90:
Academy admits non-Catholic students–"including
Muslims, Jews, Baptists, Buddhists, Hindus and Episcopalians"–it failed to meet the law's strict test for exemption as an enterprise that "limits membership, enrollment, admission, or participation to members of that religion". The school requires only administrators and the theology faculty to be Catholics. The Academy had argued that requiring it to employ Barrett violated its federal Constitutional right to "expressive association", but the court found that Barrett's employment as food service manager would not significantly burden the school's ability to communicate its message or "dilute that message, given Barrett's only assertion in conflict with the school's message had occurred when completing a form and that in the position he sought to fill he would not be engaged in the school's mission of "presenting the gospel values or the ... teachings of the Catholic Church". The court also pointed to public awareness of the issue:
56:, because in July 2013 the school withdrew an offer of employment as food service manager when officials learned he was in a same-sex marriage. After accepting the job offer, Barrett completed paperwork and provided as his emergency contact the name Ed Suplee, whom he identified as his "husband". A few days later the school withdrew its offer of employment and explained that his status as a spouse in a same-sex marriage was inconsistent with the teaching of the Roman Catholic Church.
119:, said: "You are on a slippery slope if you allow the government to determine which jobs it deems 'religious. The government should not be allowed to interfere with a religious school's hiring practices and what it believes is important to remain true to its mission and identity. Religious schools should be able to have representatives that behave in a manner that is consistent with their beliefs so that there is no misunderstanding where the school stands on controversial issues."
281:
to another woman. Margie
Winters said she had told administrators at the school about her marriage when she was hired in 2007. The school's principal said in a letter to parents that the school must comply with Catholic philosophy. In August, a Catholic college preparatory school in Macon, Georgia, settled a discrimination lawsuit filed by a music teacher who said he was fired in 2014 because of his plans to marry his partner.
115:, commented: "This court decision makes it impossible for faith-based institutions to survive....If this decision stands, it will either force faith-based schools to close their doors to anyone who is not of the same religion or they will have to give up their beliefs and hire without any regard to faith which will ultimately cease to make them faith-based institutions". Gregory S. Baylor, senior counsel at the
127:
for damages for lost wages as well as compensatory damages for discrimination. He wrote in a press release: "Religiously affiliated organizations do not get a free pass to discriminate against gay and lesbian people. When
Fontbonne fired Matt from a job that has nothing to do with religion, and simply because he is married, they came down on the wrong side of the law."
100:
interference in a religious group's selection of its ministers, teachers and those who exercise religious functions. The
Academy asserted that each of its employees is a "minister of the mission". The court found under U.S. Supreme Court precedent that more was required to meet the "ministerial exception" than such an assertion alone.
280:
Since the legalization of gay marriage, there have been cases around the country of
Catholic institutions firing employees in same-sex marriages. In June, the director of religious education at a Catholic elementary school outside Philadelphia was fired after two parents complained about her marriage
25:
decision of
December 16, 2015, that found that a Roman Catholic secondary school violated the state's laws against discrimination on the basis of both sexual orientation and gender when it withdrew an offer of employment from a candidate when officials learned he was in a civil same-sex marriage. It
142:
Barrett's attorneys announced on May 9, 2016, that he had reached a confidential settlement with the school, which would not pursue an appeal. It included a financial payment, but details were not disclosed. The school issued a statement that said: "Fontbonne
Academy expresses deep gratitude to Mr.
126:
Barrett's attorney, Bennett Klein of GLAD, said: "Marriage equality has been the law of
Massachusetts for over a decade, and it is now the law of the land. But you can't have equality if you can get married on Saturday and fired on Monday." He noted that the decision meant that the school is liable
122:
Denise
Donohue, deputy director of K-12 education programs for the Cardinal Newman Society, said students need a consistent message: "Hiring individuals who are not on mission, whether they are a classroom teacher, librarian or grounds keeper, weakens Catholic identity and undermines the mission of
94:
The widespread public awareness of the civil laws allowing same-sex marriage and prohibiting employment discrimination, coupled with
Fontbonne's ability to explain its position without interference in the form of advocacy from Barrett, leaves little risk that Fontbonne's involuntary compliance with
99:
Finally, the court considered the Academy's claim that it merited an exception from the anti-discrimination statutes based on the "ministerial exception" established under both the federal and state constitutions that prevents government interference in the free exercise of religion, specifically
85:
The court identified two types of discrimination. It held that Barrett suffered discriminated on the basis of sexual orientation because basing the school's action on his marriage is not distinct from basing it on his sexual orientation. It also found gender-based discrimination, because "he was
89:
The court then weighed the Academy's claims that it qualified for exemption under the statutes, first examining certain contradictory language in the relevant statutes. It said that the legislature allowed only a very narrow exemption for religious institutions as employers and that because the
59:
The facts of the case were not in dispute. A spokesperson for the school said it "does not discriminate based on sexual orientation, but that church doctrine against same-sex marriage drives policy at Fontbonne, and other Catholic schools." The Academy is an all-girls college preparatory school
134:, called the decision "pretty solid, from a strictly legal point of view." He noted the impact of the case was uncertain given the differences in the exemptions afforded religious institutions as employers under Massachusetts law and under federal a law.
161:
143:
Barrett for his willingness to come together with us in a spirit of conciliation, and wishes him well as the school moves ahead in its mission to foster educational excellence and social justice in an open and inclusive community".
169:
263:
354:
604:
70:
was asked how to reconcile the Church's outreach to gays and lesbians with the number of LGBT-related employment disputes in the news. He replied that the situation "needs to be rectified".
63:
Some negative reaction from alumnae of Fontbonne Academy, on social media and in comments on news articles, was directed at the school, though some blamed the Church rather than the school.
572:
465:
214:
437:
112:
526:
267:
362:
26:
was the first decision in the United States since the nationwide legalization of same-sex marriage accomplished by the U.S. Supreme Court decision in
108:
The decision received national news coverage, and much of the response broke down along the lines established in the debate over same-sex marriage.
388:
293:
495:
45:
411:
659:
325:
192:
32:
the previous June to consider the competing claims of discrimination in employment and the protections afforded religious institutions.
634:
131:
580:
237:
705:
695:
690:
596:
639:
664:
488:
549:
82:
that the Academy had violated the state's laws against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender.
78:
The case moved to Massachusetts Superior Court in May 2014. On December 16, 2015, Judge Douglas H. Wilkins ruled in
86:
denied employment for marrying a person whom a female could have married without suffering the same consequences".
700:
481:
544:
536:
22:
67:
116:
521:
649:
554:
669:
53:
516:
28:
8:
644:
49:
355:"Judge rules against Catholic prep school Fontbonne Academy in gay hiring case"
684:
588:
654:
326:"Judge says Catholic school discriminated against man in same-sex marriage"
238:"O'Malley: Trend of workers fired for LGBT issues 'needs to be rectified'"
412:"Judge: No Religious Excuse for Catholic School's Antigay Discrimination"
473:
215:"Alumnae react to Catholic high school's refusal to hire openly gay man"
605:
Massachusetts v. United States Department of Health and Human Services
389:"Did a Massachusetts court ruling essentially ban Catholic schools?"
573:
Hurley v. Irish-American Gay, Lesbian, and Bisexual Group of Boston
193:"Mass. Suit Aims To Clarify Religious Groups' Latitude In Hiring"
95:
civil law will be mistaken for endorsement of same-sex marriage.
264:"Judge rules against Catholic school in gay-hiring retraction"
41:
162:"Gay married man says Catholic school rescinded job offer"
438:"Catholic school, gay man settle discrimination lawsuit"
361:. Associated Press. December 17, 2015. Archived from
40:
On January 29, 2014, Matthew Barrett represented by
527:Massachusetts Governor's Task Force on Hate Crimes
60:sponsored by the Sisters of St. Joseph of Boston.
470:, Massachusetts Superior Court, December 16, 2015
682:
294:"Douglas H. Wilkins appointed to Superior Court"
46:Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination
660:Massachusetts Transgender Political Coalition
489:
635:Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders
564:
496:
482:
130:Dwight G. Duncan, professor of law at the
503:
132:University of Massachusetts School of Law
581:Goodridge v. Department of Public Health
160:Valencia, Milton J. (January 30, 2014).
159:
435:
382:
380:
319:
317:
315:
683:
597:Gill v. Office of Personnel Management
261:
217:. Al Jazeera America. February 3, 2014
477:
387:Vuoto, Loredana (February 15, 2016).
386:
323:
235:
190:
640:Gay and Lesbian Athletics Foundation
409:
377:
349:
347:
312:
262:Lavoie, Denise (December 17, 2015).
665:Harvard Gender and Sexuality Caucus
436:Herndon, Astead W. (May 10, 2016).
66:In September 2014, Boston Cardinal
13:
550:Same-sex marriage in Massachusetts
266:. Associated Press. Archived from
191:Smith, Tovia (February 12, 2014).
111:Andrew Beckwith, president of the
14:
717:
459:
410:Ring, Trudy (December 17, 2015).
344:
324:Labbe, Mark (December 28, 2015).
236:Shine, Bob (September 25, 2014).
52:, a Catholic secondary school in
429:
403:
706:2015 in United States case law
696:Legal history of Massachusetts
286:
255:
229:
207:
184:
153:
113:Massachusetts Family Institute
1:
691:LGBTQ rights in Massachusetts
146:
137:
35:
613:Barrett v. Fontbonne Academy
545:LGBT rights in Massachusetts
467:Barrett v. Fontbonne Academy
80:Barrett v. Fontbonne Academy
23:Massachusetts Superior Court
18:Barrett v. Fontbonne Academy
7:
103:
73:
44:filed a complaint with the
10:
722:
330:National Catholic Reporter
242:National Catholic Reporter
117:Alliance Defending Freedom
627:
535:
522:Combahee River Collective
509:
650:Family Equality Council
332:. Catholic News Service
555:Massachusetts 1913 law
391:. Catholic News Agency
97:
701:2015 in Massachusetts
504:LGBT in Massachusetts
92:
54:Milton, Massachusetts
517:Secret Court of 1920
365:on February 21, 2016
172:on February 22, 2014
29:Obergefell v. Hodges
645:Knowthyneighbor.org
678:
677:
623:
622:
300:. January 1, 2011
50:Fontbonne Academy
713:
562:
561:
498:
491:
484:
475:
474:
453:
452:
450:
448:
433:
427:
426:
424:
422:
407:
401:
400:
398:
396:
384:
375:
374:
372:
370:
351:
342:
341:
339:
337:
321:
310:
309:
307:
305:
290:
284:
283:
277:
275:
270:on March 7, 2016
259:
253:
252:
250:
248:
233:
227:
226:
224:
222:
211:
205:
204:
202:
200:
188:
182:
181:
179:
177:
168:. Archived from
157:
721:
720:
716:
715:
714:
712:
711:
710:
681:
680:
679:
674:
619:
560:
531:
505:
502:
462:
457:
456:
446:
444:
434:
430:
420:
418:
408:
404:
394:
392:
385:
378:
368:
366:
353:
352:
345:
335:
333:
322:
313:
303:
301:
298:Lawyers Journal
292:
291:
287:
273:
271:
260:
256:
246:
244:
234:
230:
220:
218:
213:
212:
208:
198:
196:
189:
185:
175:
173:
158:
154:
149:
140:
106:
76:
38:
12:
11:
5:
719:
709:
708:
703:
698:
693:
676:
675:
673:
672:
667:
662:
657:
652:
647:
642:
637:
631:
629:
625:
624:
621:
620:
618:
617:
609:
601:
593:
585:
577:
568:
566:
559:
558:
552:
547:
541:
539:
533:
532:
530:
529:
524:
519:
513:
511:
507:
506:
501:
500:
493:
486:
478:
472:
471:
461:
460:External links
458:
455:
454:
428:
402:
376:
343:
311:
285:
254:
228:
206:
183:
151:
150:
148:
145:
139:
136:
105:
102:
75:
72:
37:
34:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
718:
707:
704:
702:
699:
697:
694:
692:
689:
688:
686:
671:
668:
666:
663:
661:
658:
656:
653:
651:
648:
646:
643:
641:
638:
636:
633:
632:
630:
628:Organizations
626:
615:
614:
610:
607:
606:
602:
599:
598:
594:
591:
590:
589:Cook v. Gates
586:
583:
582:
578:
575:
574:
570:
569:
567:
563:
556:
553:
551:
548:
546:
543:
542:
540:
538:
534:
528:
525:
523:
520:
518:
515:
514:
512:
508:
499:
494:
492:
487:
485:
480:
479:
476:
469:
468:
464:
463:
443:
439:
432:
417:
413:
406:
390:
383:
381:
364:
360:
356:
350:
348:
331:
327:
320:
318:
316:
299:
295:
289:
282:
269:
265:
258:
243:
239:
232:
216:
210:
194:
187:
171:
167:
163:
156:
152:
144:
135:
133:
128:
124:
123:the school."
120:
118:
114:
109:
101:
96:
91:
87:
83:
81:
71:
69:
68:Sean O'Malley
64:
61:
57:
55:
51:
47:
43:
33:
31:
30:
24:
20:
19:
655:MassEquality
612:
611:
603:
595:
587:
579:
571:
466:
445:. Retrieved
442:Boston Globe
441:
431:
421:February 20,
419:. Retrieved
416:The Advocate
415:
405:
395:February 20,
393:. Retrieved
369:February 20,
367:. Retrieved
363:the original
358:
336:February 20,
334:. Retrieved
329:
304:February 20,
302:. Retrieved
297:
288:
279:
274:February 20,
272:. Retrieved
268:the original
257:
247:February 20,
245:. Retrieved
241:
231:
221:February 20,
219:. Retrieved
209:
199:February 12,
197:. Retrieved
186:
176:February 12,
174:. Retrieved
170:the original
166:Boston Globe
165:
155:
141:
129:
125:
121:
110:
107:
98:
93:
88:
84:
79:
77:
65:
62:
58:
39:
27:
17:
16:
15:
565:Court cases
557:(1913–2008)
685:Categories
147:References
138:Settlement
36:Background
104:Reaction
74:Decision
48:against
510:History
447:May 13,
670:Keshet
616:(2015)
608:(2013)
600:(2013)
592:(2008)
584:(2003)
576:(1995)
537:Rights
195:. NPR
21:is a
449:2016
423:2016
397:2016
371:2016
359:CRUX
338:2016
306:2016
276:2016
249:2016
223:2016
201:2014
178:2014
42:GLAD
687::
440:.
414:.
379:^
357:.
346:^
328:.
314:^
296:.
278:.
240:.
164:.
497:e
490:t
483:v
451:.
425:.
399:.
373:.
340:.
308:.
251:.
225:.
203:.
180:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.