Template talk:Campaignbox Northern Ireland Troubles

812: 794: 682: 650: 1259:

inside a UDA "romper room" folowing a UDA kangaroo court. The perps were all members of the women's UDA unit, despite the attack not being politically-motivated. It was a classic case of a punishment beating/rompering because Ogilby had made the mistake of repeating defamatory comments which could have landed a member of the women's UDA (Elizabeth Young) in hot water had she really been misusing LPA money as Anne Ogilby implied in public. Perhaps there would be a new template to cover individual killings such as Anne Ogilby's, the Reavey and O'Dowds, the Tandragee killings, etc.--

276: 502: 484: 1019: 1001: 127: 1029: 666: 428: 955: 930: 418: 21: 400: 220: 880: 862: 266: 248: 182: 158: 728: 710: 588: 556: 350: 1155:'s Troubles articles. However, I don't think it belongs in this campaignbox. Altho Anne Ogilby was killed during The Troubles by female members of the UDA, the killing wasn't politically motivated. It was the result of a personal dispute between a group of women, who just happend to be UDA members. If we include the killing of an individual like Anne Ogilby, we'd also hav to include 738: 332: 92: 1331:

Fair enough. If the Mountbatten, Neave and Nelson killings aren't listed it does appear to be inconsistent to list the Ogilby and Wilson/Andrews killings. A separate navbox would be good to list the assassinations and individual killings. I also agree with DagosNavy that there should be a separate

1258:

Thanks for your praise. I really appreciate it. Regarding the Wilson/Andrews killings, I would say that was politically-motivated considering Wilson was a prominent nationalist politician and the UFF claimed it. As for Anne Ogilby, the reason I did include it was on account that it was carried out

1322:, a.s.f). Some of those killings had more of an impact than the Wilson/Andrews killing, but even if we wer to include all the noteworthy ones then the campaignbox would become much too big. As Darius noted, such lone killings generally don't belong on a military campaignbox anyway. 1244:). I am of the personal opinion that individual killings (exceptions made of Airey Neave or Ian Gow) don't belong to the campaignbox, even those of low-rank, off-duty members of the UDR/RIR or RUC where there was returning fire or some sort of "gun battle" with the gunmen.-- 1370:

murders. Using a knife instead of a gun or bomb was just the normal MO for a lot of Loyalist paramilitaries. But there are no articles specifically relating to the killings of Mountbatten, Finucane, Stronge, Bill Wright etc.. there is an article to Airey Neave's killing.

1187:

Well, first of all, the work of Jeanne in Knowledge is absolutely impressive, both regarding Nobility-related articles and also on pages related to the Troubles. On the other hand, I agree with Asarlaí that the campaignbox must include: 1) military operations

1273:

Yeah, it might be a good idea to hav another navbox for all the more noteworthy assassinations or lone killings. Altho the Wilson/Andrews killing would seem to be politically-motivated, it'd be inconsistent to include that one and not the others

1089:

The notability of the sniping IRA campaign in South Armagh during the 1990s deserves to be included in the campaignbox. The fact that the incidents happened (as in any campaign) in different periods of time doesn't matters

107: 229: 168: 673: 570: 657: 566: 193:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of Crime and Criminal Biography articles on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join 1181: 1543: 1142: 689: 574: 1548: 1156: 1366:

were politically motivated and journalist Peter Taylor interviewed the killer and he explained his reasons for killing senator Wilson, it was as gruesome as some of the

1268: 1508: 1423: 1341: 1326: 1375: 1528: 1498: 1468: 828: 1533: 1443: 1253: 1132: 1123: 1109: 1448: 194: 1513: 895:, individual terrorists, incidents and related subjects on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the 1503: 1453: 819: 799: 1483: 1099: 366: 189: 163: 1493: 1488: 1428: 600: 1433: 1299: 1568: 1538: 1438: 1413: 1573: 1518: 1478: 1398: 522: 1403: 1170:

is another truly exellent article. However (as I noted with the Ogilby article), if we include it in the template then we'd hav to include a

357: 337: 1578: 1418: 760: 298: 1553: 1523: 1408: 1558: 1051: 961: 935: 509: 489: 1458: 1563: 1463: 1363: 1167: 1473: 751: 715: 595: 561: 289: 253: 604: 1042: 1006: 896: 450: 1201: 887: 867: 811: 793: 521:

related topics on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join

1084: 824: 54:: All editors on Troubles-related articles are directed to get the advice of neutral parties via means such as 441: 405: 1362:

I agree the killing of Anne Ogibly should not be included because it was not politically motivated. But the

599:. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the project and see a 1225: 138: 77: 31: 1213: 76:

may be blocked or restricted by an administrator. Editors are advised to familiarise themselves with the

681: 1291: 73: 98: 1283: 1205: 1050: