Knowledge

:Knowledge Signpost/2015-02-11/News and notes - Knowledge

Source 📝

259:, the prize "recognizes and encourages innovative and interdisciplinary research that cuts across traditional boundaries and paradigms. It aims to foster universal values of excellence, creativity, justice, democracy and progress and to promote the scientific, technological and humanistic achievements that advance and improve our world." Each year winners are selected for their work affecting the past, present, and future in a different broad category for each time frame. A US$ 1 million prize is awarded to the winner or winners in each time frame. This year's categories and winners were: 737:, That RfA was just a few months before I had reason to get so heavily involved in how our admins get (s)elected. If I saw a question like that today it would immediately ring all my alrm bells very loudly and certainly incur a clear oppose vote. Such findings are strong grounds for getting our CU policy changed at least for adminship candidates when someone comes up with such compelling evidence. Even if it works only once a year, it would throw out a warning to candidates with an agenda. -- 660:"I'm concerned by this pro-forma behaviour too. Early in his career, the candidate was accused of being a reappearance of a prolific sockmaster. I would expect a smart person of this kind to work their passage up to admin status by perfunctory activity of the kind that we see. My impression is that there are still some unresolved COI issues around The Indian Institute of Planning and Management. Colonel Warden (talk) 2:39 am, 14 September 2010, Tuesday (4 years, 5 months, 1 day ago) (UTC−7)" 422: 122: 112: 36: 132: 92: 142: 102: 95: 234: 620:
There is also an even larger and far rarer Giant Mario, who can walk over and destroy everything in his path, including the largest and most powerful enemies. Giant Mario has a time limit after which he reverts to being Super Mario, but can be killed with great difficulty. The analogy here is left as
115: 614:
In Mario Brothers, When Small Mario takes a hit, he dies. When Super Mario takes the same hit he turns into Small Mario. The obvious analogy would be a case where when a regular user misbehaves badly enough he is site banned, but when an administrator misbehaves in the exact same way he is desysoped
538:
I see the UAE complaints as totally valid, but not this one. This isn't the Israeli government promoting itself, its a university that happens to be located in its boundaries, yeah it's public, but universities usually operate pretty independently of their governments interests. The fact that the IP
706:
The clear message the recent Arbcom case sends to us all therefore, is that anyone who is thinking of starting yet another perennial motion to lower the bar at RfA (or even to unbundle the tools) had better think again. We can't be careful enough when (s)electing our admins and we have a duty
213:
While a site ban appears to be a foregone conclusion at this point, arbitrators continue to discuss the wording of an associated restriction that would ostensibly remain in effect if Wifione returns to the project. The case appears to be nearing closure, and this is one case of alleged long-term
700:
again either (for those who have been around long enough to remember it) but who knows whether or not they have reincarnated their ugly head under some other guise? I already made the mistake once of supporting one candidate who later turned into an unpleasant adversary and was finally
690:
I particularly liked the accused admin in question and had absolutely no previous inkling of what came to be exposed at Arbcom. I somehow missed out on voting on their RfA, where even regular RfA oposers were unable to to sway it to a non-promotion although it was a fairly close
487: 135: 105: 145: 209:
initially commented that "even keeping the 'Super Mario Problem' in mind, I do not feel that this reaches the level of a site ban," he later changed his vote on the site ban to support, noting that administrators should be held to a higher standard.
205:, at minimum, in addition to the desysopping. Many arbitrators discussed a so-called "Super Mario Problem"—essentially, conduct that would get a non-administrator banned only gets an administrator desysopped. Although 662:— Myself, I found Wifione to be a very reasonable person in general administrative sorts of discussions, although I admittedly never ventured within a 10 mile radius of their editing areas of interest. 335: 198: 573:
I feel that the Wifione section understates what's going on with the case. While sockpuppetry is a factor, I think the bigger issues Arbitrators are trying to address is the editing. --
30:
One editor faces likely ban for work on Knowledge; Jimmy Wales awarded $ 1 million: Also: GLAM-Wiki Conference; Ombudsman Commission announced; Slovak Knowledge now has 200,000 articles
651: 636: 634: 632: 604: 584: 716: 671: 78: 190: 70: 502: 640: 548: 471: 165: 342:
Wales if he will turn down the award from an Israeli organization, though it remains to be seen if this award will attract as much criticism as the Knowledge Award.
746: 729: 567: 461: 446: 125: 466: 409: 400: 456: 697: 439: 532: 433: 228: 55: 44: 476: 696:
This is probably a rare case as far as site bans of sysops are concerned and we’ll probably never see the likes again of such a fiasco as
820: 722: 186: 507: 372:, a group of volunteers tasked by the Wikimedia Foundation's Board of Trustees with scrutinizing potential violations of the global 222: 218:
while supporting a site ban, the "level of deception and manipulation of rises to a very high level over a long period of time."
514: 181:
allegedly using sockpuppets and his tools as an administrator to edit with a major conflict of interest, the English Knowledge's
21: 523:
The IP mentioned in the Jimmy Wales article has been blocked for trolling. The comment was his/her only visible contribution. —
194: 795: 491: 790: 785: 595:
makes it sound like the second editor was awarded $ 1 million for doing the same thing the first editor was banned for. --
554:
Super Mario Problem... I like this phrase. I would suppose then, a 'crat is Fire Mario? What an interesting comparison. --
658:
Re:Wifione. None of this is particularly new. Particular credit to the illustrious Col. Warden who noted during the RFA:
172:
Editor's note: This will receive more extensive coverage in next week's arbitration report; a brief update appears here.
780: 721:
Oh Pastor Theo. That case still irks me. NuclearWarfare and I, talking off-wiki, called that they were a sock (see
241: 562: 764: 775: 421: 49: 35: 17: 555: 707:(including me of all people) to do more research before placing our !votes in the upstairs lobby. -- 193:
receiving little support, he now faces significant sanctions from the committee. Wifione has already
214:
abuse that the committee appears ready to put to rest. "Based upon duration, severity, etc.," wrote
221:
Wifione first edited in April 2009, racking up over 16,000 edits since. He became an administrator
369: 273: 377: 355: 339: 394:
is spoken by approximately seven million people in Slovakia, the Czech Republic, and Hungary.
801: 544: 328: 215: 8: 647: 600: 579: 277: 256: 362:, which will be hosted by the Dutch Wikimedia chapter in The Hague from April 10 to 12. 359: 155: 701:
desysoped for acting in a way totally unbecoming for the role we invest in our admins.
373: 742: 712: 682: 667: 626:
And no, I didn't know any of this before tonight. I looked it up on mariowiki.com. :)
528: 498: 202: 387: 315: 182: 540: 391: 345: 324: 252: 206: 643: 596: 574: 311: 685:
was largely responsible for, and vital to, its conclusion by the arbitrators.
593:
One editor faces likely ban for work on Knowledge; another awarded $ 1 million
323:
Last year, Wales shared a separate $ 1 million prize—the Knowledge Award—with
814: 734: 726: 307: 159: 738: 708: 663: 524: 178: 539:
is blocked has nothing to do with the validity of the complaint, however.
292: 248: 237: 233: 638: 197:
his adminship under a cloud, and as of press time, ten arbitrators have
631:
Knowledge edits where the Super Mario Problem has been discussed:
681:
The deep research made by at least one uninvolved admin for
354:: Conference tickets and discounted hotel rooms are now 725:), but we backed off because there was no solid proof. 331:
due to that nation's human rights abuses (see previous
760:
Get the latest headlines on your user page – just add
512:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try 166:
English Knowledge editor faces ban for sockpuppetry
327:, but was criticized for accepting money from the 270:Retrieving the Past: Historians and their Sources 71:One editor faces likely ban for work on Knowledge; 812: 255:. First awarded in 2002 and administered by 153: 251:will be one of the recipients of the 2015 229:Another $ 1 million prize for Jimmy Wales 338:). In a similar vein, an IP editor has 232: 515: 14: 813: 390:has reached the 200,000 article mark. 225:, passing with about 80% in support. 54: 29: 821:Knowledge Signpost archives 2015-02 27: 420: 185:is in the final stages of closing 73:Jimmy Wales is awarded $ 1 million 56: 34: 28: 832: 497:These comments are automatically 140: 130: 120: 110: 100: 90: 508:add the page to your watchlist 368:: The composition of the 2015 366:Ombudsman Commission announced 13: 1: 747:10:57, 14 February 2015 (UTC) 730:05:15, 14 February 2015 (UTC) 717:04:18, 14 February 2015 (UTC) 672:16:45, 13 February 2015 (UTC) 652:05:20, 13 February 2015 (UTC) 605:01:49, 13 February 2015 (UTC) 585:23:13, 12 February 2015 (UTC) 568:17:54, 12 February 2015 (UTC) 549:15:22, 12 February 2015 (UTC) 533:14:57, 12 February 2015 (UTC) 483: 18:Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost 7: 621:an exercise for the reader. 615:and becomes a regular user. 289:The Information Revolution 10: 837: 360:2015 GLAM-Wiki Conference 242:Gottlieb Duttweiler Prize 191:proposals in the workshop 189:on the matter. With his 698:Pastor Theo’s adminship 177:In the ongoing saga of 505:. To follow comments, 425: 245: 39: 765:Signpost-subscription 424: 236: 183:Arbitration Committee 38: 501:from this article's 370:Ombudsman Commission 352:GLAM-Wiki Conference 329:United Arab Emirates 278:Alessandro Portelli 257:Tel Aviv University 492:Discuss this story 472:WikiProject report 426: 413:"News and notes" → 246: 201:of a twelve-month 45:← Back to Contents 40: 723:the RfA questions 516:purging the cache 321: 320: 223:in September 2010 50:View Latest Issue 828: 804: 769: 763: 582: 577: 565: 564:Pls No Pineapple 560: 519: 517: 511: 490: 462:Featured content 447:From the editors 444: 436: 434:11 February 2015 429: 412: 405:"News and notes" 404: 388:Slovak Knowledge 384:Slovak Knowledge 316:Michael Waterman 262: 261: 162: 144: 143: 134: 133: 124: 123: 114: 113: 104: 103: 94: 93: 62: 60: 58: 57:11 February 2015 836: 835: 831: 830: 829: 827: 826: 825: 811: 810: 809: 808: 807: 806: 805: 800: 798: 793: 788: 783: 778: 771: 767: 761: 757: 756: 739:Kudpung กุดผึ้ง 709:Kudpung กุดผึ้ง 580: 575: 563: 556: 521: 513: 506: 495: 494: 488:+ Add a comment 486: 482: 481: 480: 437: 432: 430: 427: 416: 415: 410: 407: 402: 348: 325:Tim Berners-Lee 304:Bioinformatics 253:Dan David Prize 231: 216:NativeForeigner 168: 163: 152: 151: 150: 141: 131: 121: 111: 101: 91: 85: 82: 69: 65: 63: 53: 52: 47: 41: 31: 26: 25: 24: 12: 11: 5: 834: 824: 823: 799: 794: 789: 784: 779: 774: 773: 772: 759: 758: 755: 754: 753: 752: 751: 750: 749: 703: 702: 693: 692: 687: 686: 675: 674: 655: 654: 628: 627: 623: 622: 617: 616: 608: 607: 588: 587: 552: 551: 496: 493: 485: 484: 479: 474: 469: 467:Traffic report 464: 459: 454: 452:News and notes 449: 443: 431: 419: 418: 417: 408: 399: 398: 397: 396: 395: 381: 374:privacy policy 363: 347: 344: 319: 318: 312:David Haussler 305: 302: 296: 295: 290: 287: 281: 280: 271: 268: 240:receiving the 230: 227: 199:voted in favor 175: 174: 167: 164: 149: 148: 138: 128: 118: 108: 98: 87: 86: 83: 77: 76: 75: 74: 72: 68:News and notes 67: 66: 64: 61: 48: 43: 42: 33: 32: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 833: 822: 819: 818: 816: 803: 797: 792: 787: 782: 777: 766: 748: 744: 740: 736: 733: 732: 731: 728: 724: 720: 719: 718: 714: 710: 705: 704: 699: 695: 694: 689: 688: 684: 680: 677: 676: 673: 669: 665: 661: 657: 656: 653: 649: 645: 641: 639: 637: 635: 633: 630: 629: 625: 624: 619: 618: 613: 610: 609: 606: 602: 598: 594: 591:The headline 590: 589: 586: 583: 578: 572: 571: 570: 569: 566: 561: 559: 550: 546: 542: 537: 536: 535: 534: 530: 526: 518: 509: 504: 500: 489: 478: 475: 473: 470: 468: 465: 463: 460: 458: 455: 453: 450: 448: 445: 441: 435: 428:In this issue 423: 414: 406: 393: 389: 385: 382: 379: 375: 371: 367: 364: 361: 357: 353: 350: 349: 343: 341: 337: 334: 330: 326: 317: 313: 309: 308:Cyrus Chothia 306: 303: 301: 298: 297: 294: 291: 288: 286: 283: 282: 279: 275: 272: 269: 267: 264: 263: 260: 258: 254: 250: 243: 239: 235: 226: 224: 219: 217: 211: 208: 204: 200: 196: 192: 188: 184: 180: 173: 170: 169: 161: 157: 156:Go Phightins! 147: 139: 137: 129: 127: 119: 117: 109: 107: 99: 97: 89: 88: 80: 59: 51: 46: 37: 23: 19: 679:Re: Wifione: 678: 659: 611: 592: 557: 553: 522: 457:In the media 451: 440:all comments 383: 365: 351: 332: 322: 299: 284: 265: 247: 220: 212: 176: 171: 802:Suggestions 612:Background: 499:transcluded 376:, has been 293:Jimmy Wales 274:Peter Brown 249:Jimmy Wales 238:Jimmy Wales 541:Oiyarbepsy 207:Guerillero 84:Share this 79:Contribute 22:2015-02-11 796:Subscribe 683:this case 644:Guy Macon 597:Guy Macon 503:talk page 378:announced 356:available 815:Category 791:Newsroom 786:Archives 403:Previous 358:for the 346:In brief 336:coverage 333:Signpost 203:site ban 195:resigned 187:its case 160:Gamaliel 126:LinkedIn 106:Facebook 20:‎ | 664:Carrite 558:DSA510 525:Brianhe 477:Gallery 285:Present 244:in 2011 179:Wifione 116:Twitter 581:(ʞlɐʇ) 392:Slovak 386:: The 300:Future 136:Reddit 96:E-mail 781:About 691:call. 340:asked 16:< 776:Home 743:talk 713:talk 668:talk 648:talk 601:talk 545:talk 529:talk 411:Next 266:Past 146:Digg 154:By 81:— 817:: 768:}} 762:{{ 745:) 735:Ed 727:Ed 715:) 670:) 650:) 642:-- 603:) 576:DQ 547:) 531:) 401:← 314:, 310:, 276:, 158:, 770:. 741:( 711:( 666:( 646:( 599:( 543:( 527:( 520:. 510:. 442:) 438:( 380:.

Index

Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost
2015-02-11
The Signpost
← Back to Contents
View Latest Issue
11 February 2015
Contribute
E-mail
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Digg
Go Phightins!
Gamaliel
Wifione
Arbitration Committee
its case
proposals in the workshop
resigned
voted in favor
site ban
Guerillero
NativeForeigner
in September 2010

Jimmy Wales
Gottlieb Duttweiler Prize
Jimmy Wales
Dan David Prize

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.