Knowledge

Text world theory

Source 📝

163:"stepped", and will identify a character (presumably a protagonist) with whom the reader is expected to identify through the first person pronoun, "I." The word "pavement" makes the reader use their background knowledge in order to build a text world in which this action takes place, and this will differ between readers. While many readers might construct an urban environment based on this word, each reader's text world would be informed by how their background knowledge and lived experience has influenced their understanding of the word "pavement". 252:
in mind, such as reading a cookbook in order to make a meal) and aesthetic reading (reading while examining the emotional and intellectual experience of the reader). She argues that pupils are implicitly encouraged to read poetry in an efferent way. To show this, she gives an example of a third-grade textbook wherein a poem about a cow is followed by the question, "what facts does this poem teach you?". This literal-mindedness, she argues, had removed the agency of the pupil as a reader, which leads to a reduced engagement with literature.
263:
that this unequal distribution of power can often lead to pupils believing that their interpretations of literature are less valuable than their teachers, which, in turn, leads to pupils failing to build an independent "text world". One of the solutions that Giovanelli gives to this issue is the importance of pictorial representations of texts as related to the work in education through
103:
participants do not share a common environment. An individual's discourse world influences how they interpret language due to their background knowledge, thoughts and feelings. Rather than being an "objective set of physical surroundings", the context of a discourse world is a mental process carried out as part of a negotiation between discourse-world participants.
23:
describes a piece of language (such as a text, a speech or conversation) as a "world" that the reader, hearer or interlocutor must "build" in their mind. Text world theory was first developed by Paul Werth in the 1980s, and has subsequently been used as in education as a method for pupils to engage with literature.
259:, has been linked to text world theory. Text world theory provides a model through which pupils can build an "authentic" text world, and monitor their cognitive experience while reading a text. It also models the "creative nature" inherent in the reading process as pupils construct their unique text worlds. 262:
In a classroom setting, discourse-worlds are complicated by the fact that there are multiple participants engaging with the discourse world, namely the other pupils and the educational staff. Moreover, in a classroom setting, there is often an unequal distribution of power. Marcello Giovanelli argues
251:
Text world theory has been used in schools in order to encourage a personal engagement with texts from pupils and help teachers to understand the "nature of communicative interaction and literary transaction." Louise Rosenblatt argues two types of reading are efferent reading (reading with an outcome
171:
Text world scholars often use diagrams as initial points of entry for analysing different texts. This is to provide a visual way of understanding the different text worlds at play, as well as highlight the key elements of the schema the reader is being asked to call upon. They are used to demonstrate
124:
World-switches are departures from the initial text world through a shift in space or time. These involve the reader constructing a mental model of a new text world through which the new time or place can be conceptualised. For instance, "Gavin stared at the crowd of revellers at the staff party..."
133:
Worlds that are accessible to every enactor within that world are known as participant accessible. This means that multiple characters in the text are having the same experience and express their own judgment of it. Enactor accessible means that only one enactor can access that world. One example of
111:
Within these discourse worlds, humans create "mental representations" which allow the language they are encountering to be understood. In Text worlds a person uses the linguistic stimuli of the text/speech and expands upon it using their background knowledge, perspectives and emotions. Language acts
242:
The diagram demonstrates how the first few paragraphs could trigger schemas around poverty, manual labour, conflict with nature, and loneliness. These diagrams can become significantly more sophisticated, with links to multiple text-worlds demonstrating when world-shifts occur. Text world scholars
22:
is a cognitive model of language processing which aims to explain how people construct meaning from language. Text world theory and schema theory seek to help people understand how we process language and create mental representations when we read or listen to something. This theory figuratively
270:
Several researchers have observed the benefits of using approaches informed by text world theory in the classroom. They both give pupils an understanding of the importance of multiple interpretations of texts, and give teachers a model for how pupils construct meaning during the reading process.
162:
The first clause of Italo Calvino's short story 'The Man Who Shouted Teresa' is "I stepped off the pavement". When this is read, a split discourse world occurs due to the separation between Calvino and the reader. The reader will locate their text world in the past due to the past tense verb
102:
The discourse world is the immediate environment a person is in when they are communicating. Discourse worlds can either be shared or split. A shared discourse world would include a face-to-face conversation, whereas a split discourse world would include an author and reader, where the two
112:
as a means of refining and determining the schema the reader draws upon. For instance "the house" draws up no schema other than houses the individual reader has experienced in their lifetime, whereas "the abandoned house surrounded by dead trees" likely calls up the linguistic schema of
142:
Modal worlds are distinct from world-switches. Changes in time and space are world-switches, while shifts in perception are described as modal worlds. They express modes of approaching the world and are only accessible to the enactors of the text experiencing these shifts.
125:
plants the reader in one text world. However, if the sentence continued "...and he recalled the school discos of his lonely childhood", this would constitute a world shift that requires readers to call upon new schema quite differentiated from the original text world.
74:. While Werth's study was largely limited to short extracts, text world theory has been expanded and tested against many different discourse types, including personal ads, poetry, recipes and radio programmes. 54:
These ideas have been expanded upon by contemporary researchers like Joanna Gavins. Since Werth's conception of text world theory, the theory has been incorporated into the study of
153:
The boulomaic modality refers to a particular desire the character has, such as a fantasy or ideal and is often demonstrated through verbs like 'wish', 'hope' and 'desire'.
243:
typically use diagrams as an entry point into the reader's experience and the cognitive experience of reading the text, which they elaborate on through in-depth analysis.
620: 150:
In the deontic modality, the character expresses a form of duty or a requirement they must fulfill: "it was required that he feed the animals."
687: 147:
In the perception modality, the enactor's sub-world is believed to be factual and true: "surely she was wrong about the price of the book."
176:
is shown below. The material actions or verbs are denoted with the arrow symbol →, while descriptions are marked with the = symbol.
707: 670: 640: 524: 494: 338: 43:. Werth claimed to have created an approach that accounted for all aspects of human communication, but his monograph 663:
The reader, the text, the poem: the transactional theory of the literary work ; with a new preface and epilogue
172:
complex structures in a relatively simple way. A basic diagram of a single text-world from the first paragraphs of
35:
that was first developed by Professor Paul Werth in the 1980s and 1990s. Werth was a text linguist working within
773: 368: 256: 369:"'Suddenly, I am part of the poem': texts as worlds, reader-response and grammar in teaching poetry" 48: 173: 40: 330: 729: 320: 32: 8: 396: 36: 749: 703: 666: 636: 601: 520: 490: 442: 400: 388: 334: 63: 741: 695: 628: 593: 434: 380: 326: 51:
completed and edited the text between 1995 and 1998, and it was published in 1999.
423:"'Well I don't feel that': Schemas, worlds and authentic reading in the classroom" 384: 582:"Readers building fictional worlds: visual representations, poetry and cognition" 514: 71: 113: 767: 753: 745: 699: 605: 446: 392: 665:(Paperback ed.,  ed.). Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. 632: 460: 199: 67: 55: 39:
who developed his text world theory as a professor of linguistics at the
581: 422: 128: 59: 597: 438: 540: 264: 82:
Text world theory is structured into three conceptual levels: the
134:
this might be an individual's imagination or inner feelings.
489:. Textual explorations (1. publ ed.). Harlow: Longman. 255:
This aspect of Rosenblatt's writing, part of her work on
516:
Text Worlds: Representing Conceptual Space in Discourse
487:
Text worlds: representing conceptual space in discourse
45:
Text Worlds: Representing Conceptual Space in Discourse
215:
The boy → helps Santiago with lines, other equipment
212:
Old man (Santiago) → refusing to let boy join again
129:
Participant-accessible and enactor-accessible worlds
47:
was not completed by the time of his death in 1995.
421:Giovanelli, Marcello; Mason, Jessica (March 2015). 765: 420: 618: 694:(2 ed.), Routledge, pp. 215–230, 685: 660: 579: 461:"The Text World Theory Special Collection" 26: 331:10.3366/edinburgh/9780748622993.001.0001 366: 766: 730:"Towards a Semiotics-based Curriculum" 318: 727: 625:Common Knowledge (Routledge Revivals) 619:Edwards, Derek; Mercer, Neil (1987), 512: 484: 314: 312: 310: 308: 306: 304: 232:sail = furled, like a flag of defeat 226:scars → running down Santiago's face 661:Rosenblatt, Louise Michelle (1998). 575: 573: 571: 569: 567: 565: 563: 561: 508: 506: 416: 414: 412: 410: 362: 360: 358: 356: 354: 352: 350: 302: 300: 298: 296: 294: 292: 290: 288: 286: 284: 191:End of fortieth day without a catch 580:Giovanelli, Marcello (2016-08-16). 246: 97: 13: 14: 785: 558: 503: 407: 347: 322:Text World Theory An Introduction 281: 119: 31:Text world theory is a branch of 721: 679: 654: 137: 16:A theory of language processing 612: 533: 478: 453: 325:. Edinburgh University Press. 106: 1: 734:Journal of Curriculum Studies 385:10.1080/04250494.2018.1414398 319:Gavins, Joanna (2007-03-07). 274: 116:and its associated features. 728:Suhor, Charles (July 1984). 7: 686:Fairclough, Norman (2001), 621:"Communication and control" 367:Cushing, Ian (2018-01-02). 166: 10: 790: 157: 688:"Language and power 2000" 541:"About Text World Theory" 229:sea → reflecting the sun 746:10.1080/0022027840160304 700:10.4324/9781315838250-15 77: 633:10.4324/9780203095287-7 174:The Old Man and the Sea 41:University of Amsterdam 257:reader response theory 37:generative linguistics 27:Origin and development 774:Cognitive linguistics 33:cognitive linguistics 513:Werth, Paul (1999). 485:Werth, Paul (1999). 427:English in Education 373:English in Education 692:Language and Power 267:by Charles Suhor. 709:978-1-315-83825-0 672:978-0-8093-1805-6 642:978-0-203-09528-7 598:10.1111/lit.12091 545:Text World Theory 526:978-0-582-22914-3 496:978-0-582-22914-3 465:Text World Theory 439:10.1111/eie.12052 340:978-0-7486-2299-3 240: 239: 64:cognitive poetics 20:Text world theory 781: 758: 757: 725: 719: 718: 717: 716: 683: 677: 676: 658: 652: 651: 650: 649: 616: 610: 609: 577: 556: 555: 553: 552: 537: 531: 530: 510: 501: 500: 482: 476: 475: 473: 472: 457: 451: 450: 418: 405: 404: 364: 345: 344: 316: 247:Use in education 179: 178: 98:Discourse worlds 789: 788: 784: 783: 782: 780: 779: 778: 764: 763: 762: 761: 726: 722: 714: 712: 710: 684: 680: 673: 659: 655: 647: 645: 643: 617: 613: 578: 559: 550: 548: 539: 538: 534: 527: 511: 504: 497: 483: 479: 470: 468: 459: 458: 454: 419: 408: 365: 348: 341: 317: 282: 277: 249: 235:lines = coiled 169: 160: 140: 131: 122: 109: 100: 84:discourse-world 80: 72:literary theory 29: 17: 12: 11: 5: 787: 777: 776: 760: 759: 740:(3): 247–257. 720: 708: 678: 671: 653: 641: 611: 557: 532: 525: 502: 495: 477: 452: 406: 346: 339: 279: 278: 276: 273: 248: 245: 238: 237: 223:skiff = empty 184: 183: 168: 165: 159: 156: 155: 154: 151: 148: 139: 136: 130: 127: 121: 120:World-switches 118: 114:Gothic fiction 108: 105: 99: 96: 92:world-switches 79: 76: 28: 25: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 786: 775: 772: 771: 769: 755: 751: 747: 743: 739: 735: 731: 724: 711: 705: 701: 697: 693: 689: 682: 674: 668: 664: 657: 644: 638: 634: 630: 627:, Routledge, 626: 622: 615: 607: 603: 599: 595: 591: 587: 583: 576: 574: 572: 570: 568: 566: 564: 562: 546: 542: 536: 528: 522: 518: 517: 509: 507: 498: 492: 488: 481: 466: 462: 456: 448: 444: 440: 436: 432: 428: 424: 417: 415: 413: 411: 402: 398: 394: 390: 386: 382: 378: 374: 370: 363: 361: 359: 357: 355: 353: 351: 342: 336: 332: 328: 324: 323: 315: 313: 311: 309: 307: 305: 303: 301: 299: 297: 295: 293: 291: 289: 287: 285: 280: 272: 268: 266: 260: 258: 253: 244: 236: 233: 230: 227: 224: 221: 220: 216: 213: 210: 209: 205: 202: 201: 197: 196: 192: 189: 186: 185: 182:TEXT-WORLD 1 181: 180: 177: 175: 164: 152: 149: 146: 145: 144: 135: 126: 117: 115: 104: 95: 93: 89: 85: 75: 73: 69: 65: 61: 57: 52: 50: 46: 42: 38: 34: 24: 21: 737: 733: 723: 713:, retrieved 691: 681: 662: 656: 646:, retrieved 624: 614: 592:(1): 26–35. 589: 585: 549:. Retrieved 547:. 2015-02-10 544: 535: 515: 486: 480: 469:. Retrieved 467:. 2017-09-11 464: 455: 433:(1): 41–55. 430: 426: 376: 372: 321: 269: 261: 254: 250: 241: 234: 231: 228: 225: 222: 218: 217: 214: 211: 207: 206: 203: 200:Gulf Stream 198: 194: 193: 190: 187: 170: 161: 141: 138:Modal Worlds 132: 123: 110: 101: 91: 87: 83: 81: 53: 44: 30: 19: 18: 519:. Longman. 379:(1): 7–19. 107:Text worlds 88:text-worlds 68:narratology 56:linguistics 715:2024-02-18 648:2024-02-18 551:2024-03-01 471:2024-03-01 275:References 204:On a boat 60:stylistics 49:Mick Short 754:0022-0272 606:1741-4350 447:0425-0494 401:149068617 393:0425-0494 265:semiotics 208:Enactors: 195:Location: 768:Category 586:Literacy 219:Objects: 167:Approach 158:Example 752:  706:  669:  639:  604:  523:  493:  445:  399:  391:  337:  86:, the 397:S2CID 188:Time: 78:Types 750:ISSN 704:ISBN 667:ISBN 637:ISBN 602:ISSN 521:ISBN 491:ISBN 443:ISSN 389:ISSN 335:ISBN 90:and 70:and 742:doi 696:doi 629:doi 594:doi 435:doi 381:doi 327:doi 770:: 748:. 738:16 736:. 732:. 702:, 690:, 635:, 623:, 600:. 590:51 588:. 584:. 560:^ 543:. 505:^ 463:. 441:. 431:49 429:. 425:. 409:^ 395:. 387:. 377:52 375:. 371:. 349:^ 333:. 283:^ 94:. 66:, 62:, 58:, 756:. 744:: 698:: 675:. 631:: 608:. 596:: 554:. 529:. 499:. 474:. 449:. 437:: 403:. 383:: 343:. 329::

Index

cognitive linguistics
generative linguistics
University of Amsterdam
Mick Short
linguistics
stylistics
cognitive poetics
narratology
literary theory
Gothic fiction
The Old Man and the Sea
Gulf Stream
reader response theory
semiotics















Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.