431:
117:
107:
33:
127:
87:
137:
97:
90:
110:
301:
If editors disagree on how to express a problem and/or solution in mathematics articles, citations to reliable published sources that are directly related to the topic of the article and directly support the material as presented must be supplied by the editor(s) who wishes to include the material.
650:
was famous for invariably starting his answer "It all depends on what you mean by ...". On the occasion that the question was "What is the law of averages." Joad replied "The law of averages says that if you spin a coin one hundred times it will come down heads fifty times and tail fifty times."
641:
It was an interesting case, although I didn't follow the actual cut and thrust, I did review the proposed rulings. The interest came from the fact that ArbCom is generally leery of getting tangled in content issues (quite rightly) they initially allowed themselves to move further into that sphere
592:
For my own part and on behalf of the committee, I'd like to confirm that Dr Gill did not do anything underhand in respect to using his own material, nor was there anything "wrong" with the material itself - these were not self published blogs, but material accepted by recognised journals. The
491:
130:
100:
140:
540:
297:
to the widest possible audience. For most articles, this means understandable to a general audience. Every reasonable attempt should be made to ensure that material is presented in the most widely understandable manner possible.
548:
207:
203:
555:
544:
593:
reminder issued by the committee is just that, a reminder that there is an etiquette in sourcing to one's own work, and the poor environment on the article talkpage had definitely not been conducive to etiquette. --
559:
260:
submitted several proposed principles in the workshop before submitting a proposed decision for arbitrators to vote on. The case came to a close during the week after a total of 12 arbitrators voted on the proposed
194:
193:
651:
For some reason lured outside his normal cautious approach, by a subject he was less familiar with than many of the questions he did answer so well, he committed what we would today call an
628:
602:
666:
224:
695:
506:
73:
67:
470:
465:
418:
409:
120:
545:
impossible to write (most) articles on mathematics, because editors would have been barred from providing simple examples that were not directly from reliable sources
480:
186:
586:
272:
686:
Suppose there are three editors and one of them is going to be topic banned. I tell you who one of the editors who is not topic banned is.... Um, nevermind. ;-P
397:
531:
455:
240:
642:
than normal, despite, or perhaps because of, the esoteric nature of the subject. This is a pattern seen widely, for example the well known philosopher Dr
290:
of articles by engaging in sustained attacks on other editors may be banned from the affected articles, and in extreme cases, may be banned from the site.
607:
That is another accurate and fair statement by a habitually graceful truth-teller. Elen was the principal author of the adopted statement, I should add.
460:
448:
215:
442:
173:
52:
41:
765:
511:
181:
This case was opened this week after allegations of tendentious POV-pushing and a content dispute involving the usage of sources in the
271:
Article talk pages should not be used by editors for proposing unpublished solutions, forwarding original ideas, redefining terms, or
518:
21:
740:
495:
735:
730:
725:
275:. Although more general discussion may be permissible in some circumstances, it will not be tolerated when it becomes
385:, when referencing or inserting his own sources of his own authoring into the article as references, namely to avoid
378:
358:
172:
161:
321:
287:
239:
302:
Novel derivations, applications or conclusions that cannot be supported by sources are likely to constitute
720:
624:
582:
430:
342:
46:
32:
17:
598:
660:
551:
that both is consistent with the WP rules and allows us to write articles for a general audience.
214:
594:
253:
691:
610:
568:
746:
657:
558:
Gill referenced his own papers when referring to only others' results (and never his own).
372:
352:
164:
closed one case during the week, and opened one new case. Three cases are currently open.
8:
549:
the arbitration committee listened to the mathematicians' concerns and drafted a decision
294:
234:
527:
362:
315:
249:
502:
167:
687:
647:
393:, and to seek consensus first if editing in a contentious segment of the mainspace.
336:
150:
386:
368:
348:
345:) is topic-banned from the subject of the Monty Hall problem until 25 March 2012.
68:
New case opens; Monty Hall problem case closes – what does the decision tell us?
257:
154:
560:
One ArbCom member opposed the statement about Gill; another formally abstained
324:) is indefinitely topic-banned on subjects related to the Monty Hall problem.
759:
382:
311:
390:
303:
280:
276:
643:
332:
182:
361:) is subject to a 1RR restriction until 25 March 2012 when editing the
248:
This case involves allegations of problematic behavior relating to the
652:
556:
I have long expressed displeasure with the statement about Gill.
279:, overwhelms the page, impedes productive work, or is otherwise
252:
article. Evidence was submitted on-wiki by 17 editors. Drafters
202:
During the week, another 66 kilobytes was submitted as on-wiki
327:
Glkanter is banned from editing
Knowledge until 25 March 2012.
266:
What is the effect of the decision and what does it tell us?
396:
Articles related to the Monty Hall problem are subject to
381:) is reminded to follow good practice in respect of
306:
within the definition used by the
English Knowledge.
516:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try
539:However, the article missed the main news story:
757:
185:article. 21 kilobytes was submitted as on-wiki
206:while several proposals were submitted in the
148:
536:The article summarizes the decision well.
195:Arbitration Enforcement sanction handling
646:, a member of an early radio panel show
519:
14:
758:
51:
766:Knowledge Signpost archives 2011-03
27:
429:
398:"standard" discretionary sanctions
53:
31:
28:
777:
501:These comments are automatically
135:
125:
115:
105:
95:
85:
715:: doing it for free since 2005.
197:(AE sanction handling) (Week 3)
512:add the page to your watchlist
13:
1:
487:
210:by arbitrators and others.
18:Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost
7:
10:
782:
696:14:43, 31 March 2011 (UTC)
667:10:58, 30 March 2011 (UTC)
629:17:36, 29 March 2011 (UTC)
603:11:09, 29 March 2011 (UTC)
587:19:00, 28 March 2011 (UTC)
541:the early drafted decision
547:. The good news is that
509:. To follow comments,
434:
422:"Arbitration report" →
36:
433:
35:
505:from this article's
414:"Arbitration report"
383:conflict of interest
543:would have made it
471:Features and admins
293:Articles should be
288:disrupt the editing
528:Monty Hall problem
496:Discuss this story
476:Arbitration report
466:WikiProject report
435:
250:Monty Hall problem
241:Monty Hall problem
65:Arbitration report
42:← Back to Contents
37:
670:
622:
595:Elen of the Roads
580:
554:Another concern:
520:purging the cache
481:Technology report
391:reliable sourcing
304:original research
254:Elen of the Roads
176:(Coanda) (Week 1)
47:View Latest Issue
773:
749:
665:
648:The Brains Trust
621:
619:
608:
579:
577:
566:
523:
521:
515:
494:
453:
445:
438:
421:
413:
262:
231:
223:See last week’s
211:
190:
157:
139:
138:
129:
128:
119:
118:
109:
108:
99:
98:
89:
88:
59:
57:
55:
781:
780:
776:
775:
774:
772:
771:
770:
756:
755:
754:
753:
752:
751:
750:
745:
743:
738:
733:
728:
723:
716:
708:
707:
611:
609:
569:
567:
525:
517:
510:
499:
498:
492:+ Add a comment
490:
486:
485:
484:
446:
441:
439:
436:
425:
424:
419:
416:
411:
247:
245:
237:
222:
220:
201:
199:
189:by three users.
180:
178:
170:
158:
147:
146:
145:
136:
126:
116:
106:
96:
86:
80:
77:
66:
62:
60:
50:
49:
44:
38:
26:
25:
24:
12:
11:
5:
779:
769:
768:
744:
739:
734:
729:
724:
719:
718:
717:
710:
709:
706:
705:
704:
703:
702:
701:
700:
699:
698:
677:
676:
675:
674:
673:
672:
671:
634:
633:
632:
631:
500:
497:
489:
488:
483:
478:
473:
468:
463:
458:
456:News and notes
452:
440:
428:
427:
426:
417:
408:
407:
406:
404:
402:
401:
394:
366:
346:
330:
329:
328:
309:
308:
307:
295:understandable
291:
284:
268:
267:
244:
238:
236:
233:
219:
213:
198:
192:
177:
171:
169:
166:
144:
143:
133:
123:
113:
103:
93:
82:
81:
78:
72:
71:
70:
69:
64:
63:
61:
58:
45:
40:
39:
30:
29:
15:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
778:
767:
764:
763:
761:
748:
742:
737:
732:
727:
722:
714:
697:
693:
689:
685:
684:
683:
682:
681:
680:
679:
678:
668:
663:
662:
659:
654:
649:
645:
640:
639:
638:
637:
636:
635:
630:
626:
620:
618:
614:
606:
605:
604:
600:
596:
591:
590:
589:
588:
584:
578:
576:
572:
563:
561:
557:
552:
550:
546:
542:
537:
533:
529:
522:
513:
508:
504:
493:
482:
479:
477:
474:
472:
469:
467:
464:
462:
459:
457:
454:
450:
444:
443:28 March 2011
437:In this issue
432:
423:
415:
405:
399:
395:
392:
388:
384:
380:
377:
374:
370:
367:
364:
360:
357:
354:
350:
347:
344:
341:
338:
334:
331:
326:
325:
323:
320:
317:
313:
310:
305:
300:
299:
296:
292:
289:
285:
282:
278:
274:
270:
269:
265:
264:
263:
259:
255:
251:
242:
232:
229:
227:
217:
216:Rodhullandemu
212:
209:
205:
196:
191:
188:
184:
175:
165:
163:
156:
152:
142:
134:
132:
124:
122:
114:
112:
104:
102:
94:
92:
84:
83:
75:
56:
54:28 March 2011
48:
43:
34:
23:
19:
712:
656:
616:
612:
574:
570:
564:
553:
538:
535:
475:
449:all comments
403:
387:undue weight
375:
355:
339:
318:
246:
235:Closed cases
225:
221:
200:
179:
174:Henri Coanda
159:
747:Suggestions
688:Jason Quinn
644:C.E.M. Joad
532:Arbitration
503:transcluded
461:In the news
277:tendentious
183:Coanda-1910
151:Ncmvocalist
661:Farmbrough
625:Discussion
583:Discussion
369:Gill110951
349:Rick Block
286:Users who
281:disruptive
168:Open cases
79:Share this
74:Contribute
22:2011-03-28
741:Subscribe
653:epic fail
617:Wolfowitz
575:Wolfowitz
507:talk page
261:decision.
258:SirFozzie
162:Committee
155:Lord Roem
760:Category
736:Newsroom
731:Archives
713:Signpost
565:Thanks,
412:Previous
379:contribs
359:contribs
343:contribs
322:contribs
312:Glkanter
273:so forth
243:(Week 7)
228:coverage
226:Signpost
218:(Week 4)
208:workshop
204:evidence
187:evidence
121:LinkedIn
101:Facebook
20: |
363:article
111:Twitter
613:Kiefer
571:Kiefer
389:, use
333:Nijdam
131:Reddit
91:E-mail
726:About
16:<
721:Home
711:The
692:talk
658:Rich
599:talk
420:Next
373:talk
353:talk
337:talk
316:talk
256:and
160:The
153:and
141:Digg
534:==
149:By
76:—
762::
694:)
664:,
655:.
627:)
601:)
585:)
562:.
530::
526:==
410:←
690:(
669:.
623:(
615:.
597:(
581:(
573:.
524:.
514:.
451:)
447:(
400:.
376:·
371:(
365:.
356:·
351:(
340:·
335:(
319:·
314:(
283:.
230:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
