Knowledge

:Knowledge Signpost/2007-06-11/Arbitration report - Knowledge

Source 📝

644:. Various remedies have been proposed including an early proposal to impose no sanctions on any of the parties but calling on the parties to enter into mediation, based on a finding of fact noting a lack of reliable evidence in the case, and a proposal to prohibit administrator actions between the parties has the support of six. Voting on a recent proposal to desysop Rama's Arrow is split at three-to-one. Voting on principles regarding the posting of private e-mails is split but it appears that a majority of arbitrators will support the principle that private e-mails may not be posted on-wiki without the consent of the sender. 73: 93: 853: 53: 83: 103: 63: 113: 209:. Badlydrawnjeff then filed for a deletion review, which was speedily closed or removed by a number of administrators and others consecutively, including JzG, Doc Glasgow and Tony Sidaway, and the closures often reverted or new DRVs opened. There is dispute as to whether the actions of all parties were within process, and whether, as some believe, 683:) alleges that he has engaged in "controversial edits", edit warring, incivility, and possibly sockpuppetry. TingMing denies the allegations, and alleges incivility on the part of Ideogram. Kirill Lokshin has proposed a remedy banning TingMing for one year, which has the support of eight arbitrators. 954: 923: 706:, but the mediation broke down after Tajik was alleged to have edited through sockpuppets while claiming to be away and unavailable for the mediation. Remedies have been proposed banning Tajik either indefinitely or for one year (which have the support of six arbitrators), and reminding 106: 76: 66: 870: 116: 96: 361:) has disruptively tagged non-free images for deletion, even when a valid fair-use justification exists, and has harassed editors who have complained about this behavior. Abu badali denies the allegations. 473:
and other editors on Central and Eastern Europe-related articles. Multiple parties accuse others of edit warring, incivility, unethical behavior and biased editing. (An earlier arbitration case,
33: 589: 327: 39: 758:-related articles. MariusM alleges that Mauco (who has not made a statement because he is blocked) has engaged in sockpuppetry, edit warring and other misconduct. If closed, 217:, apparently after discussions on the admin IRC channel, although some have stated that the consensus on the channel did not favour the block. The block was quickly undone by 495:), who was listed as a party in the new case.) An amnesty for past behaviour in editing disputes on articles relating to Eastern Europe has the support of two arbitrators. 468: 902: 831: 86: 907: 835: 640:, and blocked them for six months. They deny the allegations, and allege that Rama's Arrow acted improperly in blocking them, and in posting private e-mails to the 887: 877: 819: 811: 897: 882: 827: 815: 231: 166: 892: 823: 474: 160: 864: 689: 721: 707: 527: 523: 501: 342: 1022: 536: 367: 935: 650: 522:. Proposals placing paranormal-related articles on article probation, limiting editors on them to one revert per week, and cautioning 415: 942: 260: 247: 143: 56: 21: 998: 970: 993: 988: 783: 751: 619: 553: 397: 983: 605: 565: 492: 769: 583: 571: 358: 291: 559: 383: 135: 797: 680: 666: 633: 577: 303: 737: 432: 321: 309: 241: 978: 852: 297: 276: 17: 519: 444: 315: 462: 450: 927: 438: 456: 237: 777: 745: 613: 547: 391: 213:
takes priority over DRV. A peripheral issue to the case is a 60-hour block of Badlydrawnjeff by
714: 599: 486: 153: 1004: 763: 352: 285: 8: 408: 377: 791: 773: 741: 674: 660: 627: 609: 542: 387: 731: 478: 426: 174: 126: 595: 482: 270: 170: 759: 348: 280: 222: 641: 515: 507: 373: 206: 1016: 787: 710:
that Knowledge operates by consensus (with the support of three arbitrators).
703: 670: 656: 623: 511: 333: 251: 218: 210: 198: 190: 147: 636:), Rama's Arrow alleges that the others acted as meatpuppets of banned user 755: 727: 695: 637: 421: 401: 266: 186: 800:) would be indefinitely banned from any editing related to Transnistria. 699: 214: 202: 194: 139: 506:
A case involving the actions of various users, especially as regards
514:, on "articles on paranormal and pseudoscientific topics", such as 178: 225:
acted improperly in undeleting some articles deleted under BLP.
372:
A case involving the actions of a number of users, including
146:(resolved without a full case) from an indefinite block by 138:
did not accept or close any cases this week, except that
332:
for one month (later reduced to one week) for alleged
702:. The case had been suspended to allow a referral to 165:
A highly controversial case involving the actions of
142:
was unblocked and placed on revert parole, after an
940:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try 205:. The resulting AfD was then speedily closed by 1014: 124: 951:No comments yet. Yours could be the first! 943: 14: 1015: 279:), who was controversially blocked by 1023:Knowledge Signpost archives 2007-06 27: 851: 221:. Additionally, some allege that 28: 1034: 726:A case involving the actions of 694:A case involving the actions of 655:A case involving the actions of 541:A case involving the actions of 265:A case involving the actions of 236:A case involving the actions of 111: 101: 91: 81: 71: 61: 51: 34:The Report on Lengthy Litigation 704:Community enforceable mediation 936:add the page to your watchlist 252:Community sanction noticeboard 193:which was closed as delete by 13: 1: 481:in part due to inactivity of 919: 18:Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost 7: 971:delivered to your talk page 520:Electronic voice phenomenon 10: 1039: 185:to the article known as 856: 400:), in relation to the 855: 642:incidents noticeboard 347:A case alleging that 250:), referred from the 189:, which underwent an 136:Arbitration Committee 933:To follow comments, 197:, but overturned on 903:Features and admins 832:Features and admins 238:PalestineRemembered 232:PalestineRemembered 928:Discuss this story 913:Arbitration report 857: 31:Arbitration report 944:purging the cache 908:Technology report 843: 810:Also this week: 479:without prejudice 420:A case involving 1030: 1007: 966:Want the latest 947: 945: 939: 926: 875: 867: 860: 808: 593: 477:, was dismissed 472: 331: 129: 115: 114: 105: 104: 95: 94: 85: 84: 75: 74: 65: 64: 55: 54: 1038: 1037: 1033: 1032: 1031: 1029: 1028: 1027: 1013: 1012: 1011: 1010: 1009: 1008: 1003: 1001: 996: 991: 986: 981: 974: 963: 962: 957: 955:+ Add a comment 952: 949: 941: 934: 931: 930: 924:+ Add a comment 922: 918: 917: 916: 888:Board elections 878:From the editor 868: 863: 861: 858: 846: 845: 844: 820:Board elections 812:From the editor 717: 715:Motion to close 545: 424: 411: 283: 156: 131: 130: 123: 122: 121: 112: 102: 92: 82: 72: 62: 52: 46: 43: 32: 26: 25: 24: 12: 11: 5: 1036: 1026: 1025: 1002: 997: 992: 987: 982: 977: 976: 975: 965: 964: 961: 960: 959: 958: 953: 950: 932: 929: 921: 920: 915: 910: 905: 900: 898:News and notes 895: 890: 885: 883:Privacy report 880: 874: 862: 850: 849: 848: 847: 828:News and notes 816:Privacy report 807: 806: 804: 802: 801: 716: 713: 712: 711: 685: 684: 646: 645: 532: 531: 516:parapsychology 497: 496: 475:Piotrus-Ghirla 410: 407: 406: 405: 363: 362: 338: 337: 334:revert warring 256: 255: 227: 226: 167:Badlydrawnjeff 161:Badlydrawnjeff 155: 154:Evidence phase 152: 132: 120: 119: 109: 99: 89: 79: 69: 59: 48: 47: 44: 38: 37: 36: 35: 30: 29: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1035: 1024: 1021: 1020: 1018: 1006: 1000: 995: 990: 985: 980: 972: 969: 956: 946: 937: 925: 914: 911: 909: 906: 904: 901: 899: 896: 894: 891: 889: 886: 884: 881: 879: 876: 872: 866: 859:In this issue 854: 842: 841: 837: 833: 829: 825: 821: 817: 813: 805: 799: 796: 793: 789: 785: 782: 779: 775: 774:William Mauco 771: 768: 765: 761: 757: 753: 750: 747: 743: 742:William Mauco 739: 736: 733: 729: 725: 723: 719: 718: 709: 705: 701: 697: 693: 691: 690:E104421-Tajik 687: 686: 682: 679: 676: 672: 668: 665: 662: 658: 654: 652: 648: 647: 643: 639: 635: 632: 629: 625: 621: 618: 615: 611: 610:Dangerous-Boy 607: 604: 601: 597: 591: 588: 585: 582: 579: 576: 573: 570: 567: 564: 561: 558: 555: 552: 549: 544: 540: 538: 534: 533: 529: 525: 521: 517: 513: 509: 505: 503: 499: 498: 494: 491: 488: 484: 480: 476: 470: 467: 464: 461: 458: 455: 452: 449: 446: 443: 440: 437: 434: 431: 428: 423: 419: 417: 413: 412: 403: 399: 396: 393: 389: 388:Notmyrealname 385: 382: 379: 375: 371: 369: 365: 364: 360: 357: 354: 350: 346: 344: 340: 339: 335: 329: 326: 323: 320: 317: 314: 311: 308: 305: 302: 299: 296: 293: 290: 287: 282: 278: 275: 272: 268: 264: 262: 258: 257: 253: 249: 246: 243: 239: 235: 233: 229: 228: 224: 220: 216: 212: 208: 204: 200: 196: 192: 188: 184: 180: 176: 172: 168: 164: 162: 158: 157: 151: 149: 145: 141: 137: 128: 118: 110: 108: 100: 98: 90: 88: 80: 78: 70: 68: 60: 58: 50: 49: 41: 23: 19: 967: 912: 871:all comments 865:11 June 2007 839: 809: 803: 794: 780: 766: 756:Transnistria 748: 734: 722:Transnistria 720: 688: 677: 663: 649: 630: 616: 602: 586: 580: 574: 568: 562: 556: 550: 543:Rama's Arrow 535: 500: 489: 465: 459: 453: 447: 441: 435: 429: 414: 409:Voting phase 394: 380: 366: 355: 341: 324: 318: 312: 306: 300: 294: 288: 273: 259: 244: 230: 182: 181:in relation 175:Tony Sidaway 159: 133: 127:David Mestel 57:PDF download 1005:Suggestions 973:each month? 840:Arbitration 596:Bakasuprman 566:protections 512:attribution 483:Ghirlandajo 445:protections 402:Lewis Libby 304:protections 171:Doc glasgow 107:X (Twitter) 836:Technology 760:MarkStreet 578:page moves 502:Paranormal 457:page moves 349:Abu badali 343:Abu badali 316:page moves 281:Swatjester 223:violetriga 183:inter alia 45:Share this 40:Contribute 22:2007-06-11 999:Subscribe 893:WikiWorld 824:WikiWorld 572:deletions 537:Hkelkar 2 451:deletions 374:NYScholar 368:NYScholar 310:deletions 207:thebainer 1017:Category 994:Newsroom 989:Archives 968:Signpost 798:contribs 788:EvilAlex 784:contribs 770:contribs 752:contribs 738:contribs 681:contribs 671:Ideogram 667:contribs 657:TingMing 651:TingMing 634:contribs 624:Sbhushan 620:contribs 606:contribs 554:contribs 493:contribs 433:contribs 404:article. 398:contribs 384:contribs 359:contribs 292:contribs 277:contribs 248:contribs 219:Gaillimh 148:Dmcdevit 97:Facebook 87:LinkedIn 77:Mastodon 20:‎ | 728:MariusM 708:AzaToth 696:E104421 638:Hkelkar 422:Piotrus 416:Piotrus 786:) and 740:) and 622:) and 584:rights 560:blocks 528:Kazuba 524:Dradin 463:rights 439:blocks 386:) and 322:rights 298:blocks 267:Miskin 261:Miskin 211:WP:BLP 144:appeal 117:Reddit 67:E-mail 984:About 754:) on 700:Tajik 215:Zsinj 203:Xoloz 195:Drini 140:Koavf 16:< 979:Home 792:talk 778:talk 764:talk 746:talk 732:talk 698:and 675:talk 669:). 661:talk 628:talk 614:talk 600:talk 548:talk 526:and 518:and 510:and 508:bias 487:talk 427:talk 392:talk 378:talk 353:talk 286:talk 271:talk 242:talk 177:and 134:The 772:), 608:), 590:RfA 469:RfA 328:RfA 201:by 199:DRV 191:AfD 179:JzG 125:By 42:— 1019:: 838:— 834:— 830:— 826:— 822:— 818:— 814:— 594:, 187:QZ 173:, 169:, 150:. 948:. 938:. 873:) 869:( 795:· 790:( 781:· 776:( 767:· 762:( 749:· 744:( 735:· 730:( 724:: 692:: 678:· 673:( 664:· 659:( 653:: 631:· 626:( 617:· 612:( 603:· 598:( 592:) 587:· 581:· 575:· 569:· 563:· 557:· 551:· 546:( 539:: 530:. 504:: 490:· 485:( 471:) 466:· 460:· 454:· 448:· 442:· 436:· 430:· 425:( 418:: 395:· 390:( 381:· 376:( 370:: 356:· 351:( 345:: 336:. 330:) 325:· 319:· 313:· 307:· 301:· 295:· 289:· 284:( 274:· 269:( 263:: 254:. 245:· 240:( 234:: 163::

Index

Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost
2007-06-11
Contribute
PDF download
E-mail
Mastodon
LinkedIn
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Reddit
David Mestel
Arbitration Committee
Koavf
appeal
Dmcdevit
Badlydrawnjeff
Badlydrawnjeff
Doc glasgow
Tony Sidaway
JzG
QZ
AfD
Drini
DRV
Xoloz
thebainer
WP:BLP
Zsinj
Gaillimh
violetriga

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.