Knowledge:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Kudpung/Proposed decision

5271:, I am the first to admit that seeing my name in this section is probably confusing. I thought about it for a long time but I cannot shake the feeling that over the years Kudpung might have gotten the wrong impression that his conduct was not really problematic and thus he never had any reason to address it.I'll try to explain what I mean: With the exception of extraordinary cases, I think every user should have received a clear "warning shot". Only if they ignored this warning shot, they should be sanctioned. With all due respect to my colleagues who maintain otherwise, the discussions mentioned in FoF proposals 4, 4.1 and 4.2 do not actually contain any such warning shots and most were closed by different admins with the conclusion that there is nothing to do. It's not hard to believe that Kudpung, upon seeing the comments and consensus in these discussions about his behavior (combined with the fact that he did pass an RFA in which his behavior was mentioned by several people in the discussion), came to the conclusion that the community is okay with his behavior.As such, it appears that this Case is the first actual warning shot Kudpung will be receiving based on a discussion with community-wide input. But since a warning shot is supposed to allow the user to improve based on the criticism received, it cannot also contain a sanction for not improving at the same time. As such, I believe that xeno's suspended remedy idea below is the better solution. Regards 5056:

arbitration". Users brought before arbitration generally have trouble identifying when they've crossed a line (hence, arbitration), and it's highly likely they may cross those same lines during arbitration. On the other hand: arbitration cases are the only formal disciplinary hearings for administrative conduct, so some participation by those under review is expected (and arguably required by WP:ADMINTACCT). What I'm reading from Kudpung's linked submission is that he wants the committee members to come to their own conclusions about his behaviour and provide adequate and appropriate direction to him. Accordingly, I don't know that the lack of specific concessions or additional participation in the evidence and workshop phases should be taken as an unwillingness to change or an unwillingness to consider adopting a moderated approach as dictated by the committee's ruling. That being said: to avoid participating further in the case than Kudpung did - to neglect to assist in appropriately contextualizing the evidence and long history, and then to later complain that committee members are deliberately biased, distorting the facts, impugning rights, or holding a kangaroo court, all strike me as somewhat unfair, given every opportunity was provided for Kudpung to participate more directly in the development of this proposed decision. –

6701:, that arbitration procedure could do with an update because it seems to reflect how arbitration was being used nine years ago. Some are wondering if the community were to have made concerted efforts at taking Kudpung to task, would he have needed to come to arbitration at all? Kudpung did seem to act, in part, with impunity for a period of years. I agree that the Knowledge community often seems to lack the ability of tackling that sort of behaviour. But in this case or any other, I think we would have ended up here even if more users had protested the admin's behaviour – or protested it more formally in an RFCU. To a large degree, users (or admins) will change their ways only if they want to. I am also reluctant to impose additional burdens on the community. Sometimes an admin grows into a problem in the years following their RFA. I think that when such a problem emerges in any case, the community should know an arbitration request would deal with it. 5118:

has been a growing source of concern by the community in recent years. I see this in the number of ArbCom cases being filed and even indirectly in the scrutiny admin candidates now undergo at RFA. Many have framed this case against other recent cases where a seeming pattern emerges. A long-time and prolific administrator has been given considerable leeway and allowed to carry on in a way not consistent with community expectations and norms. It then reaches a breaking a point. We do not expect administrators to be able to always self-identify when the line has been crossed, but we do expect them to take concerns about their actions seriously, especially when raised repeatedly, and in many of these cases by other trusted and experienced administrators. I understand

489:, arbitrators may make proposals which are ready for voting. Arbitrators will vote for or against each provision, or they may abstain. Only items which are supported by an absolute majority of the active, non-recused arbitrators will pass into the final decision. Conditional votes and abstentions will be denoted as such by the arbitrator, before or after their time-stamped signature. For example, an arbitrator can state that their support vote for one provision only applies if another provision fails to pass (these are denoted as "first" and "second choice" votes). Only arbitrators and clerks may edit this page, but non-arbitrators may comment on the talk page. 5097:

across diverse situations, with a number of users, over a prolonged period of time. There has been no indication from Kudpung that these problems are going away or that it would be possible to address them. The community appoints administrators on the basis that they will continue complying with Knowledge's standards of conduct. Administrators who cannot do so will usually have the permissions removed by ArbCom. I agree that in this case, removal of the permissions would be justified and I support the remedy on that basis. First choice.

8106: 8040: 8006: 7764: 7694: 7661: 559: 5412:

2) refrain from suggesting editors critical of his actions are making personal attacks or engaging in sanctionable behaviour; 3) refrain from unnecessarily suggesting wide and unspecific groups of users are participating in an anti-administrator bloc or disrupting community discussions, or the like; 4) refrain from personalizing disputes or making vague or critical references about unnamed editors; and 5) refrain from unnecessarily prohibiting other editors from posting to their talk page.

6724:

the Procedures bradv mentions but reading the sentence in question in context suggests that "allegations of administrator misconduct" was meant to refer to serious misconduct that requires immediate attention of the Committee, not allegations of constant "low-level" misconduct going back a decade. That the Committee accepted this case does not rule out the possibility that there might not have been a reason to accept the case if the ANI thread had been allowed to run its course. Regards

2644: 8243: 8207: 8139: 8073: 7972: 7904: 7869: 7834: 7799: 7730: 7628: 7593: 7558: 7490: 7455: 7420: 7385: 7350: 7315: 7280: 151: 4828:. I don't agree with Kudpung's reaction to GWF's comments but they did not come "out of the blue". In the end, this FoF boils down to what the 2018 ANI already highlighted, i.e. that both editors should assume a little bit more good faith of the other. I don't think it really helps to establish any kind of behavioral pattern though but instead highlights a very specific conflict between two editors in which neither is really blameless. Regards 7069: 3369:

result of progress made in the discussion and not a reflection on the initial validity of the filing. If others believe the outcomes demonstrate that Kudpung has resolved complaints in a productive way, or the initial filings were not valid, then that could be stated in its own FOF more clearly. Separately, ARC has always been taken under consideration during cases and historically seen as

6098:

GiantSnowman also participated in the full case in meaningful ways. In Kudpung's case, much more substantial concerns were raised than simply the over-use of the rollback tool. Kudpung did not participate in the evidence and workshop phase with the purpose of working towards a suitable solution, a fundamental requirement when considering whether probation will be effectively adopted.

5375:

community will still have trouble addressing the situation beyond the conclusion of this case. I'd prefer to have the committee retain jurisdiction via the suspended remedy route. If that dog will not hunt, we should include a remedy that specifies in more general terms the undesired behaviour that is being addressed to ensure that it does not re-occur. –

5203:

tools is actually too many for me to feel comfortable with. We try to make wikipedia as level as playing field as possible and the pattern of comments Kudpung has made that are antithetical to that are problematic. I should add that I don't have an issue with a person not participating as such (other than not presenting their side)

6816:

Kudpung at community noticeboards demonstrate the community's inability to address issues such as what we've seen here outside of the structure of an arbitration case. Some discussion could be had on whether there should be a structure for community review of long-standing conduct issues (such as the old

4710:

poorly on his judgement and civility, and the "proud women" comment is well over the line. The only mitigating factor I can see was that this was a very insider, wiki-political dispute, mostly involving admins and functionaries, but we shouldn't tolerate this kind of conduct anywhere in our community. –

7194:

Clerks and Arbitrators should use this section to clarify their understanding of the final decision—at a minimum, a list of items that have passed. Additionally, a list of which remedies are conditional on others (for instance a ban that should only be implemented if a mentorship should fail), and so

7135:

While asking the enforcing administrator and seeking reviews at AN or AE are not mandatory prior to seeking a decision from the committee, once the committee has reviewed a request, further substantive review at any forum is barred. The sole exception is editors under an active sanction who may still

7102:

Administrators are free to modify sanctions placed by former administrators – that is, editors who do not have the administrator permission enabled (due to a temporary or permanent relinquishment or desysop) – without regard to the requirements of this section. If an administrator modifies a sanction

6723:

Going together with FoF #4. Something not being strictly necessary does not mean that it wouldn't be beneficial and cutting discussions short by filing for Arbitration while people are actually trying to talk about things is not a good precedent. I don't know why the Committee members of 2011 adopted

5625:

The committee aims to act in a way that stems the effect had by a problem upon Knowledge. We have concluded that Kudpung is a problem. If he is to cease being a problem, we know the things that Kudpung must stop doing. The set of things Kudpung must stop doing is fairly small and most of Kudpung's

5202:

Actually on re-reading some exchanges, I can't support continued adminship. Isolated dustups with other people, and even saying misogynistic comments in the heat of the moment, I did not feel warranted a desysop, but looking back, the number of veiled threats where Kudpung alludes to admin status or

4823:

highlighted that there is probably bad blood on both sides. For the same reasons I think it might be equally possible that Kudpung referred to GWF in his ACE2019 answers or that GWF interpreted an answer not related to her as an attack on her. As for the Signpost article, I read it for the first time

4753:

I agree with SoWhy in that it seems clear Kudpung was merely trying to add gravitas to the invoking of GW's name in a post where he grouped her "among our most experienced and respected admins". Let's be honest, some of our handles are a bit...jocose? I'm sure Kudpung would have realnamed Boing! said

4414:. As to the autopatrolled discussion, a courtesy notification wouldn't have gone amiss, but I can give Kudpung the benefit of the doubt that he was using (his interpretation of) her creations as a springboard for a general discussion on the problem of having autopatrolled bundled with other rights. – 3368:

First choice. I find these relevant to the point being raised about counselling, and less to do with how each incident was resolved. A no action necessary outcome does not change the fact that people had concerns and raised them with respect to Kudpung. In many cases, no action outcomes are often the

742:

1) Administrators are trusted members of the community, who are expected to follow Knowledge policies and are held to a high standard of conduct. They are expected to perform administrative tasks to the best of their abilities. Occasional mistakes are entirely compatible with this; administrators are

654:

A temporary injunction is a directive from the Arbitration Committee that parties to the case, or other editors notified of the injunction, do or refrain from doing something while the case is pending. It can also be used to impose temporary sanctions (such as discretionary sanctions) or restrictions

6750:

Ideally, concerns about an administrator's conduct should be raised directly with them first so that every administrator has a fair opportunity to adequately explain their actions. Sometimes this is not always possible and the Arbitration Committee may accept a case where this has not been possible,

4983:

Factual, but subject to my comment below in that I don't see what evidence, in particular, Kudpung was expected to submit. Kudpung did not attempt to rebut, concede, or add context, to any of the evidence submitted by others, to be sure. I do think they're willing to take constructive criticism from

4409:

Support as a factual summary of part of the immediate background to the case, but as with FoF#5 I don't see much to fault Kudpung on here. The PRODs were not strictly within policy but PROD is designed as an "easily proposed, easily reverted" deletion process. If we were talking about a new editor's

584:

Arbitrators may place proposed motions affecting the case in this section for voting. Typical motions might be to close or dismiss a case without a full decision (a reason should normally be given). Suggestions by the parties or other non-arbitrators for motions or other requests should be placed on

6815:

explicitly say that previous attempts at dispute resolution are not required for cases involving allegations of administrator misconduct, and I have seen no evidence to suggest that a community-wide discussion would have resulted in a satisfactory resolution. On the contrary, the many threads about

5987:

2) For his failure to meet the conduct standards expected of an administrator, Kudpung is placed on administrative probation for a period of twelve months. During this probation period, Kudpung is required to refrain from any further incidents of incivility, failure to remain accountable in his use

5411:

policy, including the conduct and accountability expectations. Kudpung is advised to remain civil, consider criticism objectively, and assume good faith. Specifically, Kudpung is advised to 1) refrain from indicating on-wiki that they are conducting investigations, and the like, into other editors;

5117:

Unfortunately, I see no realistic or reasonable alternative. For a long time, our community has given administrators, in general, a wide degree of discretion about responding to concerns and criticisms about their administrative actions. Civility has been an even greater enduring problem. ADMINCOND

5096:

Knowledge is a collaborative project. Users should listen carefully to others, respond thoughtfully, avoid speaking in anger as much as possible, and try to further the purpose of Knowledge wherever possible. In this case, evidence was presented that shows Kudpung falling short of those standards

4489:

I'm willing to accept that Kudpung sincerely wanted to source opinions from a sympathetic venue as to whether removing autopatrolled from the administrative package might be indicated. However, the implicatory manner in which the post was written, immediately following the notability disagreement,

3867:

I changed "which were closed without action" to "which each resulted in consensus that no action was necessary" which imho better summarizes the closers' comments (see my comments on 4.1). I also reworded the last half-sentence because it sounded like it was closed as resolved in favor of this Case

6213:

3) Kudpung is admonished for failing to meet the conduct standards expected of an administrator. In future, he is urged to ensure that he remains civil in his interactions with both new and regular editors, and responds to feedback on his conduct objectively and with an assumption of good faith.

6097:

has been cited as an example of effective administrative probation. However, the probationary restrictions implemented were materially based upon specific administrative actions only. Civility, accountability, and hostility were noted but were not the central concerns raised as outlined in FOF#5.

5287:

Per my comments on series of FoF 4, I'd rather go with a less drastic solution. Ideally our admins should be aware that we expect collegial behavior and accountability for their actions, but if a lot of these previous attempts to resolve go nowhere fast, it risks normalizing such behavior. To me,

4709:

Kudpung is not the first person to react badly to being "called out". While far from ideal, his conduct in the initial dispute is at least understandable as an emotional overreaction. But dredging it up over a year later (I can't believe that his ACE comments weren't directed at GW) reflects very

3785:

This wording completely disregards the complaints that led to these ANI threads being opened. Yes, they were technically closed without action, but that does not imply that the complaints were without merit, nor that they were not "attempts to address his behaviour." I know this vote doesn't help

3451:

contains no real discussion of Kudpung's conduct in general but rather his relationship with GorillaWarfare and comments mainly were about how those two editors should (both) rethink their approach with regard to each other. If anything, those links show the opposite of what they purport to show,

8616:

As I see it, both can't logically co-exist but if there were another support or abstain on 1.1, both would theoretically pass. Then those in favor of either would have to indicate which one they prefer in order to resolve the conflict before we can close. As it stands now, one vote in favor of 1

5055:

While a factual comment, I'm not sure what evidence, in particular, Kudpung should have been expected to submit. I'm also sympathetic to the concern that had he mounted a vigorous defense (or even a mild defense), it could have lead to a finding similar to one in a prior case re: "conduct during

2730:

Adding that in all the cases I looked at, it seemed very unlikely that the subjects of these accusations did have any vendetta against Kudpung or admins generally. Like the threats above, reacting in this way to disputes and criticism creates a chilling effect that is incompatible with the admin

7143:

All actions designated as arbitration enforcement actions, including those alleged to be out of process or against existing policy, must first be appealed following arbitration enforcement procedures to establish if such enforcement is inappropriate before the action may be reversed or formally

7139:

These provisions apply only to contentious topics placed by administrators and to blocks placed by administrators to enforce arbitration case decisions. They do not apply to sanctions directly authorised by the committee, and enacted either by arbitrators or by arbitration clerks, or to special

4668:

I would have hoped that after the August 2018 incident Kudpung would realize how deeply his comments regarding gender and sexuality have affected other people. Making similar comments over a year later, regardless of whether they were intended to target an individual or a group, shows a lack of

1955:

I understand that Kudpung is highly active in the new page patrol process and thus would have heightened opportunity for interaction with new editors and should AGF, be polite, refrain from BITE, etc., so I withdraw my opposition. However, I can't support including a principle that has no clear

5374:

to administrator conduct standards sends the wrong message. If this is the only remedy passed, we are implying Kudpung's behaviour would have been okay if it had come from a non-administrator. This is not so. Should the undesired behaviours not ameliorate on their own, it is highly likely the

5141:

Little of Kudpung's conduct has directly related to his use of the tools. However that non-tool conduct does rise to a level of antagonism and disagreeableness that merits this remedy. More importantly, this hasn't been limited to a problematic interaction or single pain point—it's endemic to

3807:

I don't think this clearly outlines the point being made about the previous attempts being closed as no action needed. It implies to me that there was no fault by the party rather than implying it was worked out or that the threads were closed inappropriately, the community could not reach a

2514:

The PAs are debatable, but the evidence shows that Kudpung has had this habit of making vague threats when he falls out with someone for a long time. And coming from someone with not just the tools, but the level of social influence in the community Kudpung has, it's an extremely bad habit.

6841:

I appreciate the sentiment. I do. But this case is about admin misconduct. How many dozens of times have we seen AN or ANI threads about administrators closed preemptively with 'we can't do anything about this here, take it to Arbcom'? If we're going to change ARBPOL to require preliminary

5662:

I cannot vote in favour of a motion that stipulates that Kudpung's behaviour warrants a desysop, yet allows him to keep the tools without any concrete evidence that he has taken steps to restore the trust of the community. I also have serious concerns about using a remedy that was designed

5634:

time, as this remedy has us do. We should only rule now on the adminship question if reform is close enough to impossible. There are such prospects and I do not object to this remedy on that basis. However, I do think this remedy is a little unlikely to work: personalised and convoluted

941:

2) Administrators are expected to lead by example and to behave in a respectful, civil manner in their interactions with others. While such an ideal applies to interactions with all editors, it is particularly relevant to interactions with newer and inexperienced users, as in those cases,

5190:

I too have sat on this for a few days while recovering from the flu, and I apologize for holding everything up. There is a distinctly unbecoming sense of entitlement to some of Kudpung's interactions. I'm unwilling to, as Bradv puts it, kick the can down the road for a future committee.

5435:

I'm cautiously optimistic that this will work. I would be rather disappointed if the previous undesired behaviours re-emerge following the closure of this case, and willing to swiftly enact (unsuspend) the remedy if it becomes clear it did not have the appropriate preventative effect.

8646:

With your indication on 4.1, this puts it at 4-4-1, so 4.1 would currently fail because 4.3 (your first choice) fails and 4.2 (your second choice) passes. I updated the table accordingly. Can a clerk check my math please (pinging those I saw active here and assigned to case,

1140:

3) Administrators are expected to objectively consider criticism and questions relating to their decisions including those raised by anonymous editors. For an administrator to not promptly and appropriately deal with concerns, without good cause, may constitute misconduct.

5153:

I've been sitting on this for a few days as I was really hoping to see some evidence that Kudpung has taken the feedback in this case on board and made some sort of commitment to improve his behaviour. The evidence is clear that Kudpung has fallen short of the standards of

6966:

iirc. I’m not seeing much in the ways of discussion on that particular paragraph, so I can’t really speak confidently as to the intention of the framers with respect to how serious the alleged misconduct need be to waive the prior resolution attempt requirement.

5168:

case, this was accompanied by evidence that the administrator was receptive to feedback and had made concrete steps to improve their behaviour. This is not the case here, which makes anything less than a desysop just kicking the can further down the road. –

8617:(Xeno) and two votes in favor of 1.1 (AGK and David Fuchs) are designated as second choice, so they would count as opposes when it comes to decide whether to pass 1 or 1.1 (meaning 1 stands at 6-3 considering second choices and 1.1 stands at 3-6). Regards 7036:

Appeals may be made only by the editor under sanction and only for a currently active sanction. Requests for modification of page restrictions may be made by any editor. The process has three possible stages (see "Important notes" below). The editor may:

2785:

that admins are some kind of better editor, just that he was and is unintentionally using language that some might misinterpret as arrogance even when he is most likely just trying to point out actual problems). I'm with xeno in that I don't support the

4754:

Zebedee if it was publicly disclosed. The use of the real name was thus unlikely to have diminutive intent. While GW would have probably done better to make the request privately, Kudpung's manner of public response was inappropriate, to say the least.

3434:

I think those additional links are potentially misleading (per my comment when voting whether to accept this case). The first three discussions really were not attempts to address his behavior in general but rather single issue reports that ended with

2493:

Some of this evidence goes back 4 years, but I can agree that it needs to be included. Recognising patterns in this sort of conduct can take time, and the conduct itself can be irregular. That requires us to look deeply and sometimes further back.

5807:

Could you advise how remedy 1 addresses FoF 3,6,7, other than changing the buttons Kudpung sees when he logs in? None of those findings related to the use of administrative user rights per se, the removal of which is the only remedy provided by 1.

5626:

interactions are problem-free. The issues in Kudpung are ones of attitude and, it troubles me not to say, an inflated sense of his importance. I can see how this remedy might deal with those problems. It is not axiomatic that because a case has

7103:

placed by a former administrator, the administrator who made the modification becomes the "enforcing administrator". If a former administrator regains the tools, the provisions of this section again apply to their unmodified enforcement actions.

4824:

for this Case and while it was critical of Maher's performance, I cannot find any language to suggest that this criticism was based (solely) on the fact that she is a woman, which means it's hard to understand why GWF assumed it to be based on

5162:, and his refusal to participate meaningfully in this case while criticizing it elsewhere is not exactly reassuring. In previous cases where the committee has agreed to a lesser sanction such as a probation or editing restriction, such as the 6027:

Second choice (ie if remedy 1 passes, I oppose this proposal). Kudpung has had a number of months or years to address the problems in evidence, so I am not sure that I see how placing him on probation would be likely to achieve very much.

4132:

This should be noted because it's the incident that precipitated this case, but it was resolved amicably so I don't think it reacts particularly badly on Kudpung (other than as a further example of the pattern of threat-making discussed

4818:

I think the initial comment was understandable, in that Kudpung merely used the real name for those admins where the real name was known (which just happened to be Joe and GWF). The following comments between them less so, although the

3447:. Additional link #5 is the same as link #3 in the original FoF #4 (and was closed with 'Any further discussion regarding behavior or policy should be taken to the appropriate talk page or discussion board.' which did not happen) and 4927:

I get that ArbCom cases are stressful, but given that the central issue here is a lack of openness and poor reaction to feedback on his conduct, Kudpung missed a golden opportunity to demonstrate that he can take criticism on board.

4741:

I'm of the opinion that GW's initial comment was ill-considered and unnecessarily confrontational, but Kudpung's reaction and dredging up the old dispute while feigning ignorance do not strike me as any model of considered behavior.

1561:

5) Knowledge was founded on the principle that "anyone can edit" and that by the collaboration of editors of all backgrounds, the best possible encyclopedia can be created. Hostility towards any editor is prohibited by Knowledge's

1923:

Factually correct, but there is no matching FoF. This principle is quite specific and it would stand to reason that a major purpose of it would be to support a FoF that Kudpung bites newcomers (a claim which we do not make).

3256: 3106: 3915: 3596: 3244: 3094: 2926:

I'd be fine with this change, although we could equally do without the "trolling" diff altogether, as it may not say what we initially thought it did. "He often reacts to criticism by dismissing it or by requesting..." –

2224:) has been a user since 2006 and an administrator since 2011. He has made over 100,000 edits and performed more than 14,000 admin actions. He has been particularly active in coordinating and driving improvements to the 4458:

discussion on the valid question whether we should assume all admins to be sufficiently skilled in article writing that their creations do not need patrolling. Even taking into account Missvain's prior episode of UPE

3052:

I agree with both parts; I don't think the diffs given below are really good examples of prior dispute resolution specifically around Kudpung, rather than being adjacent discussions. It's a difference of perspective.

6645:

is supposed to be the final step in the dispute resolution process. The community is reminded that attempting to have a community-wide discussion of problematic behavior early on can prevent unnecessary escalations.

7098:

Nothing in this section prevents an administrator from replacing an existing sanction issued by another administrator with a new sanction if fresh misconduct has taken place after the existing sanction was applied.

2471:

Nonspecific threats used as a means of intimidation are not appropriate in a collaborative environment. Comments to good-faith editors about their conduct should be constructive and encouraging wherever possible. –

7026:

This procedure applies to appeals related to, and modifications of, actions taken by administrators to enforce the Committee's remedies. It does not apply to appeals related to the remedies directly enacted by the

5953: 7136:

request an easing or removal of the sanction on the grounds that said sanction is no longer needed, but such requests may only be made once every six months, or whatever longer period the committee may specify.

6993:

0) Should any user subject to a restriction in this case violate that restriction, that user may be blocked, initially for up to one month, and then with blocks increasing in duration to a maximum of one year.

1986:(PROD) is a streamlined process for nominating an article for deletion. It should only be used for obvious and uncontroversial deletions where no opposition is expected. Proposed deletions are subject to the 8561:

4.2 has currently three votes designated as "second choice". If we were to count them as "oppose if 4.1 passes", we would arrive at 5 to 4, so still passing. Maybe those who indicated no preference (pinging

5781: 5430: 5365:

Since I am in agreement that a desysop is warranted, but willing to suspend it, I also am compelled to support a desysop remedy if there lacks committee majority for the suspended route. That said, I feel

3840: 5396:

1.1) For his failure to meet the conduct standards expected of an administrator, Kudpung's administrative user rights are removed. He may regain them at any time via a successful request for adminship.

4997:

Factual. The approach is understandable if one takes of a view of this process as a largely judicial; however, if one treats it more as a disciplinary case, then responding to evidence would be useful.

3370: 5089:

1) For his failure to meet the conduct standards expected of an administrator, Kudpung's administrative user rights are removed. He may regain them at any time via a successful request for adminship.

4460: 5122:'s desire to acknowledge positive contributions and length of service, but at the same time we must cautious and recognize the long-term damage that has been caused by past committees by enacting 5288:

such a remedy moves the goalposts; they should be moved, not by making an example out of an individual, but rather by encouraging the community to not quickly dismiss such noticeboard threads.

4454:

Factually mostly correct although I am assuming good faith that Kudpung did not in fact start a "discussion of Missvain's autopatrolled right" but instead merely used this incident to start a

2545:

Few of Kudpung's individual comments would I think be considered severe personal attacks on their own, but their cumulative effect is a perceived pugnacious attitude that degrades discussion.

1632:

This isn't a principle ArbCom has articulated before, but I believe it reflects an important pillar of our community and conduct policies, and in this case is especially relevant to FoF #7. –

4887:

Increased participation in the case would have been nice. What I would particularly love to see is some acknowledgement of the problems mentioned in the case and a commitment to do better. –

4861:

indicating he is willing to take on board objective criticism and generally try to learn from the feedback given, but he did not make any specific concessions to the criticism brought forth.

4063: 3923: 3604: 3260: 2975: 8570:) could specify which they would prefer? I noted AGK has struck his equal preference vote on 4.1 in favor of 4.2 but at 6-3 with no second choice indicators, it would still pass. Regards 6476: 4012: 2631: 2636:

3) Kudpung frequently reacts to feedback on his conduct unobjectively and without assuming good faith. On multiple occasions, he has interpreted criticism as a vendetta against himself

5784:(and I should probably have noted this somewhere more obvious) that I did invite and have a conversation about suspended remedies with Kudpung, among others, on my talk page (archived 3452:

i.e. that previous discussions never really attempted to resolve a potential general problem with Kudpung's approach and mostly ended in consensus that there is nothing to do. Regards

2682: 7000: 5865:

of removing the toolset "more than just the removal of a toolset"? If this were an actual restriction that would be enforced by blocks, sure, but that's not what you have proposed. –

569: 78: 4625:

Kudpung and GorillaWarfare did not interact again until the ArbCom elections in November 2019. In response to a question about his boycott of Women in Red, Kudpung made reference to

7156: 5025: 4797: 4613: 4610: 4530: 4232: 3498:

The noticeboard discussions seemed to go nowhere fast and they did not result in any useful advice to Kudpung with reference to previous FoFs (accountability/uncollegial conduct).

3064:

The noticeboard discussions seemed to go nowhere fast and they did not result in any useful advice to Kudpung with reference to previous FoFs (accountability/uncollegial conduct).

2833: 2596: 2167: 1896: 1762:

6) Knowledge articles are improved through the hard work of both regular editors and newcomers; every new editor is a potential long-term contributor. All editors should therefore

1726: 1525: 1301: 1102: 4173:

I think it should also be noted that Chris.sherlock, despite this incident being the impetus of this request, has accepted that Kudpung meant him no harm and strongly opined that

8379: 6745: 6616: 6345: 4963: 4748: 4483:

opposition can be expected? An article writer will almost always oppose the deletion of their work. So you should never use prod, except when you don't expect the article writer

4449: 4168: 3059: 2766: 2551: 2388: 2109: 1872: 1668: 1467: 1243: 1044: 903: 8353: 6556: 6303: 4882: 2329: 845: 6848: 6812: 5736: 3717: 3394: 3204: 6186: 5401: 4939: 4858: 4721: 4425: 4144: 2742: 2526: 2084: 1847: 1643: 1442: 1218: 1019: 498: 5444: 5404:

to take on board feedback made during this case, and accept the committee's decision and apply it accordingly, this remedy will be suspended upon the closure of this case.

5197: 4316: 3919: 3911: 3656: 3600: 3592: 3493: 3252: 3248: 3102: 3098: 6800: 6510: 6119: 5620: 5015: 4978: 4839: 4786: 4685: 4520: 4474: 4385: 4222: 4188: 3944: 3894:

4.3) Multiple editors have individually counseled Kudpung or complained about his behavior in messages on his talk page or in the context of other discussions including in

3628: 3286: 3081: 2822: 2801: 2706: 2586: 2488: 2305: 2157: 2099: 2040: 1862: 1812: 1716: 1658: 1608: 1515: 1457: 1406: 1291: 1233: 1183: 1092: 1034: 984: 820: 6778: 5148: 4992: 4953: 4922: 4764: 4736: 4704: 4498: 4404: 4158: 4127: 3023: 3000: 2853: 2756: 2564: 2540: 2136: 2123: 1886: 1695: 1682: 1494: 1481: 1270: 1257: 1071: 1058: 372: 8700: 8457: 8419: 8369: 6836: 6735: 6605: 6584: 6531: 6374: 6335: 6277: 6081: 5756: 5635:

arrangements have a high social cost and are rarely worth the slim benefits they bring, when they manage even that much. Second choice: support only if remedy 1 fails.

5606: 5305: 5282: 4903: 4852: 4108: 3773: 3542: 3306: 3149: 3129: 3047: 2725: 2509: 2378: 2344: 2289: 2270: 2068: 1831: 1627: 1426: 1202: 1003: 893: 835: 785: 8527:

Ah, my bad. Then both FoFs are currently passing. Again, if this is not the desired outcome, arbitrators should resolve the vote before passing a motion to close. Best,

8343: 8330: 6910: 6761: 6569: 6545: 6320: 6292: 6108: 5064: 4439: 4340: 4201: 3903: 3733: 3584: 3363: 3165: 3110: 2885: 2357: 2319: 1964: 1916: 872: 859: 8398: 6688: 6494: 6256: 6043: 5259: 5218: 1162: 804: 672: 7056: 6022: 5848:: The community is looking for much more than just the removal of a toolset. There is no guarantee that simply removing the user rights will have the desired effect. – 5790:

Rschen7754 has also suggested I recuse from this case as a result of this conversation which Rschen7754 feels lacked transparency. I am considering their suggestion. –

5708: 5416: 3802: 3706: 3515: 3463: 409: 241: 8674: 8641: 8628: 8604: 8581: 8556: 8522: 8498: 6926: 6175: 6154: 5897: 5881: 5856: 5840: 5725: 5683: 5585: 5563: 4663: 4087: 4030: 3957: 3879: 3851: 3818: 3669: 3643: 3562: 3480: 3407: 3383: 3193: 3180: 2943: 2906: 1941: 6975: 6132: 5964: 5947: 5816: 5798: 5692:

Kudpung from notifying Missvain of his investigation into her edits, which is the opposite of what we want. FoFs 3, 6, and 7 are all not addressed by this remedy. –

5541: 5524: 5482: 5351: 5338: 5185: 3970: 3753: 3682: 3420: 3345: 67: 56: 6946: 5650: 5383: 5325: 5231: 5136: 5079:

Note: All remedies that refer to a period of time, for example to a ban of X months or a revert parole of Y months, are to run concurrently unless otherwise stated.

1791: 7211: 6716: 6470: 6063: 3889: 3570: 3226: 1357: 6094: 5730:

If I ever vote for another civility parole, somebody beat me with a frying pan. If we feel like we have to desysop, let's pull up our big girl panties and do it.

764: 174: 5330:

See comment; willing to support subject to the passing of an additional remedy to address the undesired behaviour that did not involve administrative actions. –

4364: 3436: 5391: 4621: 4603: 6236: 3614: 963: 4820: 3448: 2466: 2019: 403: 6668: 3575:

4.2) Multiple users have individually counseled Kudpung about his behavior in messages on his talk page or in the context of other discussions including in

6515:

The incident with Missvain was one of several unacceptable interactions which we hope to address with this case, and not tied to Missvain in particular. –

4638: 2957: 1587: 656: 586: 486: 482: 62: 51: 594: 5112: 3399:

I've reviewed the noticeboard links with fresh eyes and there are indeed users within those threads attempting to deliver feedback to modify behaviour. –

3113:). While several of those discussions may have been closed prematurely, it's not quite accurate to say that dispute resolution attempts were not made. – 4619: 4617: 4615: 2778:"comes across as a rather creepy idea that admins constitute some kind of Knowledge aristocracy who should be treated with more respect than the peons" 8289:

will close the case 24 hours after the fourth net support vote has been cast, unless an absolute majority of arbitrators vote to fast-track the close.

4641: 2654: 367: 4635: 3633:

Distant second choice for reasons stated above. I believe this somewhat dilutes the point being made about attempts rather than outcomes and blame.

5163: 3843:

to including links that were submitted at the case request, but not submitted into evidence. I dropped "4" because it's referenced below already. –

2249: 1385: 399: 195: 187: 45: 4561: 4038: 3895: 3576: 3241: 2972: 8316: 4756:

I hope that it's clear we aren't endorsing the characterization of the Signpost piece as misogynistic, just describing the sequence of events. –

3607:

report that was closed after the reporting user indicated that the issue was resolved. At this time, this Case request had already been opened.

1340:

4) Knowledge users are expected to behave reasonably, calmly, and courteously in their interactions with other users. Unseemly conduct, such as

3231:

4.1) Multiple users have individually counseled Kudpung about his behavior in messages on his talk page or in the context of other discussions

3093:

I agree with the first part of this finding, but not the second. There were many attempts to resolve these issues on public noticeboards (e.g.

1135: 2962:

4) Multiple users have individually counseled Kudpung about his behavior in messages on his talk page or in the context of other discussions

2431: 2200: 341: 8469:

Under the rules, 4.1 is passing and 4.2 is not. I've updated the table, but if arbitrators prefer a different outcome they should so vote.

5982: 5824:, you and I both know that adminship is about more than changing the buttons someone sees when they log in. See principles 1, 2, and 3. – 191: 5268: 4609:

critical of WMF director Katherine Maher. GorillaWarfare commented on the piece, describing it as continued "misogyny" on Kudpung's part.

4410:

creations it might be different, but Missvain is a very well-established editor who can be expected to be familiar with the principle of

548: 361: 206: 184: 40: 29: 6455:

Given the history, this is put forward for consideration. I don't think it is necessary as it appears to have been a one-off encounter.

7045: 5688:

I should also point out that this remedy does not sufficiently address the conduct concerns in this case. In particular, it would have

1757: 442: 394: 332: 251: 179: 4463:

and Kudpung's understandable aversion against UPE, I don't see any reason why Kudpung could have expected the PRODs to stick. Regards

4331: 2875: 2647: 2429: 5433:: actually handing down the remedy (so that the appropriate denunciatory effect is achieved) while suspending it in the same action. 4263: 544: 357: 2419: 6398: 3445:'nothing here rises to a level that would lead the community in general to question an individual's "fitness as an editor admin".' 468: 337: 655:

on an article or topic. Suggestions by the parties or other non-arbitrators for motions or other requests should be placed on the

3926:

report that was closed after the reporting user indicated that the issue was resolved (after this case had already been opened).

737: 732: 347: 327: 210: 4612:

This comment led to an edit war and block of GorillaWarfare by uninvolved administrator Fram, which was subsequently overturned.

8286: 7049: 2435:

In disputes with other editors, he has also made nonspecific threats of retaliating against or "investigating" the other party.

352: 265: 246: 8285:

Four net "support" votes (each "oppose" vote subtracts a "support") or an absolute majority are needed to close the case. The

6436: 2790:

part of this finding. The diff does not prove that and even if it did, a single instance does not constitute "often". Regards

743:

not expected to be perfect. However, repeated or egregiously poor judgment may result in the removal of administrator status.

315: 5072: 3899: 3580: 1766:

when dealing with new editors and, if it is necessary to comment on problematic actions, do so in a clear and polite manner.

386: 277: 5415:

If any editor feels that Kudpung's behaviour does not accord with the letter or the spirit of this remedy, they may file an

3907: 3588: 7188: 4577: 4054: 936: 310: 7183: 6208: 5419:

or contact the committee privately to request the remedy be enacted and Kudpung's administrative user rights be removed.

5084: 4326: 3235: 2966: 1977: 236: 165: 25: 565:

Under no circumstances may this page be edited by anyone other than members of the Arbitration Committee or the clerks.

4490:

made it clear that it concerned a specific user. Accordingly, a courtesy note to that user, at least, was indicated. –

6988: 6636: 2917:

Kudpung has removed material from his talk page, dismissing it as "trolling" or similar, and reacted to criticism by

1556: 7195:

on. Arbitrators should not pass the motion to close the case until they are satisfied with the implementation notes.

7173: 4060: 4058: 2440: 4637:

GorillaWarfare interpreted this as referring to her, and challenged Kudpung on why he emphasised that she is queer.

3238: 2969: 6282:

If PD 1 and 2 do not pass. Otherwise, I would say this is inappropriately too light when placed with FOFs 1 to 8.

2641: 2639: 7120:(i) the clear and substantial consensus of (a) uninvolved administrators at AE or (b) uninvolved editors at AN or 7008: 2915:

I'm gathering the "often" is meant tie in to the latter part of the sentence. So the sentence could be reworded:

2660: 2438: 727: 302: 142: 4984:

the committee on board. It shouldn't require this level of intervention for an administrator to self-moderate. –

4174: 2777: 493:

For this case there are 10 active arbitrators, not counting 5 recused. 6 support or oppose votes are a majority.

8535: 8477: 8312: 7091:

prior affirmative agreement for the modification at (a) AE or (b) AN or (c) ARCA (see "Important notes" below).

6664: 6466: 6432: 6232: 6113:

I can appreciate trying this as I don't think the admin tools are the fulcrum on which the ill behavior turns.

6018: 5752: 5602: 5255: 5214: 4878: 4659: 4360: 4322: 4280: 4083: 3769: 3554:

I'd prefer if we work on a 4.3 that we can all agree on, rather than passing a FoF so deeply split like this. –

3538: 3302: 3145: 2996: 2678: 2462: 2245: 2015: 1787: 1583: 1381: 1158: 959: 760: 288: 231: 21: 3868:

when in fact Rosguill assumed that the request would not be accepted and things would thus end there. Regards

2888:(In other words, the claim of "often" is not supported by the evidence attached) 00:15, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 671:

the fastest an injunction will be imposed, unless there are at least four votes to implement immediately. See

6414: 4584: 4333: 4324: 2221: 1341: 539:

If observing editors notice any discrepancies between the arbitrators' tallies and the final decision or the

223: 5785: 5664: 4066:

and was considered to be resolved after Kudpung wrote privately to Chris.sherlock clarifying his intention.

3839:

This is a draft to address concerns raised in previous versions and talk. Feel free to tweak. Note there is

3444: 3440: 3232: 3036:

discussion and might even have pulled it off if it hadn't been closed in favor of the Case request. Regards

2963: 2436: 2433: 942:

administrators provide a public face to both the broader administrative corps and to Knowledge as a whole.

593:

Motions require an absolute majority of all active, unrecused arbitrators (same as the final decision). See

551:. Similarly, arbitrators may request clerk assistance via the same method, or via the clerks' mailing list. 4292: 2205: 1566:

and, if directed towards a particular group, can be especially damaging to the inclusivity of the project.

461: 273: 171: 6983: 2658: 6357:

Accomplished by 1.1 as it is more of an admonishment with a path to enforcement should problems persist.

4336: 4328: 4310: 4298: 1361: 1349: 283: 201: 7095:

Administrators modifying sanctions out of process may at the discretion of the committee be desysopped.

6820:), but that is outside the jurisdiction of this committee and well outside of the scope of this case. – 4369:

I find the failure to notify Missvain of a discussion about her conduct and user rights unacceptable. –

3591:. Kudpung has also been the subject of incident reports on the administrators' noticeboard including in 2442: 8552: 8494: 7060: 5223:

Per my comments; remedy 3 is now passing which does address the undesired behaviour in broad strokes. –

4286: 322: 1998:

is not required but considered good practice when the main concern is lack of notability or sources.

649: 4304: 1335: 3243:(2020). There were also several attempts to address his behaviour on public noticeboards, including 5408: 4571: 4048: 2827:

I agree that the third sentence could use some wordsmithing, but I get the gist and I can support.

454: 5903: 4015: 4008: 4004: 3028:

I think it's important to note that the 2020 ANI thread was the first to try to address a more

8594:

It would be my understanding that if PD 1 passes then PD 1.1 would not pass. Is that correct?

4092:

Chris.sherlock considered the matter resolved, but that doesn't mean the threats were okay. –

2569:

While the PAs are debatable, it is a pattern of overall intimidating and uncollegial behavior.

6962:: It was part of an omnibus update to committee policy and procedure, largely spearheaded by 6642: 2444: 1770:

can alienate a potential contributor and is therefore detrimental to the project as a whole.

679: 161: 17: 3352:

I don't think we saw these extra diffs in the evidence phase, but they are very relevant. –

2424:

2) Kudpung has occasionally made remarks towards other editors that could be interpreted as

8267: 6767: 5123: 2690:

requires that administrators be open and ready to discuss their conduct when questioned. –

1353: 7084:

No administrator may modify or remove a sanction placed by another administrator without:

8: 5989: 5159: 5155: 4567: 4044: 2974:(2020). However, there had been no community-wide dispute resolution attempts before the 2687: 95: 4330:. Two of these nominations were made after he was made aware that Missvain would object 8696: 8446:

Per the table, currently 4.1 and 4.2 would pass. That still needs sorting out. Regards

8375: 8306: 6844: 6658: 6612: 6460: 6426: 6341: 6226: 6182: 6012: 5746: 5732: 5596: 5249: 5208: 5193: 5021: 4872: 4793: 4653: 4526: 4354: 4335:

and therefore could not be considered "uncontroversial", as all proposed deletions are

4274: 4228: 4077: 3763: 3713: 3532: 3437:'no consensus that Kudpung's actions represent a need for any sanctions via this board' 3390: 3296: 3200: 3139: 2990: 2829: 2672: 2592: 2456: 2384: 2239: 2163: 2009: 1892: 1781: 1722: 1577: 1521: 1375: 1345: 1297: 1152: 1098: 953: 899: 754: 120: 5422:

Kudpung may apply to have this remedy vacated one year from the closure of this case.

3910:

and in the reports on the administrators' noticeboards about his actions including in

6963: 6505: 6408: 4934: 4716: 4420: 4139: 3728: 3358: 3160: 2737: 2521: 2300: 2215: 2079: 1842: 1638: 1563: 1437: 1213: 1014: 815: 109: 6842:

discussions first, we should do that. Until then, the committee is the destination.

8546: 8488: 8348: 7202: 6874: 6740: 6551: 6298: 6114: 6093:

As per my comments in PD#1, I do not see this has being an acceptable outcome. The

5929: 5615: 5506: 5143: 4958: 4743: 4444: 4163: 3651: 3488: 3054: 2761: 2546: 2324: 2104: 1995: 1987: 1867: 1663: 1462: 1238: 1039: 840: 7178: 6003:

We were trying to come up with something a bit more concrete than 'admonishment'.

663:

Four net "support" votes needed to pass (each "oppose" vote subtracts a "support")

8669: 8660: 8623: 8576: 8517: 8452: 8414: 8392: 8364: 6940: 6921: 6831: 6817: 6785: 6730: 6710: 6682: 6590: 6579: 6526: 6488: 6359: 6330: 6272: 6250: 6170: 6139: 6076: 6057: 6037: 5876: 5835: 5777: 5703: 5678: 5644: 5570: 5558: 5290: 5277: 5180: 5106: 5000: 4973: 4916: 4898: 4834: 4771: 4698: 4680: 4505: 4469: 4398: 4380: 4207: 4183: 4121: 4103: 3939: 3874: 3797: 3747: 3691: 3623: 3500: 3458: 3339: 3322: 3281: 3124: 3066: 3042: 3017: 2938: 2901: 2807: 2796: 2772: 2719: 2701: 2650: 2571: 2503: 2483: 2363: 2339: 2283: 2265: 2142: 2094: 2062: 2035: 1926: 1857: 1825: 1807: 1701: 1653: 1621: 1603: 1500: 1452: 1420: 1401: 1276: 1228: 1196: 1178: 1077: 1029: 997: 979: 878: 830: 798: 780: 131: 5992:. If Kudpung does not meet this requirement at any time, any editor may file an 4640:

Kudpung denied that he was referring to GorillaWarfare or any particular editor.

8656: 8639: 8602: 8341: 8328: 7982:

One vote is "second choice" if 1.1 does not pass which currently does not pass

7216: 6973: 6908: 6776: 6759: 6567: 6543: 6418: 6318: 6290: 6130: 6106: 5993: 5962: 5945: 5895: 5854: 5814: 5796: 5723: 5539: 5522: 5480: 5442: 5381: 5349: 5336: 5323: 5229: 5134: 5062: 4990: 4951: 4762: 4734: 4496: 4437: 4343:, although without mentioning her username or notifying her of the discussion. 4199: 4156: 4028: 3968: 3955: 3849: 3816: 3680: 3667: 3661:

I would be fine dropping the bracketed remark if that enhances acceptability. –

3641: 3560: 3478: 3418: 3405: 3381: 3191: 3178: 2883: 2851: 2754: 2562: 2538: 2355: 2317: 2134: 2121: 1983: 1962: 1914: 1884: 1767: 1693: 1680: 1492: 1479: 1268: 1255: 1069: 1056: 870: 857: 90: 6048:

Update: remedy 1 or any remedy for sanction above the level of admonishment.

1908:

I agree with the content of this Principle, but there is no related Finding. –

426: 8683: 8302: 6654: 6456: 6422: 6222: 6008: 5921: 5742: 5592: 5530: 5502: 5464: 5245: 5204: 5119: 4868: 4649: 4591: 4411: 4350: 4269: 4073: 3759: 3528: 3292: 3135: 2986: 2668: 2452: 2235: 2225: 2005: 1991: 1777: 1763: 1573: 1371: 1148: 949: 750: 115: 2643:

or admins in general, making numerous references to an "anti-admin brigade".

430: 8563: 6870: 6500: 6404: 5667:, while he steadfastly refused to participate meaningfully in this case. – 4929: 4711: 4583:

Kudpung reacted to negatively to this in comments referencing "men haters",

4580:) asked Kudpung to refer to her by her username "when discussed among men". 4415: 4134: 3723: 3603:, (which each resulted in consensus that no action was necessary), and the 3353: 3155: 2877:, the removed post was criticism directed at another editor, not Kudpung. – 2732: 2516: 2425: 2295: 2211: 2074: 1837: 1633: 1432: 1208: 1009: 810: 673:

Knowledge:Arbitration Committee/Procedures#Passing of temporary injunctions

601: 568:

Please submit comments on the proposed decision in your own section on the

104: 7126:

is required. If consensus at AE or AN is unclear, the status quo prevails.

5487:

I’m sorry for continuing to add clauses. I’ll stop if it becomes passing.

5244:

weakly, trying to process this all and balance against length of service.

579: 8280:

before initiating a motion to close, so that the final decision is clear.

7088:

the explicit prior affirmative consent of the enforcing administrator; or

485:

and discussing proposals with other arbitrators, parties, and editors at

8506:, David Fuchs' vote on 4.2 is actually a second choice to 4, not 4.1. – 8016:

Two votes are "second choice" if 1 does not pass which currently passes

5568:

Reasonable solution, and a less drastic option than a straight desysop.

8679: 8664: 8618: 8571: 8507: 8464: 8447: 8404: 8359: 6959: 6916: 6892: 6869:

I’ve changed the heading to “General reminder” per comments on talk by

6821: 6725: 6698: 6694: 6574: 6516: 6325: 6262: 6160: 6071: 5925: 5917: 5886: 5866: 5845: 5825: 5804: 5693: 5668: 5553: 5498: 5460: 5272: 5170: 4968: 4888: 4829: 4670: 4464: 4370: 4178: 4093: 4019: 4000: 3934: 3869: 3787: 3618: 3453: 3271: 3114: 3037: 2928: 2896: 2791: 2691: 2646:

He often reacts to criticism by dismissing it as "trolling" or similar

2473: 2334: 2255: 2089: 2025: 1852: 1797: 1648: 1593: 1447: 1391: 1223: 1168: 1024: 969: 825: 770: 126: 7041:

ask the enforcing administrator to reconsider their original decision;

6310:

as if remedy 1.1 is one day vacated this should remain for the record.

2788:

He often reacts to criticism by dismissing it as "trolling" or similar

8648: 8634: 8611: 8596: 8567: 8540: 8529: 8503: 8482: 8471: 8336: 8322: 6968: 6903: 6771: 6753: 6562: 6537: 6479:, so I do not see what is to be gained from imposing this sanction. 6313: 6284: 6125: 6100: 5957: 5940: 5890: 5849: 5821: 5809: 5791: 5717: 5534: 5517: 5475: 5437: 5376: 5344: 5331: 5318: 5224: 5128: 5057: 4985: 4945: 4757: 4728: 4628: 4491: 4431: 4194: 4150: 4023: 3963: 3950: 3862: 3844: 3810: 3675: 3662: 3635: 3555: 3473: 3413: 3400: 3375: 3186: 3172: 2878: 2846: 2748: 2557: 2532: 2350: 2311: 2129: 2115: 1957: 1909: 1878: 1688: 1674: 1487: 1473: 1263: 1249: 1064: 1050: 865: 851: 150: 7059:. If the editor is blocked, the appeal may be made by email through 8652: 8385: 6933: 6888: 6703: 6675: 6481: 6243: 6050: 6030: 5637: 5099: 4909: 4825: 4691: 4600: 4391: 4114: 3740: 3332: 3315: 3010: 2874:

Although he is removing a post with the edit summary "rm trolling"

2712: 2496: 2276: 2055: 1818: 1614: 1413: 1189: 990: 791: 428: 4826:"the hatred of, contempt for, or prejudice against women or girls" 4597: 4595: 4588: 4586: 4581: 2637: 7611: 4857:

8) Kudpung has not submitted any evidence in this case. Kudpung

7215:; the last edit to this page was on 12:19, 9 July 2023 (UTC) by 2895:

I agree. I think we should remove that part of the FoF. Regards

1411:

As a universality, not a finding about Kudpung or other users.

5614:

Support weakly as alternative option if desysop does not pass.

431: 8633:

I’ve indicated preferences, does that resolve the ambiguity? –

7157:

procedure for the standard appeals and modifications provision

5269:

was against Kudpung being granted the tools in the first place

432: 8358:

Now that all competing proposals have been resolved. Regards

4175:

he thinks Kudpung is a good admin who should retain the tools

3330:

Removing in favour of 4.2 because it enjoys broader support.

595:

Knowledge:Arbitration Committee/Procedures#Motions to dismiss

3468:

The description of the noticeboard links should be reworded

6439:). This ban can be appealed after six months have elapsed. 3470:(and "5" removed as already used in the preceding sentence) 7990: 7159:

adopted 3 May 2014, this provision did not require a vote.

7003:

adopted 3 May 2014, this provision did not require a vote.

7887: 6751:

but it should be attempted whenever reasonably possible.

7748: 7713: 7678: 6550:

I think it's unecessary given the lack of pattern here.

5889:: how would I add the standard enforcement provisions? – 5591:

Support this as a more solid version of probation below

3808:

consensus, and so forth as suggested by some comments.

1996:

A prior search for more sources to establish notability

1956:

relation to a finding of fact or remedy contemplated. –

5996:

for the committee to review his administrator status.

5988:

of the administrator tools, or other breaches of the

7645: 5142:

Kudpung's interactions and actions across the wiki.

3922:, (which were closed with no action taken), and the 7740:Two votes are designated as "second choice" to 4.1 6261:Regardless of other remedies, this is important. – 2781:(to clarify: I don't believe that Kudpung actually 5370:removing administrative user rights and referring 3261:incident report on the administrator's noticeboard 2976:incident report on the administrator's noticeboard 7333: 4321:for deletion using the proposed deletion process 3786:with the math at all, but I still support 4.1. – 8190: 8024: 7001:procedure for the standard enforcement provision 7852: 7782: 5630:been opened, we cannot defer judgement until a 3008:Accurate and relevant. Fine with this and 4.1: 8226: 7504: 6877:. I believe this is not a substantive change, 4268:6) Kudpung nominated four articles created by 7438: 4599:and temporarily resigned as an administrator. 4057:) that Chris.sherlock interpreted as threats 3441:'a consensus that there's nothing to do here' 3313:Accurate and relevant. Equal choice with 4: 462: 8090: 7612:Kudpung's accountability as an administrator 7123:(ii) a passing motion of arbitrators at ARCA 6499:I agree that this was a one-off conflict. – 5407:Kudpung is advised to fully comply with the 4632:women accuse such men of being misogynists 4341:discussion of Missvain's autopatrolled right 4064:discussed on the administrator's noticeboard 2651:requesting that users not edit his talk page 2632:Kudpung's accountability as an administrator 6477:seems to have happened in the same few days 8682:, That is currently how I see it as well. 7263: 6297:Regardless of passing the other remedies. 4859:made a statement during the workshop phase 3527:Not wrong as such but less exact than 4.2 469: 455: 8277: 8153: 7817: 6308:Regardless of passing the other remedies 5431:Martinp's "suspended sentence" suggestion 540: 7226: 6435:) anywhere on Knowledge (subject to the 5741:pointless. Just re-reading a few things 8056: 7955: 7298: 7061:Special:EmailUser/Arbitration Committee 5474:I have added a clause. Please review. – 4602:Later the same month, Kudpung wrote an 4590:publicly withdraw his support from the 659:page for consideration and discussion. 589:page for consideration and discussion. 14: 7918: 7704:One vote designated as "third choice" 7576: 7473: 7140:functionary blocks of whatever nature. 3185:There have been noticeboard threads. – 8122: 7991:Kudpung desysopped (suspended remedy) 6673:A bit wishy-washy, but all correct. 6159:Per my comments on other remedies. – 5392:Kudpung desysopped (suspended remedy) 8276:Please ask the case clerk to author 7888:Kudpung's participation in this case 7403: 7063:(or, if email access is revoked, to 6221:(unless a stronger sanction passes) 6137:Prefer 1.1 as more straightforward. 4853:Kudpung's participation in this case 3270:Proposing as an alternative to 4. – 553: 242:Clarification and Amendment requests 7749:Previous attempts at resolution (4) 7714:Previous attempts at resolution (3) 7679:Previous attempts at resolution (2) 7046:arbitration enforcement noticeboard 6005:See my comment in previous section. 5429:This is closer to how I envisioned 3890:Previous attempts at resolution (4) 3571:Previous attempts at resolution (3) 3227:Previous attempts at resolution (2) 35: 7055:submit a request for amendment at 6561:Seemed to be a bit of a one-off. – 6419:interacting with, or commenting on 6417:) is indefinitely prohibited from 6070:Second choice after #1.1. Regards 2653:(at least six times, by Kudpung's 1994:are considered before nomination. 509:Support votes needed for majority 36: 8722: 6770:, I think we need to dispel it. – 6610:I don't think this is necessary. 4022:does this look more acceptable? – 2845:Third sentence needs rewording. – 1768:Treating newcomers with hostility 8241: 8205: 8137: 8104: 8071: 8038: 8004: 7970: 7902: 7867: 7832: 7797: 7762: 7728: 7692: 7659: 7626: 7591: 7556: 7488: 7453: 7418: 7383: 7348: 7313: 7278: 7200:These notes were last updated by 7113:For a request to succeed, either 7067: 4043:5) Kudpung made two comments to 667:24 hours from the first vote is 557: 149: 8252: 8247: 8240: 8237: 8234: 8231: 8224: 8216: 8211: 8204: 8201: 8198: 8195: 8188: 8154:Proposed Enforcement Provisions 8148: 8143: 8136: 8133: 8130: 8127: 8120: 8113: 8110: 8103: 8100: 8097: 8094: 8089: 8082: 8077: 8070: 8067: 8064: 8061: 8054: 8047: 8044: 8037: 8034: 8031: 8028: 8023: 8015: 8010: 8003: 8000: 7997: 7994: 7989: 7981: 7976: 7969: 7966: 7963: 7960: 7953: 7913: 7908: 7901: 7898: 7895: 7892: 7885: 7878: 7873: 7866: 7863: 7860: 7857: 7850: 7843: 7838: 7831: 7828: 7825: 7822: 7815: 7808: 7803: 7796: 7793: 7790: 7787: 7780: 7773: 7768: 7761: 7758: 7755: 7752: 7747: 7739: 7734: 7727: 7724: 7721: 7718: 7711: 7703: 7698: 7691: 7688: 7685: 7682: 7677: 7670: 7665: 7658: 7655: 7652: 7649: 7646:Previous attempts at resolution 7644: 7637: 7632: 7625: 7622: 7619: 7616: 7609: 7602: 7597: 7590: 7587: 7584: 7581: 7574: 7567: 7562: 7555: 7552: 7549: 7546: 7539: 7499: 7494: 7487: 7484: 7481: 7478: 7471: 7464: 7459: 7452: 7449: 7446: 7443: 7436: 7429: 7424: 7417: 7414: 7411: 7408: 7401: 7394: 7389: 7382: 7379: 7376: 7373: 7366: 7359: 7354: 7347: 7344: 7341: 7338: 7331: 7324: 7319: 7312: 7309: 7306: 7303: 7296: 7289: 7284: 7277: 7274: 7271: 7268: 7261: 7080:Modifications by administrators 5715:Per my comments above in PD#1. 5552:Per my comments above. Regards 3371:part of the arbitration process 2958:Previous attempts at resolution 6766:To the extent that there is a 6653:reiterating standard conduct. 5400:In consideration of Kudpung's 4461:that was mentioned in evidence 684:1) {text of proposed orders} 650:Proposed temporary injunctions 606:1) {text of proposed motion} 13: 1: 8701:17:04, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 8675:12:32, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 8642:11:22, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 8629:08:08, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 8605:20:31, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 8582:08:04, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 8557:18:51, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 8523:18:49, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 8499:18:45, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 8458:15:55, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 8420:13:25, 29 February 2020 (UTC) 8399:13:20, 29 February 2020 (UTC) 8380:11:26, 29 February 2020 (UTC) 8370:17:24, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 8354:17:05, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 8344:11:22, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 8331:05:54, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 8317:13:22, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 7212:23:00, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 7032:Appeals by sanctioned editors 6976:14:50, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 6947:16:14, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 6927:15:58, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 6911:15:53, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 6849:01:37, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 6837:22:11, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6801:11:40, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6783:Per comments on the desysop. 6779:05:38, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6762:20:18, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6746:19:10, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6736:11:59, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 6717:14:05, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 6689:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6669:01:30, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6617:01:37, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 6606:11:40, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6585:11:22, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6570:05:38, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6557:19:10, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6546:18:55, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6532:22:17, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6511:20:06, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6495:18:25, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6471:01:30, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6375:11:40, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6346:01:37, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 6336:11:22, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6321:05:38, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6304:19:10, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6293:18:54, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6278:22:20, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6257:18:25, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6237:01:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6187:01:37, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 6176:13:37, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6155:11:40, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6133:05:38, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6120:19:10, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6109:19:16, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 6082:11:22, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 6064:10:19, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 6044:18:25, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 6023:01:26, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 5994:arbitration amendment request 5965:21:52, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5948:21:03, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5898:20:29, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5882:19:53, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5857:19:48, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5841:19:03, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5817:17:49, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5799:06:49, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5757:13:05, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5737:01:37, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5726:16:47, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5709:14:28, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5684:13:35, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5651:10:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5621:18:13, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5607:13:31, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5586:11:40, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5564:11:22, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5542:20:20, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5525:19:59, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5483:18:05, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5445:05:30, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5384:02:59, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5352:16:56, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5339:02:59, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5326:05:38, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5306:11:40, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5283:11:22, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5260:01:28, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 5232:16:56, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5219:13:10, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5198:01:37, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5186:13:25, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5149:19:10, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 5137:18:42, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 5113:18:25, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 5065:02:43, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 5026:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 5016:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4993:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4979:21:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4964:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4954:20:43, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 4940:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4923:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4904:03:40, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4883:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4840:21:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4798:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 4787:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4765:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4749:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4737:20:43, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 4722:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4705:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4686:03:31, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4664:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4531:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 4521:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4499:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4475:21:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4450:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4440:20:45, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 4426:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4405:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4386:03:31, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4365:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4233:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 4223:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4202:02:58, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 4189:21:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4169:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 4159:20:43, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 4145:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4128:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4109:03:31, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4088:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 4031:13:07, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 3971:11:22, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 3958:13:06, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 3945:12:58, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 3880:08:29, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3852:20:52, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 3819:19:56, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 3803:19:00, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3774:08:45, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 3754:10:20, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3734:08:26, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3718:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3707:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 3683:11:22, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 3670:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 3657:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3644:18:14, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3629:08:30, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3563:03:18, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3543:08:45, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 3516:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 3494:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3481:01:22, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 3464:21:39, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3421:11:22, 28 February 2020 (UTC) 3408:19:14, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3395:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3384:18:14, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3364:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3346:07:53, 27 February 2020 (UTC) 3328:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3307:11:26, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3287:03:58, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3205:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 3194:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 3181:18:14, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3170:Third choice to 4.1 and 4.2. 3166:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3150:11:26, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3130:03:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3082:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 3060:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 3048:21:42, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3024:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 3001:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2944:14:05, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2907:21:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 2886:21:16, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 2854:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2834:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 2823:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2802:21:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 2767:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 2757:20:43, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 2743:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2726:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2707:02:53, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2683:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2597:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 2587:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2565:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2552:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 2541:20:43, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 2527:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2510:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2489:02:53, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2467:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2389:01:25, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 2379:11:21, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2358:04:26, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2345:21:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 2330:19:04, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 2320:20:43, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 2306:20:04, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2290:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2271:02:53, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2250:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2168:01:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 2158:11:04, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 2137:13:12, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 2124:06:36, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 2110:02:32, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 2100:21:45, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2085:19:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2069:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2041:02:33, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 2020:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1965:04:35, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 1942:11:04, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 1917:01:44, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1897:01:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 1887:06:36, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1873:02:32, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1863:21:45, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1848:19:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1832:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1813:02:33, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1792:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1727:01:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 1717:11:04, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 1696:13:12, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 1683:06:36, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1669:02:32, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1659:21:45, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1644:19:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1628:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1609:02:33, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1588:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1526:01:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 1516:11:04, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 1495:13:12, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 1482:06:36, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1468:02:32, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1458:21:45, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1443:19:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1427:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1407:02:33, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1386:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1302:01:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 1292:11:04, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 1271:13:12, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 1258:06:36, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1244:02:32, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1234:21:45, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1219:19:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1203:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1184:02:33, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1163:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1103:01:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 1093:11:04, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 1072:13:12, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 1059:06:36, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1045:02:32, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 1035:21:45, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1020:19:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 1004:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 985:02:33, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 964:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 904:01:16, 26 February 2020 (UTC) 894:11:04, 25 February 2020 (UTC) 873:13:12, 24 February 2020 (UTC) 860:06:36, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 846:02:32, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 836:21:45, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 821:19:29, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 805:18:12, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 786:02:33, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 765:01:21, 22 February 2020 (UTC) 7541: 7368: 7334:Administrator accountability 7018:0) Appeals and modifications 6915:No problem with me. Regards 5990:administrator conduct policy 5665:in consultation with Kudpung 1136:Administrator accountability 373:Conflict of interest reports 7: 8191:Enforcement of restrictions 8025:Kudpung placed on probation 7144:discussed at another venue. 7050:administrators’ noticeboard 6989:Enforcement of restrictions 6902:, revert if you disagree. – 5983:Kudpung placed on probation 5529:There was a broken ping to 3738:These are all fine to me. 202:Search archived proceedings 10: 8727: 7853:Kudpung and GorillaWarfare 7783:Kudpung and Chris.sherlock 6007:Second choice after #1.1. 5343:Remedy 3 is now passing. – 4562:Kudpung and GorillaWarfare 4039:Kudpung and Chris.sherlock 3722:Don't mind this or 4.1. – 2047:is not explicitly required 247:Arbitrator motion requests 8350:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 8227:Appeals and modifications 8152: 7917: 7505:Proposed Findings of Fact 7503: 7225: 7174:Discussion by Arbitrators 7068: 7009:Appeals and modifications 6742:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 6693:Re. the points raised by 6553:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 6475:Everything with Missvain 6300:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 6116:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 5617:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 5145:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 4960:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 4745:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 4446:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 4339:. Kudpung also started a 4165:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 3653:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 3490:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 3056:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 2763:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 2731:accountability policy. – 2548:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 2326:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 2228:process over many years. 2201:Proposed findings of fact 2106:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 1869:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 1665:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 1464:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 1240:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 1041:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 842:Der Wohltemperierte Fuchs 8278:the implementation notes 7439:Treatment of new editors 5409:Knowledge:Administrators 3263:that led to this case. 2978:that led to this case. 1992:alternatives to deletion 1758:Treatment of new editors 1350:assumptions of bad faith 8091:One-way interaction ban 7155:In accordance with the 7134: 6999:In accordance with the 6399:One-way interaction ban 6241:This does need saying: 6180:Per my comments above. 3388:First choice per Mkdw. 2771:Unfortunately, yes. As 1358:disruptive point-making 728:Proposed final decision 7044:request review at the 6813:Arbitration procedures 2045:(With change) Changed 1990:, which requires that 8301:Okay, I'm done here. 7264:Administrator conduct 5533:(re: added clause). – 3933:This or 4.2. Regards 3259:, in addition to the 738:Administrator conduct 541:#Implementation notes 443:Track related changes 303:Arbitration Committee 143:Knowledge Arbitration 18:Knowledge:Arbitration 7818:Kudpung and Missvain 7189:Implementation notes 6984:Proposed enforcement 6768:blue wall of silence 5956:on talk. Thoughts? – 4264:Kudpung and Missvain 4062:. This incident was 3841:an objection on talk 3487:Per comments above. 3154:In favour of 4.1. – 252:Enforcement requests 180:Guide to arbitration 101:Drafting arbitrators 7227:Proposed Principles 6437:ordinary exceptions 4566:7) In August 2018, 733:Proposed principles 502: 8253:Passes by default 8217:Passes by default 8057:Kudpung admonished 7956:Kudpung desysopped 7299:Leading by example 6931:Good with me too. 6209:Kudpung admonished 5952:I undid that, per 5085:Kudpung desysopped 4669:self-awareness. – 1364:, is prohibited. 937:Leading by example 497: 481:After considering 274:Contentious topics 172:Arbitration policy 8539: 8481: 8257: 8256: 7919:Proposed Remedies 7577:Kudpung's conduct 7474:Proposed deletion 7150: 7149: 7048:("AE") or at the 6899: 6895: 6885: 6795: 6600: 6509: 6369: 6149: 6095:GiantSnowman case 5936: 5932: 5914: 5580: 5513: 5509: 5495: 5471: 5467: 5457: 5300: 5081: 5073:Proposed remedies 5010: 4938: 4781: 4720: 4515: 4424: 4217: 4143: 3732: 3701: 3689:Also reasonable. 3510: 3362: 3164: 3076: 2817: 2775:aptly put it, it 2741: 2581: 2525: 2420:Kudpung's conduct 2373: 2304: 2152: 2083: 1984:Proposed deletion 1978:Proposed deletion 1936: 1846: 1764:assume good faith 1711: 1642: 1510: 1441: 1362:gaming the system 1286: 1217: 1087: 1018: 888: 819: 676: 577: 576: 537: 536: 479: 478: 446: 414: 284:General sanctions 232:All open requests 162:About arbitration 135: 124: 113: 99: 82: 74:Proposed decision 71: 60: 49: 8718: 8691: 8689: 8672: 8667: 8626: 8621: 8615: 8599: 8579: 8574: 8534: 8520: 8515: 8476: 8468: 8455: 8450: 8417: 8412: 8397: 8395: 8390: 8378: 8367: 8362: 8351: 8325: 8245: 8244: 8209: 8208: 8141: 8140: 8123:General reminder 8108: 8107: 8075: 8074: 8042: 8041: 8008: 8007: 7974: 7973: 7906: 7905: 7871: 7870: 7836: 7835: 7801: 7800: 7766: 7765: 7732: 7731: 7696: 7695: 7663: 7662: 7630: 7629: 7595: 7594: 7560: 7559: 7492: 7491: 7457: 7456: 7422: 7421: 7387: 7386: 7352: 7351: 7317: 7316: 7282: 7281: 7223: 7222: 7074: 7072: 7071: 7070: 7014: 7013: 6945: 6943: 6938: 6924: 6919: 6901: 6900: 6897: 6887: 6886: 6883: 6880: 6847: 6834: 6829: 6797: 6794: 6791: 6789: 6756: 6743: 6733: 6728: 6715: 6713: 6708: 6687: 6685: 6680: 6637:General reminder 6615: 6602: 6599: 6596: 6594: 6582: 6577: 6554: 6540: 6529: 6524: 6503: 6493: 6491: 6486: 6371: 6368: 6365: 6363: 6344: 6333: 6328: 6301: 6287: 6275: 6270: 6255: 6253: 6248: 6185: 6173: 6168: 6151: 6148: 6145: 6143: 6117: 6103: 6079: 6074: 6062: 6060: 6055: 6042: 6040: 6035: 5938: 5937: 5934: 5916: 5915: 5912: 5909: 5879: 5874: 5838: 5833: 5735: 5720: 5706: 5701: 5681: 5676: 5649: 5647: 5642: 5618: 5582: 5579: 5576: 5574: 5561: 5556: 5515: 5514: 5511: 5497: 5496: 5493: 5490: 5473: 5472: 5469: 5459: 5458: 5455: 5452: 5302: 5299: 5296: 5294: 5280: 5275: 5196: 5183: 5178: 5146: 5131: 5111: 5109: 5104: 5077: 5024: 5012: 5009: 5006: 5004: 4976: 4971: 4961: 4948: 4932: 4921: 4919: 4914: 4901: 4896: 4837: 4832: 4796: 4783: 4780: 4777: 4775: 4746: 4731: 4714: 4703: 4701: 4696: 4683: 4678: 4529: 4517: 4514: 4511: 4509: 4472: 4467: 4447: 4434: 4418: 4403: 4401: 4396: 4383: 4378: 4320: 4231: 4219: 4216: 4213: 4211: 4186: 4181: 4166: 4153: 4137: 4126: 4124: 4119: 4106: 4101: 3949:With my tweak. – 3942: 3937: 3877: 3872: 3866: 3813: 3800: 3795: 3752: 3750: 3745: 3726: 3716: 3703: 3700: 3697: 3695: 3674:Second choice. – 3654: 3638: 3626: 3621: 3512: 3509: 3506: 3504: 3491: 3461: 3456: 3393: 3378: 3356: 3344: 3342: 3337: 3327: 3325: 3320: 3284: 3279: 3203: 3175: 3158: 3127: 3122: 3078: 3075: 3072: 3070: 3057: 3045: 3040: 3022: 3020: 3015: 2941: 2936: 2919: 2918: 2904: 2899: 2832: 2819: 2816: 2813: 2811: 2799: 2794: 2789: 2780: 2764: 2751: 2735: 2724: 2722: 2717: 2704: 2699: 2595: 2583: 2580: 2577: 2575: 2549: 2535: 2519: 2508: 2506: 2501: 2486: 2481: 2426:personal attacks 2387: 2375: 2372: 2369: 2367: 2342: 2337: 2327: 2314: 2298: 2288: 2286: 2281: 2268: 2263: 2166: 2154: 2151: 2148: 2146: 2118: 2107: 2097: 2092: 2077: 2067: 2065: 2060: 2038: 2033: 1938: 1935: 1932: 1930: 1895: 1881: 1870: 1860: 1855: 1840: 1830: 1828: 1823: 1810: 1805: 1725: 1713: 1710: 1707: 1705: 1677: 1666: 1656: 1651: 1636: 1626: 1624: 1619: 1606: 1601: 1564:conduct policies 1524: 1512: 1509: 1506: 1504: 1476: 1465: 1455: 1450: 1435: 1425: 1423: 1418: 1404: 1399: 1342:personal attacks 1300: 1288: 1285: 1282: 1280: 1252: 1241: 1231: 1226: 1211: 1201: 1199: 1194: 1181: 1176: 1101: 1089: 1086: 1083: 1081: 1053: 1042: 1032: 1027: 1012: 1002: 1000: 995: 982: 977: 902: 890: 887: 884: 882: 854: 843: 833: 828: 813: 803: 801: 796: 783: 778: 666: 580:Proposed motions 561: 560: 554: 503: 496: 494: 471: 464: 457: 445: 440: 433: 412: 368:Clerk procedures 360: 318: 289:Editor sanctions 266:Active sanctions 224:Open proceedings 194: 153: 139: 138: 129: 118: 107: 93: 76: 65: 54: 43: 8726: 8725: 8721: 8720: 8719: 8717: 8716: 8715: 8687: 8686: 8670: 8665: 8624: 8619: 8609: 8597: 8577: 8572: 8518: 8508: 8462: 8453: 8448: 8415: 8405: 8393: 8386: 8384: 8374: 8365: 8360: 8349: 8323: 8270: 8242: 8206: 8178:Support needed 8138: 8105: 8072: 8039: 8005: 7971: 7943:Support needed 7903: 7868: 7833: 7798: 7763: 7729: 7693: 7660: 7627: 7592: 7557: 7529:Support needed 7489: 7454: 7419: 7404:Anyone can edit 7384: 7349: 7314: 7279: 7251:Support needed 7191: 7186: 7184:Motion to close 7181: 7176: 7151: 7107:Important notes 7066: 7064: 7019: 7011: 6991: 6986: 6941: 6934: 6932: 6922: 6917: 6896: 6882: 6881: 6878: 6843: 6832: 6822: 6796: 6792: 6787: 6786: 6754: 6741: 6731: 6726: 6711: 6704: 6702: 6683: 6676: 6674: 6639: 6611: 6601: 6597: 6592: 6591: 6580: 6575: 6552: 6538: 6527: 6517: 6489: 6482: 6480: 6401: 6370: 6366: 6361: 6360: 6340: 6331: 6326: 6299: 6285: 6273: 6263: 6251: 6244: 6242: 6211: 6181: 6171: 6161: 6150: 6146: 6141: 6140: 6115: 6101: 6077: 6072: 6058: 6051: 6049: 6038: 6031: 6029: 5985: 5933: 5911: 5910: 5907: 5877: 5867: 5836: 5826: 5731: 5718: 5704: 5694: 5679: 5669: 5645: 5638: 5636: 5616: 5581: 5577: 5572: 5571: 5559: 5554: 5510: 5492: 5491: 5488: 5468: 5454: 5453: 5450: 5394: 5301: 5297: 5292: 5291: 5278: 5273: 5267:As someone who 5192: 5181: 5171: 5144: 5129: 5107: 5100: 5098: 5087: 5075: 5020: 5011: 5007: 5002: 5001: 4974: 4969: 4959: 4946: 4917: 4910: 4908: 4899: 4889: 4855: 4835: 4830: 4792: 4782: 4778: 4773: 4772: 4744: 4729: 4699: 4692: 4690: 4681: 4671: 4564: 4525: 4516: 4512: 4507: 4506: 4479:Prod is weird. 4470: 4465: 4445: 4432: 4399: 4392: 4390: 4381: 4371: 4272: 4266: 4227: 4218: 4214: 4209: 4208: 4184: 4179: 4164: 4151: 4122: 4115: 4113: 4104: 4094: 4041: 3962:First choice. – 3940: 3935: 3892: 3875: 3870: 3860: 3811: 3798: 3788: 3748: 3741: 3739: 3712: 3711:Second choice. 3702: 3698: 3693: 3692: 3652: 3650:Second choice. 3636: 3624: 3619: 3615:With my changes 3573: 3511: 3507: 3502: 3501: 3489: 3459: 3454: 3412:Third choice. – 3389: 3376: 3340: 3333: 3331: 3323: 3316: 3314: 3282: 3272: 3229: 3199: 3173: 3125: 3115: 3077: 3073: 3068: 3067: 3055: 3043: 3038: 3018: 3011: 3009: 2960: 2939: 2929: 2902: 2897: 2828: 2818: 2814: 2809: 2808: 2797: 2792: 2787: 2776: 2762: 2749: 2720: 2713: 2711: 2702: 2692: 2634: 2591: 2582: 2578: 2573: 2572: 2547: 2533: 2504: 2497: 2495: 2484: 2474: 2422: 2383: 2374: 2370: 2365: 2364: 2340: 2335: 2325: 2312: 2284: 2277: 2275: 2266: 2256: 2226:new page patrol 2208: 2203: 2162: 2153: 2149: 2144: 2143: 2116: 2105: 2095: 2090: 2063: 2056: 2054: 2051:is not required 2036: 2026: 1988:deletion policy 1980: 1937: 1933: 1928: 1927: 1891: 1879: 1868: 1858: 1853: 1826: 1819: 1817: 1808: 1798: 1760: 1721: 1712: 1708: 1703: 1702: 1675: 1664: 1654: 1649: 1622: 1615: 1613: 1604: 1594: 1559: 1557:Anyone can edit 1520: 1511: 1507: 1502: 1501: 1474: 1463: 1453: 1448: 1421: 1414: 1412: 1402: 1392: 1338: 1296: 1287: 1283: 1278: 1277: 1250: 1239: 1229: 1224: 1197: 1190: 1188: 1179: 1169: 1138: 1097: 1088: 1084: 1079: 1078: 1051: 1040: 1030: 1025: 998: 991: 989: 980: 970: 939: 898: 889: 885: 880: 879: 852: 841: 831: 826: 799: 792: 790: 781: 771: 740: 735: 730: 682: 652: 604: 582: 558: 549:clerk talk page 492: 475: 441: 435: 434: 429: 419: 418: 417: 406: 389: 379: 378: 377: 364: 356: 344: 319: 314: 305: 295: 294: 293: 268: 258: 257: 256: 226: 216: 213: 198: 190: 168: 137: 34: 33: 32: 12: 11: 5: 8724: 8714: 8713: 8712: 8711: 8710: 8709: 8708: 8707: 8706: 8705: 8704: 8703: 8592: 8591: 8590: 8589: 8588: 8587: 8586: 8585: 8584: 8444: 8438: 8437: 8436: 8435: 8432: 8431: 8425: 8424: 8423: 8422: 8401: 8382: 8372: 8356: 8346: 8333: 8319: 8298: 8297: 8269: 8266: 8264: 8262: 8261: 8255: 8254: 8251: 8246: 8239: 8236: 8233: 8230: 8223: 8219: 8218: 8215: 8210: 8203: 8200: 8197: 8194: 8187: 8183: 8182: 8179: 8176: 8173: 8170: 8167: 8164: 8163:Proposal Name 8161: 8157: 8156: 8150: 8149: 8147: 8142: 8135: 8132: 8129: 8126: 8119: 8115: 8114: 8112: 8109: 8102: 8099: 8096: 8093: 8088: 8084: 8083: 8081: 8076: 8069: 8066: 8063: 8060: 8053: 8049: 8048: 8046: 8043: 8036: 8033: 8030: 8027: 8022: 8018: 8017: 8014: 8009: 8002: 7999: 7996: 7993: 7988: 7984: 7983: 7980: 7975: 7968: 7965: 7962: 7959: 7952: 7948: 7947: 7944: 7941: 7938: 7935: 7932: 7929: 7928:Proposal Name 7926: 7922: 7921: 7915: 7914: 7912: 7907: 7900: 7897: 7894: 7891: 7884: 7880: 7879: 7877: 7872: 7865: 7862: 7859: 7856: 7849: 7845: 7844: 7842: 7837: 7830: 7827: 7824: 7821: 7814: 7810: 7809: 7807: 7802: 7795: 7792: 7789: 7786: 7779: 7775: 7774: 7772: 7767: 7760: 7757: 7754: 7751: 7746: 7742: 7741: 7738: 7733: 7726: 7723: 7720: 7717: 7710: 7706: 7705: 7702: 7697: 7690: 7687: 7684: 7681: 7676: 7672: 7671: 7669: 7664: 7657: 7654: 7651: 7648: 7643: 7639: 7638: 7636: 7631: 7624: 7621: 7618: 7615: 7608: 7604: 7603: 7601: 7596: 7589: 7586: 7583: 7580: 7573: 7569: 7568: 7566: 7561: 7554: 7551: 7548: 7545: 7538: 7534: 7533: 7530: 7527: 7524: 7521: 7518: 7515: 7514:Proposal Name 7512: 7508: 7507: 7501: 7500: 7498: 7493: 7486: 7483: 7480: 7477: 7470: 7466: 7465: 7463: 7458: 7451: 7448: 7445: 7442: 7435: 7431: 7430: 7428: 7423: 7416: 7413: 7410: 7407: 7400: 7396: 7395: 7393: 7388: 7381: 7378: 7375: 7372: 7365: 7361: 7360: 7358: 7353: 7346: 7343: 7340: 7337: 7330: 7326: 7325: 7323: 7318: 7311: 7308: 7305: 7302: 7295: 7291: 7290: 7288: 7283: 7276: 7273: 7270: 7267: 7260: 7256: 7255: 7252: 7249: 7246: 7243: 7240: 7237: 7236:Proposal Name 7234: 7230: 7229: 7190: 7187: 7185: 7182: 7180: 7177: 7175: 7172: 7171: 7170: 7169: 7168: 7162: 7161: 7148: 7147: 7146: 7145: 7141: 7137: 7133: 7130: 7129: 7128: 7127: 7124: 7121: 7115: 7114: 7093: 7092: 7089: 7082: 7081: 7077: 7076: 7053: 7042: 7034: 7033: 7021: 7020: 7017: 7012: 7010: 7007: 7006: 7005: 6990: 6987: 6985: 6982: 6981: 6980: 6979: 6978: 6954: 6953: 6952: 6951: 6950: 6949: 6929: 6863: 6862: 6861: 6860: 6854: 6853: 6852: 6851: 6839: 6806: 6805: 6804: 6803: 6790: 6781: 6764: 6748: 6738: 6721: 6720: 6719: 6671: 6638: 6635: 6634: 6633: 6629: 6628: 6627: 6626: 6621: 6620: 6619: 6608: 6595: 6587: 6572: 6559: 6548: 6534: 6513: 6497: 6473: 6449: 6448: 6447: 6446: 6400: 6397: 6396: 6395: 6393: 6389: 6388: 6387: 6386: 6380: 6379: 6378: 6377: 6364: 6351: 6350: 6349: 6348: 6338: 6323: 6306: 6295: 6280: 6259: 6239: 6210: 6207: 6206: 6205: 6201: 6200: 6199: 6198: 6192: 6191: 6190: 6189: 6178: 6157: 6144: 6135: 6122: 6111: 6087: 6086: 6085: 6084: 6068: 6067: 6066: 6025: 5984: 5981: 5980: 5979: 5978: 5977: 5976: 5975: 5974: 5973: 5972: 5971: 5970: 5969: 5968: 5967: 5802: 5775: 5771: 5770: 5769: 5768: 5762: 5761: 5760: 5759: 5739: 5728: 5713: 5712: 5711: 5656: 5655: 5654: 5653: 5623: 5612: 5611: 5610: 5575: 5566: 5550: 5549: 5548: 5547: 5546: 5545: 5544: 5393: 5390: 5389: 5388: 5387: 5386: 5359: 5358: 5357: 5356: 5355: 5354: 5328: 5311: 5310: 5309: 5308: 5295: 5285: 5264: 5263: 5237: 5236: 5235: 5234: 5221: 5200: 5188: 5151: 5139: 5115: 5086: 5083: 5074: 5071: 5070: 5069: 5068: 5067: 5049: 5048: 5047: 5046: 5040: 5039: 5038: 5037: 5031: 5030: 5029: 5028: 5018: 5005: 4995: 4981: 4966: 4956: 4942: 4925: 4906: 4885: 4854: 4851: 4850: 4849: 4845: 4844: 4843: 4842: 4812: 4811: 4810: 4809: 4803: 4802: 4801: 4800: 4789: 4776: 4768: 4751: 4739: 4724: 4707: 4688: 4666: 4568:GorillaWarfare 4563: 4560: 4559: 4558: 4554: 4553: 4552: 4551: 4545: 4544: 4543: 4542: 4536: 4535: 4534: 4533: 4523: 4510: 4502: 4487:to oppose...? 4477: 4452: 4442: 4428: 4407: 4388: 4367: 4337:required to be 4265: 4262: 4261: 4260: 4256: 4255: 4254: 4253: 4247: 4246: 4245: 4244: 4238: 4237: 4236: 4235: 4225: 4212: 4204: 4191: 4171: 4161: 4147: 4130: 4111: 4090: 4045:Chris.sherlock 4040: 4037: 4036: 4035: 4034: 4033: 3994: 3993: 3992: 3991: 3986: 3985: 3984: 3978: 3977: 3976: 3975: 3974: 3973: 3947: 3891: 3888: 3887: 3886: 3885: 3884: 3883: 3882: 3855: 3854: 3833: 3832: 3831: 3830: 3824: 3823: 3822: 3821: 3805: 3779: 3778: 3777: 3776: 3756: 3736: 3720: 3709: 3696: 3687: 3686: 3685: 3659: 3648: 3647: 3646: 3572: 3569: 3568: 3567: 3566: 3565: 3548: 3547: 3546: 3545: 3521: 3520: 3519: 3518: 3505: 3496: 3485: 3484: 3483: 3428: 3427: 3426: 3425: 3424: 3423: 3397: 3386: 3366: 3350: 3349: 3348: 3310: 3228: 3225: 3224: 3223: 3219: 3218: 3217: 3216: 3210: 3209: 3208: 3207: 3198:Third choice. 3196: 3183: 3168: 3152: 3132: 3088: 3087: 3086: 3084: 3071: 3062: 3050: 3034:community-wide 3026: 3005: 3004: 2959: 2956: 2955: 2954: 2953: 2952: 2951: 2950: 2949: 2948: 2947: 2946: 2921: 2920: 2910: 2909: 2890: 2889: 2868: 2867: 2866: 2865: 2859: 2858: 2857: 2856: 2839: 2838: 2837: 2836: 2825: 2812: 2804: 2769: 2759: 2745: 2728: 2709: 2685: 2633: 2630: 2629: 2628: 2625: 2624: 2620: 2619: 2618: 2617: 2611: 2610: 2609: 2608: 2602: 2601: 2600: 2599: 2589: 2576: 2567: 2554: 2543: 2529: 2512: 2491: 2469: 2421: 2418: 2417: 2416: 2412: 2411: 2410: 2409: 2403: 2402: 2401: 2400: 2394: 2393: 2392: 2391: 2381: 2368: 2360: 2347: 2332: 2322: 2308: 2292: 2273: 2252: 2207: 2204: 2202: 2199: 2198: 2197: 2195: 2191: 2190: 2189: 2188: 2182: 2181: 2180: 2179: 2173: 2172: 2171: 2170: 2160: 2147: 2139: 2126: 2112: 2102: 2087: 2071: 2043: 2022: 1979: 1976: 1975: 1974: 1970: 1969: 1968: 1967: 1949: 1948: 1947: 1946: 1944: 1931: 1920: 1919: 1902: 1901: 1900: 1899: 1889: 1875: 1865: 1850: 1834: 1815: 1794: 1759: 1756: 1755: 1754: 1750: 1749: 1748: 1747: 1741: 1740: 1739: 1738: 1732: 1731: 1730: 1729: 1719: 1706: 1698: 1685: 1671: 1661: 1646: 1630: 1611: 1590: 1558: 1555: 1554: 1553: 1549: 1548: 1547: 1546: 1540: 1539: 1538: 1537: 1531: 1530: 1529: 1528: 1518: 1505: 1497: 1484: 1470: 1460: 1445: 1429: 1409: 1388: 1337: 1334: 1332: 1330: 1329: 1325: 1324: 1323: 1322: 1316: 1315: 1314: 1313: 1307: 1306: 1305: 1304: 1294: 1281: 1273: 1260: 1246: 1236: 1221: 1205: 1186: 1165: 1137: 1134: 1133: 1132: 1130: 1126: 1125: 1124: 1123: 1117: 1116: 1115: 1114: 1108: 1107: 1106: 1105: 1095: 1082: 1074: 1061: 1047: 1037: 1022: 1006: 987: 966: 938: 935: 934: 933: 931: 927: 926: 925: 924: 918: 917: 916: 915: 909: 908: 907: 906: 896: 883: 875: 862: 848: 838: 823: 807: 788: 767: 739: 736: 734: 731: 729: 726: 725: 724: 723: 722: 721: 720: 712: 711: 710: 709: 703: 702: 701: 700: 694: 693: 692: 691: 681: 678: 665: 651: 648: 647: 646: 645: 644: 643: 642: 634: 633: 632: 631: 625: 624: 623: 622: 616: 615: 614: 613: 603: 600: 581: 578: 575: 574: 562: 535: 534: 531: 527: 526: 523: 519: 518: 515: 511: 510: 507: 477: 476: 474: 473: 466: 459: 451: 448: 447: 437: 436: 427: 425: 424: 421: 420: 416: 415: 407: 402: 397: 391: 390: 385: 384: 381: 380: 376: 375: 370: 365: 355: 350: 345: 340: 335: 330: 325: 320: 313: 307: 306: 301: 300: 297: 296: 292: 291: 286: 281: 270: 269: 264: 263: 260: 259: 255: 254: 249: 244: 239: 234: 228: 227: 222: 221: 218: 217: 215: 214: 209: 204: 199: 189: 182: 177: 169: 164: 158: 155: 154: 146: 145: 41:Main case page 39: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 8723: 8702: 8698: 8694: 8693: 8692: 8681: 8678: 8677: 8676: 8673: 8668: 8662: 8658: 8654: 8650: 8645: 8644: 8643: 8640: 8638: 8637: 8632: 8631: 8630: 8627: 8622: 8613: 8608: 8607: 8606: 8603: 8601: 8600: 8593: 8583: 8580: 8575: 8569: 8565: 8560: 8559: 8558: 8554: 8551: 8548: 8545: 8542: 8537: 8532: 8531: 8526: 8525: 8524: 8521: 8516: 8514: 8513: 8505: 8502: 8501: 8500: 8496: 8493: 8490: 8487: 8484: 8479: 8474: 8473: 8466: 8461: 8460: 8459: 8456: 8451: 8445: 8442: 8441: 8440: 8439: 8434: 8433: 8429: 8428: 8427: 8426: 8421: 8418: 8413: 8411: 8410: 8402: 8400: 8396: 8391: 8389: 8383: 8381: 8377: 8373: 8371: 8368: 8363: 8357: 8355: 8352: 8347: 8345: 8342: 8340: 8339: 8334: 8332: 8329: 8327: 8326: 8320: 8318: 8314: 8311: 8308: 8304: 8300: 8299: 8295: 8294: 8293: 8292: 8291: 8290: 8288: 8282: 8281: 8279: 8275: 8265: 8259: 8258: 8250: 8229: 8228: 8221: 8220: 8214: 8193: 8192: 8185: 8184: 8180: 8177: 8174: 8171: 8168: 8165: 8162: 8159: 8158: 8155: 8151: 8146: 8125: 8124: 8117: 8116: 8092: 8086: 8085: 8080: 8059: 8058: 8051: 8050: 8026: 8020: 8019: 8013: 7992: 7986: 7985: 7979: 7958: 7957: 7950: 7949: 7945: 7942: 7939: 7936: 7933: 7930: 7927: 7924: 7923: 7920: 7916: 7911: 7890: 7889: 7882: 7881: 7876: 7855: 7854: 7847: 7846: 7841: 7820: 7819: 7812: 7811: 7806: 7785: 7784: 7777: 7776: 7771: 7750: 7744: 7743: 7737: 7716: 7715: 7708: 7707: 7701: 7680: 7674: 7673: 7668: 7647: 7641: 7640: 7635: 7614: 7613: 7606: 7605: 7600: 7579: 7578: 7571: 7570: 7565: 7544: 7543: 7536: 7535: 7531: 7528: 7525: 7522: 7519: 7516: 7513: 7510: 7509: 7506: 7502: 7497: 7476: 7475: 7468: 7467: 7462: 7441: 7440: 7433: 7432: 7427: 7406: 7405: 7398: 7397: 7392: 7371: 7370: 7363: 7362: 7357: 7336: 7335: 7328: 7327: 7322: 7301: 7300: 7293: 7292: 7287: 7266: 7265: 7258: 7257: 7253: 7250: 7247: 7244: 7241: 7238: 7235: 7232: 7231: 7228: 7224: 7221: 7220: 7218: 7213: 7209: 7208: 7207: 7201: 7197: 7196: 7167: 7166: 7164: 7163: 7160: 7158: 7153: 7152: 7142: 7138: 7132: 7131: 7125: 7122: 7119: 7118: 7117: 7116: 7112: 7111: 7110: 7108: 7104: 7100: 7096: 7090: 7087: 7086: 7085: 7079: 7078: 7073:wikimedia.org 7062: 7058: 7054: 7051: 7047: 7043: 7040: 7039: 7038: 7031: 7030: 7029: 7028: 7023: 7022: 7016: 7015: 7004: 7002: 6997: 6996: 6995: 6977: 6974: 6972: 6971: 6965: 6961: 6958: 6957: 6956: 6955: 6948: 6944: 6939: 6937: 6930: 6928: 6925: 6920: 6914: 6913: 6912: 6909: 6907: 6906: 6894: 6890: 6876: 6872: 6868: 6867: 6865: 6864: 6859: 6858: 6856: 6855: 6850: 6846: 6840: 6838: 6835: 6830: 6828: 6827: 6819: 6814: 6811: 6810: 6808: 6807: 6802: 6799: 6798: 6782: 6780: 6777: 6775: 6774: 6769: 6765: 6763: 6760: 6758: 6757: 6749: 6747: 6744: 6739: 6737: 6734: 6729: 6722: 6718: 6714: 6709: 6707: 6700: 6696: 6692: 6691: 6690: 6686: 6681: 6679: 6672: 6670: 6666: 6663: 6660: 6656: 6652: 6651: 6649: 6648: 6647: 6644: 6631: 6630: 6625: 6624: 6622: 6618: 6614: 6609: 6607: 6604: 6603: 6588: 6586: 6583: 6578: 6573: 6571: 6568: 6566: 6565: 6560: 6558: 6555: 6549: 6547: 6544: 6542: 6541: 6535: 6533: 6530: 6525: 6523: 6522: 6514: 6512: 6507: 6502: 6498: 6496: 6492: 6487: 6485: 6478: 6474: 6472: 6468: 6465: 6462: 6458: 6454: 6453: 6451: 6450: 6445: 6444: 6442: 6441: 6440: 6438: 6434: 6431: 6428: 6424: 6420: 6416: 6413: 6410: 6406: 6394: 6391: 6390: 6385: 6384: 6382: 6381: 6376: 6373: 6372: 6356: 6355: 6353: 6352: 6347: 6343: 6339: 6337: 6334: 6329: 6324: 6322: 6319: 6317: 6316: 6311: 6307: 6305: 6302: 6296: 6294: 6291: 6289: 6288: 6281: 6279: 6276: 6271: 6269: 6268: 6260: 6258: 6254: 6249: 6247: 6240: 6238: 6234: 6231: 6228: 6224: 6220: 6219: 6217: 6216: 6215: 6203: 6202: 6197: 6196: 6194: 6193: 6188: 6184: 6179: 6177: 6174: 6169: 6167: 6166: 6158: 6156: 6153: 6152: 6136: 6134: 6131: 6129: 6128: 6124:Prefer 1.1. – 6123: 6121: 6118: 6112: 6110: 6107: 6105: 6104: 6096: 6092: 6091: 6089: 6088: 6083: 6080: 6075: 6069: 6065: 6061: 6056: 6054: 6047: 6046: 6045: 6041: 6036: 6034: 6026: 6024: 6020: 6017: 6014: 6010: 6006: 6002: 6001: 5999: 5998: 5997: 5995: 5991: 5966: 5963: 5961: 5960: 5955: 5951: 5950: 5949: 5946: 5944: 5943: 5931: 5927: 5923: 5919: 5905: 5901: 5900: 5899: 5896: 5894: 5893: 5888: 5885: 5884: 5883: 5880: 5875: 5873: 5872: 5864: 5860: 5859: 5858: 5855: 5853: 5852: 5847: 5844: 5843: 5842: 5839: 5834: 5832: 5831: 5823: 5820: 5819: 5818: 5815: 5813: 5812: 5806: 5803: 5801: 5800: 5797: 5795: 5794: 5787: 5783: 5779: 5776: 5773: 5772: 5767: 5766: 5764: 5763: 5758: 5754: 5751: 5748: 5744: 5740: 5738: 5734: 5729: 5727: 5724: 5722: 5721: 5714: 5710: 5707: 5702: 5700: 5699: 5691: 5687: 5686: 5685: 5682: 5677: 5675: 5674: 5666: 5661: 5660: 5658: 5657: 5652: 5648: 5643: 5641: 5633: 5629: 5624: 5622: 5619: 5613: 5609: 5608: 5604: 5601: 5598: 5594: 5589: 5588: 5587: 5584: 5583: 5567: 5565: 5562: 5557: 5551: 5543: 5540: 5538: 5537: 5532: 5528: 5527: 5526: 5523: 5521: 5520: 5508: 5504: 5500: 5486: 5485: 5484: 5481: 5479: 5478: 5466: 5462: 5449: 5448: 5447: 5446: 5443: 5441: 5440: 5432: 5428: 5427: 5425: 5424: 5423: 5420: 5418: 5413: 5410: 5405: 5403: 5398: 5385: 5382: 5380: 5379: 5373: 5369: 5364: 5363: 5361: 5360: 5353: 5350: 5348: 5347: 5342: 5341: 5340: 5337: 5335: 5334: 5329: 5327: 5324: 5322: 5321: 5317:Prefer 1.1. – 5316: 5315: 5313: 5312: 5307: 5304: 5303: 5286: 5284: 5281: 5276: 5270: 5266: 5265: 5262: 5261: 5257: 5254: 5251: 5247: 5242: 5241: 5239: 5238: 5233: 5230: 5228: 5227: 5222: 5220: 5216: 5213: 5210: 5206: 5201: 5199: 5195: 5189: 5187: 5184: 5179: 5177: 5176: 5167: 5166: 5161: 5157: 5152: 5150: 5147: 5140: 5138: 5135: 5133: 5132: 5125: 5124:WP:SUPERMARIO 5121: 5116: 5114: 5110: 5105: 5103: 5095: 5094: 5092: 5091: 5090: 5082: 5080: 5066: 5063: 5061: 5060: 5054: 5053: 5051: 5050: 5045: 5044: 5042: 5041: 5036: 5035: 5033: 5032: 5027: 5023: 5019: 5017: 5014: 5013: 4996: 4994: 4991: 4989: 4988: 4982: 4980: 4977: 4972: 4967: 4965: 4962: 4957: 4955: 4952: 4950: 4949: 4943: 4941: 4936: 4931: 4926: 4924: 4920: 4915: 4913: 4907: 4905: 4902: 4897: 4895: 4894: 4886: 4884: 4880: 4877: 4874: 4870: 4867: 4866: 4864: 4863: 4862: 4860: 4847: 4846: 4841: 4838: 4833: 4827: 4822: 4817: 4816: 4814: 4813: 4808: 4807: 4805: 4804: 4799: 4795: 4790: 4788: 4785: 4784: 4769: 4767: 4766: 4763: 4761: 4760: 4752: 4750: 4747: 4740: 4738: 4735: 4733: 4732: 4725: 4723: 4718: 4713: 4708: 4706: 4702: 4697: 4695: 4689: 4687: 4684: 4679: 4677: 4676: 4667: 4665: 4661: 4658: 4655: 4651: 4648: 4647: 4645: 4644: 4643: 4642: 4639: 4636: 4633: 4631: 4630: 4623: 4622: 4620: 4618: 4616: 4614: 4611: 4608: 4607: 4601: 4598: 4596: 4593: 4589: 4587: 4585: 4582: 4579: 4576: 4573: 4569: 4556: 4555: 4550: 4549: 4547: 4546: 4541: 4540: 4538: 4537: 4532: 4528: 4524: 4522: 4519: 4518: 4503: 4501: 4500: 4497: 4495: 4494: 4486: 4482: 4478: 4476: 4473: 4468: 4462: 4457: 4453: 4451: 4448: 4443: 4441: 4438: 4436: 4435: 4429: 4427: 4422: 4417: 4413: 4408: 4406: 4402: 4397: 4395: 4389: 4387: 4384: 4379: 4377: 4376: 4368: 4366: 4362: 4359: 4356: 4352: 4349: 4348: 4346: 4345: 4344: 4342: 4338: 4334: 4332: 4329: 4327: 4325: 4323: 4318: 4315: 4312: 4309: 4306: 4303: 4300: 4297: 4294: 4291: 4288: 4285: 4282: 4279: 4276: 4271: 4258: 4257: 4252: 4251: 4249: 4248: 4243: 4242: 4240: 4239: 4234: 4230: 4226: 4224: 4221: 4220: 4205: 4203: 4200: 4198: 4197: 4192: 4190: 4187: 4182: 4176: 4172: 4170: 4167: 4162: 4160: 4157: 4155: 4154: 4148: 4146: 4141: 4136: 4131: 4129: 4125: 4120: 4118: 4112: 4110: 4107: 4102: 4100: 4099: 4091: 4089: 4085: 4082: 4079: 4075: 4072: 4071: 4069: 4068: 4067: 4065: 4061: 4059: 4056: 4053: 4050: 4046: 4032: 4029: 4027: 4026: 4021: 4017: 4014: 4010: 4006: 4002: 3999: 3998: 3996: 3995: 3990: 3989: 3987: 3983: 3982: 3980: 3979: 3972: 3969: 3967: 3966: 3961: 3960: 3959: 3956: 3954: 3953: 3948: 3946: 3943: 3938: 3932: 3931: 3929: 3928: 3927: 3925: 3921: 3917: 3913: 3909: 3905: 3901: 3897: 3881: 3878: 3873: 3864: 3859: 3858: 3857: 3856: 3853: 3850: 3848: 3847: 3842: 3838: 3837: 3835: 3834: 3829: 3828: 3826: 3825: 3820: 3817: 3815: 3814: 3806: 3804: 3801: 3796: 3794: 3793: 3784: 3783: 3781: 3780: 3775: 3771: 3768: 3765: 3761: 3757: 3755: 3751: 3746: 3744: 3737: 3735: 3730: 3725: 3721: 3719: 3715: 3710: 3708: 3705: 3704: 3688: 3684: 3681: 3679: 3678: 3673: 3672: 3671: 3668: 3666: 3665: 3660: 3658: 3655: 3649: 3645: 3642: 3640: 3639: 3632: 3631: 3630: 3627: 3622: 3616: 3613: 3612: 3610: 3609: 3608: 3606: 3602: 3598: 3594: 3590: 3586: 3582: 3578: 3564: 3561: 3559: 3558: 3553: 3552: 3550: 3549: 3544: 3540: 3537: 3534: 3530: 3526: 3525: 3523: 3522: 3517: 3514: 3513: 3497: 3495: 3492: 3486: 3482: 3479: 3477: 3476: 3471: 3467: 3466: 3465: 3462: 3457: 3450: 3446: 3442: 3438: 3433: 3432: 3430: 3429: 3422: 3419: 3417: 3416: 3411: 3410: 3409: 3406: 3404: 3403: 3398: 3396: 3392: 3387: 3385: 3382: 3380: 3379: 3372: 3367: 3365: 3360: 3355: 3351: 3347: 3343: 3338: 3336: 3329: 3326: 3321: 3319: 3311: 3309: 3308: 3304: 3301: 3298: 3294: 3290: 3289: 3288: 3285: 3280: 3278: 3277: 3269: 3268: 3266: 3265: 3264: 3262: 3258: 3254: 3250: 3246: 3242: 3239: 3236: 3233: 3221: 3220: 3215: 3214: 3212: 3211: 3206: 3202: 3197: 3195: 3192: 3190: 3189: 3184: 3182: 3179: 3177: 3176: 3169: 3167: 3162: 3157: 3153: 3151: 3147: 3144: 3141: 3137: 3133: 3131: 3128: 3123: 3121: 3120: 3112: 3108: 3104: 3100: 3096: 3092: 3091: 3089: 3085: 3083: 3080: 3079: 3063: 3061: 3058: 3051: 3049: 3046: 3041: 3035: 3032:problem in a 3031: 3027: 3025: 3021: 3016: 3014: 3007: 3006: 3003: 3002: 2998: 2995: 2992: 2988: 2984: 2983: 2981: 2980: 2979: 2977: 2973: 2970: 2967: 2964: 2945: 2942: 2937: 2935: 2934: 2925: 2924: 2923: 2922: 2914: 2913: 2912: 2911: 2908: 2905: 2900: 2894: 2893: 2892: 2891: 2887: 2884: 2882: 2881: 2876: 2873: 2872: 2870: 2869: 2864: 2863: 2861: 2860: 2855: 2852: 2850: 2849: 2844: 2843: 2841: 2840: 2835: 2831: 2826: 2824: 2821: 2820: 2805: 2803: 2800: 2795: 2784: 2779: 2774: 2770: 2768: 2765: 2760: 2758: 2755: 2753: 2752: 2746: 2744: 2739: 2734: 2729: 2727: 2723: 2718: 2716: 2710: 2708: 2705: 2700: 2698: 2697: 2689: 2686: 2684: 2680: 2677: 2674: 2670: 2667: 2666: 2664: 2663: 2662: 2661: 2659: 2656: 2652: 2648: 2645: 2642: 2640: 2638: 2627: 2626: 2622: 2621: 2616: 2615: 2613: 2612: 2607: 2606: 2604: 2603: 2598: 2594: 2590: 2588: 2585: 2584: 2568: 2566: 2563: 2561: 2560: 2555: 2553: 2550: 2544: 2542: 2539: 2537: 2536: 2530: 2528: 2523: 2518: 2513: 2511: 2507: 2502: 2500: 2492: 2490: 2487: 2482: 2480: 2479: 2470: 2468: 2464: 2461: 2458: 2454: 2451: 2450: 2448: 2447: 2446: 2445: 2443: 2441: 2439: 2437: 2434: 2432: 2430: 2427: 2414: 2413: 2408: 2407: 2405: 2404: 2399: 2398: 2396: 2395: 2390: 2386: 2382: 2380: 2377: 2376: 2361: 2359: 2356: 2354: 2353: 2348: 2346: 2343: 2338: 2333: 2331: 2328: 2323: 2321: 2318: 2316: 2315: 2309: 2307: 2302: 2297: 2293: 2291: 2287: 2282: 2280: 2274: 2272: 2269: 2264: 2262: 2261: 2253: 2251: 2247: 2244: 2241: 2237: 2234: 2233: 2231: 2230: 2229: 2227: 2223: 2220: 2217: 2213: 2196: 2193: 2192: 2187: 2186: 2184: 2183: 2178: 2177: 2175: 2174: 2169: 2165: 2161: 2159: 2156: 2155: 2140: 2138: 2135: 2133: 2132: 2127: 2125: 2122: 2120: 2119: 2113: 2111: 2108: 2103: 2101: 2098: 2093: 2088: 2086: 2081: 2076: 2072: 2070: 2066: 2061: 2059: 2052: 2048: 2044: 2042: 2039: 2034: 2032: 2031: 2023: 2021: 2017: 2014: 2011: 2007: 2004: 2003: 2001: 2000: 1999: 1997: 1993: 1989: 1985: 1972: 1971: 1966: 1963: 1961: 1960: 1954: 1953: 1951: 1950: 1945: 1943: 1940: 1939: 1922: 1921: 1918: 1915: 1913: 1912: 1907: 1906: 1904: 1903: 1898: 1894: 1890: 1888: 1885: 1883: 1882: 1876: 1874: 1871: 1866: 1864: 1861: 1856: 1851: 1849: 1844: 1839: 1835: 1833: 1829: 1824: 1822: 1816: 1814: 1811: 1806: 1804: 1803: 1795: 1793: 1789: 1786: 1783: 1779: 1776: 1775: 1773: 1772: 1771: 1769: 1765: 1752: 1751: 1746: 1745: 1743: 1742: 1737: 1736: 1734: 1733: 1728: 1724: 1720: 1718: 1715: 1714: 1699: 1697: 1694: 1692: 1691: 1686: 1684: 1681: 1679: 1678: 1672: 1670: 1667: 1662: 1660: 1657: 1652: 1647: 1645: 1640: 1635: 1631: 1629: 1625: 1620: 1618: 1612: 1610: 1607: 1602: 1600: 1599: 1591: 1589: 1585: 1582: 1579: 1575: 1572: 1571: 1569: 1568: 1567: 1565: 1551: 1550: 1545: 1544: 1542: 1541: 1536: 1535: 1533: 1532: 1527: 1523: 1519: 1517: 1514: 1513: 1498: 1496: 1493: 1491: 1490: 1485: 1483: 1480: 1478: 1477: 1471: 1469: 1466: 1461: 1459: 1456: 1451: 1446: 1444: 1439: 1434: 1430: 1428: 1424: 1419: 1417: 1410: 1408: 1405: 1400: 1398: 1397: 1389: 1387: 1383: 1380: 1377: 1373: 1370: 1369: 1367: 1366: 1365: 1363: 1359: 1355: 1351: 1347: 1343: 1333: 1327: 1326: 1321: 1320: 1318: 1317: 1312: 1311: 1309: 1308: 1303: 1299: 1295: 1293: 1290: 1289: 1274: 1272: 1269: 1267: 1266: 1261: 1259: 1256: 1254: 1253: 1247: 1245: 1242: 1237: 1235: 1232: 1227: 1222: 1220: 1215: 1210: 1206: 1204: 1200: 1195: 1193: 1187: 1185: 1182: 1177: 1175: 1174: 1166: 1164: 1160: 1157: 1154: 1150: 1147: 1146: 1144: 1143: 1142: 1131: 1128: 1127: 1122: 1121: 1119: 1118: 1113: 1112: 1110: 1109: 1104: 1100: 1096: 1094: 1091: 1090: 1075: 1073: 1070: 1068: 1067: 1062: 1060: 1057: 1055: 1054: 1048: 1046: 1043: 1038: 1036: 1033: 1028: 1023: 1021: 1016: 1011: 1007: 1005: 1001: 996: 994: 988: 986: 983: 978: 976: 975: 967: 965: 961: 958: 955: 951: 948: 947: 945: 944: 943: 932: 929: 928: 923: 922: 920: 919: 914: 913: 911: 910: 905: 901: 897: 895: 892: 891: 876: 874: 871: 869: 868: 863: 861: 858: 856: 855: 849: 847: 844: 839: 837: 834: 829: 824: 822: 817: 812: 808: 806: 802: 797: 795: 789: 787: 784: 779: 777: 776: 768: 766: 762: 759: 756: 752: 749: 748: 746: 745: 744: 719: 718: 717: 716: 714: 713: 708: 707: 705: 704: 699: 698: 696: 695: 690: 689: 687: 686: 685: 677: 674: 670: 664: 660: 658: 641: 640: 639: 638: 636: 635: 630: 629: 627: 626: 621: 620: 618: 617: 612: 611: 609: 608: 607: 599: 598: 596: 590: 588: 573: 571: 566: 563: 556: 555: 552: 550: 546: 543:, you should 542: 532: 529: 528: 524: 521: 520: 516: 513: 512: 508: 505: 504: 500: 495: 490: 488: 484: 472: 467: 465: 460: 458: 453: 452: 450: 449: 444: 439: 438: 423: 422: 411: 408: 405: 401: 398: 396: 393: 392: 388: 383: 382: 374: 371: 369: 366: 363: 359: 354: 351: 349: 346: 343: 339: 336: 334: 331: 329: 326: 324: 321: 317: 312: 309: 308: 304: 299: 298: 290: 287: 285: 282: 279: 275: 272: 271: 267: 262: 261: 253: 250: 248: 245: 243: 240: 238: 237:Case requests 235: 233: 230: 229: 225: 220: 219: 212: 208: 205: 203: 200: 197: 193: 188: 186: 183: 181: 178: 176: 173: 170: 167: 163: 160: 159: 157: 156: 152: 148: 147: 144: 141: 140: 136: 133: 128: 122: 117: 111: 106: 102: 97: 92: 88: 84: 80: 75: 69: 64: 58: 53: 47: 42: 38: 31: 27: 23: 19: 8685: 8684: 8635: 8595: 8549: 8543: 8528: 8511: 8509: 8491: 8485: 8470: 8408: 8406: 8387: 8337: 8321: 8309: 8284: 8283: 8273: 8272: 8271: 8263: 8248: 8225: 8212: 8189: 8144: 8121: 8111:Cannot pass 8078: 8055: 8045:Cannot pass 8011: 7977: 7954: 7909: 7886: 7874: 7851: 7839: 7816: 7804: 7781: 7769: 7735: 7712: 7699: 7666: 7633: 7610: 7598: 7575: 7563: 7540: 7495: 7472: 7460: 7437: 7425: 7402: 7390: 7367: 7355: 7332: 7320: 7297: 7285: 7262: 7214: 7205: 7204: 7199: 7198: 7193: 7192: 7154: 7106: 7105: 7101: 7097: 7094: 7083: 7035: 7025: 7024: 6998: 6992: 6969: 6964:Roger Davies 6935: 6904: 6825: 6823: 6784: 6772: 6752: 6705: 6677: 6661: 6640: 6589: 6563: 6536: 6520: 6518: 6483: 6463: 6429: 6411: 6402: 6358: 6314: 6309: 6283: 6266: 6264: 6245: 6229: 6212: 6164: 6162: 6138: 6126: 6099: 6052: 6032: 6015: 6004: 5986: 5958: 5941: 5891: 5870: 5868: 5862: 5850: 5829: 5827: 5810: 5792: 5789: 5749: 5716: 5697: 5695: 5689: 5672: 5670: 5639: 5631: 5627: 5599: 5590: 5569: 5535: 5518: 5476: 5438: 5434: 5421: 5414: 5406: 5399: 5395: 5377: 5371: 5367: 5345: 5332: 5319: 5289: 5252: 5243: 5225: 5211: 5174: 5172: 5165:GiantSnowman 5164: 5160:WP:ADMINACCT 5156:WP:ADMINCOND 5127: 5101: 5088: 5078: 5076: 5058: 4999: 4986: 4944: 4911: 4892: 4890: 4875: 4856: 4770: 4758: 4755: 4727: 4693: 4674: 4672: 4656: 4627: 4626: 4624: 4606:the Signpost 4605: 4594:WikiProject, 4592:Women in Red 4574: 4565: 4504: 4492: 4488: 4485:to be around 4484: 4480: 4455: 4430: 4393: 4374: 4372: 4357: 4313: 4307: 4301: 4295: 4289: 4283: 4277: 4267: 4206: 4195: 4149: 4116: 4097: 4095: 4080: 4051: 4042: 4024: 3964: 3951: 3893: 3845: 3809: 3791: 3789: 3766: 3758:more exact. 3742: 3690: 3676: 3663: 3634: 3574: 3556: 3535: 3499: 3474: 3469: 3414: 3401: 3374: 3334: 3317: 3312: 3299: 3291: 3275: 3273: 3230: 3187: 3171: 3142: 3134:Good points 3118: 3116: 3065: 3033: 3029: 3012: 2993: 2985: 2961: 2932: 2930: 2916: 2879: 2847: 2806: 2782: 2747: 2714: 2695: 2693: 2688:WP:ADMINACCT 2675: 2635: 2570: 2558: 2531: 2498: 2477: 2475: 2459: 2423: 2362: 2351: 2310: 2278: 2259: 2257: 2242: 2218: 2209: 2141: 2130: 2114: 2057: 2050: 2046: 2029: 2027: 2012: 1981: 1958: 1925: 1910: 1877: 1820: 1801: 1799: 1784: 1761: 1700: 1689: 1673: 1616: 1597: 1595: 1580: 1560: 1499: 1488: 1472: 1415: 1395: 1393: 1378: 1339: 1331: 1275: 1264: 1248: 1191: 1172: 1170: 1155: 1139: 1076: 1065: 1049: 992: 973: 971: 956: 940: 877: 866: 850: 793: 774: 772: 757: 741: 683: 668: 662: 661: 653: 605: 592: 591: 583: 567: 564: 538: 506:Abstentions 491: 480: 100: 86: 85: 83: 73: 37: 8663:)? Regards 7052:("AN"); and 6875:Newyorkbrad 6643:Arbitration 5930:David Fuchs 5861:How is the 5782:pointed out 5507:David Fuchs 4821:related ANI 4604:article in 4293:protections 4003:: I made a 207:Ban appeals 185:Noticeboard 8661:Miniapolis 8274:Important: 7165:Comments: 7027:Committee. 6866:Comments: 5778:Rschen7754 5402:commitment 5362:Comments: 5052:Comments: 4305:page moves 4177:. Regards 4133:above). – 3997:Comments: 3836:Comments: 3617:. Regards 3551:Comments: 2871:Comments: 2773:Iridescent 2049:to simply 1354:harassment 1346:incivility 715:Comments: 637:Comments: 501:reference 413:(pre-2016) 400:Statistics 333:Procedures 87:Case clerk 8657:CodeLyoko 8303:Cas Liber 7217:Jonesey95 7065:arbcom-en 6857:Abstain: 6655:Cas Liber 6650:Support: 6632:Comments: 6623:Abstain: 6457:Cas Liber 6443:Support: 6392:Comments: 6383:Abstain: 6223:Cas Liber 6218:Support: 6204:Comments: 6195:Abstain: 6009:Cas Liber 6000:Support: 5774:Comments: 5765:Abstain: 5743:Cas Liber 5690:prevented 5593:Cas Liber 5426:Support: 5417:amendment 5314:Abstain: 5246:Cas Liber 5205:Cas Liber 5093:Support: 5043:Abstain: 4869:Cas Liber 4865:Support: 4848:Comments: 4815:Abstain: 4791:Per Joe. 4726:Per Joe. 4650:Cas Liber 4646:Support: 4557:Comments: 4548:Abstain: 4351:Cas Liber 4347:Support: 4299:deletions 4259:Comments: 4250:Abstain: 4074:Cas Liber 4070:Support: 3988:Abstain: 3930:Support: 3827:Abstain: 3760:Cas Liber 3611:Support: 3529:Cas Liber 3524:Abstain: 3293:Cas Liber 3267:Support: 3222:Comments: 3213:Abstain: 3136:Cas Liber 2987:Cas Liber 2982:Support: 2862:Abstain: 2669:Cas Liber 2665:Support: 2655:own count 2623:Comments: 2614:Abstain: 2453:Cas Liber 2449:Support: 2415:Comments: 2406:Abstain: 2236:Cas Liber 2232:Support: 2194:Comments: 2185:Abstain: 2006:Cas Liber 2002:Support: 1973:Comments: 1952:Abstain: 1778:Cas Liber 1774:Support: 1753:Comments: 1744:Abstain: 1574:Cas Liber 1570:Support: 1552:Comments: 1543:Abstain: 1372:Cas Liber 1368:Support: 1328:Comments: 1319:Abstain: 1149:Cas Liber 1145:Support: 1129:Comments: 1120:Abstain: 950:Cas Liber 946:Support: 930:Comments: 921:Abstain: 751:Cas Liber 747:Support: 706:Abstain: 688:Support: 657:/Workshop 628:Abstain: 610:Support: 587:/Workshop 570:talk page 487:/Workshop 483:/Evidence 338:Elections 91:CodeLyoko 8443:Comments 8313:contribs 8172:Abstain 8166:Support 7937:Abstain 7931:Support 7523:Abstain 7517:Support 7245:Abstain 7239:Support 6879:Casliber 6809:Oppose: 6665:contribs 6467:contribs 6452:Oppose: 6433:contribs 6423:Missvain 6415:contribs 6354:Oppose: 6233:contribs 6090:Oppose: 6019:contribs 5922:Casliber 5753:contribs 5659:Oppose: 5603:contribs 5531:Casliber 5503:Casliber 5465:Casliber 5256:contribs 5240:Oppose: 5215:contribs 5120:Casliber 5034:Oppose: 4879:contribs 4806:Oppose: 4660:contribs 4578:contribs 4539:Oppose: 4361:contribs 4281:contribs 4270:Missvain 4241:Oppose: 4084:contribs 4055:contribs 3981:Oppose: 3904:2018 (3) 3900:2018 (2) 3896:2018 (1) 3782:Oppose: 3770:contribs 3585:2018 (3) 3581:2018 (2) 3577:2018 (1) 3539:contribs 3431:Oppose: 3303:contribs 3240:(2018), 3237:(2018), 3234:(2018), 3146:contribs 3090:Oppose: 2997:contribs 2971:(2018), 2968:(2018), 2965:(2018), 2842:Oppose: 2679:contribs 2605:Oppose: 2463:contribs 2397:Oppose: 2246:contribs 2222:contribs 2176:Oppose: 2016:contribs 1905:Oppose: 1788:contribs 1735:Oppose: 1584:contribs 1534:Oppose: 1382:contribs 1310:Oppose: 1159:contribs 1111:Oppose: 960:contribs 912:Oppose: 761:contribs 697:Oppose: 680:Template 669:normally 619:Oppose: 602:Template 499:Majority 116:Casliber 63:Workshop 52:Evidence 28:‎ | 24:‎ | 22:Requests 20:‎ | 8564:Joe Roe 8296:Support 8175:Status 8169:Oppose 8160:Number 7940:Status 7934:Oppose 7925:Number 7542:Kudpung 7526:Status 7520:Oppose 7511:Number 7369:Decorum 7248:Status 7242:Oppose 7233:Number 7203:Dreamy 7179:General 6871:Lourdes 6405:Kudpung 5954:concern 5906:do it? 4456:general 3449:link #4 3030:general 2212:Kudpung 2206:Kudpung 1336:Decorum 547:to the 410:Reports 348:History 328:Members 323:Contact 311:Discuss 175:(CU/OS) 105:Joe Roe 30:Kudpung 8690:Thomas 8430:Oppose 8287:Clerks 8181:Notes 7946:Notes 7532:Notes 7254:Notes 7057:"ARCA" 6793:(talk) 6598:(talk) 6367:(talk) 6147:(talk) 5863:threat 5578:(talk) 5368:merely 5298:(talk) 5008:(talk) 4779:(talk) 4513:(talk) 4311:rights 4287:blocks 4215:(talk) 3699:(talk) 3508:(talk) 3074:(talk) 2815:(talk) 2783:thinks 2649:or by 2579:(talk) 2371:(talk) 2150:(talk) 1934:(talk) 1709:(talk) 1508:(talk) 1360:, and 1284:(talk) 1085:(talk) 886:(talk) 353:Clerks 211:Report 125:& 114:& 8680:SoWhy 8530:Kevin 8472:Kevin 8465:SoWhy 8376:Katie 8260:Notes 6960:SoWhy 6893:SoWhy 6845:Katie 6818:RFC/U 6788:Maxim 6699:Bradv 6695:SoWhy 6613:Katie 6593:Maxim 6362:Maxim 6342:Katie 6183:Katie 6142:Maxim 5926:Maxim 5918:SoWhy 5908:Bradv 5902:Does 5887:Bradv 5846:bradv 5805:bradv 5733:Katie 5632:later 5573:Maxim 5499:Maxim 5489:SoWhy 5461:Maxim 5451:SoWhy 5293:Maxim 5194:Katie 5022:Katie 5003:Maxim 4794:Katie 4774:Maxim 4629:proud 4527:Katie 4508:Maxim 4229:Katie 4210:Maxim 4020:Bradv 4005:tweak 4001:SoWhy 3714:Katie 3694:Maxim 3503:Maxim 3391:Katie 3201:Katie 3069:Maxim 2830:Katie 2810:Maxim 2593:Katie 2574:Maxim 2385:Katie 2366:Maxim 2164:Katie 2145:Maxim 1929:Maxim 1893:Katie 1723:Katie 1704:Maxim 1522:Katie 1503:Maxim 1298:Katie 1279:Maxim 1099:Katie 1080:Maxim 900:Katie 881:Maxim 387:Audit 127:SoWhy 16:< 8697:talk 8649:L235 8636:xeno 8612:Mkdw 8598:Mkdw 8568:xeno 8541:L235 8510:brad 8504:L236 8483:L235 8407:brad 8338:xeno 8324:Mkdw 8307:talk 8268:Vote 7987:1.1 7745:4.3 7709:4.2 7675:4.1 7210:🎷 7206:Jazz 6970:xeno 6905:xeno 6873:and 6824:brad 6773:xeno 6755:Mkdw 6697:and 6659:talk 6564:xeno 6539:Mkdw 6519:brad 6506:talk 6461:talk 6427:talk 6409:talk 6315:xeno 6286:Mkdw 6265:brad 6227:talk 6163:brad 6127:xeno 6102:Mkdw 6013:talk 5959:xeno 5942:xeno 5904:that 5892:xeno 5869:brad 5851:xeno 5828:brad 5822:Xeno 5811:xeno 5793:xeno 5786:here 5780:has 5747:talk 5719:Mkdw 5696:brad 5671:brad 5597:talk 5536:xeno 5519:xeno 5477:xeno 5439:xeno 5378:xeno 5372:only 5346:xeno 5333:xeno 5320:xeno 5250:talk 5226:xeno 5209:talk 5173:brad 5158:and 5130:Mkdw 5059:xeno 4987:xeno 4947:Mkdw 4935:talk 4891:brad 4873:talk 4759:xeno 4730:Mkdw 4717:talk 4673:brad 4654:talk 4572:talk 4493:xeno 4433:Mkdw 4421:talk 4373:brad 4355:talk 4275:talk 4196:xeno 4152:Mkdw 4140:talk 4096:brad 4078:talk 4049:talk 4025:xeno 4009:also 3965:xeno 3952:xeno 3924:2020 3920:2018 3916:2017 3912:2015 3908:2020 3863:Xeno 3846:xeno 3812:Mkdw 3790:brad 3764:talk 3729:talk 3677:xeno 3664:xeno 3637:Mkdw 3605:2020 3601:2018 3597:2017 3593:2015 3589:2020 3557:xeno 3533:talk 3475:xeno 3443:and 3415:xeno 3402:xeno 3377:Mkdw 3359:talk 3297:talk 3274:brad 3188:xeno 3174:Mkdw 3161:talk 3140:talk 3117:brad 2991:talk 2931:brad 2880:xeno 2848:xeno 2750:Mkdw 2738:talk 2694:brad 2673:talk 2559:xeno 2534:Mkdw 2522:talk 2476:brad 2457:talk 2352:xeno 2313:Mkdw 2301:talk 2258:brad 2240:talk 2216:talk 2131:xeno 2117:Mkdw 2080:talk 2028:brad 2010:talk 1959:xeno 1911:xeno 1880:Mkdw 1843:talk 1800:brad 1782:talk 1690:xeno 1676:Mkdw 1639:talk 1596:brad 1578:talk 1489:xeno 1475:Mkdw 1438:talk 1394:brad 1376:talk 1265:xeno 1251:Mkdw 1214:talk 1171:brad 1153:talk 1066:xeno 1052:Mkdw 1015:talk 972:brad 954:talk 867:xeno 853:Mkdw 816:talk 773:brad 755:talk 585:the 545:post 530:3–4 522:1–2 404:Talk 395:Talk 362:Talk 342:Talk 196:Talk 166:Talk 132:Talk 121:Talk 110:Talk 96:Talk 79:Talk 68:Talk 57:Talk 46:Talk 26:Case 8671:Why 8653:SQL 8625:Why 8578:Why 8536:alt 8478:alt 8454:Why 8388:AGK 8366:Why 8098:10 7893:10 7823:10 7788:10 7547:10 7479:10 7409:10 7374:10 7339:10 7304:10 7269:10 6936:AGK 6923:Why 6889:AGK 6732:Why 6706:AGK 6678:AGK 6641:5) 6581:Why 6501:Joe 6484:AGK 6403:4) 6332:Why 6246:AGK 6078:Why 6053:AGK 6033:AGK 5939:. – 5788:). 5640:AGK 5628:now 5560:Why 5516:. – 5279:Why 5102:AGK 4975:Why 4930:Joe 4912:AGK 4836:Why 4712:Joe 4694:AGK 4471:Why 4416:Joe 4412:BRD 4394:AGK 4317:RfA 4185:Why 4135:Joe 4117:AGK 4018:); 3941:Why 3876:Why 3743:AGK 3724:Joe 3625:Why 3472:. – 3460:Why 3354:Joe 3335:AGK 3318:AGK 3156:Joe 3044:Why 3013:AGK 2903:Why 2798:Why 2733:Joe 2715:AGK 2517:Joe 2499:AGK 2341:Why 2296:Joe 2279:AGK 2210:1) 2096:Why 2075:Joe 2058:AGK 1982:7) 1859:Why 1838:Joe 1821:AGK 1655:Why 1634:Joe 1617:AGK 1454:Why 1433:Joe 1416:AGK 1230:Why 1209:Joe 1192:AGK 1031:Why 1010:Joe 993:AGK 832:Why 811:Joe 794:AGK 278:Log 8699:) 8666:So 8659:, 8655:, 8651:, 8620:So 8573:So 8566:, 8555:) 8538:of 8519:🍁 8497:) 8480:of 8449:So 8416:🍁 8403:– 8361:So 8315:) 8238:0 8235:0 8232:0 8222:0 8202:0 8199:0 8196:0 8186:0 8134:0 8131:2 8128:7 8118:5 8101:0 8095:0 8087:4 8068:0 8065:1 8062:8 8052:3 8035:0 8032:6 8029:3 8021:2 8001:0 7998:4 7995:5 7967:0 7964:2 7961:7 7951:1 7899:0 7896:0 7883:8 7864:1 7861:0 7858:9 7848:7 7829:0 7826:0 7813:6 7794:0 7791:0 7778:5 7759:0 7756:0 7753:1 7725:0 7722:2 7719:8 7689:1 7686:3 7683:5 7656:0 7653:6 7650:4 7642:4 7623:0 7620:1 7617:9 7607:3 7588:0 7585:0 7582:9 7572:2 7553:0 7550:0 7537:1 7485:0 7482:0 7469:7 7450:1 7447:1 7444:8 7434:6 7415:0 7412:0 7399:5 7380:0 7377:0 7364:4 7345:0 7342:0 7329:3 7310:0 7307:0 7294:2 7275:0 7272:0 7259:1 7109:: 7075:). 6918:So 6833:🍁 6727:So 6667:) 6576:So 6528:🍁 6469:) 6421:, 6327:So 6274:🍁 6235:) 6172:🍁 6073:So 6021:) 5878:🍁 5837:🍁 5755:) 5705:🍁 5680:🍁 5605:) 5555:So 5274:So 5258:) 5217:) 5182:🍁 5126:. 4970:So 4928:– 4900:🍁 4881:) 4831:So 4682:🍁 4662:) 4481:No 4466:So 4382:🍁 4363:) 4180:So 4105:🍁 4086:) 4011:; 3936:So 3918:, 3914:, 3906:, 3902:, 3898:, 3871:So 3799:🍁 3772:) 3620:So 3599:, 3595:, 3587:, 3583:, 3579:, 3541:) 3455:So 3439:, 3373:. 3305:) 3283:🍁 3255:, 3251:, 3247:, 3148:) 3126:🍁 3109:, 3105:, 3101:, 3097:, 3039:So 2999:) 2940:🍁 2898:So 2793:So 2703:🍁 2681:) 2657:). 2515:– 2485:🍁 2465:) 2336:So 2294:– 2267:🍁 2254:– 2248:) 2091:So 2073:– 2053:: 2037:🍁 2024:– 2018:) 1854:So 1836:– 1809:🍁 1796:– 1790:) 1650:So 1605:🍁 1592:– 1586:) 1449:So 1431:– 1403:🍁 1390:– 1384:) 1356:, 1352:, 1348:, 1344:, 1225:So 1207:– 1180:🍁 1167:– 1161:) 1026:So 1008:– 981:🍁 968:– 962:) 827:So 809:– 782:🍁 769:– 763:) 533:4 525:5 517:6 514:0 103:: 89:: 72:— 61:— 50:— 8695:( 8688:C 8614:: 8610:@ 8553:c 8550:· 8547:t 8544:· 8533:( 8512:v 8495:c 8492:· 8489:t 8486:· 8475:( 8467:: 8463:@ 8409:v 8394:■ 8335:– 8310:· 8305:( 8249:· 8213:· 8145:· 8079:· 8012:· 7978:· 7910:· 7875:· 7840:· 7805:· 7770:· 7736:· 7700:· 7667:· 7634:· 7599:· 7564:· 7496:· 7461:· 7426:· 7391:· 7356:· 7321:· 7286:· 7219:. 6967:– 6942:■ 6898:) 6891:— 6884:( 6826:v 6712:■ 6684:■ 6662:· 6657:( 6521:v 6508:) 6504:( 6490:■ 6464:· 6459:( 6430:· 6425:( 6412:· 6407:( 6312:– 6267:v 6252:■ 6230:· 6225:( 6165:v 6059:■ 6039:■ 6016:· 6011:( 5935:) 5928:— 5924:— 5920:— 5913:( 5871:v 5830:v 5808:– 5750:· 5745:( 5698:v 5673:v 5646:■ 5600:· 5595:( 5512:) 5505:— 5501:— 5494:( 5470:) 5463:— 5456:( 5436:– 5253:· 5248:( 5212:· 5207:( 5175:v 5108:■ 4937:) 4933:( 4918:■ 4893:v 4876:· 4871:( 4719:) 4715:( 4700:■ 4675:v 4657:· 4652:( 4634:. 4575:· 4570:( 4423:) 4419:( 4400:■ 4375:v 4358:· 4353:( 4319:) 4314:· 4308:· 4302:· 4296:· 4290:· 4284:· 4278:· 4273:( 4193:– 4142:) 4138:( 4123:■ 4098:v 4081:· 4076:( 4052:· 4047:( 4016:3 4013:2 4007:( 3865:: 3861:@ 3792:v 3767:· 3762:( 3749:■ 3731:) 3727:( 3536:· 3531:( 3361:) 3357:( 3341:■ 3324:■ 3300:· 3295:( 3276:v 3257:4 3253:3 3249:2 3245:1 3163:) 3159:( 3143:· 3138:( 3119:v 3111:5 3107:4 3103:3 3099:2 3095:1 3019:■ 2994:· 2989:( 2933:v 2740:) 2736:( 2721:■ 2696:v 2676:· 2671:( 2556:– 2524:) 2520:( 2505:■ 2478:v 2460:· 2455:( 2428:. 2349:– 2303:) 2299:( 2285:■ 2260:v 2243:· 2238:( 2219:· 2214:( 2128:– 2082:) 2078:( 2064:■ 2030:v 2013:· 2008:( 1845:) 1841:( 1827:■ 1802:v 1785:· 1780:( 1687:– 1641:) 1637:( 1623:■ 1598:v 1581:· 1576:( 1486:– 1440:) 1436:( 1422:■ 1396:v 1379:· 1374:( 1262:– 1216:) 1212:( 1198:■ 1173:v 1156:· 1151:( 1063:– 1017:) 1013:( 999:■ 974:v 957:· 952:( 864:– 818:) 814:( 800:■ 775:v 758:· 753:( 675:. 597:. 572:. 470:e 463:t 456:v 358:+ 316:+ 280:) 276:( 192:+ 134:) 130:( 123:) 119:( 112:) 108:( 98:) 94:( 81:) 77:( 70:) 66:( 59:) 55:( 48:) 44:(

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Knowledge

:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Kudpung/Proposed decision - Knowledge

Index