that each 11527:{\displaystyle V=L} 10607:, we can use ZF in 10524:axiom of separation 9324:to define the sets 8854:Ronald Bjorn Jensen 8253: 8172:{\displaystyle V=L} 8099:{\displaystyle V=L} 7919:constructed within 7879:constructed within 7538:Furthermore, since 7331:is the same as the 6615:there exists a set 6015:was a mapping over 5701:{\displaystyle y=z} 4815:Axiom of separation 3061:Axiom of regularity 2848: 2782: 2743: 2183:bounded quantifiers 1933:{\displaystyle V=L} 1800:{\displaystyle V=L} 1233:{\displaystyle V=L} 17378:Transfer principle 17341:Semantics of logic 17326:Categorical theory 17302:Non-standard model 16816:Logical connective 15943:Information theory 15892:Mathematical logic 15327:Limitation of size 14881: 14861: 14832: 14800: 14780: 14751: 14731: 14711: 14680: 14645: 14617: 14597: 14568: 14542: 14513: 14493: 14455: 14423: 14403: 14366: 14322: 14302: 14282: 14246: 14212: 14183: 14154: 14128: 14095: 14075: 14032: 14012: 13958: 13936: 13883: 13839: 13821:transitive closure 13809: 13789: 13746: 13715: 13695: 13675: 13643: 13614: 13585: 13557: 13534: 13437: 13400: 13189: 13169: 13134: 13101: 13081: 13061: 13041: 13021: 13001: 12975: 12929: 12909: 12880: 12845: 12778: 12752: 12719: 12699: 12673: 12653: 12626: 12580: 12560: 12402: 12363: 12343: 12323: 12282: 12258: 12231: 12211: 12191: 12165: 12145: 12087: 12067: 12047: 11995: 11968: 11948: 11928: 11908: 11885: 11852: 11832: 11805: 11778: 11628: 11608: 11588: 11551: 11524: 11498: 11471: 11451: 11424: 11397: 11370: 11343: 11316: 11304:Mostowski collapse 11298:. By the downward 11288: 11261: 11234: 11212: 11080: 11041: 11021: 11001: 10981: 10940: 10920: 10893: 10838: 10811: 10791: 10764: 10718: 10663: 10637: 10617: 10597: 10568: 10544: 10493: 10473: 10450: 10430: 10410: 10390: 10370: 10350: 10326: 10306: 10286: 10263: 10230: 10210: 10190: 10167: 10147: 10120: 10096: 10044: 9992: 9952: 9900: 9860: 9820: 9794: 9784:does the same for 9774: 9728: 9708: 9688: 9642: 9615: 9595: 9572: 9546: 9519: 9499: 9478: 9468:is different from 9458: 9438: 9418: 9398: 9378: 9354: 9334: 9314: 9287: 9221: 9195: 9168: 9148: 9127: 9117:is different from 9107: 9087: 9054: 9034: 9001: 8981: 8955: 8929: 8909: 8889: 8866: 8841: 8819: 8791: 8771: 8751: 8723: 8703: 8676: 8656: 8638:, then there is a 8628: 8608: 8578: 8554: 8527: 8500: 8480: 8460: 8430: 8390: 8366: 8342: 8332:remain regular in 8318: 8294: 8274: 8254: 8234: 8217: 8169: 8143: 8116: 8096: 8070: 8043: 8016: 7996: 7969: 7949: 7929: 7909: 7889: 7869: 7832: 7805: 7785: 7765: 7738: 7718: 7694: 7674: 7648: 7628: 7608: 7588: 7568: 7548: 7525: 7492: 7448: 7438:, for any ordinal 7428: 7408: 7388: 7361: 7341: 7321: 7301: 7281: 7261: 7233: 7209: 7189: 7166: 7146: 7126: 7106: 7077: 7057: 7047:(a choice set for 7037: 7017: 6989: 6969: 6840: 6813: 6793: 6770: 6750: 6730: 6710: 6690: 6665: 6645: 6625: 6605: 6593:Axiom of power set 6578: 6558: 6538: 6492: 6472: 6452: 6442:and a subclass of 6432: 6412: 6284: 6105: 6085: 6065: 6045: 6025: 6005: 5985: 5965: 5945: 5935:are restricted to 5925: 5905: 5885: 5865: 5825: 5698: 5672: 5637: 5602: 5567: 5539: 5519: 5338: 5208: 5188: 5168: 5141: 5121: 5075: 5055: 5028: 5008: 4983: 4888: 4827: 4799: 4773: 4734: 4701: 4673: 4651:, so is the union 4641: 4621: 4601: 4581: 4561: 4533: 4507: 4336: 4309: 4289: 4262: 4235: 4197: 4177: 4157: 4129: 4109: 4089: 4051: 3922: 3889: 3856: 3836: 3810: 3779: 3747: 3727: 3699: 3679: 3650: 3623: 3548:Axiom of empty set 3532: 3512: 3492: 3472: 3452: 3432: 3412: 3392: 3359: 3339: 3319: 3299: 3273: 3253: 3221: 3201: 3169: 3143:are disjoint sets. 3133: 3113: 3093: 3073: 3038: 3018: 2998: 2978: 2958: 2938: 2910: 2890: 2851: 2829: 2807: 2783: 2763: 2746: 2724: 2702: 2682: 2655: 2607: 2574: 2554: 2521: 2501: 2474: 2441: 2421: 2388: 2355: 2335: 2304: 2258: 2231: 2205:and its elements. 2195: 2167: 2140: 2120: 2097:As defined above, 2080: 2060: 2029: 2006: 1986: 1958: 1930: 1904: 1884: 1851: 1824: 1797: 1771: 1745: 1718: 1685: 1652: 1619: 1599: 1571: 1544: 1527:or not), and thus 1517: 1497: 1477: 1450: 1423: 1400: 1376: 1331: 1308: 1270: 1250: 1230: 1200: 1180: 1153: 1129: 1098: 1065: 1038: 928: 901: 869: 855: 807: 785: 765: 739: 725: 676: 654: 592: 549: 528: 292: 272: 241: 200: 176: 121: 91: 73:, is a particular 63: 17616: 17615: 17548:Abstract category 17351:Theories of truth 17161:Rule of inference 17151:Natural deduction 17132: 17131: 16677: 16676: 16382:Cartesian product 16287: 16286: 16193:Many-valued logic 16168:Boolean functions 16051:Russell's paradox 16026:diagonal argument 15923:First-order logic 15858: 15857: 15767:Russell's paradox 15716:Zermelo–Fraenkel 15617:Dedekind-infinite 15490:Diagonal argument 15389:Cartesian product 15246:Set (mathematics) 15163:978-0-691-07927-1 14931:Ordinal definable 14884:{\displaystyle L} 14864:{\displaystyle L} 14803:{\displaystyle A} 14783:{\displaystyle L} 14754:{\displaystyle A} 14734:{\displaystyle A} 14714:{\displaystyle L} 14620:{\displaystyle L} 14600:{\displaystyle L} 14516:{\displaystyle A} 14325:{\displaystyle A} 14305:{\displaystyle A} 14285:{\displaystyle L} 14066: 13997: 13812:{\displaystyle A} 13718:{\displaystyle A} 13698:{\displaystyle A} 13646:{\displaystyle L} 13588:{\displaystyle L} 13560:{\displaystyle S} 13192:{\displaystyle s} 13147:Example: The set 13084:{\displaystyle S} 13064:{\displaystyle z} 13044:{\displaystyle S} 13024:{\displaystyle z} 12932:{\displaystyle X} 12722:{\displaystyle X} 12676:{\displaystyle y} 12570:for some formula 12346:{\displaystyle X} 12285:{\displaystyle L} 12214:{\displaystyle S} 12168:{\displaystyle S} 12090:{\displaystyle L} 12070:{\displaystyle S} 11951:{\displaystyle S} 11911:{\displaystyle S} 11855:{\displaystyle T} 11474:{\displaystyle K} 11319:{\displaystyle K} 11224:for some formula 11024:{\displaystyle S} 11004:{\displaystyle T} 10943:{\displaystyle L} 10814:{\displaystyle n} 10620:{\displaystyle V} 10571:{\displaystyle L} 10547:{\displaystyle L} 10522:Proving that the 10496:{\displaystyle L} 10476:{\displaystyle V} 10453:{\displaystyle L} 10433:{\displaystyle y} 10413:{\displaystyle x} 10393:{\displaystyle W} 10373:{\displaystyle V} 10353:{\displaystyle L} 10329:{\displaystyle y} 10309:{\displaystyle x} 10289:{\displaystyle L} 10213:{\displaystyle L} 10193:{\displaystyle n} 10123:{\displaystyle L} 9797:{\displaystyle y} 9731:{\displaystyle x} 9618:{\displaystyle n} 9522:{\displaystyle y} 9502:{\displaystyle x} 9441:{\displaystyle y} 9401:{\displaystyle x} 9357:{\displaystyle y} 9337:{\displaystyle x} 9171:{\displaystyle y} 9151:{\displaystyle x} 9064:first appears in 9057:{\displaystyle y} 9011:first appears in 9004:{\displaystyle x} 8932:{\displaystyle L} 8912:{\displaystyle y} 8892:{\displaystyle x} 8869:{\displaystyle L} 8844:{\displaystyle L} 8822:{\displaystyle L} 8794:{\displaystyle L} 8774:{\displaystyle L} 8754:{\displaystyle L} 8726:{\displaystyle L} 8679:{\displaystyle V} 8659:{\displaystyle L} 8631:{\displaystyle V} 8581:{\displaystyle L} 8503:{\displaystyle V} 8483:{\displaystyle L} 8433:{\displaystyle L} 8393:{\displaystyle L} 8369:{\displaystyle L} 8345:{\displaystyle L} 8321:{\displaystyle L} 8297:{\displaystyle L} 8277:{\displaystyle V} 8119:{\displaystyle L} 8019:{\displaystyle V} 7972:{\displaystyle L} 7952:{\displaystyle L} 7932:{\displaystyle L} 7912:{\displaystyle V} 7892:{\displaystyle L} 7872:{\displaystyle L} 7808:{\displaystyle W} 7788:{\displaystyle L} 7741:{\displaystyle W} 7697:{\displaystyle V} 7677:{\displaystyle W} 7651:{\displaystyle L} 7631:{\displaystyle L} 7611:{\displaystyle W} 7598:is a subclass of 7591:{\displaystyle L} 7571:{\displaystyle V} 7558:is a subclass of 7551:{\displaystyle L} 7431:{\displaystyle V} 7411:{\displaystyle W} 7371:. In particular, 7364:{\displaystyle V} 7344:{\displaystyle L} 7324:{\displaystyle W} 7304:{\displaystyle L} 7284:{\displaystyle V} 7264:{\displaystyle W} 7236:{\displaystyle V} 7212:{\displaystyle V} 7192:{\displaystyle L} 7169:{\displaystyle L} 7149:{\displaystyle y} 7129:{\displaystyle x} 7109:{\displaystyle L} 7080:{\displaystyle x} 7060:{\displaystyle x} 7040:{\displaystyle y} 7020:{\displaystyle x} 6992:{\displaystyle L} 6816:{\displaystyle V} 6796:{\displaystyle L} 6773:{\displaystyle L} 6753:{\displaystyle L} 6733:{\displaystyle L} 6713:{\displaystyle L} 6693:{\displaystyle L} 6668:{\displaystyle x} 6648:{\displaystyle y} 6628:{\displaystyle y} 6608:{\displaystyle x} 6581:{\displaystyle L} 6561:{\displaystyle L} 6475:{\displaystyle V} 6455:{\displaystyle L} 6435:{\displaystyle V} 6108:{\displaystyle Q} 6088:{\displaystyle V} 6068:{\displaystyle V} 6048:{\displaystyle Q} 6028:{\displaystyle L} 6008:{\displaystyle P} 5988:{\displaystyle Q} 5968:{\displaystyle Q} 5948:{\displaystyle L} 5928:{\displaystyle P} 5908:{\displaystyle L} 5888:{\displaystyle P} 5570:{\displaystyle S} 5542:{\displaystyle L} 5211:{\displaystyle L} 5191:{\displaystyle P} 5144:{\displaystyle P} 5078:{\displaystyle S} 5011:{\displaystyle P} 4830:{\displaystyle S} 4744:. In particular, 4644:{\displaystyle x} 4624:{\displaystyle y} 4604:{\displaystyle x} 4564:{\displaystyle x} 4549:Axiom of infinity 4312:{\displaystyle y} 4200:{\displaystyle x} 4180:{\displaystyle y} 4160:{\displaystyle x} 4132:{\displaystyle V} 4112:{\displaystyle L} 3750:{\displaystyle y} 3730:{\displaystyle x} 3702:{\displaystyle L} 3535:{\displaystyle L} 3515:{\displaystyle V} 3495:{\displaystyle V} 3475:{\displaystyle L} 3455:{\displaystyle L} 3435:{\displaystyle L} 3415:{\displaystyle y} 3395:{\displaystyle x} 3362:{\displaystyle x} 3342:{\displaystyle V} 3322:{\displaystyle y} 3276:{\displaystyle L} 3224:{\displaystyle L} 3136:{\displaystyle y} 3116:{\displaystyle x} 3096:{\displaystyle y} 3076:{\displaystyle x} 3041:{\displaystyle L} 3021:{\displaystyle V} 3001:{\displaystyle L} 2981:{\displaystyle V} 2961:{\displaystyle V} 2941:{\displaystyle L} 2913:{\displaystyle L} 2692:and relations on 2670:hyperarithmetical 2345:and relations on 2198:{\displaystyle X} 2143:{\displaystyle X} 2108: 1894:, for example if 1695:, and thereafter 1622:{\displaystyle L} 1602:{\displaystyle V} 1520:{\displaystyle L} 1500:{\displaystyle V} 1426:{\displaystyle n} 1361: 1273:{\displaystyle L} 1253:{\displaystyle V} 1203:{\displaystyle L} 1183:{\displaystyle L} 1156:{\displaystyle L} 1000: 980: 976: 972: 911:is an element of 904:{\displaystyle z} 832: 710: 552:{\displaystyle L} 481: 474: 464: 395: 295:{\displaystyle L} 251:to be the set of 218:stage, one takes 203:{\displaystyle V} 179:{\displaystyle L} 94:{\displaystyle L} 66:{\displaystyle L} 16:(Redirected from 17641: 17607: 17606: 17558:History of logic 17553:Category of sets 17446:Decision problem 17225:Ordinal analysis 17166:Sequent calculus 17064:Boolean algebras 17004: 17003: 16978: 16949:logical/constant 16703: 16702: 16689: 16612:Zermelo–Fraenkel 16363:Set operations: 16298: 16297: 16235: 16066: 16065: 16046:Löwenheim–Skolem 15933:Formal semantics 15885: 15878: 15871: 15862: 15861: 15840:Bertrand Russell 15830:John von Neumann 15815:Abraham Fraenkel 15810:Richard Dedekind 15772:Suslin's problem 15683:Cantor's theorem 15400:De Morgan's laws 15258: 15225: 15218: 15211: 15202: 15201: 15197: 15175: 15146: 15136: 15118: 15085: 15066: 15053:Constructibility 15049:Devlin, Keith J. 15044: 15032: 15010: 15003: 14997: 14994: 14988: 14983:K. Devlin 1975, 14981: 14975: 14972:Constructibility 14968: 14962: 14955: 14949: 14946: 14890: 14888: 14887: 14882: 14870: 14868: 14867: 14862: 14841: 14839: 14838: 14833: 14809: 14807: 14806: 14801: 14789: 14787: 14786: 14781: 14760: 14758: 14757: 14752: 14740: 14738: 14737: 14732: 14720: 14718: 14717: 14712: 14689: 14687: 14686: 14681: 14679: 14678: 14673: 14654: 14652: 14651: 14646: 14644: 14626: 14624: 14623: 14618: 14606: 14604: 14603: 14598: 14577: 14575: 14574: 14569: 14551: 14549: 14548: 14543: 14522: 14520: 14519: 14514: 14502: 14500: 14499: 14494: 14464: 14462: 14461: 14456: 14432: 14430: 14429: 14424: 14412: 14410: 14409: 14404: 14393: 14375: 14373: 14372: 14367: 14356: 14355: 14350: 14331: 14329: 14328: 14323: 14311: 14309: 14308: 14303: 14291: 14289: 14288: 14283: 14255: 14253: 14252: 14247: 14242: 14221: 14219: 14218: 14213: 14192: 14190: 14189: 14184: 14163: 14161: 14160: 14155: 14137: 14135: 14134: 14129: 14104: 14102: 14101: 14096: 14085: 14084: 14074: 14041: 14039: 14038: 14033: 14022: 14021: 14011: 13984: 13983: 13967: 13965: 13964: 13959: 13945: 13943: 13942: 13937: 13923: 13922: 13910: 13892: 13890: 13889: 13884: 13873: 13872: 13848: 13846: 13845: 13840: 13818: 13816: 13815: 13810: 13798: 13796: 13795: 13790: 13779: 13778: 13755: 13753: 13752: 13747: 13724: 13722: 13721: 13716: 13704: 13702: 13701: 13696: 13684: 13682: 13681: 13676: 13652: 13650: 13649: 13644: 13623: 13621: 13620: 13615: 13594: 13592: 13591: 13586: 13566: 13564: 13563: 13558: 13543: 13541: 13540: 13535: 13446: 13444: 13443: 13438: 13409: 13407: 13406: 13401: 13366: 13365: 13300: 13299: 13255: 13254: 13198: 13196: 13195: 13190: 13178: 13176: 13175: 13170: 13143: 13141: 13140: 13135: 13133: 13132: 13110: 13108: 13107: 13102: 13090: 13088: 13087: 13082: 13070: 13068: 13067: 13062: 13050: 13048: 13047: 13042: 13030: 13028: 13027: 13022: 13010: 13008: 13007: 13002: 12984: 12982: 12981: 12976: 12974: 12973: 12955: 12954: 12938: 12936: 12935: 12930: 12918: 12916: 12915: 12910: 12889: 12887: 12886: 12881: 12854: 12852: 12851: 12846: 12841: 12840: 12822: 12821: 12787: 12785: 12784: 12779: 12761: 12759: 12758: 12753: 12751: 12750: 12728: 12726: 12725: 12720: 12708: 12706: 12705: 12700: 12682: 12680: 12679: 12674: 12662: 12660: 12659: 12654: 12652: 12651: 12635: 12633: 12632: 12627: 12625: 12624: 12606: 12605: 12589: 12587: 12586: 12581: 12569: 12567: 12566: 12561: 12547: 12546: 12533: 12524: 12503: 12502: 12484: 12483: 12461: 12449: 12448: 12411: 12409: 12408: 12403: 12401: 12400: 12372: 12370: 12369: 12364: 12352: 12350: 12349: 12344: 12332: 12330: 12329: 12324: 12322: 12321: 12291: 12289: 12288: 12283: 12267: 12265: 12264: 12259: 12257: 12256: 12240: 12238: 12237: 12232: 12220: 12218: 12217: 12212: 12200: 12198: 12197: 12192: 12174: 12172: 12171: 12166: 12154: 12152: 12151: 12146: 12144: 12143: 12116: 12115: 12096: 12094: 12093: 12088: 12076: 12074: 12073: 12068: 12056: 12054: 12053: 12048: 12046: 12045: 12024: 12023: 12004: 12002: 12001: 11996: 11994: 11993: 11977: 11975: 11974: 11969: 11957: 11955: 11954: 11949: 11937: 11935: 11934: 11929: 11917: 11915: 11914: 11909: 11894: 11892: 11891: 11886: 11884: 11883: 11861: 11859: 11858: 11853: 11841: 11839: 11838: 11833: 11831: 11830: 11814: 11812: 11811: 11806: 11804: 11803: 11787: 11785: 11784: 11779: 11771: 11770: 11734: 11733: 11706: 11705: 11669: 11668: 11637: 11635: 11634: 11629: 11617: 11615: 11614: 11609: 11597: 11595: 11594: 11589: 11587: 11586: 11560: 11558: 11557: 11552: 11550: 11549: 11533: 11531: 11530: 11525: 11507: 11505: 11504: 11499: 11497: 11496: 11480: 11478: 11477: 11472: 11460: 11458: 11457: 11452: 11450: 11449: 11433: 11431: 11430: 11425: 11423: 11422: 11406: 11404: 11403: 11398: 11396: 11395: 11379: 11377: 11376: 11371: 11369: 11368: 11352: 11350: 11349: 11344: 11342: 11341: 11325: 11323: 11322: 11317: 11297: 11295: 11294: 11289: 11287: 11286: 11270: 11268: 11267: 11262: 11260: 11259: 11243: 11241: 11240: 11235: 11223: 11221: 11219: 11218: 11213: 11205: 11204: 11159: 11158: 11122: 11121: 11089: 11087: 11086: 11081: 11079: 11078: 11050: 11048: 11047: 11042: 11030: 11028: 11027: 11022: 11010: 11008: 11007: 11002: 10990: 10988: 10987: 10982: 10980: 10979: 10949: 10947: 10946: 10941: 10929: 10927: 10926: 10921: 10919: 10918: 10902: 10900: 10899: 10894: 10889: 10888: 10870: 10869: 10847: 10845: 10844: 10839: 10837: 10836: 10820: 10818: 10817: 10812: 10800: 10798: 10797: 10792: 10790: 10789: 10773: 10771: 10770: 10765: 10763: 10762: 10744: 10743: 10727: 10725: 10724: 10719: 10714: 10713: 10695: 10694: 10672: 10670: 10669: 10664: 10646: 10644: 10643: 10638: 10626: 10624: 10623: 10618: 10606: 10604: 10603: 10598: 10581:By induction on 10577: 10575: 10574: 10569: 10553: 10551: 10550: 10545: 10502: 10500: 10499: 10494: 10482: 10480: 10479: 10474: 10459: 10457: 10456: 10451: 10439: 10437: 10436: 10431: 10419: 10417: 10416: 10411: 10399: 10397: 10396: 10391: 10379: 10377: 10376: 10371: 10359: 10357: 10356: 10351: 10335: 10333: 10332: 10327: 10315: 10313: 10312: 10307: 10295: 10293: 10292: 10287: 10272: 10270: 10269: 10264: 10262: 10261: 10239: 10237: 10236: 10231: 10219: 10217: 10216: 10211: 10199: 10197: 10196: 10191: 10176: 10174: 10173: 10168: 10156: 10154: 10153: 10148: 10146: 10145: 10129: 10127: 10126: 10121: 10105: 10103: 10102: 10097: 10095: 10094: 10076: 10075: 10053: 10051: 10050: 10045: 10043: 10042: 10024: 10023: 10001: 9999: 9998: 9993: 9991: 9990: 9978: 9977: 9961: 9959: 9958: 9953: 9951: 9950: 9932: 9931: 9909: 9907: 9906: 9901: 9899: 9898: 9886: 9885: 9869: 9867: 9866: 9861: 9859: 9858: 9846: 9845: 9829: 9827: 9826: 9821: 9803: 9801: 9800: 9795: 9783: 9781: 9780: 9775: 9773: 9772: 9754: 9753: 9737: 9735: 9734: 9729: 9717: 9715: 9714: 9709: 9697: 9695: 9694: 9689: 9687: 9686: 9668: 9667: 9651: 9649: 9648: 9643: 9641: 9640: 9625:parameters from 9624: 9622: 9621: 9616: 9604: 9602: 9601: 9596: 9581: 9579: 9578: 9573: 9555: 9553: 9552: 9547: 9529: 9528: 9526: 9525: 9520: 9508: 9506: 9505: 9500: 9487: 9485: 9484: 9479: 9467: 9465: 9464: 9459: 9447: 9445: 9444: 9439: 9427: 9425: 9424: 9419: 9407: 9405: 9404: 9399: 9387: 9385: 9384: 9379: 9363: 9361: 9360: 9355: 9343: 9341: 9340: 9335: 9323: 9321: 9320: 9315: 9313: 9312: 9296: 9294: 9293: 9288: 9283: 9282: 9270: 9256: 9255: 9230: 9228: 9227: 9222: 9204: 9202: 9201: 9196: 9178: 9177: 9175: 9174: 9169: 9157: 9155: 9154: 9149: 9136: 9134: 9133: 9128: 9116: 9114: 9113: 9108: 9096: 9094: 9093: 9088: 9086: 9085: 9063: 9061: 9060: 9055: 9043: 9041: 9040: 9035: 9033: 9032: 9010: 9008: 9007: 9002: 8990: 8988: 8987: 8982: 8964: 8962: 8961: 8956: 8938: 8936: 8935: 8930: 8918: 8916: 8915: 8910: 8898: 8896: 8895: 8890: 8875: 8873: 8872: 8867: 8850: 8848: 8847: 8842: 8828: 8826: 8825: 8820: 8800: 8798: 8797: 8792: 8780: 8778: 8777: 8772: 8760: 8758: 8757: 8752: 8732: 8730: 8729: 8724: 8712: 8710: 8709: 8704: 8702: 8701: 8685: 8683: 8682: 8677: 8665: 8663: 8662: 8657: 8637: 8635: 8634: 8629: 8617: 8615: 8614: 8609: 8607: 8606: 8587: 8585: 8584: 8579: 8563: 8561: 8560: 8555: 8553: 8552: 8536: 8534: 8533: 8528: 8526: 8525: 8509: 8507: 8506: 8501: 8490:even if true in 8489: 8487: 8486: 8481: 8469: 8467: 8466: 8461: 8459: 8458: 8439: 8437: 8436: 8431: 8399: 8397: 8396: 8391: 8375: 8373: 8372: 8367: 8351: 8349: 8348: 8343: 8330:Regular ordinals 8327: 8325: 8324: 8319: 8306:initial ordinals 8303: 8301: 8300: 8295: 8283: 8281: 8280: 8275: 8263: 8261: 8260: 8255: 8252: 8251: 8242: 8226: 8224: 8223: 8218: 8204: 8178: 8176: 8175: 8170: 8152: 8150: 8149: 8144: 8142: 8141: 8125: 8123: 8122: 8117: 8105: 8103: 8102: 8097: 8079: 8077: 8076: 8071: 8069: 8068: 8052: 8050: 8049: 8044: 8042: 8041: 8025: 8023: 8022: 8017: 8005: 8003: 8002: 7997: 7995: 7994: 7978: 7976: 7975: 7970: 7958: 7956: 7955: 7950: 7938: 7936: 7935: 7930: 7918: 7916: 7915: 7910: 7898: 7896: 7895: 7890: 7878: 7876: 7875: 7870: 7841: 7839: 7838: 7833: 7831: 7830: 7814: 7812: 7811: 7806: 7794: 7792: 7791: 7786: 7774: 7772: 7771: 7766: 7764: 7763: 7747: 7745: 7744: 7739: 7727: 7725: 7724: 7719: 7703: 7701: 7700: 7695: 7683: 7681: 7680: 7675: 7657: 7655: 7654: 7649: 7637: 7635: 7634: 7629: 7617: 7615: 7614: 7609: 7597: 7595: 7594: 7589: 7578:and, similarly, 7577: 7575: 7574: 7569: 7557: 7555: 7554: 7549: 7534: 7532: 7531: 7526: 7524: 7523: 7501: 7499: 7498: 7493: 7488: 7487: 7475: 7457: 7455: 7454: 7449: 7437: 7435: 7434: 7429: 7417: 7415: 7414: 7409: 7397: 7395: 7394: 7389: 7387: 7386: 7370: 7368: 7367: 7362: 7350: 7348: 7347: 7342: 7330: 7328: 7327: 7322: 7310: 7308: 7307: 7302: 7290: 7288: 7287: 7282: 7270: 7268: 7267: 7262: 7242: 7240: 7239: 7234: 7218: 7216: 7215: 7210: 7198: 7196: 7195: 7190: 7175: 7173: 7172: 7167: 7155: 7153: 7152: 7147: 7135: 7133: 7132: 7127: 7115: 7113: 7112: 7107: 7086: 7084: 7083: 7078: 7066: 7064: 7063: 7058: 7046: 7044: 7043: 7038: 7026: 7024: 7023: 7018: 6998: 6996: 6995: 6990: 6978: 6976: 6975: 6970: 6968: 6967: 6942: 6933: 6912: 6906: 6893: 6881: 6880: 6849: 6847: 6846: 6841: 6839: 6838: 6822: 6820: 6819: 6814: 6802: 6800: 6799: 6794: 6779: 6777: 6776: 6771: 6759: 6757: 6756: 6751: 6739: 6737: 6736: 6731: 6719: 6717: 6716: 6711: 6699: 6697: 6696: 6691: 6674: 6672: 6671: 6666: 6654: 6652: 6651: 6646: 6634: 6632: 6631: 6626: 6614: 6612: 6611: 6606: 6587: 6585: 6584: 6579: 6567: 6565: 6564: 6559: 6547: 6545: 6544: 6539: 6537: 6536: 6518: 6517: 6501: 6499: 6498: 6493: 6481: 6479: 6478: 6473: 6461: 6459: 6458: 6453: 6441: 6439: 6438: 6433: 6421: 6419: 6418: 6413: 6389: 6374: 6353: 6347: 6326: 6293: 6291: 6290: 6285: 6276: 6267: 6230: 6215: 6190: 6169: 6151: 6114: 6112: 6111: 6106: 6094: 6092: 6091: 6086: 6074: 6072: 6071: 6066: 6054: 6052: 6051: 6046: 6034: 6032: 6031: 6026: 6014: 6012: 6011: 6006: 5994: 5992: 5991: 5986: 5974: 5972: 5971: 5966: 5954: 5952: 5951: 5946: 5934: 5932: 5931: 5926: 5914: 5912: 5911: 5906: 5894: 5892: 5891: 5886: 5874: 5872: 5871: 5866: 5834: 5832: 5831: 5826: 5802: 5787: 5762: 5741: 5707: 5705: 5704: 5699: 5681: 5679: 5678: 5673: 5646: 5644: 5643: 5638: 5611: 5609: 5608: 5603: 5576: 5574: 5573: 5568: 5557:: Given any set 5548: 5546: 5545: 5540: 5528: 5526: 5525: 5520: 5518: 5517: 5496: 5495: 5485: 5476: 5455: 5454: 5436: 5435: 5413: 5391: 5379: 5378: 5347: 5345: 5344: 5339: 5330: 5321: 5300: 5299: 5281: 5280: 5258: 5217: 5215: 5214: 5209: 5197: 5195: 5194: 5189: 5177: 5175: 5174: 5169: 5167: 5166: 5150: 5148: 5147: 5142: 5130: 5128: 5127: 5122: 5120: 5119: 5101: 5100: 5084: 5082: 5081: 5076: 5064: 5062: 5061: 5056: 5054: 5053: 5037: 5035: 5034: 5029: 5017: 5015: 5014: 5009: 4992: 4990: 4989: 4984: 4976: 4975: 4957: 4956: 4934: 4897: 4895: 4894: 4889: 4884: 4883: 4865: 4864: 4836: 4834: 4833: 4828: 4817:: Given any set 4808: 4806: 4805: 4800: 4782: 4780: 4779: 4774: 4772: 4771: 4743: 4741: 4740: 4735: 4733: 4732: 4710: 4708: 4707: 4702: 4682: 4680: 4679: 4674: 4650: 4648: 4647: 4642: 4630: 4628: 4627: 4622: 4610: 4608: 4607: 4602: 4590: 4588: 4587: 4582: 4570: 4568: 4567: 4562: 4542: 4540: 4539: 4534: 4516: 4514: 4513: 4508: 4506: 4505: 4474: 4459: 4434: 4413: 4395: 4383: 4382: 4345: 4343: 4342: 4337: 4335: 4334: 4318: 4316: 4315: 4310: 4298: 4296: 4295: 4290: 4288: 4287: 4271: 4269: 4268: 4263: 4261: 4260: 4244: 4242: 4241: 4236: 4234: 4233: 4206: 4204: 4203: 4198: 4186: 4184: 4183: 4178: 4166: 4164: 4163: 4158: 4138: 4136: 4135: 4130: 4118: 4116: 4115: 4110: 4098: 4096: 4095: 4090: 4060: 4058: 4057: 4052: 4050: 4049: 4015: 3993: 3981: 3980: 3931: 3929: 3928: 3923: 3921: 3920: 3898: 3896: 3895: 3890: 3888: 3887: 3865: 3863: 3862: 3857: 3845: 3843: 3842: 3837: 3819: 3817: 3816: 3811: 3788: 3786: 3785: 3780: 3756: 3754: 3753: 3748: 3736: 3734: 3733: 3728: 3715:Axiom of pairing 3708: 3706: 3705: 3700: 3688: 3686: 3685: 3680: 3659: 3657: 3656: 3651: 3649: 3648: 3632: 3630: 3629: 3624: 3607: 3606: 3579: 3578: 3541: 3539: 3538: 3533: 3521: 3519: 3518: 3513: 3501: 3499: 3498: 3493: 3481: 3479: 3478: 3473: 3461: 3459: 3458: 3453: 3441: 3439: 3438: 3433: 3421: 3419: 3418: 3413: 3401: 3399: 3398: 3393: 3368: 3366: 3365: 3360: 3348: 3346: 3345: 3340: 3328: 3326: 3325: 3320: 3308: 3306: 3305: 3300: 3282: 3280: 3279: 3274: 3262: 3260: 3259: 3254: 3230: 3228: 3227: 3222: 3210: 3208: 3207: 3202: 3178: 3176: 3175: 3170: 3142: 3140: 3139: 3134: 3122: 3120: 3119: 3114: 3102: 3100: 3099: 3094: 3082: 3080: 3079: 3074: 3047: 3045: 3044: 3039: 3027: 3025: 3024: 3019: 3007: 3005: 3004: 2999: 2987: 2985: 2984: 2979: 2967: 2965: 2964: 2959: 2947: 2945: 2944: 2939: 2922:transitive class 2919: 2917: 2916: 2911: 2899: 2897: 2896: 2891: 2860: 2858: 2857: 2852: 2850: 2849: 2847: 2846: 2837: 2817:that belongs to 2816: 2814: 2813: 2808: 2792: 2790: 2789: 2784: 2781: 2780: 2771: 2755: 2753: 2752: 2747: 2745: 2744: 2742: 2741: 2732: 2711: 2709: 2708: 2703: 2691: 2689: 2688: 2683: 2664: 2662: 2661: 2656: 2654: 2653: 2631: 2629: 2628: 2625:{\displaystyle } 2623: 2616: 2614: 2613: 2608: 2606: 2605: 2583: 2581: 2580: 2575: 2563: 2561: 2560: 2555: 2553: 2552: 2530: 2528: 2527: 2522: 2510: 2508: 2507: 2502: 2500: 2499: 2483: 2481: 2480: 2475: 2473: 2472: 2450: 2448: 2447: 2442: 2430: 2428: 2427: 2422: 2420: 2419: 2397: 2395: 2394: 2389: 2387: 2386: 2364: 2362: 2361: 2356: 2344: 2342: 2341: 2336: 2316:Gödel operations 2313: 2311: 2310: 2305: 2300: 2299: 2284: 2283: 2267: 2265: 2264: 2259: 2257: 2256: 2240: 2238: 2237: 2232: 2230: 2229: 2204: 2202: 2201: 2196: 2176: 2174: 2173: 2168: 2166: 2165: 2149: 2147: 2146: 2141: 2129: 2127: 2126: 2121: 2110: 2109: 2106: 2089: 2087: 2086: 2081: 2069: 2067: 2066: 2061: 2059: 2058: 2038: 2036: 2035: 2030: 2015: 2013: 2012: 2007: 1995: 1993: 1992: 1987: 1985: 1984: 1967: 1965: 1964: 1959: 1957: 1956: 1939: 1937: 1936: 1931: 1913: 1911: 1910: 1905: 1893: 1891: 1890: 1885: 1883: 1882: 1860: 1858: 1857: 1852: 1850: 1849: 1833: 1831: 1830: 1825: 1823: 1822: 1807:does imply that 1806: 1804: 1803: 1798: 1780: 1778: 1777: 1772: 1754: 1752: 1751: 1746: 1744: 1743: 1727: 1725: 1724: 1719: 1717: 1716: 1694: 1692: 1691: 1686: 1684: 1683: 1661: 1659: 1658: 1653: 1651: 1650: 1628: 1626: 1625: 1620: 1608: 1606: 1605: 1600: 1580: 1578: 1577: 1572: 1570: 1569: 1553: 1551: 1550: 1545: 1543: 1542: 1526: 1524: 1523: 1518: 1506: 1504: 1503: 1498: 1486: 1484: 1483: 1478: 1476: 1475: 1459: 1457: 1456: 1451: 1449: 1448: 1432: 1430: 1429: 1424: 1409: 1407: 1406: 1401: 1395: 1394: 1375: 1357: 1356: 1340: 1338: 1337: 1332: 1321:For any ordinal 1317: 1315: 1314: 1309: 1307: 1306: 1279: 1277: 1276: 1271: 1259: 1257: 1256: 1251: 1239: 1237: 1236: 1231: 1209: 1207: 1206: 1201: 1189: 1187: 1186: 1181: 1170:The elements of 1162: 1160: 1159: 1154: 1138: 1136: 1135: 1130: 1128: 1127: 1107: 1105: 1104: 1099: 1097: 1096: 1074: 1072: 1071: 1066: 1064: 1063: 1047: 1045: 1044: 1039: 1037: 1036: 1015: 1014: 1002: 1001: 998: 978: 977: 974: 970: 969: 968: 937: 935: 934: 929: 927: 926: 910: 908: 907: 902: 887:of all ordinals. 878: 876: 875: 870: 865: 864: 854: 853: 816: 814: 813: 808: 794: 792: 791: 786: 774: 772: 771: 766: 748: 746: 745: 740: 735: 734: 724: 706: 705: 685: 683: 682: 677: 663: 661: 660: 655: 647: 646: 625: 624: 601: 599: 598: 593: 582: 581: 558: 556: 555: 550: 537: 535: 534: 529: 524: 523: 511: 510: 492: 491: 482: 479: 472: 471: 470: 462: 455: 454: 436: 435: 396: 393: 373: 372: 301: 299: 298: 293: 281: 279: 278: 273: 271: 270: 250: 248: 247: 242: 240: 239: 209: 207: 206: 201: 185: 183: 182: 177: 130: 128: 127: 122: 120: 119: 100: 98: 97: 92: 72: 70: 69: 64: 21: 17649: 17648: 17644: 17643: 17642: 17640: 17639: 17638: 17619: 17618: 17617: 17612: 17601: 17594: 17539:Category theory 17529:Algebraic logic 17512: 17483:Lambda calculus 17421:Church encoding 17407: 17383:Truth predicate 17239: 17205:Complete theory 17128: 16997: 16993: 16989: 16984: 16976: 16696: and  16692: 16687: 16673: 16649:New Foundations 16617:axiom of choice 16600: 16562:Gödel numbering 16502: and  16494: 16398: 16283: 16233: 16214: 16163:Boolean algebra 16149: 16113:Equiconsistency 16078:Classical logic 16055: 16036:Halting problem 16024: and  16000: and  15988: and  15987: 15982:Theorems ( 15977: 15894: 15889: 15859: 15854: 15781: 15760: 15744: 15709:New Foundations 15656: 15546: 15465:Cardinal number 15448: 15434: 15375: 15259: 15250: 15234: 15229: 15194: 15164: 15082: 15063: 15041: 15018: 15013: 15004: 15000: 14995: 14991: 14982: 14978: 14969: 14965: 14957:K. J. Devlin, " 14956: 14952: 14947: 14943: 14939: 14897: 14876: 14873: 14872: 14847: 14844: 14843: 14818: 14815: 14814: 14795: 14792: 14791: 14766: 14763: 14762: 14746: 14743: 14742: 14726: 14723: 14722: 14697: 14694: 14693: 14674: 14663: 14662: 14660: 14657: 14656: 14634: 14632: 14629: 14628: 14612: 14609: 14608: 14583: 14580: 14579: 14557: 14554: 14553: 14528: 14525: 14524: 14508: 14505: 14504: 14470: 14467: 14466: 14438: 14435: 14434: 14418: 14415: 14414: 14383: 14381: 14378: 14377: 14351: 14340: 14339: 14337: 14334: 14333: 14317: 14314: 14313: 14297: 14294: 14293: 14268: 14265: 14264: 14238: 14230: 14227: 14226: 14198: 14195: 14194: 14169: 14166: 14165: 14143: 14140: 14139: 14114: 14111: 14110: 14080: 14076: 14070: 14049: 14046: 14045: 14017: 14013: 14001: 13979: 13975: 13973: 13970: 13969: 13953: 13950: 13949: 13918: 13914: 13900: 13898: 13895: 13894: 13862: 13858: 13856: 13853: 13852: 13828: 13825: 13824: 13804: 13801: 13800: 13774: 13770: 13768: 13765: 13764: 13732: 13729: 13728: 13710: 13707: 13706: 13690: 13687: 13686: 13661: 13658: 13657: 13629: 13626: 13625: 13600: 13597: 13596: 13580: 13577: 13576: 13573: 13552: 13549: 13548: 13454: 13451: 13450: 13417: 13414: 13413: 13361: 13357: 13295: 13291: 13244: 13240: 13206: 13203: 13202: 13184: 13181: 13180: 13152: 13149: 13148: 13144:as parameters. 13128: 13124: 13116: 13113: 13112: 13096: 13093: 13092: 13076: 13073: 13072: 13056: 13053: 13052: 13036: 13033: 13032: 13016: 13013: 13012: 12990: 12987: 12986: 12963: 12959: 12950: 12946: 12944: 12941: 12940: 12924: 12921: 12920: 12895: 12892: 12891: 12860: 12857: 12856: 12836: 12832: 12817: 12813: 12793: 12790: 12789: 12767: 12764: 12763: 12746: 12742: 12734: 12731: 12730: 12714: 12711: 12710: 12688: 12685: 12684: 12668: 12665: 12664: 12647: 12643: 12641: 12638: 12637: 12620: 12616: 12601: 12597: 12595: 12592: 12591: 12575: 12572: 12571: 12542: 12538: 12526: 12508: 12498: 12494: 12479: 12475: 12451: 12444: 12440: 12417: 12414: 12413: 12390: 12386: 12378: 12375: 12374: 12358: 12355: 12354: 12338: 12335: 12334: 12317: 12313: 12305: 12302: 12301: 12298: 12277: 12274: 12273: 12272:relativized to 12252: 12248: 12246: 12243: 12242: 12226: 12223: 12222: 12206: 12203: 12202: 12180: 12177: 12176: 12160: 12157: 12156: 12133: 12129: 12111: 12110: 12102: 12099: 12098: 12082: 12079: 12078: 12062: 12059: 12058: 12041: 12037: 12019: 12018: 12010: 12007: 12006: 11989: 11985: 11983: 11980: 11979: 11963: 11960: 11959: 11943: 11940: 11939: 11938:as the rank of 11923: 11920: 11919: 11903: 11900: 11899: 11873: 11869: 11867: 11864: 11863: 11847: 11844: 11843: 11826: 11822: 11820: 11817: 11816: 11799: 11795: 11793: 11790: 11789: 11766: 11762: 11729: 11725: 11701: 11697: 11664: 11660: 11643: 11640: 11639: 11623: 11620: 11619: 11603: 11600: 11599: 11582: 11578: 11570: 11567: 11566: 11564: 11545: 11541: 11539: 11536: 11535: 11513: 11510: 11509: 11492: 11488: 11486: 11483: 11482: 11466: 11463: 11462: 11445: 11441: 11439: 11436: 11435: 11418: 11414: 11412: 11409: 11408: 11391: 11387: 11385: 11382: 11381: 11364: 11360: 11358: 11355: 11354: 11337: 11333: 11331: 11328: 11327: 11311: 11308: 11307: 11282: 11278: 11276: 11273: 11272: 11255: 11251: 11249: 11246: 11245: 11229: 11226: 11225: 11200: 11196: 11154: 11150: 11117: 11113: 11096: 11093: 11092: 11091: 11068: 11064: 11056: 11053: 11052: 11036: 11033: 11032: 11016: 11013: 11012: 10996: 10993: 10992: 10975: 10971: 10963: 10960: 10959: 10956: 10935: 10932: 10931: 10914: 10910: 10908: 10905: 10904: 10884: 10880: 10865: 10861: 10853: 10850: 10849: 10832: 10828: 10826: 10823: 10822: 10806: 10803: 10802: 10785: 10781: 10779: 10776: 10775: 10758: 10754: 10739: 10735: 10733: 10730: 10729: 10709: 10705: 10690: 10686: 10678: 10675: 10674: 10652: 10649: 10648: 10632: 10629: 10628: 10612: 10609: 10608: 10586: 10583: 10582: 10563: 10560: 10559: 10539: 10536: 10535: 10532:axiom of choice 10520: 10517: 10509:axiom of choice 10488: 10485: 10484: 10468: 10465: 10464: 10445: 10442: 10441: 10425: 10422: 10421: 10405: 10402: 10401: 10385: 10382: 10381: 10365: 10362: 10361: 10345: 10342: 10341: 10321: 10318: 10317: 10301: 10298: 10297: 10281: 10278: 10277: 10251: 10247: 10245: 10242: 10241: 10225: 10222: 10221: 10205: 10202: 10201: 10185: 10182: 10181: 10162: 10159: 10158: 10141: 10137: 10135: 10132: 10131: 10115: 10112: 10111: 10084: 10080: 10065: 10061: 10059: 10056: 10055: 10032: 10028: 10013: 10009: 10007: 10004: 10003: 9986: 9982: 9973: 9969: 9967: 9964: 9963: 9940: 9936: 9921: 9917: 9915: 9912: 9911: 9894: 9890: 9881: 9877: 9875: 9872: 9871: 9854: 9850: 9841: 9837: 9835: 9832: 9831: 9809: 9806: 9805: 9789: 9786: 9785: 9768: 9764: 9749: 9745: 9743: 9740: 9739: 9723: 9720: 9719: 9703: 9700: 9699: 9682: 9678: 9663: 9659: 9657: 9654: 9653: 9636: 9632: 9630: 9627: 9626: 9610: 9607: 9606: 9590: 9587: 9586: 9561: 9558: 9557: 9535: 9532: 9531: 9530:if and only if 9514: 9511: 9510: 9494: 9491: 9490: 9489: 9473: 9470: 9469: 9453: 9450: 9449: 9433: 9430: 9429: 9413: 9410: 9409: 9393: 9390: 9389: 9373: 9370: 9369: 9366:Gödel numbering 9349: 9346: 9345: 9329: 9326: 9325: 9308: 9304: 9302: 9299: 9298: 9278: 9274: 9260: 9245: 9241: 9239: 9236: 9235: 9210: 9207: 9206: 9184: 9181: 9180: 9179:if and only if 9163: 9160: 9159: 9143: 9140: 9139: 9138: 9122: 9119: 9118: 9102: 9099: 9098: 9075: 9071: 9069: 9066: 9065: 9049: 9046: 9045: 9022: 9018: 9016: 9013: 9012: 8996: 8993: 8992: 8970: 8967: 8966: 8944: 8941: 8940: 8924: 8921: 8920: 8904: 8901: 8900: 8884: 8881: 8880: 8861: 8858: 8857: 8836: 8833: 8832: 8814: 8811: 8810: 8807: 8786: 8783: 8782: 8766: 8763: 8762: 8746: 8743: 8742: 8718: 8715: 8714: 8697: 8693: 8691: 8688: 8687: 8671: 8668: 8667: 8651: 8648: 8647: 8623: 8620: 8619: 8602: 8598: 8596: 8593: 8592: 8573: 8570: 8569: 8548: 8544: 8542: 8539: 8538: 8521: 8517: 8515: 8512: 8511: 8495: 8492: 8491: 8475: 8472: 8471: 8454: 8450: 8448: 8445: 8444: 8425: 8422: 8421: 8406:Mahlo cardinals 8385: 8382: 8381: 8361: 8358: 8357: 8354:limit cardinals 8337: 8334: 8333: 8313: 8310: 8309: 8289: 8286: 8285: 8269: 8266: 8265: 8244: 8243: 8238: 8232: 8229: 8228: 8194: 8192: 8189: 8188: 8185: 8158: 8155: 8154: 8137: 8133: 8131: 8128: 8127: 8111: 8108: 8107: 8085: 8082: 8081: 8064: 8060: 8058: 8055: 8054: 8037: 8033: 8031: 8028: 8027: 8011: 8008: 8007: 7990: 7986: 7984: 7981: 7980: 7964: 7961: 7960: 7959:, and both the 7944: 7941: 7940: 7924: 7921: 7920: 7904: 7901: 7900: 7884: 7881: 7880: 7864: 7861: 7860: 7826: 7822: 7820: 7817: 7816: 7800: 7797: 7796: 7780: 7777: 7776: 7759: 7755: 7753: 7750: 7749: 7733: 7730: 7729: 7713: 7710: 7709: 7689: 7686: 7685: 7669: 7666: 7665: 7643: 7640: 7639: 7623: 7620: 7619: 7603: 7600: 7599: 7583: 7580: 7579: 7563: 7560: 7559: 7543: 7540: 7539: 7513: 7509: 7507: 7504: 7503: 7483: 7479: 7465: 7463: 7460: 7459: 7443: 7440: 7439: 7423: 7420: 7419: 7403: 7400: 7399: 7398:is the same in 7382: 7378: 7376: 7373: 7372: 7356: 7353: 7352: 7336: 7333: 7332: 7316: 7313: 7312: 7296: 7293: 7292: 7276: 7273: 7272: 7256: 7253: 7252: 7249: 7228: 7225: 7224: 7204: 7201: 7200: 7184: 7181: 7180: 7161: 7158: 7157: 7141: 7138: 7137: 7121: 7118: 7117: 7101: 7098: 7097: 7095: 7072: 7069: 7068: 7052: 7049: 7048: 7032: 7029: 7028: 7012: 7009: 7008: 7005:Axiom of choice 6984: 6981: 6980: 6957: 6953: 6935: 6914: 6908: 6899: 6883: 6876: 6872: 6855: 6852: 6851: 6834: 6830: 6828: 6825: 6824: 6808: 6805: 6804: 6788: 6785: 6784: 6765: 6762: 6761: 6745: 6742: 6741: 6725: 6722: 6721: 6705: 6702: 6701: 6700:will not be in 6685: 6682: 6681: 6660: 6657: 6656: 6640: 6637: 6636: 6620: 6617: 6616: 6600: 6597: 6596: 6573: 6570: 6569: 6553: 6550: 6549: 6526: 6522: 6513: 6509: 6507: 6504: 6503: 6487: 6484: 6483: 6467: 6464: 6463: 6447: 6444: 6443: 6427: 6424: 6423: 6376: 6361: 6349: 6328: 6310: 6299: 6296: 6295: 6269: 6251: 6217: 6202: 6171: 6153: 6141: 6120: 6117: 6116: 6100: 6097: 6096: 6080: 6077: 6076: 6060: 6057: 6056: 6040: 6037: 6036: 6020: 6017: 6016: 6000: 5997: 5996: 5980: 5977: 5976: 5960: 5957: 5956: 5940: 5937: 5936: 5920: 5917: 5916: 5900: 5897: 5896: 5880: 5877: 5876: 5845: 5842: 5841: 5789: 5774: 5743: 5725: 5713: 5710: 5709: 5687: 5684: 5683: 5652: 5649: 5648: 5617: 5614: 5613: 5582: 5579: 5578: 5562: 5559: 5558: 5534: 5531: 5530: 5507: 5503: 5491: 5487: 5478: 5460: 5450: 5446: 5431: 5427: 5403: 5381: 5374: 5370: 5353: 5350: 5349: 5323: 5305: 5295: 5291: 5276: 5272: 5248: 5227: 5224: 5223: 5203: 5200: 5199: 5183: 5180: 5179: 5178:if and only if 5162: 5158: 5156: 5153: 5152: 5136: 5133: 5132: 5115: 5111: 5096: 5092: 5090: 5087: 5086: 5070: 5067: 5066: 5049: 5045: 5043: 5040: 5039: 5023: 5020: 5019: 5003: 5000: 4999: 4971: 4967: 4952: 4948: 4924: 4903: 4900: 4899: 4879: 4875: 4860: 4856: 4842: 4839: 4838: 4822: 4819: 4818: 4788: 4785: 4784: 4761: 4757: 4749: 4746: 4745: 4722: 4718: 4716: 4713: 4712: 4696: 4693: 4692: 4656: 4653: 4652: 4636: 4633: 4632: 4616: 4613: 4612: 4596: 4593: 4592: 4576: 4573: 4572: 4556: 4553: 4552: 4522: 4519: 4518: 4495: 4491: 4461: 4446: 4415: 4397: 4385: 4378: 4374: 4351: 4348: 4347: 4330: 4326: 4324: 4321: 4320: 4319:is a subset of 4304: 4301: 4300: 4283: 4279: 4277: 4274: 4273: 4256: 4252: 4250: 4247: 4246: 4229: 4225: 4217: 4214: 4213: 4192: 4189: 4188: 4172: 4169: 4168: 4167:there is a set 4152: 4149: 4148: 4124: 4121: 4120: 4104: 4101: 4100: 4066: 4063: 4062: 4039: 4035: 4008: 3983: 3976: 3972: 3937: 3934: 3933: 3916: 3912: 3904: 3901: 3900: 3883: 3879: 3871: 3868: 3867: 3851: 3848: 3847: 3825: 3822: 3821: 3799: 3796: 3795: 3762: 3759: 3758: 3757:are sets, then 3742: 3739: 3738: 3722: 3719: 3718: 3694: 3691: 3690: 3665: 3662: 3661: 3644: 3640: 3638: 3635: 3634: 3602: 3598: 3574: 3570: 3559: 3556: 3555: 3527: 3524: 3523: 3507: 3504: 3503: 3487: 3484: 3483: 3467: 3464: 3463: 3447: 3444: 3443: 3427: 3424: 3423: 3407: 3404: 3403: 3387: 3384: 3383: 3354: 3351: 3350: 3334: 3331: 3330: 3314: 3311: 3310: 3288: 3285: 3284: 3268: 3265: 3264: 3236: 3233: 3232: 3216: 3213: 3212: 3184: 3181: 3180: 3152: 3149: 3148: 3128: 3125: 3124: 3108: 3105: 3104: 3088: 3085: 3084: 3068: 3065: 3064: 3033: 3030: 3029: 3013: 3010: 3009: 2993: 2990: 2989: 2973: 2970: 2969: 2953: 2950: 2949: 2933: 2930: 2929: 2905: 2902: 2901: 2873: 2870: 2869: 2867: 2839: 2838: 2833: 2828: 2824: 2822: 2819: 2818: 2802: 2799: 2798: 2793:stands for the 2773: 2772: 2767: 2761: 2758: 2757: 2734: 2733: 2728: 2723: 2719: 2717: 2714: 2713: 2697: 2694: 2693: 2677: 2674: 2673: 2643: 2639: 2637: 2634: 2633: 2621: 2618: 2617: 2595: 2591: 2589: 2586: 2585: 2569: 2566: 2565: 2542: 2538: 2536: 2533: 2532: 2516: 2513: 2512: 2495: 2491: 2489: 2486: 2485: 2462: 2458: 2456: 2453: 2452: 2436: 2433: 2432: 2409: 2405: 2403: 2400: 2399: 2376: 2372: 2370: 2367: 2366: 2350: 2347: 2346: 2330: 2327: 2326: 2295: 2291: 2279: 2275: 2273: 2270: 2269: 2252: 2248: 2246: 2243: 2242: 2219: 2215: 2213: 2210: 2209: 2190: 2187: 2186: 2161: 2157: 2155: 2152: 2151: 2135: 2132: 2131: 2105: 2104: 2102: 2099: 2098: 2075: 2072: 2071: 2054: 2050: 2048: 2045: 2044: 2024: 2021: 2020: 2001: 1998: 1997: 1980: 1976: 1974: 1971: 1970: 1952: 1948: 1946: 1943: 1942: 1919: 1916: 1915: 1899: 1896: 1895: 1878: 1874: 1866: 1863: 1862: 1845: 1841: 1839: 1836: 1835: 1818: 1814: 1812: 1809: 1808: 1786: 1783: 1782: 1760: 1757: 1756: 1739: 1735: 1733: 1730: 1729: 1706: 1702: 1700: 1697: 1696: 1673: 1669: 1667: 1664: 1663: 1640: 1636: 1634: 1631: 1630: 1614: 1611: 1610: 1594: 1591: 1590: 1565: 1561: 1559: 1556: 1555: 1538: 1534: 1532: 1529: 1528: 1512: 1509: 1508: 1492: 1489: 1488: 1471: 1467: 1465: 1462: 1461: 1444: 1440: 1438: 1435: 1434: 1418: 1415: 1414: 1411: 1390: 1386: 1365: 1352: 1348: 1346: 1343: 1342: 1326: 1323: 1322: 1302: 1298: 1296: 1293: 1292: 1289: 1287: 1265: 1262: 1261: 1245: 1242: 1241: 1219: 1216: 1215: 1195: 1192: 1191: 1175: 1172: 1171: 1148: 1145: 1144: 1141:transitive sets 1123: 1119: 1117: 1114: 1113: 1086: 1082: 1080: 1077: 1076: 1075:is a subset of 1059: 1055: 1053: 1050: 1049: 1026: 1022: 1010: 1006: 997: 996: 973: 964: 960: 943: 940: 939: 922: 918: 916: 913: 912: 896: 893: 892: 860: 856: 843: 836: 824: 821: 820: 802: 799: 798: 780: 777: 776: 754: 751: 750: 730: 726: 714: 701: 697: 695: 692: 691: 671: 668: 667: 642: 638: 614: 610: 608: 605: 604: 577: 573: 571: 568: 567: 544: 541: 540: 519: 518: 506: 502: 487: 483: 478: 466: 465: 450: 446: 431: 427: 394: and  392: 368: 367: 347: 344: 343: 316:formal language 310:definable by a 287: 284: 283: 266: 262: 260: 257: 256: 229: 225: 223: 220: 219: 195: 192: 191: 171: 168: 167: 165: 155:with the basic 145:axiom of choice 115: 111: 109: 106: 105: 86: 83: 82: 58: 55: 54: 35: 28: 23: 22: 15: 12: 11: 5: 17647: 17637: 17636: 17631: 17614: 17613: 17599: 17596: 17595: 17593: 17592: 17587: 17582: 17577: 17572: 17571: 17570: 17560: 17555: 17550: 17541: 17536: 17531: 17526: 17524:Abstract logic 17520: 17518: 17514: 17513: 17511: 17510: 17505: 17503:Turing machine 17500: 17495: 17490: 17485: 17480: 17475: 17474: 17473: 17468: 17463: 17458: 17453: 17443: 17441:Computable set 17438: 17433: 17428: 17423: 17417: 17415: 17409: 17408: 17406: 17405: 17400: 17395: 17390: 17385: 17380: 17375: 17370: 17369: 17368: 17363: 17358: 17348: 17343: 17338: 17336:Satisfiability 17333: 17328: 17323: 17322: 17321: 17311: 17310: 17309: 17299: 17298: 17297: 17292: 17287: 17282: 17277: 17267: 17266: 17265: 17260: 17253:Interpretation 17249: 17247: 17241: 17240: 17238: 17237: 17232: 17227: 17222: 17217: 17207: 17202: 17201: 17200: 17199: 17198: 17188: 17183: 17173: 17168: 17163: 17158: 17153: 17148: 17142: 17140: 17134: 17133: 17130: 17129: 17127: 17126: 17118: 17117: 17116: 17115: 17110: 17109: 17108: 17103: 17098: 17078: 17077: 17076: 17074:minimal axioms 17071: 17060: 17059: 17058: 17047: 17046: 17045: 17040: 17035: 17030: 17025: 17020: 17007: 17005: 16986: 16985: 16983: 16982: 16981: 16980: 16968: 16963: 16962: 16961: 16956: 16951: 16946: 16936: 16931: 16926: 16921: 16920: 16919: 16914: 16904: 16903: 16902: 16897: 16892: 16887: 16877: 16872: 16871: 16870: 16865: 16860: 16850: 16849: 16848: 16843: 16838: 16833: 16828: 16823: 16813: 16808: 16803: 16798: 16797: 16796: 16791: 16786: 16781: 16771: 16766: 16764:Formation rule 16761: 16756: 16755: 16754: 16749: 16739: 16738: 16737: 16727: 16722: 16717: 16712: 16706: 16700: 16683:Formal systems 16679: 16678: 16675: 16674: 16672: 16671: 16666: 16661: 16656: 16651: 16646: 16641: 16636: 16631: 16626: 16625: 16624: 16619: 16608: 16606: 16602: 16601: 16599: 16598: 16597: 16596: 16586: 16581: 16580: 16579: 16572:Large cardinal 16569: 16564: 16559: 16554: 16549: 16535: 16534: 16533: 16528: 16523: 16508: 16506: 16496: 16495: 16493: 16492: 16491: 16490: 16485: 16480: 16470: 16465: 16460: 16455: 16450: 16445: 16440: 16435: 16430: 16425: 16420: 16415: 16409: 16407: 16400: 16399: 16397: 16396: 16395: 16394: 16389: 16384: 16379: 16374: 16369: 16361: 16360: 16359: 16354: 16344: 16339: 16337:Extensionality 16334: 16332:Ordinal number 16329: 16319: 16314: 16313: 16312: 16301: 16295: 16289: 16288: 16285: 16284: 16282: 16281: 16276: 16271: 16266: 16261: 16256: 16251: 16250: 16249: 16239: 16238: 16237: 16224: 16222: 16216: 16215: 16213: 16212: 16211: 16210: 16205: 16200: 16190: 16185: 16180: 16175: 16170: 16165: 16159: 16157: 16151: 16150: 16148: 16147: 16142: 16137: 16132: 16127: 16122: 16117: 16116: 16115: 16105: 16100: 16095: 16090: 16085: 16080: 16074: 16072: 16063: 16057: 16056: 16054: 16053: 16048: 16043: 16038: 16033: 16028: 16016:Cantor's  16014: 16009: 16004: 15994: 15992: 15979: 15978: 15976: 15975: 15970: 15965: 15960: 15955: 15950: 15945: 15940: 15935: 15930: 15925: 15920: 15915: 15914: 15913: 15902: 15900: 15896: 15895: 15888: 15887: 15880: 15873: 15865: 15856: 15855: 15853: 15852: 15847: 15845:Thoralf Skolem 15842: 15837: 15832: 15827: 15822: 15817: 15812: 15807: 15802: 15797: 15791: 15789: 15783: 15782: 15780: 15779: 15774: 15769: 15763: 15761: 15759: 15758: 15755: 15749: 15746: 15745: 15743: 15742: 15741: 15740: 15735: 15730: 15729: 15728: 15713: 15712: 15711: 15699: 15698: 15697: 15686: 15685: 15680: 15675: 15670: 15664: 15662: 15658: 15657: 15655: 15654: 15649: 15644: 15639: 15630: 15625: 15620: 15610: 15605: 15604: 15603: 15598: 15593: 15583: 15573: 15568: 15563: 15557: 15555: 15548: 15547: 15545: 15544: 15539: 15534: 15529: 15527:Ordinal number 15524: 15519: 15514: 15509: 15508: 15507: 15502: 15492: 15487: 15482: 15477: 15472: 15462: 15457: 15451: 15449: 15447: 15446: 15443: 15439: 15436: 15435: 15433: 15432: 15427: 15422: 15417: 15412: 15407: 15405:Disjoint union 15402: 15397: 15391: 15385: 15383: 15377: 15376: 15374: 15373: 15372: 15371: 15366: 15355: 15354: 15352:Martin's axiom 15349: 15344: 15339: 15334: 15329: 15324: 15319: 15317:Extensionality 15314: 15313: 15312: 15302: 15297: 15296: 15295: 15290: 15285: 15275: 15269: 15267: 15261: 15260: 15253: 15251: 15249: 15248: 15242: 15240: 15236: 15235: 15228: 15227: 15220: 15213: 15205: 15199: 15198: 15192: 15176: 15162: 15147: 15086: 15080: 15067: 15061: 15045: 15039: 15017: 15014: 15012: 15011: 15005:P. Odifreddi, 14998: 14989: 14976: 14970:K. J. Devlin, 14963: 14950: 14940: 14938: 14935: 14934: 14933: 14928: 14923: 14921:Transitive set 14918: 14913: 14908: 14903: 14896: 14893: 14880: 14860: 14857: 14854: 14851: 14831: 14828: 14825: 14822: 14799: 14779: 14776: 14773: 14770: 14750: 14730: 14710: 14707: 14704: 14701: 14677: 14672: 14669: 14666: 14643: 14640: 14637: 14616: 14596: 14593: 14590: 14587: 14567: 14564: 14561: 14541: 14538: 14535: 14532: 14512: 14492: 14489: 14486: 14483: 14480: 14477: 14474: 14454: 14451: 14448: 14445: 14442: 14422: 14402: 14399: 14396: 14392: 14389: 14386: 14365: 14362: 14359: 14354: 14349: 14346: 14343: 14321: 14301: 14281: 14278: 14275: 14272: 14245: 14241: 14237: 14234: 14211: 14208: 14205: 14202: 14182: 14179: 14176: 14173: 14153: 14150: 14147: 14127: 14124: 14121: 14118: 14107: 14106: 14094: 14091: 14088: 14083: 14079: 14073: 14069: 14065: 14062: 14059: 14056: 14053: 14043: 14031: 14028: 14025: 14020: 14016: 14010: 14007: 14004: 14000: 13996: 13993: 13990: 13987: 13982: 13978: 13957: 13946: 13935: 13932: 13929: 13926: 13921: 13917: 13913: 13909: 13906: 13903: 13882: 13879: 13876: 13871: 13868: 13865: 13861: 13850: 13838: 13835: 13832: 13808: 13788: 13785: 13782: 13777: 13773: 13756:is defined by 13745: 13742: 13739: 13736: 13714: 13694: 13674: 13671: 13668: 13665: 13642: 13639: 13636: 13633: 13613: 13610: 13607: 13604: 13584: 13572: 13569: 13556: 13533: 13530: 13527: 13524: 13521: 13518: 13515: 13512: 13509: 13506: 13503: 13500: 13497: 13494: 13491: 13488: 13485: 13482: 13479: 13476: 13473: 13470: 13467: 13464: 13461: 13458: 13447:is short for: 13436: 13433: 13430: 13427: 13424: 13421: 13399: 13396: 13393: 13390: 13387: 13384: 13381: 13378: 13375: 13372: 13369: 13364: 13360: 13356: 13353: 13349: 13345: 13342: 13339: 13336: 13333: 13330: 13327: 13324: 13321: 13318: 13315: 13312: 13309: 13306: 13303: 13298: 13294: 13290: 13287: 13283: 13279: 13276: 13273: 13270: 13267: 13264: 13261: 13258: 13253: 13250: 13247: 13243: 13239: 13236: 13233: 13229: 13225: 13222: 13219: 13216: 13213: 13210: 13188: 13168: 13165: 13162: 13159: 13156: 13131: 13127: 13123: 13120: 13100: 13080: 13060: 13040: 13020: 13000: 12997: 12994: 12972: 12969: 12966: 12962: 12958: 12953: 12949: 12928: 12908: 12905: 12902: 12899: 12879: 12876: 12873: 12870: 12867: 12864: 12844: 12839: 12835: 12831: 12828: 12825: 12820: 12816: 12812: 12809: 12806: 12803: 12800: 12797: 12777: 12774: 12771: 12749: 12745: 12741: 12738: 12718: 12698: 12695: 12692: 12672: 12650: 12646: 12623: 12619: 12615: 12612: 12609: 12604: 12600: 12579: 12559: 12556: 12553: 12550: 12545: 12541: 12537: 12532: 12529: 12523: 12520: 12517: 12514: 12511: 12506: 12501: 12497: 12493: 12490: 12487: 12482: 12478: 12474: 12471: 12468: 12465: 12460: 12457: 12454: 12447: 12443: 12439: 12436: 12433: 12430: 12427: 12424: 12421: 12399: 12396: 12393: 12389: 12385: 12382: 12362: 12342: 12320: 12316: 12312: 12309: 12297: 12294: 12281: 12255: 12251: 12230: 12210: 12190: 12187: 12184: 12164: 12142: 12139: 12136: 12132: 12128: 12125: 12122: 12119: 12114: 12109: 12106: 12086: 12066: 12044: 12040: 12036: 12033: 12030: 12027: 12022: 12017: 12014: 11992: 11988: 11967: 11947: 11927: 11907: 11882: 11879: 11876: 11872: 11862:is in fact in 11851: 11829: 11825: 11802: 11798: 11777: 11774: 11769: 11765: 11761: 11758: 11755: 11752: 11749: 11746: 11743: 11740: 11737: 11732: 11728: 11724: 11721: 11718: 11715: 11712: 11709: 11704: 11700: 11696: 11693: 11690: 11687: 11684: 11681: 11678: 11675: 11672: 11667: 11663: 11659: 11656: 11653: 11650: 11647: 11627: 11607: 11585: 11581: 11577: 11574: 11562: 11548: 11544: 11523: 11520: 11517: 11495: 11491: 11470: 11448: 11444: 11421: 11417: 11394: 11390: 11367: 11363: 11340: 11336: 11315: 11285: 11281: 11258: 11254: 11233: 11211: 11208: 11203: 11199: 11195: 11192: 11189: 11186: 11183: 11180: 11177: 11174: 11171: 11168: 11165: 11162: 11157: 11153: 11149: 11146: 11143: 11140: 11137: 11134: 11131: 11128: 11125: 11120: 11116: 11112: 11109: 11106: 11103: 11100: 11077: 11074: 11071: 11067: 11063: 11060: 11040: 11020: 11000: 10978: 10974: 10970: 10967: 10955: 10952: 10939: 10917: 10913: 10892: 10887: 10883: 10879: 10876: 10873: 10868: 10864: 10860: 10857: 10835: 10831: 10810: 10788: 10784: 10761: 10757: 10753: 10750: 10747: 10742: 10738: 10717: 10712: 10708: 10704: 10701: 10698: 10693: 10689: 10685: 10682: 10662: 10659: 10656: 10636: 10616: 10596: 10593: 10590: 10567: 10543: 10519: 10515: 10513: 10492: 10472: 10449: 10429: 10409: 10389: 10369: 10349: 10325: 10305: 10285: 10260: 10257: 10254: 10250: 10229: 10209: 10189: 10166: 10144: 10140: 10119: 10093: 10090: 10087: 10083: 10079: 10074: 10071: 10068: 10064: 10041: 10038: 10035: 10031: 10027: 10022: 10019: 10016: 10012: 9989: 9985: 9981: 9976: 9972: 9949: 9946: 9943: 9939: 9935: 9930: 9927: 9924: 9920: 9897: 9893: 9889: 9884: 9880: 9857: 9853: 9849: 9844: 9840: 9819: 9816: 9813: 9793: 9771: 9767: 9763: 9760: 9757: 9752: 9748: 9727: 9707: 9685: 9681: 9677: 9674: 9671: 9666: 9662: 9639: 9635: 9614: 9594: 9571: 9568: 9565: 9545: 9542: 9539: 9518: 9498: 9477: 9457: 9437: 9417: 9397: 9377: 9353: 9333: 9311: 9307: 9286: 9281: 9277: 9273: 9269: 9266: 9263: 9259: 9254: 9251: 9248: 9244: 9220: 9217: 9214: 9194: 9191: 9188: 9167: 9147: 9126: 9106: 9084: 9081: 9078: 9074: 9053: 9031: 9028: 9025: 9021: 9000: 8980: 8977: 8974: 8954: 8951: 8948: 8928: 8908: 8888: 8865: 8840: 8818: 8806: 8803: 8790: 8770: 8750: 8735:indiscernibles 8722: 8700: 8696: 8675: 8655: 8627: 8605: 8601: 8577: 8551: 8547: 8524: 8520: 8499: 8479: 8457: 8453: 8429: 8410:large cardinal 8389: 8365: 8341: 8317: 8293: 8273: 8250: 8247: 8241: 8237: 8216: 8213: 8210: 8207: 8203: 8200: 8197: 8184: 8181: 8168: 8165: 8162: 8140: 8136: 8115: 8095: 8092: 8089: 8080:, we get that 8067: 8063: 8040: 8036: 8015: 7993: 7989: 7968: 7948: 7928: 7908: 7888: 7868: 7859:Because both " 7829: 7825: 7804: 7784: 7762: 7758: 7737: 7717: 7706:standard model 7693: 7673: 7661:If there is a 7647: 7627: 7607: 7587: 7567: 7547: 7522: 7519: 7516: 7512: 7491: 7486: 7482: 7478: 7474: 7471: 7468: 7447: 7427: 7407: 7385: 7381: 7360: 7340: 7320: 7300: 7280: 7260: 7248: 7245: 7232: 7208: 7188: 7177: 7176: 7165: 7145: 7125: 7105: 7093: 7089: 7088: 7076: 7056: 7036: 7016: 7007:: Given a set 7001: 7000: 6988: 6966: 6963: 6960: 6956: 6952: 6949: 6946: 6941: 6938: 6932: 6929: 6926: 6923: 6920: 6917: 6911: 6905: 6902: 6897: 6892: 6889: 6886: 6879: 6875: 6871: 6868: 6865: 6862: 6859: 6837: 6833: 6812: 6792: 6769: 6749: 6729: 6709: 6689: 6677: 6676: 6664: 6644: 6624: 6604: 6595:: For any set 6589: 6588: 6577: 6557: 6535: 6532: 6529: 6525: 6521: 6516: 6512: 6491: 6471: 6451: 6431: 6411: 6408: 6405: 6402: 6399: 6396: 6393: 6388: 6385: 6382: 6379: 6373: 6370: 6367: 6364: 6359: 6356: 6352: 6346: 6343: 6340: 6337: 6334: 6331: 6325: 6322: 6319: 6316: 6313: 6309: 6306: 6303: 6283: 6280: 6275: 6272: 6266: 6263: 6260: 6257: 6254: 6249: 6246: 6243: 6240: 6237: 6234: 6229: 6226: 6223: 6220: 6214: 6211: 6208: 6205: 6200: 6197: 6194: 6189: 6186: 6183: 6180: 6177: 6174: 6168: 6165: 6162: 6159: 6156: 6150: 6147: 6144: 6139: 6136: 6133: 6130: 6127: 6124: 6104: 6084: 6064: 6044: 6024: 6004: 5984: 5964: 5944: 5924: 5904: 5884: 5864: 5861: 5858: 5855: 5852: 5849: 5837: 5836: 5824: 5821: 5818: 5815: 5812: 5809: 5806: 5801: 5798: 5795: 5792: 5786: 5783: 5780: 5777: 5772: 5769: 5766: 5761: 5758: 5755: 5752: 5749: 5746: 5740: 5737: 5734: 5731: 5728: 5723: 5720: 5717: 5697: 5694: 5691: 5671: 5668: 5665: 5662: 5659: 5656: 5636: 5633: 5630: 5627: 5624: 5621: 5601: 5598: 5595: 5592: 5589: 5586: 5566: 5551: 5550: 5538: 5516: 5513: 5510: 5506: 5502: 5499: 5494: 5490: 5484: 5481: 5475: 5472: 5469: 5466: 5463: 5458: 5453: 5449: 5445: 5442: 5439: 5434: 5430: 5426: 5423: 5420: 5417: 5412: 5409: 5406: 5401: 5398: 5395: 5390: 5387: 5384: 5377: 5373: 5369: 5366: 5363: 5360: 5357: 5337: 5334: 5329: 5326: 5320: 5317: 5314: 5311: 5308: 5303: 5298: 5294: 5290: 5287: 5284: 5279: 5275: 5271: 5268: 5265: 5262: 5257: 5254: 5251: 5246: 5243: 5240: 5237: 5234: 5231: 5207: 5187: 5165: 5161: 5140: 5118: 5114: 5110: 5107: 5104: 5099: 5095: 5074: 5052: 5048: 5027: 5007: 4995: 4994: 4982: 4979: 4974: 4970: 4966: 4963: 4960: 4955: 4951: 4947: 4944: 4941: 4938: 4933: 4930: 4927: 4922: 4919: 4916: 4913: 4910: 4907: 4887: 4882: 4878: 4874: 4871: 4868: 4863: 4859: 4855: 4852: 4849: 4846: 4826: 4811: 4810: 4798: 4795: 4792: 4770: 4767: 4764: 4760: 4756: 4753: 4731: 4728: 4725: 4721: 4700: 4685: 4684: 4672: 4669: 4666: 4663: 4660: 4640: 4620: 4600: 4580: 4560: 4545: 4544: 4532: 4529: 4526: 4504: 4501: 4498: 4494: 4490: 4487: 4484: 4481: 4478: 4473: 4470: 4467: 4464: 4458: 4455: 4452: 4449: 4444: 4441: 4438: 4433: 4430: 4427: 4424: 4421: 4418: 4412: 4409: 4406: 4403: 4400: 4394: 4391: 4388: 4381: 4377: 4373: 4370: 4367: 4364: 4361: 4358: 4355: 4333: 4329: 4308: 4286: 4282: 4259: 4255: 4232: 4228: 4224: 4221: 4209: 4208: 4196: 4176: 4156: 4147:: For any set 4145:Axiom of union 4141: 4140: 4128: 4108: 4088: 4085: 4082: 4079: 4076: 4073: 4070: 4048: 4045: 4042: 4038: 4034: 4031: 4028: 4025: 4022: 4019: 4014: 4011: 4006: 4003: 4000: 3997: 3992: 3989: 3986: 3979: 3975: 3971: 3968: 3965: 3962: 3959: 3956: 3953: 3950: 3947: 3944: 3941: 3919: 3915: 3911: 3908: 3886: 3882: 3878: 3875: 3855: 3835: 3832: 3829: 3809: 3806: 3803: 3791: 3790: 3778: 3775: 3772: 3769: 3766: 3746: 3726: 3711: 3710: 3698: 3678: 3675: 3672: 3669: 3647: 3643: 3633:, which is in 3622: 3619: 3616: 3613: 3610: 3605: 3601: 3597: 3594: 3591: 3588: 3585: 3582: 3577: 3573: 3569: 3566: 3563: 3552: 3551: 3550:: {} is a set. 3544: 3543: 3531: 3511: 3491: 3471: 3451: 3431: 3411: 3391: 3379: 3378: 3371: 3370: 3358: 3338: 3318: 3298: 3295: 3292: 3272: 3252: 3249: 3246: 3243: 3240: 3220: 3200: 3197: 3194: 3191: 3188: 3168: 3165: 3162: 3159: 3156: 3145: 3144: 3132: 3112: 3092: 3072: 3048:is a model of 3037: 3017: 2997: 2977: 2957: 2937: 2909: 2889: 2886: 2883: 2880: 2877: 2866: 2863: 2845: 2842: 2836: 2832: 2827: 2806: 2779: 2776: 2770: 2766: 2740: 2737: 2731: 2727: 2722: 2701: 2681: 2652: 2649: 2646: 2642: 2604: 2601: 2598: 2594: 2573: 2551: 2548: 2545: 2541: 2520: 2498: 2494: 2471: 2468: 2465: 2461: 2440: 2418: 2415: 2412: 2408: 2385: 2382: 2379: 2375: 2354: 2334: 2303: 2298: 2294: 2290: 2287: 2282: 2278: 2255: 2251: 2228: 2225: 2222: 2218: 2194: 2179:Levy hierarchy 2164: 2160: 2139: 2119: 2116: 2113: 2079: 2057: 2053: 2028: 2005: 1983: 1979: 1955: 1951: 1929: 1926: 1923: 1903: 1881: 1877: 1873: 1870: 1848: 1844: 1821: 1817: 1796: 1793: 1790: 1770: 1767: 1764: 1742: 1738: 1715: 1712: 1709: 1705: 1682: 1679: 1676: 1672: 1649: 1646: 1643: 1639: 1618: 1598: 1568: 1564: 1541: 1537: 1516: 1496: 1474: 1470: 1447: 1443: 1422: 1398: 1393: 1389: 1385: 1382: 1379: 1374: 1371: 1368: 1364: 1360: 1355: 1351: 1330: 1320: 1305: 1301: 1288: 1285: 1282: 1269: 1249: 1229: 1226: 1223: 1199: 1179: 1152: 1126: 1122: 1095: 1092: 1089: 1085: 1062: 1058: 1035: 1032: 1029: 1025: 1021: 1018: 1013: 1009: 1005: 995: 992: 989: 986: 983: 967: 963: 959: 956: 953: 950: 947: 925: 921: 900: 889: 888: 868: 863: 859: 852: 849: 846: 842: 839: 835: 831: 828: 818: 806: 784: 764: 761: 758: 738: 733: 729: 723: 720: 717: 713: 709: 704: 700: 675: 664: 653: 650: 645: 641: 637: 634: 631: 628: 623: 620: 617: 613: 602: 591: 588: 585: 580: 576: 559:is defined by 548: 527: 522: 517: 514: 509: 505: 501: 498: 495: 490: 486: 477: 469: 461: 458: 453: 449: 445: 442: 439: 434: 430: 426: 423: 420: 417: 414: 411: 408: 405: 402: 399: 391: 388: 385: 382: 379: 376: 371: 366: 363: 360: 357: 354: 351: 334: 333: 326: 319: 318:of set theory, 291: 269: 265: 238: 235: 232: 228: 199: 175: 164: 161: 118: 114: 90: 62: 53:), denoted by 26: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 17646: 17635: 17632: 17630: 17627: 17626: 17624: 17611: 17610: 17605: 17597: 17591: 17588: 17586: 17583: 17581: 17578: 17576: 17573: 17569: 17566: 17565: 17564: 17561: 17559: 17556: 17554: 17551: 17549: 17545: 17542: 17540: 17537: 17535: 17532: 17530: 17527: 17525: 17522: 17521: 17519: 17515: 17509: 17506: 17504: 17501: 17499: 17498:Recursive set 17496: 17494: 17491: 17489: 17486: 17484: 17481: 17479: 17476: 17472: 17469: 17467: 17464: 17462: 17459: 17457: 17454: 17452: 17449: 17448: 17447: 17444: 17442: 17439: 17437: 17434: 17432: 17429: 17427: 17424: 17422: 17419: 17418: 17416: 17414: 17410: 17404: 17401: 17399: 17396: 17394: 17391: 17389: 17386: 17384: 17381: 17379: 17376: 17374: 17371: 17367: 17364: 17362: 17359: 17357: 17354: 17353: 17352: 17349: 17347: 17344: 17342: 17339: 17337: 17334: 17332: 17329: 17327: 17324: 17320: 17317: 17316: 17315: 17312: 17308: 17307:of arithmetic 17305: 17304: 17303: 17300: 17296: 17293: 17291: 17288: 17286: 17283: 17281: 17278: 17276: 17273: 17272: 17271: 17268: 17264: 17261: 17259: 17256: 17255: 17254: 17251: 17250: 17248: 17246: 17242: 17236: 17233: 17231: 17228: 17226: 17223: 17221: 17218: 17215: 17214:from ZFC 17211: 17208: 17206: 17203: 17197: 17194: 17193: 17192: 17189: 17187: 17184: 17182: 17179: 17178: 17177: 17174: 17172: 17169: 17167: 17164: 17162: 17159: 17157: 17154: 17152: 17149: 17147: 17144: 17143: 17141: 17139: 17135: 17125: 17124: 17120: 17119: 17114: 17113:non-Euclidean 17111: 17107: 17104: 17102: 17099: 17097: 17096: 17092: 17091: 17089: 17086: 17085: 17083: 17079: 17075: 17072: 17070: 17067: 17066: 17065: 17061: 17057: 17054: 17053: 17052: 17048: 17044: 17041: 17039: 17036: 17034: 17031: 17029: 17026: 17024: 17021: 17019: 17016: 17015: 17013: 17009: 17008: 17006: 17001: 16995: 16990:Example  16987: 16979: 16974: 16973: 16972: 16969: 16967: 16964: 16960: 16957: 16955: 16952: 16950: 16947: 16945: 16942: 16941: 16940: 16937: 16935: 16932: 16930: 16927: 16925: 16922: 16918: 16915: 16913: 16910: 16909: 16908: 16905: 16901: 16898: 16896: 16893: 16891: 16888: 16886: 16883: 16882: 16881: 16878: 16876: 16873: 16869: 16866: 16864: 16861: 16859: 16856: 16855: 16854: 16851: 16847: 16844: 16842: 16839: 16837: 16834: 16832: 16829: 16827: 16824: 16822: 16819: 16818: 16817: 16814: 16812: 16809: 16807: 16804: 16802: 16799: 16795: 16792: 16790: 16787: 16785: 16782: 16780: 16777: 16776: 16775: 16772: 16770: 16767: 16765: 16762: 16760: 16757: 16753: 16750: 16748: 16747:by definition 16745: 16744: 16743: 16740: 16736: 16733: 16732: 16731: 16728: 16726: 16723: 16721: 16718: 16716: 16713: 16711: 16708: 16707: 16704: 16701: 16699: 16695: 16690: 16684: 16680: 16670: 16667: 16665: 16662: 16660: 16657: 16655: 16652: 16650: 16647: 16645: 16642: 16640: 16637: 16635: 16634:Kripke–Platek 16632: 16630: 16627: 16623: 16620: 16618: 16615: 16614: 16613: 16610: 16609: 16607: 16603: 16595: 16592: 16591: 16590: 16587: 16585: 16582: 16578: 16575: 16574: 16573: 16570: 16568: 16565: 16563: 16560: 16558: 16555: 16553: 16550: 16547: 16543: 16539: 16536: 16532: 16529: 16527: 16524: 16522: 16519: 16518: 16517: 16513: 16510: 16509: 16507: 16505: 16501: 16497: 16489: 16486: 16484: 16481: 16479: 16478:constructible 16476: 16475: 16474: 16471: 16469: 16466: 16464: 16461: 16459: 16456: 16454: 16451: 16449: 16446: 16444: 16441: 16439: 16436: 16434: 16431: 16429: 16426: 16424: 16421: 16419: 16416: 16414: 16411: 16410: 16408: 16406: 16401: 16393: 16390: 16388: 16385: 16383: 16380: 16378: 16375: 16373: 16370: 16368: 16365: 16364: 16362: 16358: 16355: 16353: 16350: 16349: 16348: 16345: 16343: 16340: 16338: 16335: 16333: 16330: 16328: 16324: 16320: 16318: 16315: 16311: 16308: 16307: 16306: 16303: 16302: 16299: 16296: 16294: 16290: 16280: 16277: 16275: 16272: 16270: 16267: 16265: 16262: 16260: 16257: 16255: 16252: 16248: 16245: 16244: 16243: 16240: 16236: 16231: 16230: 16229: 16226: 16225: 16223: 16221: 16217: 16209: 16206: 16204: 16201: 16199: 16196: 16195: 16194: 16191: 16189: 16186: 16184: 16181: 16179: 16176: 16174: 16171: 16169: 16166: 16164: 16161: 16160: 16158: 16156: 16155:Propositional 16152: 16146: 16143: 16141: 16138: 16136: 16133: 16131: 16128: 16126: 16123: 16121: 16118: 16114: 16111: 16110: 16109: 16106: 16104: 16101: 16099: 16096: 16094: 16091: 16089: 16086: 16084: 16083:Logical truth 16081: 16079: 16076: 16075: 16073: 16071: 16067: 16064: 16062: 16058: 16052: 16049: 16047: 16044: 16042: 16039: 16037: 16034: 16032: 16029: 16027: 16023: 16019: 16015: 16013: 16010: 16008: 16005: 16003: 15999: 15996: 15995: 15993: 15991: 15985: 15980: 15974: 15971: 15969: 15966: 15964: 15961: 15959: 15956: 15954: 15951: 15949: 15946: 15944: 15941: 15939: 15936: 15934: 15931: 15929: 15926: 15924: 15921: 15919: 15916: 15912: 15909: 15908: 15907: 15904: 15903: 15901: 15897: 15893: 15886: 15881: 15879: 15874: 15872: 15867: 15866: 15863: 15851: 15850:Ernst Zermelo 15848: 15846: 15843: 15841: 15838: 15836: 15835:Willard Quine 15833: 15831: 15828: 15826: 15823: 15821: 15818: 15816: 15813: 15811: 15808: 15806: 15803: 15801: 15798: 15796: 15793: 15792: 15790: 15788: 15787:Set theorists 15784: 15778: 15775: 15773: 15770: 15768: 15765: 15764: 15762: 15756: 15754: 15751: 15750: 15747: 15739: 15736: 15734: 15733:Kripke–Platek 15731: 15727: 15724: 15723: 15722: 15719: 15718: 15717: 15714: 15710: 15707: 15706: 15705: 15704: 15700: 15696: 15693: 15692: 15691: 15688: 15687: 15684: 15681: 15679: 15676: 15674: 15671: 15669: 15666: 15665: 15663: 15659: 15653: 15650: 15648: 15645: 15643: 15640: 15638: 15636: 15631: 15629: 15626: 15624: 15621: 15618: 15614: 15611: 15609: 15606: 15602: 15599: 15597: 15594: 15592: 15589: 15588: 15587: 15584: 15581: 15577: 15574: 15572: 15569: 15567: 15564: 15562: 15559: 15558: 15556: 15553: 15549: 15543: 15540: 15538: 15535: 15533: 15530: 15528: 15525: 15523: 15520: 15518: 15515: 15513: 15510: 15506: 15503: 15501: 15498: 15497: 15496: 15493: 15491: 15488: 15486: 15483: 15481: 15478: 15476: 15473: 15470: 15466: 15463: 15461: 15458: 15456: 15453: 15452: 15450: 15444: 15441: 15440: 15437: 15431: 15428: 15426: 15423: 15421: 15418: 15416: 15413: 15411: 15408: 15406: 15403: 15401: 15398: 15395: 15392: 15390: 15387: 15386: 15384: 15382: 15378: 15370: 15369:specification 15367: 15365: 15362: 15361: 15360: 15357: 15356: 15353: 15350: 15348: 15345: 15343: 15340: 15338: 15335: 15333: 15330: 15328: 15325: 15323: 15320: 15318: 15315: 15311: 15308: 15307: 15306: 15303: 15301: 15298: 15294: 15291: 15289: 15286: 15284: 15281: 15280: 15279: 15276: 15274: 15271: 15270: 15268: 15266: 15262: 15257: 15247: 15244: 15243: 15241: 15237: 15233: 15226: 15221: 15219: 15214: 15212: 15207: 15206: 15203: 15195: 15193:3-540-44085-2 15189: 15185: 15181: 15177: 15173: 15169: 15165: 15159: 15155: 15154: 15148: 15144: 15140: 15135: 15130: 15126: 15122: 15117: 15112: 15108: 15104: 15100: 15096: 15092: 15087: 15083: 15081:3-540-05591-6 15077: 15073: 15068: 15064: 15062:0-387-13258-9 15058: 15054: 15050: 15046: 15042: 15040:0-387-07451-1 15036: 15031: 15030: 15024: 15020: 15019: 15008: 15002: 14993: 14986: 14980: 14973: 14967: 14960: 14954: 14945: 14941: 14932: 14929: 14927: 14924: 14922: 14919: 14917: 14914: 14912: 14909: 14907: 14904: 14902: 14899: 14898: 14892: 14878: 14855: 14849: 14826: 14820: 14811: 14797: 14774: 14768: 14748: 14728: 14705: 14699: 14691: 14675: 14614: 14591: 14585: 14565: 14562: 14559: 14536: 14530: 14510: 14487: 14484: 14481: 14478: 14475: 14449: 14446: 14443: 14433:in the model 14397: 14360: 14352: 14319: 14299: 14276: 14270: 14261: 14259: 14232: 14223: 14206: 14200: 14177: 14171: 14148: 14122: 14116: 14089: 14081: 14077: 14071: 14067: 14063: 14057: 14051: 14044: 14026: 14018: 14014: 14008: 14005: 14002: 13998: 13994: 13988: 13980: 13976: 13955: 13947: 13927: 13919: 13915: 13877: 13869: 13866: 13863: 13859: 13851: 13833: 13822: 13806: 13783: 13775: 13771: 13763: 13762: 13761: 13759: 13740: 13734: 13726: 13712: 13692: 13669: 13663: 13654: 13637: 13631: 13608: 13602: 13582: 13568: 13554: 13544: 13531: 13519: 13516: 13513: 13507: 13504: 13501: 13495: 13492: 13489: 13486: 13480: 13477: 13474: 13465: 13462: 13459: 13448: 13431: 13425: 13422: 13419: 13410: 13382: 13376: 13373: 13370: 13367: 13362: 13358: 13354: 13351: 13343: 13340: 13337: 13331: 13325: 13316: 13310: 13307: 13304: 13301: 13296: 13292: 13288: 13285: 13277: 13274: 13271: 13265: 13256: 13251: 13248: 13245: 13241: 13237: 13234: 13223: 13220: 13217: 13211: 13200: 13186: 13163: 13160: 13157: 13145: 13129: 13125: 13121: 13118: 13098: 13078: 13058: 13038: 13018: 12998: 12995: 12992: 12970: 12967: 12964: 12960: 12956: 12951: 12947: 12926: 12903: 12874: 12871: 12868: 12837: 12833: 12829: 12826: 12823: 12818: 12814: 12810: 12807: 12804: 12801: 12775: 12772: 12769: 12747: 12743: 12739: 12736: 12716: 12696: 12693: 12690: 12670: 12648: 12644: 12621: 12617: 12613: 12610: 12607: 12602: 12598: 12551: 12548: 12543: 12539: 12499: 12495: 12491: 12488: 12485: 12480: 12476: 12472: 12469: 12445: 12441: 12437: 12434: 12431: 12428: 12422: 12419: 12397: 12394: 12391: 12387: 12383: 12380: 12360: 12340: 12318: 12314: 12310: 12307: 12293: 12279: 12271: 12253: 12249: 12228: 12208: 12185: 12162: 12140: 12137: 12134: 12130: 12126: 12120: 12107: 12104: 12084: 12064: 12042: 12038: 12034: 12028: 12015: 12012: 11990: 11986: 11965: 11945: 11925: 11905: 11896: 11880: 11877: 11874: 11870: 11849: 11827: 11823: 11800: 11796: 11767: 11763: 11759: 11756: 11747: 11744: 11741: 11738: 11735: 11730: 11726: 11722: 11719: 11713: 11702: 11698: 11694: 11691: 11682: 11679: 11676: 11673: 11670: 11665: 11661: 11657: 11654: 11648: 11645: 11625: 11605: 11583: 11579: 11575: 11572: 11546: 11542: 11521: 11518: 11515: 11493: 11489: 11468: 11446: 11442: 11419: 11415: 11392: 11388: 11365: 11361: 11338: 11334: 11313: 11305: 11301: 11283: 11279: 11256: 11252: 11201: 11197: 11193: 11190: 11181: 11178: 11175: 11172: 11166: 11155: 11151: 11147: 11144: 11135: 11132: 11129: 11126: 11123: 11118: 11114: 11110: 11107: 11101: 11098: 11075: 11072: 11069: 11065: 11061: 11058: 11038: 11018: 10998: 10976: 10972: 10968: 10965: 10951: 10937: 10915: 10911: 10885: 10881: 10877: 10874: 10871: 10866: 10862: 10855: 10833: 10829: 10808: 10786: 10782: 10759: 10755: 10751: 10748: 10745: 10740: 10736: 10710: 10706: 10702: 10699: 10696: 10691: 10687: 10680: 10660: 10657: 10654: 10634: 10614: 10594: 10591: 10588: 10579: 10565: 10557: 10541: 10533: 10529: 10525: 10512: 10510: 10506: 10490: 10470: 10461: 10447: 10427: 10407: 10387: 10367: 10347: 10339: 10323: 10303: 10283: 10274: 10258: 10255: 10252: 10248: 10227: 10207: 10187: 10178: 10164: 10142: 10138: 10117: 10109: 10091: 10088: 10085: 10081: 10077: 10072: 10069: 10066: 10062: 10039: 10036: 10033: 10029: 10025: 10020: 10017: 10014: 10010: 9987: 9983: 9979: 9974: 9970: 9947: 9944: 9941: 9937: 9933: 9928: 9925: 9922: 9918: 9895: 9891: 9887: 9882: 9878: 9855: 9851: 9847: 9842: 9838: 9817: 9814: 9811: 9791: 9769: 9765: 9761: 9758: 9755: 9750: 9746: 9725: 9683: 9679: 9675: 9672: 9669: 9664: 9660: 9637: 9633: 9612: 9585:Suppose that 9583: 9566: 9540: 9516: 9496: 9435: 9395: 9367: 9351: 9331: 9309: 9305: 9279: 9275: 9257: 9252: 9249: 9246: 9242: 9232: 9218: 9215: 9212: 9192: 9189: 9186: 9165: 9145: 9124: 9104: 9082: 9079: 9076: 9072: 9051: 9029: 9026: 9023: 9019: 8998: 8978: 8975: 8972: 8952: 8949: 8946: 8926: 8906: 8886: 8877: 8863: 8855: 8851: 8838: 8816: 8802: 8788: 8781:. This gives 8768: 8748: 8740: 8736: 8720: 8694: 8673: 8653: 8645: 8644:indiscernible 8641: 8625: 8599: 8589: 8575: 8567: 8545: 8518: 8497: 8477: 8451: 8441: 8427: 8419: 8415: 8411: 8407: 8403: 8387: 8379: 8363: 8355: 8339: 8331: 8315: 8307: 8291: 8271: 8239: 8214: 8211: 8208: 8205: 8180: 8166: 8163: 8160: 8138: 8134: 8113: 8093: 8090: 8087: 8065: 8061: 8053:are the real 8038: 8034: 8013: 7991: 7987: 7966: 7946: 7926: 7906: 7886: 7866: 7857: 7853: 7851: 7847: 7846: 7845:minimal model 7827: 7823: 7802: 7782: 7760: 7756: 7735: 7715: 7707: 7691: 7671: 7664: 7659: 7645: 7625: 7605: 7585: 7565: 7545: 7536: 7520: 7517: 7514: 7510: 7484: 7480: 7445: 7425: 7405: 7383: 7379: 7358: 7338: 7318: 7298: 7278: 7258: 7244: 7230: 7222: 7206: 7186: 7163: 7143: 7123: 7103: 7091: 7090: 7074: 7054: 7034: 7014: 7006: 7003: 7002: 6986: 6964: 6961: 6958: 6954: 6950: 6944: 6895: 6877: 6873: 6869: 6866: 6863: 6860: 6835: 6831: 6810: 6790: 6782: 6767: 6747: 6727: 6707: 6687: 6679: 6678: 6662: 6642: 6622: 6602: 6594: 6591: 6590: 6575: 6555: 6533: 6530: 6527: 6523: 6519: 6514: 6510: 6489: 6469: 6449: 6429: 6403: 6400: 6397: 6391: 6357: 6354: 6307: 6304: 6278: 6244: 6241: 6238: 6232: 6198: 6195: 6192: 6137: 6134: 6131: 6128: 6125: 6102: 6082: 6062: 6042: 6022: 6002: 5982: 5962: 5942: 5922: 5902: 5882: 5859: 5856: 5853: 5847: 5839: 5838: 5816: 5813: 5810: 5804: 5770: 5767: 5764: 5721: 5718: 5695: 5692: 5689: 5666: 5663: 5660: 5654: 5631: 5628: 5625: 5619: 5596: 5593: 5590: 5584: 5564: 5556: 5553: 5552: 5536: 5514: 5511: 5508: 5504: 5500: 5492: 5488: 5451: 5447: 5443: 5440: 5437: 5432: 5428: 5424: 5421: 5415: 5399: 5396: 5393: 5375: 5371: 5367: 5364: 5361: 5358: 5332: 5296: 5292: 5288: 5285: 5282: 5277: 5273: 5269: 5266: 5260: 5244: 5241: 5238: 5235: 5232: 5221: 5205: 5185: 5163: 5159: 5138: 5116: 5112: 5108: 5105: 5102: 5097: 5093: 5072: 5050: 5046: 5025: 5005: 4997: 4996: 4972: 4968: 4964: 4961: 4958: 4953: 4949: 4945: 4942: 4936: 4920: 4917: 4914: 4911: 4908: 4880: 4876: 4872: 4869: 4866: 4861: 4857: 4853: 4850: 4844: 4824: 4816: 4813: 4812: 4796: 4793: 4790: 4768: 4765: 4762: 4758: 4754: 4751: 4729: 4726: 4723: 4719: 4698: 4690: 4687: 4686: 4667: 4661: 4658: 4638: 4618: 4611:and whenever 4598: 4578: 4558: 4550: 4547: 4546: 4530: 4527: 4524: 4502: 4499: 4496: 4492: 4488: 4482: 4479: 4476: 4442: 4439: 4436: 4379: 4375: 4371: 4368: 4365: 4362: 4356: 4353: 4331: 4327: 4306: 4284: 4280: 4257: 4253: 4230: 4226: 4222: 4219: 4211: 4210: 4194: 4174: 4154: 4146: 4143: 4142: 4126: 4106: 4086: 4083: 4077: 4074: 4071: 4046: 4043: 4040: 4036: 4032: 4023: 4020: 4017: 4004: 4001: 3998: 3977: 3973: 3969: 3966: 3963: 3960: 3954: 3948: 3945: 3942: 3917: 3913: 3909: 3906: 3884: 3880: 3876: 3873: 3853: 3833: 3830: 3827: 3807: 3804: 3801: 3793: 3792: 3773: 3770: 3767: 3744: 3724: 3716: 3713: 3712: 3696: 3676: 3673: 3645: 3641: 3617: 3614: 3611: 3608: 3603: 3599: 3595: 3592: 3589: 3586: 3580: 3575: 3571: 3567: 3554: 3553: 3549: 3546: 3545: 3529: 3509: 3489: 3469: 3449: 3429: 3409: 3389: 3381: 3380: 3376: 3373: 3372: 3356: 3336: 3316: 3296: 3293: 3290: 3270: 3250: 3247: 3244: 3241: 3238: 3218: 3195: 3192: 3189: 3163: 3160: 3157: 3147: 3146: 3130: 3110: 3090: 3070: 3062: 3059: 3058: 3057: 3055: 3051: 3035: 3015: 2995: 2975: 2955: 2935: 2927: 2923: 2907: 2884: 2881: 2878: 2862: 2834: 2830: 2825: 2804: 2796: 2768: 2764: 2729: 2725: 2720: 2699: 2679: 2671: 2666: 2650: 2647: 2644: 2640: 2602: 2599: 2596: 2592: 2571: 2549: 2546: 2543: 2539: 2518: 2496: 2492: 2469: 2466: 2463: 2459: 2451:belonging to 2438: 2416: 2413: 2410: 2406: 2383: 2380: 2377: 2373: 2352: 2332: 2324: 2319: 2317: 2296: 2292: 2285: 2280: 2276: 2253: 2249: 2226: 2223: 2220: 2216: 2206: 2192: 2184: 2180: 2162: 2137: 2114: 2095: 2093: 2077: 2055: 2051: 2042: 2026: 2017: 2003: 1981: 1977: 1968: 1953: 1949: 1927: 1924: 1921: 1901: 1879: 1875: 1871: 1868: 1846: 1842: 1819: 1815: 1794: 1791: 1788: 1768: 1765: 1762: 1740: 1736: 1713: 1710: 1707: 1703: 1680: 1677: 1674: 1670: 1647: 1644: 1641: 1637: 1616: 1596: 1588: 1584: 1566: 1562: 1539: 1535: 1514: 1494: 1472: 1468: 1445: 1441: 1420: 1391: 1387: 1380: 1377: 1372: 1369: 1366: 1362: 1358: 1353: 1349: 1328: 1319: 1303: 1299: 1281: 1267: 1247: 1227: 1224: 1221: 1213: 1197: 1177: 1168: 1166: 1150: 1142: 1124: 1120: 1111: 1093: 1090: 1087: 1083: 1060: 1056: 1033: 1030: 1027: 1023: 1019: 1011: 1007: 993: 987: 984: 981: 965: 961: 957: 954: 948: 945: 923: 919: 898: 886: 882: 866: 861: 857: 840: 837: 833: 829: 826: 819: 804: 797: 782: 762: 759: 756: 736: 731: 727: 721: 718: 715: 711: 707: 702: 698: 689: 688:limit ordinal 673: 665: 651: 643: 639: 632: 629: 626: 621: 618: 615: 611: 603: 589: 583: 578: 574: 566: 565: 564: 562: 546: 538: 525: 515: 512: 507: 503: 499: 496: 493: 488: 484: 451: 447: 443: 440: 437: 432: 428: 424: 421: 412: 406: 403: 400: 389: 386: 383: 380: 377: 364: 358: 352: 349: 341: 338: 331: 327: 324: 320: 317: 313: 309: 308: 307: 305: 289: 267: 263: 254: 236: 233: 230: 226: 217: 213: 197: 189: 173: 160: 158: 154: 150: 146: 142: 138: 134: 116: 112: 104: 88: 80: 76: 60: 52: 48: 44: 40: 33: 19: 17600: 17398:Ultraproduct 17245:Model theory 17210:Independence 17146:Formal proof 17138:Proof theory 17121: 17094: 17051:real numbers 17023:second-order 16934:Substitution 16811:Metalanguage 16752:conservative 16725:Axiom schema 16669:Constructive 16639:Morse–Kelley 16605:Set theories 16584:Aleph number 16577:inaccessible 16483:Grothendieck 16477: 16367:intersection 16254:Higher-order 16242:Second-order 16188:Truth tables 16145:Venn diagram 15928:Formal proof 15800:Georg Cantor 15795:Paul Bernays 15726:Morse–Kelley 15701: 15634: 15633:Subset  15580:hereditarily 15542:Venn diagram 15500:ordered pair 15479: 15415:Intersection 15359:Axiom schema 15183: 15180:Jech, Thomas 15152: 15098: 15094: 15071: 15052: 15028: 15023:Barwise, Jon 15006: 15001: 14992: 14979: 14971: 14966: 14953: 14944: 14813:The sets in 14812: 14692: 14655:replaced by 14262: 14224: 14108: 13760:as follows: 13727: 13655: 13574: 13545: 13449: 13411: 13201: 13146: 12299: 11897: 10957: 10580: 10521: 10462: 10275: 10179: 9584: 9233: 8878: 8808: 8590: 8470:is false in 8442: 8376:because the 8186: 7858: 7854: 7843: 7662: 7660: 7537: 7250: 7220: 7178: 6780: 6422:is a set in 3522:and thus in 2926:well-founded 2868: 2667: 2632:so it is in 2323:arithmetical 2320: 2207: 2096: 2092:equinumerous 2018: 1412: 1290: 1169: 1165:proper class 1163:itself is a 890: 883:denotes the 880: 563:as follows: 539: 342: 339: 335: 303: 252: 166: 102: 50: 46: 36: 32:Gödel metric 17508:Type theory 17456:undecidable 17388:Truth value 17275:equivalence 16954:non-logical 16567:Enumeration 16557:Isomorphism 16504:cardinality 16488:Von Neumann 16453:Ultrafilter 16418:Uncountable 16352:equivalence 16269:Quantifiers 16259:Fixed-point 16228:First-order 16108:Consistency 16093:Proposition 16070:Traditional 16041:Lindström's 16031:Compactness 15973:Type theory 15918:Cardinality 15825:Thomas Jech 15668:Alternative 15647:Uncountable 15601:Ultrafilter 15460:Cardinality 15364:replacement 15305:Determinacy 14948:Gödel 1938. 12201:. Assuming 11534:is true in 11461:; and this 11326:containing 11271:drawn from 10338:truth value 9804:. Then let 9488:, then let 9137:, then let 8126:and in any 8106:is true in 7351:defined in 7311:defined in 7291:, then the 5198:is true in 5151:is true in 2672:subsets of 2325:subsets of 2150:defined by 1433:, the sets 330:quantifiers 302:, one uses 137:inner model 39:mathematics 17623:Categories 17319:elementary 17012:arithmetic 16880:Quantifier 16858:functional 16730:Expression 16448:Transitive 16392:identities 16377:complement 16310:hereditary 16293:Set theory 15820:Kurt Gödel 15805:Paul Cohen 15642:Transitive 15410:Identities 15394:Complement 15381:Operations 15342:Regularity 15310:projective 15273:Adjunction 15232:Set theory 15184:Set Theory 15016:References 14741:is a set, 14627:only with 14263:The class 13656:The class 12729:such that 10991:, and let 10440:is not in 9718:to define 9652:. Suppose 9234:The stage 7704:that is a 5038:such that 4571:such that 3866:such that 3462:, then by 3103:such that 2988:. However 2712:belong to 2365:belong to 323:parameters 153:consistent 133:Kurt Gödel 43:set theory 17590:Supertask 17493:Recursion 17451:decidable 17285:saturated 17263:of models 17186:deductive 17181:axiomatic 17101:Hilbert's 17088:Euclidean 17069:canonical 16992:axiomatic 16924:Signature 16853:Predicate 16742:Extension 16664:Ackermann 16589:Operation 16468:Universal 16458:Recursive 16433:Singleton 16428:Inhabited 16413:Countable 16403:Types of 16387:power set 16357:partition 16274:Predicate 16220:Predicate 16135:Syllogism 16125:Soundness 16098:Inference 16088:Tautology 15990:paradoxes 15753:Paradoxes 15673:Axiomatic 15652:Universal 15628:Singleton 15623:Recursive 15566:Countable 15561:Amorphous 15420:Power set 15337:Power set 15288:dependent 15283:countable 14563:∈ 14482:∈ 14450:∈ 14421:Φ 14082:α 14072:α 14068:⋃ 14019:α 14009:λ 14003:α 13999:⋃ 13981:λ 13956:λ 13920:α 13864:α 13517:∈ 13505:∈ 13499:∀ 13496:∧ 13490:∈ 13478:∈ 13472:∀ 13463:∈ 13457:∀ 13368:∧ 13363:ω 13355:∈ 13348:⟺ 13341:∈ 13329:∀ 13326:∨ 13302:∧ 13289:∈ 13282:⟺ 13275:∈ 13263:∀ 13257:∧ 13246:ω 13238:∈ 13228:⟺ 13221:∈ 13209:∀ 13164:ω 13130:α 13099:α 12999:α 12993:β 12985:for some 12965:β 12957:∈ 12904:… 12898:Φ 12875:… 12863:Ψ 12827:… 12796:Ψ 12773:∈ 12748:α 12694:∈ 12649:α 12611:… 12590:and some 12578:Φ 12552:∈ 12544:α 12489:… 12464:Φ 12446:α 12438:∈ 12432:∣ 12392:α 12384:∈ 12361:α 12319:α 12250:κ 12229:κ 12186:δ 12135:δ 12127:∈ 12108:∩ 12043:δ 12035:⊆ 12016:∩ 11987:κ 11966:δ 11926:κ 11875:γ 11828:γ 11801:β 11751:Φ 11748:∧ 11742:∈ 11731:γ 11723:∈ 11686:Φ 11683:∧ 11677:∈ 11666:β 11658:∈ 11626:α 11606:γ 11598:for some 11584:γ 11547:β 11494:α 11407:with the 11393:β 11353:and some 11339:α 11284:β 11244:and some 11232:Φ 11185:Φ 11176:∈ 11139:Φ 11136:∧ 11130:∈ 11119:β 11111:∈ 11070:β 11062:∈ 11039:β 10977:α 10969:∈ 10916:β 10903:holds in 10875:… 10834:β 10787:β 10749:… 10700:… 10661:α 10655:β 10635:α 10595:ω 10253:α 10228:α 10165:α 10143:α 10089:− 10070:− 10037:− 10018:− 9945:− 9926:− 9759:… 9706:Φ 9673:… 9638:α 9593:Φ 9570:Φ 9564:Ψ 9544:Ψ 9538:Φ 9476:Φ 9456:Ψ 9416:Ψ 9376:Φ 9310:α 9280:α 9247:α 9219:α 9213:β 9193:β 9187:α 9125:α 9105:β 9077:β 9024:α 8699:♯ 8618:holds in 8604:♯ 8550:♯ 8523:♯ 8456:♯ 8443:However, 8416:(see the 8400:. Weakly 8380:holds in 8236:Π 8212:⊆ 8206:⊂ 8139:κ 8066:κ 8039:κ 7992:κ 7828:κ 7761:κ 7716:κ 7515:α 7485:α 7446:α 7384:α 6959:α 6951:∈ 6878:α 6870:∈ 6864:∣ 6836:α 6528:α 6520:∈ 6515:α 6490:α 6355:∈ 6308:∣ 6196:∈ 6135:∈ 6129:∣ 5835:is a set. 5768:∈ 5722:∣ 5509:α 5501:∈ 5493:α 5441:… 5397:∈ 5376:α 5368:∈ 5362:∣ 5286:… 5242:∈ 5236:∣ 5164:α 5106:… 5065:contains 5051:α 5026:α 4993:is a set. 4962:… 4918:∈ 4912:∣ 4870:… 4794:∈ 4791:ω 4783:and thus 4763:ω 4755:∈ 4752:ω 4724:α 4699:α 4662:∪ 4579:∅ 4528:∈ 4497:α 4489:∈ 4480:∈ 4440:∈ 4380:α 4372:∈ 4366:∣ 4332:α 4285:α 4258:α 4231:α 4223:∈ 4084:∈ 4041:α 4033:∈ 3978:α 3970:∈ 3964:∣ 3918:α 3910:∈ 3885:α 3877:∈ 3854:α 3831:∈ 3805:∈ 3789:is a set. 3674:∈ 3609:∧ 3596:∈ 3590:∣ 3294:∈ 3248:∈ 3242:∈ 3196:∈ 3164:∈ 2885:∈ 2831:ω 2805:ω 2765:ω 2726:ω 2700:ω 2680:ω 2645:ω 2597:ω 2572:ω 2544:ω 2519:∈ 2497:ω 2464:ω 2439:ω 2411:ω 2378:ω 2353:ω 2333:ω 2297:α 2286:∪ 2281:α 2254:α 2221:α 2159:Δ 2078:α 2056:α 2041:bijection 2027:α 2004:α 1982:α 1954:α 1902:α 1880:α 1876:ω 1869:α 1847:α 1820:α 1769:ω 1763:α 1741:α 1708:α 1675:ω 1642:ω 1589:in which 1567:ω 1540:ω 1392:β 1381:⁡ 1373:α 1367:β 1363:⋃ 1354:α 1329:α 1304:α 1125:α 1110:power set 1088:α 1061:α 1028:α 1012:α 994:∈ 985:∈ 966:α 958:∈ 924:α 862:α 841:∈ 838:α 834:⋃ 805:λ 783:α 763:λ 757:α 732:α 722:λ 716:α 712:⋃ 703:λ 674:λ 644:α 633:⁡ 616:α 587:∅ 513:∈ 497:… 476:Φ 441:… 416:Φ 413:⊨ 407:∈ 387:∈ 381:∣ 353:⁡ 328:with the 268:α 231:α 216:successor 163:What L is 143:with the 117:α 17575:Logicism 17568:timeline 17544:Concrete 17403:Validity 17373:T-schema 17366:Kripke's 17361:Tarski's 17356:semantic 17346:Strength 17295:submodel 17290:spectrum 17258:function 17106:Tarski's 17095:Elements 17082:geometry 17038:Robinson 16959:variable 16944:function 16917:spectrum 16907:Sentence 16863:variable 16806:Language 16759:Relation 16720:Automata 16710:Alphabet 16694:language 16548:-jection 16526:codomain 16512:Function 16473:Universe 16443:Infinite 16347:Relation 16130:Validity 16120:Argument 16018:theorem, 15757:Problems 15661:Theories 15637:Superset 15613:Infinite 15442:Concepts 15322:Infinity 15239:Overview 15182:(2002). 15143:16577857 15051:(1984). 15025:(1975). 14895:See also 14891:itself. 14312:, where 12855:] where 11788:because 11508:. Since 10534:hold in 8879:Suppose 8304:. Hence 8006:and the 7136:to form 5682:implies 2043:between 1940:implies 1755:for all 1214:", aka " 938:, then 796:precedes 212:ordinals 17517:Related 17314:Diagram 17212: ( 17191:Hilbert 17176:Systems 17171:Theorem 17049:of the 16994:systems 16774:Formula 16769:Grammar 16685: ( 16629:General 16342:Forcing 16327:Element 16247:Monadic 16022:paradox 15963:Theorem 15899:General 15695:General 15690:Zermelo 15596:subbase 15578: ( 15517:Forcing 15495:Element 15467: ( 15445:Methods 15332:Pairing 15172:0002514 15134:1077160 15103:Bibcode 12412:, then 12077:within 12005:, then 8352:. Weak 7899:" and " 7775:is the 7748:, then 5222:"). So 4517:. Thus 4346:. Then 4119:as for 4061:. Thus 3932:. Then 3422:are in 2756:(where 1834:equals 1609:equals 1507:equals 690:, then 314:in the 312:formula 17280:finite 17043:Skolem 16996:  16971:Theory 16939:Symbol 16929:String 16912:atomic 16789:ground 16784:closed 16779:atomic 16735:ground 16698:syntax 16594:binary 16521:domain 16438:Finite 16203:finite 16061:Logics 16020:  15968:Theory 15586:Filter 15576:Finite 15512:Family 15455:Almost 15293:global 15278:Choice 15265:Axioms 15190:  15170:  15160:  15141:  15131:  15123:  15078:  15059:  15037:  14503:where 13412:where 11638:. And 10530:, and 9962:) or ( 9738:, and 9448:, and 9408:, and 8187:Since 5612:where 4711:is in 4631:is in 4591:is in 3329:as in 3054:axioms 1143:. But 979:  971:  775:means 473:  463:  157:axioms 45:, the 17270:Model 17018:Peano 16875:Proof 16715:Arity 16644:Naive 16531:image 16463:Fuzzy 16423:Empty 16372:union 16317:Class 15958:Model 15948:Lemma 15906:Axiom 15678:Naive 15608:Fuzzy 15571:Empty 15554:types 15505:tuple 15475:Class 15469:large 15430:Union 15347:Union 15125:87239 15121:JSTOR 14937:Notes 11565:, so 11090:, so 11051:with 10728:with 10380:, or 9605:uses 9509:< 9158:< 8991:. If 8761:into 6115:. So 5131:and ( 4299:. So 3717:: If 3660:. So 2920:is a 1048:. So 885:class 879:Here 749:Here 686:is a 321:with 75:class 41:, in 17393:Type 17196:list 17000:list 16977:list 16966:Term 16900:rank 16794:open 16688:list 16500:Maps 16405:sets 16264:Free 16234:list 15984:list 15911:list 15591:base 15188:ISBN 15158:ISBN 15139:PMID 15076:ISBN 15057:ISBN 15035:ISBN 14926:L(R) 14006:< 13624:and 12996:< 12788:and 12762:and 12353:and 11815:and 11302:and 10958:Let 10658:> 10592:< 10558:for 10316:and 10078:< 10054:and 10002:and 9934:< 9910:and 9870:or ( 9848:< 9815:< 9541:< 9344:and 9190:< 9097:and 9044:and 8976:> 8950:< 8899:and 7418:and 5840:Let 5647:and 5085:and 3899:and 3820:and 3402:and 3123:and 2668:All 2321:All 2070:and 1766:> 1460:and 1370:< 1318:is: 760:< 719:< 304:only 79:sets 49:(or 17080:of 17062:of 17010:of 16542:Sur 16516:Map 16323:Ur- 16305:Set 15552:Set 15129:PMC 15111:doi 14842:or 14552:is 14109:If 13948:If 13823:of 12919:to 12636:in 10774:in 10420:or 10130:to 8965:or 8741:of 8713:in 8646:in 8591:If 8284:to 8026:of 7979:of 7795:of 7684:in 7663:set 7251:If 7221:not 6783:in 6095:to 5895:to 5708:), 4212:If 3794:If 3382:If 3050:ZFC 2665:). 2107:Def 2019:If 1861:if 1587:ZFC 1378:Def 1112:of 999:Def 975:and 891:If 881:Ord 666:If 630:Def 350:Def 253:all 77:of 37:In 17625:: 17466:NP 17090:: 17084:: 17014:: 16691:), 16546:Bi 16538:In 15168:MR 15166:. 15137:. 15127:. 15119:. 15109:. 15099:24 15097:. 15093:. 14690:. 14260:. 14222:. 13893:= 13653:. 12683:, 12292:. 11895:. 10950:. 10526:, 10460:. 10360:, 10273:. 10177:. 9582:. 9231:. 8588:. 8440:. 8328:. 7618:, 7535:. 7243:. 6781:is 6294:= 6035:, 5955:. 5348:= 4898:, 3737:, 3542:). 3283:, 3056:: 3028:. 2928:. 2016:. 1969:= 1629:, 1554:= 1341:, 1280:. 1167:. 830::= 708::= 627::= 584::= 365::= 190:, 17546:/ 17461:P 17216:) 17002:) 16998:( 16895:∀ 16890:! 16885:∃ 16846:= 16841:↔ 16836:→ 16831:∧ 16826:∨ 16821:¬ 16544:/ 16540:/ 16514:/ 16325:) 16321:( 16208:∞ 16198:3 15986:) 15884:e 15877:t 15870:v 15635:· 15619:) 15615:( 15582:) 15471:) 15224:e 15217:t 15210:v 15196:. 15174:. 15145:. 15113:: 15105:: 15084:. 15065:. 15043:. 14879:L 14859:] 14856:A 14853:[ 14850:L 14830:) 14827:A 14824:( 14821:L 14798:A 14778:] 14775:A 14772:[ 14769:L 14749:A 14729:A 14709:] 14706:A 14703:[ 14700:L 14676:A 14671:f 14668:e 14665:D 14642:f 14639:e 14636:D 14615:L 14595:] 14592:A 14589:[ 14586:L 14566:A 14560:y 14540:) 14537:y 14534:( 14531:A 14511:A 14491:) 14488:A 14485:, 14479:, 14476:X 14473:( 14453:) 14447:, 14444:X 14441:( 14401:) 14398:X 14395:( 14391:f 14388:e 14385:D 14364:) 14361:X 14358:( 14353:A 14348:f 14345:e 14342:D 14320:A 14300:A 14280:] 14277:A 14274:[ 14271:L 14244:) 14240:R 14236:( 14233:L 14210:) 14207:A 14204:( 14201:L 14181:) 14178:A 14175:( 14172:L 14152:} 14149:A 14146:{ 14126:) 14123:A 14120:( 14117:L 14105:. 14093:) 14090:A 14087:( 14078:L 14064:= 14061:) 14058:A 14055:( 14052:L 14042:. 14030:) 14027:A 14024:( 14015:L 13995:= 13992:) 13989:A 13986:( 13977:L 13934:) 13931:) 13928:A 13925:( 13916:L 13912:( 13908:f 13905:e 13902:D 13881:) 13878:A 13875:( 13870:1 13867:+ 13860:L 13849:. 13837:} 13834:A 13831:{ 13807:A 13787:) 13784:A 13781:( 13776:0 13772:L 13744:) 13741:A 13738:( 13735:L 13713:A 13693:A 13673:) 13670:A 13667:( 13664:L 13641:] 13638:A 13635:[ 13632:L 13612:) 13609:A 13606:( 13603:L 13583:L 13555:S 13532:. 13529:) 13526:) 13523:) 13520:c 13514:e 13511:( 13508:d 13502:e 13493:a 13487:d 13484:( 13481:c 13475:d 13469:( 13466:a 13460:c 13435:) 13432:a 13429:( 13426:d 13423:r 13420:O 13398:) 13395:) 13392:) 13389:) 13386:) 13383:b 13380:( 13377:d 13374:r 13371:O 13359:L 13352:b 13344:y 13338:b 13335:( 13332:b 13323:) 13320:) 13317:a 13314:( 13311:d 13308:r 13305:O 13297:5 13293:L 13286:a 13278:y 13272:a 13269:( 13266:a 13260:( 13252:1 13249:+ 13242:L 13235:y 13232:( 13224:s 13218:y 13215:( 13212:y 13187:s 13167:} 13161:, 13158:5 13155:{ 13126:L 13122:= 13119:x 13079:S 13059:z 13039:S 13019:z 12971:1 12968:+ 12961:L 12952:k 12948:z 12927:X 12907:) 12901:( 12878:) 12872:, 12869:X 12866:( 12843:) 12838:n 12834:z 12830:, 12824:, 12819:1 12815:z 12811:, 12808:y 12805:, 12802:X 12799:( 12776:X 12770:y 12744:L 12740:= 12737:X 12717:X 12697:S 12691:y 12671:y 12645:L 12622:n 12618:z 12614:, 12608:, 12603:1 12599:z 12558:} 12555:) 12549:, 12540:L 12536:( 12531:n 12528:i 12522:s 12519:d 12516:l 12513:o 12510:h 12505:) 12500:n 12496:z 12492:, 12486:, 12481:1 12477:z 12473:, 12470:y 12467:( 12459:d 12456:n 12453:a 12442:L 12435:y 12429:y 12426:{ 12423:= 12420:S 12398:1 12395:+ 12388:L 12381:S 12341:X 12315:L 12311:= 12308:X 12280:L 12254:+ 12209:S 12189:| 12183:| 12163:S 12141:1 12138:+ 12131:L 12124:) 12121:S 12118:( 12113:P 12105:L 12085:L 12065:S 12039:L 12032:) 12029:S 12026:( 12021:P 12013:L 11991:+ 11946:S 11906:S 11881:1 11878:+ 11871:L 11850:T 11824:L 11797:L 11776:} 11773:) 11768:i 11764:w 11760:, 11757:x 11754:( 11745:S 11739:x 11736:: 11727:L 11720:x 11717:{ 11714:= 11711:} 11708:) 11703:i 11699:z 11695:, 11692:x 11689:( 11680:S 11674:x 11671:: 11662:L 11655:x 11652:{ 11649:= 11646:T 11580:L 11576:= 11573:K 11563:K 11543:L 11522:L 11519:= 11516:V 11490:L 11469:K 11447:i 11443:z 11420:i 11416:w 11389:L 11366:i 11362:w 11335:L 11314:K 11280:L 11257:i 11253:z 11222:, 11210:} 11207:) 11202:i 11198:z 11194:, 11191:x 11188:( 11182:: 11179:S 11173:x 11170:{ 11167:= 11164:} 11161:) 11156:i 11152:z 11148:, 11145:x 11142:( 11133:S 11127:x 11124:: 11115:L 11108:x 11105:{ 11102:= 11099:T 11076:1 11073:+ 11066:L 11059:T 11019:S 10999:T 10973:L 10966:S 10938:L 10912:L 10891:) 10886:k 10882:z 10878:, 10872:, 10867:1 10863:z 10859:( 10856:P 10830:L 10809:n 10783:L 10760:k 10756:z 10752:, 10746:, 10741:1 10737:z 10716:) 10711:k 10707:z 10703:, 10697:, 10692:1 10688:z 10684:( 10681:P 10615:V 10589:n 10566:L 10542:L 10516:L 10491:L 10471:V 10448:L 10428:y 10408:x 10388:W 10368:V 10348:L 10324:y 10304:x 10284:L 10259:1 10256:+ 10249:L 10208:L 10188:n 10139:L 10118:L 10092:2 10086:n 10082:w 10073:2 10067:n 10063:z 10040:1 10034:n 10030:w 10026:= 10021:1 10015:n 10011:z 9988:n 9984:w 9980:= 9975:n 9971:z 9948:1 9942:n 9938:w 9929:1 9923:n 9919:z 9896:n 9892:w 9888:= 9883:n 9879:z 9856:n 9852:w 9843:n 9839:z 9818:y 9812:x 9792:y 9770:n 9766:w 9762:, 9756:, 9751:1 9747:w 9726:x 9684:n 9680:z 9676:, 9670:, 9665:1 9661:z 9634:L 9613:n 9567:= 9517:y 9497:x 9436:y 9396:x 9352:y 9332:x 9306:L 9285:) 9276:L 9272:( 9268:f 9265:e 9262:D 9258:= 9253:1 9250:+ 9243:L 9216:= 9166:y 9146:x 9083:1 9080:+ 9073:L 9052:y 9030:1 9027:+ 9020:L 8999:x 8979:y 8973:x 8953:y 8947:x 8927:L 8907:y 8887:x 8864:L 8839:L 8817:L 8789:L 8769:L 8749:L 8721:L 8695:0 8674:V 8654:L 8626:V 8600:0 8576:L 8546:0 8519:0 8498:V 8478:L 8452:0 8428:L 8414:0 8388:L 8364:L 8340:L 8316:L 8292:L 8272:V 8249:F 8246:Z 8240:1 8215:V 8209:L 8202:d 8199:r 8196:O 8167:L 8164:= 8161:V 8135:L 8114:L 8094:L 8091:= 8088:V 8062:L 8035:L 8014:V 7988:L 7967:L 7947:L 7927:L 7907:V 7887:L 7867:L 7824:L 7803:W 7783:L 7757:L 7736:W 7692:V 7672:W 7646:L 7626:L 7606:W 7586:L 7566:V 7546:L 7521:1 7518:+ 7511:L 7490:) 7481:L 7477:( 7473:f 7470:e 7467:D 7426:V 7406:W 7380:L 7359:V 7339:L 7319:W 7299:L 7279:V 7259:W 7231:V 7207:V 7187:L 7164:L 7144:y 7124:x 7104:L 7094:L 7087:. 7075:x 7055:x 7035:y 7015:x 6999:. 6987:L 6965:1 6962:+ 6955:L 6948:} 6945:x 6940:f 6937:o 6931:t 6928:e 6925:s 6922:b 6919:u 6916:s 6910:a 6904:s 6901:i 6896:z 6891:d 6888:n 6885:a 6874:L 6867:z 6861:z 6858:{ 6832:L 6811:V 6791:L 6768:L 6748:L 6728:L 6708:L 6688:L 6675:. 6663:x 6643:y 6623:y 6603:x 6576:L 6556:L 6534:1 6531:+ 6524:L 6511:L 6470:V 6450:L 6430:V 6410:} 6407:) 6404:y 6401:, 6398:x 6395:( 6392:Q 6387:t 6384:a 6381:h 6378:t 6372:h 6369:c 6366:u 6363:s 6358:S 6351:x 6345:s 6342:t 6339:s 6336:i 6333:x 6330:e 6324:e 6321:r 6318:e 6315:h 6312:t 6305:y 6302:{ 6282:} 6279:L 6274:n 6271:i 6265:s 6262:d 6259:l 6256:o 6253:h 6248:) 6245:y 6242:, 6239:x 6236:( 6233:P 6228:t 6225:a 6222:h 6219:t 6213:h 6210:c 6207:u 6204:s 6199:S 6193:x 6188:s 6185:t 6182:s 6179:i 6176:x 6173:e 6167:e 6164:r 6161:e 6158:h 6155:t 6149:d 6146:n 6143:a 6138:L 6132:y 6126:y 6123:{ 6103:Q 6083:V 6063:V 6043:Q 6023:L 6003:P 5983:Q 5963:Q 5943:L 5923:P 5903:L 5883:P 5863:) 5860:y 5857:, 5854:x 5851:( 5848:Q 5823:} 5820:) 5817:y 5814:, 5811:x 5808:( 5805:P 5800:t 5797:a 5794:h 5791:t 5785:h 5782:c 5779:u 5776:s 5771:S 5765:x 5760:s 5757:t 5754:s 5751:i 5748:x 5745:e 5739:e 5736:r 5733:e 5730:h 5727:t 5719:y 5716:{ 5696:z 5693:= 5690:y 5670:) 5667:z 5664:, 5661:x 5658:( 5655:P 5635:) 5632:y 5629:, 5626:x 5623:( 5620:P 5600:) 5597:y 5594:, 5591:x 5588:( 5585:P 5565:S 5549:. 5537:L 5515:1 5512:+ 5505:L 5498:} 5489:L 5483:n 5480:i 5474:s 5471:d 5468:l 5465:o 5462:h 5457:) 5452:n 5448:z 5444:, 5438:, 5433:1 5429:z 5425:, 5422:x 5419:( 5416:P 5411:d 5408:n 5405:a 5400:S 5394:x 5389:d 5386:n 5383:a 5372:L 5365:x 5359:x 5356:{ 5336:} 5333:L 5328:n 5325:i 5319:s 5316:d 5313:l 5310:o 5307:h 5302:) 5297:n 5293:z 5289:, 5283:, 5278:1 5274:z 5270:, 5267:x 5264:( 5261:P 5256:d 5253:n 5250:a 5245:S 5239:x 5233:x 5230:{ 5206:L 5186:P 5160:L 5139:P 5117:n 5113:z 5109:, 5103:, 5098:1 5094:z 5073:S 5047:L 5006:P 4981:} 4978:) 4973:n 4969:z 4965:, 4959:, 4954:1 4950:z 4946:, 4943:x 4940:( 4937:P 4932:d 4929:n 4926:a 4921:S 4915:x 4909:x 4906:{ 4886:) 4881:n 4877:z 4873:, 4867:, 4862:1 4858:z 4854:, 4851:x 4848:( 4845:P 4825:S 4809:. 4797:L 4769:1 4766:+ 4759:L 4730:1 4727:+ 4720:L 4683:. 4671:} 4668:y 4665:{ 4659:y 4639:x 4619:y 4599:x 4559:x 4543:. 4531:L 4525:y 4503:1 4500:+ 4493:L 4486:} 4483:z 4477:s 4472:t 4469:a 4466:h 4463:t 4457:h 4454:c 4451:u 4448:s 4443:x 4437:z 4432:s 4429:t 4426:s 4423:i 4420:x 4417:e 4411:e 4408:r 4405:e 4402:h 4399:t 4393:d 4390:n 4387:a 4376:L 4369:s 4363:s 4360:{ 4357:= 4354:y 4328:L 4307:y 4281:L 4254:L 4227:L 4220:x 4207:. 4195:x 4175:y 4155:x 4139:. 4127:V 4107:L 4087:L 4081:} 4078:y 4075:, 4072:x 4069:{ 4047:1 4044:+ 4037:L 4030:} 4027:) 4024:y 4021:= 4018:s 4013:r 4010:o 4005:x 4002:= 3999:s 3996:( 3991:d 3988:n 3985:a 3974:L 3967:s 3961:s 3958:{ 3955:= 3952:} 3949:y 3946:, 3943:x 3940:{ 3914:L 3907:y 3881:L 3874:x 3834:L 3828:y 3808:L 3802:x 3777:} 3774:y 3771:, 3768:x 3765:{ 3745:y 3725:x 3709:. 3697:L 3677:L 3671:} 3668:{ 3646:1 3642:L 3621:} 3618:y 3615:= 3612:y 3604:0 3600:L 3593:y 3587:y 3584:{ 3581:= 3576:0 3572:L 3568:= 3565:} 3562:{ 3530:L 3510:V 3490:V 3470:L 3450:L 3430:L 3410:y 3390:x 3357:x 3337:V 3317:y 3297:L 3291:y 3271:L 3251:L 3245:x 3239:y 3219:L 3199:) 3193:, 3190:V 3187:( 3167:) 3161:, 3158:L 3155:( 3131:y 3111:x 3091:y 3071:x 3036:L 3016:V 2996:L 2976:V 2956:V 2936:L 2908:L 2888:) 2882:, 2879:L 2876:( 2844:K 2841:C 2835:1 2826:L 2778:K 2775:C 2769:1 2739:K 2736:C 2730:1 2721:L 2651:2 2648:+ 2641:L 2603:1 2600:+ 2593:L 2550:2 2547:+ 2540:L 2493:L 2470:1 2467:+ 2460:L 2417:1 2414:+ 2407:L 2384:1 2381:+ 2374:L 2302:} 2293:L 2289:{ 2277:L 2250:L 2227:1 2224:+ 2217:L 2193:X 2163:0 2138:X 2118:) 2115:X 2112:( 2052:L 1978:L 1950:H 1928:L 1925:= 1922:V 1872:= 1843:L 1816:V 1795:L 1792:= 1789:V 1737:L 1714:1 1711:+ 1704:L 1681:1 1678:+ 1671:V 1648:1 1645:+ 1638:L 1617:L 1597:V 1563:V 1536:L 1515:L 1495:V 1473:n 1469:V 1446:n 1442:L 1421:n 1410:. 1397:) 1388:L 1384:( 1359:= 1350:L 1300:L 1286:α 1268:L 1248:V 1228:L 1225:= 1222:V 1198:L 1178:L 1151:L 1121:L 1094:1 1091:+ 1084:L 1057:L 1034:1 1031:+ 1024:L 1020:= 1017:) 1008:L 1004:( 991:} 988:z 982:y 962:L 955:y 952:{ 949:= 946:z 920:L 899:z 867:. 858:L 851:d 848:r 845:O 827:L 817:. 737:. 728:L 699:L 652:. 649:) 640:L 636:( 622:1 619:+ 612:L 590:. 579:0 575:L 547:L 526:. 521:} 516:X 508:n 504:z 500:, 494:, 489:1 485:z 468:| 460:} 457:) 452:n 448:z 444:, 438:, 433:1 429:z 425:, 422:y 419:( 410:) 404:, 401:X 398:( 390:X 384:y 378:y 375:{ 370:{ 362:) 359:X 356:( 290:L 264:V 237:1 234:+ 227:V 198:V 174:L 113:L 89:L 61:L 34:. 20:)

Index

Gödel's constructible universe
Gödel metric
mathematics
set theory
class
sets
Kurt Gödel
inner model
Zermelo–Fraenkel set theory
axiom of choice
generalized continuum hypothesis
consistent
axioms
von Neumann universe
ordinals
successor
formula
formal language
parameters
quantifiers
transfinite recursion
limit ordinal
precedes
class
power set
transitive sets
proper class
axiom of constructibility
hereditarily finite sets
ZFC

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.